Written submission from NUS-USI (ANI0322)

 

An important note regarding the background of NUS-USI

 

The National Union of Students-Union of Students in Ireland (NUS-USI) was established in 1972 under a unique arrangement where both the British and Irish national student unions, the National Union of Students (NUS) and Union of Students in Ireland (USI) respectively, jointly organised in Northern Ireland to promote student unity across the sectarian divide.

 

In 2018 NUS-USI is the recognised voice of students in Northern Ireland at a national (NUS, USI) and international (European Students’ Union) level.

 

The agreed mission of NUS-USI is

                            to promote, extend and defend the rights of students; and

                            to develop and champion strong students’ unions.

 

The vision of NUS-USI includes the promotion of social justice and respect for human rights.

 

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

 

  1.                  Students are harmed by the lack of access to abortion services in Northern Ireland because they must travel abroad to access abortion or risk prosecution by self-aborting with pills. Young people between 20 and 29 are the most common groups travelling from Northern Ireland to England to access abortion. International students and students from Great Britain lose the right to access abortion services when they register with a GP in Northern Ireland.

 

  1.                  Students support the decriminalisation of abortion and want abortion to be accessible in Northern Ireland on a free, safe, legal and local basis. This is demonstrated by the policy positions of NUS-USI and some of our member unions.

 

  1.                  Students’ views on abortion have evolved significantly in recent years: this can be seen in the histories of our students’ unions (see below). From the 1970s to the 1990s, abortion rights campaigning within the Northern Ireland student movement was limited to a core group of activists. Now it is widely recognised as a student rights issue and pro-choice demonstrations are well-attended by students. Queen’s University Belfast Students’ Union now holds a position firmly in favour of decriminalising abortion, following many years of back and forth on the topic.

 

  1.                  Access to abortion is a class issue and therefore a student issue. Many students in Northern Ireland are below the age of 25 and live on low incomes. This has meant that safe but illegal abortions are often the only financially viable option for students who wish to end a pregnancy.

 

  1.                  Students and young people cannot seek the advice of their local GP regarding abortion, therefore they often turn to students’ union officers for advice. The criminalisation of abortion and the Criminal Law (Northern Ireland) Act 1967 puts student officers in a difficult position when providing confidential support to students with crisis pregnancies and signposting them to other organisations.

 

  1.                  The harms of a lack of abortion services in Northern Ireland are compounded by poor sex education, abortion stigma and a lack of access to aftercare due to the fear of criminalisation.

 

  1.                  Members of the women’s movement in the 1970s-1990s recall that backstreet abortion was taboo but not uncommon among working class women who could not afford to travel to access abortion. A 21-year-old woman died from septicaemia following a backstreet abortion in Belfast in 1979. In 2018, illegal abortions continue, however the typical method used since the early 2000s (early medical abortion with pills) is safe.

 

 

How attitudes to abortion within the NI student movement have changed

 

National Union of Students-Union of Students in Ireland (NUS-USI)

Membership: over 200,000 further and higher education students across Northern Ireland

 

There is a limited archive of abortion rights activism by NUS-USI officers and members between 1972 and the mid-2000s. The documents currently available do not do justice to the extent of NI student activism on abortion in this period and must be supplemented by oral histories. The following account of NUS-USI history on abortion rights campaigning is based on a review of a small archive of papers dating back to 1997, informal interviews with NUS-USI staff members and elected officers, and the Linenhall Library ‘Divided Society’ archive.

              NUS-USI staff and former elected officers recall that there was a strong core group of women students who were passionate about abortion reform in the 1980s and 1990s. It might initially appear from gaps in the archives that the NUS-USI of the 1970s-2000s was less vocal on reproductive rights than its sister unions, but the nature of grassroots activism must be kept in mind. Activists who are focused on campaigning against a particular law or practice (e.g. the Eighth Amendment to the Irish Constitution) concentrate their energy on that campaign and therefore have little time to document the details of their activism.[1] The process of documenting activist work has become easier with access to the internet and social media. Archiving activist work from the 1970s to the early 1990s was a much more labour intensive and expensive process, it is therefore unsurprising that there are few public records available of student activism on abortion rights in Northern Ireland from this period. I must emphasise that the scarcity of written records does not mean that abortion rights activism by students did not happen in Northern Ireland: this is why I refer to oral histories.

              At several points in the history of NUS-USI, the organisation has had to focus its campaigning resources on challenging education policy changes such as reviews of higher education funding, cuts to student bursaries and increases in tuition fees. In periods where access to education was under threat, NUS-USI has had to focus almost exclusively on advocating for students’ interests within further and higher education institutions. This meant that student-led social justice campaigns received less attention in periods of educational policy change e.g. 2008-11.

              During the Troubles (1968-1998), NUS-USI campaigned on many complex issues such as housing, sectarianism, community relations and opposition to tuition fees.[2] The relatively low profile of abortion rights campaigning within written histories of the first three decades of NUS-USI might also be the result of the disruptive nature of civil conflict. Civil society campaigns in the 1970s-1990s on domestic and sexual violence, LGBT+ rights and access to abortion were often overshadowed by the fallout of the Troubles.[3] It could also be true that abortion rights attracted comparatively little attention beyond a core group of students because student politics has, at times, mirrored the dynamics of parliamentary politics at Stormont and Westminster in regarding the question of abortion reform as a controversial issue.[4]

              Staff and former elected officers recall that members of NUS-USI were passionate about campaigning against the insertion of the Eighth Amendment to the Irish Constitution in 1983. During the early 1990s, student activists in Northern Ireland actively supported USI, Trinity College and University College Dublin Students’ Union (TCDSU and UCDSU) student officers who were sued in the Republic of Ireland for providing information on accessing an abortion in England.[5] In solidarity with the USI, TCDSU and UCDSU activists, Northern students printed leaflets containing the abortion information at the centre of SPUC v Grogan injunction and sold t-shirts bearing the phone number of the abortion information line in Queen’s Students Union shop.[6] Students also attended a demonstration in support of the arrival of a Brook clinic Belfast in 1992. Brook was accused by conservative religious groups of ‘bringing abortion by the back door’.[7]             

              NUS-USI adopted a pro-choice policy calling for abortion law reform in Northern Ireland at an extraordinary conference in 2008. It is not entirely clear from the NUS-USI archives whether NUS-USI had already adopted a pro-choice position before 2008. Staff and former elected officers suggest this may have been the case. Between 2009 and 2012, a vocal group of students and elected students’ union officers opposed NUS-USI’s decision to take a position on abortion, arguing that taking a side in the abortion reform debate is as controversial as adopting a position on the constitutional question. This view was rejected by the NUS-USI membership by democratic vote.

              From 2008 onwards, individual NUS-USI presidents and women’s officers have supported external pro-choice campaigns such as the Amnesty International My Body, My Rights campaign and the Alliance for Choice Trust Women campaign. In recent years NUS-USI has frequently shared press releases responding to developments around abortion law in Northern Ireland including court judgments and debates at Stormont, highlighting that a lack of access to abortion services is a student issue.[8]

              NUS-USI actively campaigned alongside USI to repeal the Eighth Amendment between 2016 and 2018. In April 2018, NUS-USI President Olivia Potter-Hughes and Women’s Officer-elect Rachel Watters created a campaign in solidarity with USI to support repeal of the Eighth Amendment. The Home to V8te campaign (see Appendix A) mobilised Irish vote-eligible students studying at UK universities and colleges to return home to vote in the referendum on the Eighth Amendment. NUS Women’s Officer Hareem Ghani gathered funding from NUS to create Home to V8te travel bursaries: a total of 136 students received travel bursaries in May 2018 to enable them to travel to vote in the referendum. NUS-USI members attended USI training events on pro-choice campaigning and NUS-USI President Olivia Potter-Hughes attended numerous Students for Choice events to support a Yes vote in the 2018 referendum.

                            NUS-USI women’s officers have worked closely with member unions in Northern Ireland, the NUS Women’s Campaign and external student feminist groups in Great Britain to raise awareness of the lack of abortion access in Northern Ireland (and the Republic of Ireland).

                            NUS-USI Women’s Conference unanimously passed a motion in favour of the decriminalisation of abortion in Northern Ireland and the removal of barriers to abortion access (see Appendix B) in February 2018. This policy was ratified by NUS-USI Conference in March 2018 and strengthened NUS-USI’s existing pro-choice stance. In September 2018, NUS-USI launched its first abortion rights campaign called ‘Trust Us’ (see Appendix C). NUS-USI officers and committee members regularly attend pro-choice demonstrations and events across Northern Ireland. The NUS-USI membership is supportive of the organisation’s firm commitment to campaigning for free, safe, legal and local access to abortion.

 

 

Queen’s University Belfast Students’ Union (QUBSU)

Membership: 23,850 undergraduate and postgraduate students (2016/17)

 

Queen’s University Belfast Students’ Union was established in 1966 when two single-sex student representative groups merged to form a single union. Unlike many students’ unions in Great Britain, QUBSU did not support the extension of the 1967 Abortion Act for most of the past 50 years, despite the activism of women student campaigners. From the mid 1980s to 2015, the union’s position on abortion varied from anti-choice (or ‘pro-life’) to pro-choice depending on the prevailing opinion of students and elected officers.

              The fact that abortion rights were a source of contention within QUBSU before 2015 is perhaps explained by the historic role of the union as a training ground for Northern Irish politicians.[9] Many current and former MLAs and Northern Irish MPs were elected to the Students’ Union Council or sabbatical officer positions while studying at Queen’s. Many (but not all) students engaged in QUBSU politics are to some extent affiliated with Northern Irish political parties. Student debates on abortion rights have been strongly influenced by party-affiliated students who share their parties’ views on abortion reform. Until recently, the 5 largest political parties in Northern Ireland have either avoided discussion of abortion law reform or actively opposed it.[10]

              For many years, QUBSU was polarised along political party and community affiliation (CNR/PUL) lines.[11] From the 1970s to 2015, opposition to abortion law reform united socially conservative students with divergent community backgrounds. MP Ian Paisley referenced this dynamic at an address to the Presbyterian Assembly in 1990.[12] Pro-choice women student campaigners have always operated on a cross-community basis.

              From the 1970s to 2015, small but dedicated groups of students campaigned on abortion rights and provided advice within the Students’ Union on accessing abortion (see ‘The implications for students of lack of access to abortion services’ below). The QUBSU position on abortion was intensely debated between 2010 and 2015. The union’s position flipped between pro-choice (May 2012), neutrality on abortion (December 2012) and in favour of limited abortion reform (2015) depending on the views of the elected sabbatical officers and the composition of the Students’ Union Council. These debates were influenced in part by the stances of Northern Irish political parties and the emerging campaign to repeal the Eighth Amendment in the Republic of Ireland.

              During the period of neutrality on abortion within QUBSU (2012-2015), students proposed a motion to Students’ Union Council which argued that the neutrality policy created confusion about what advice the Students’ Union welfare system could give to students experiencing crisis pregnancy. The neutrality policy was perceived by some students as a mechanism for anti-choice student officers to maintain the status quo and suppress discussion of abortion rights. Things came to a head around USI Congress 2013, when a student delegate from QUBSU was publicly disciplined by the Union’s Executive Management Committee for voting in favour of a pro-choice motion at a national conference.[13] It could be argued that some QUBSU sabbatical officers implemented the policy of neutrality on abortion in order to obstruct pro-choice campaigning by QUB students on a local and national level between 2012 and 2015.

              A tipping point in QUBSU’s position on abortion rights came in 2015 when the Students’ Union Council approved a motion to support Amnesty International’s My Body, My Rights campaign. The union’s position on abortion consequently changed from neutrality to support for limited abortion law reform. In 2016, the Students’ Union Council approved a policy calling for an extension of the 1967 Abortion Act to Northern Ireland. This policy changed in 2017 when the Students’ Union Council approved a motion that mandated QUBSU to campaign for the decriminalisation of abortion. Students proposing the decriminalisation motion stated that the 1967 Abortion Act was not fit for purpose and decriminalisation was necessary to deliver access to abortion in Northern Ireland for vulnerable groups. (Neither NUS-USI, QUBSU nor UUSU support the extension of the 1967 Abortion Act for reasons set out on Appendix C, in the section titled “Why decriminalise abortion in Northern Ireland?”.)

              In August 2017, 3 QUBSU sabbatical officers wore ‘Repeal’ jumpers (in support of the campaign to repeal the Eighth Amendment) to a prominent event at Queen’s University attended by Taoiseach Leo Varadkar. During a question and answer session, one of the officers asked the Taoiseach about the timing of the referendum on the Eighth Amendment and asked that the vote be held at a time when students would be in the country.[14]

                            QUBSU launched its first major pro-choice campaign, Project Choice, in October 2017.[15] Project Choice consists of a group of students (called ‘Choice Ambassadors’) from different academic and campaigning perspectives working together to campaign for full access to reproductive healthcare on the island of Ireland for anyone who can become pregnant. The activities of Project Choice involve lobbying to change Northern Ireland’s restrictive abortion laws, myth-busting and holding training workshops for students. QUBSU is home to three other pro-choice student societies: Amnesty International QUB, the Pro-Choice Society and Medical Students for Choice. The latter has organised training in abortion provision for medical students and raised concerns about the lack of training in abortion procedures in Northern Ireland.[16]

              Recent pro-choice demonstrations at Queen’s University have been well-attended and supported by students and members of the public (see Appendix D). Sabbatical officers at QUBSU supported and processed students’ applications for travel bursaries as part of NUS-USI’s Home to V8te campaign in May 2018 (see Appendix A). Staff and current student officers believe that the pro-choice position of QUBSU is now firmly embedded.

 

Ulster University Students’ Union (UUSU)

Membership: 24,640 undergraduate and postgraduate students (2016/17)

 

Ulster University Students’ Union was established in 1985 and represents students across 4 campuses in Belfast, Jordanstown, Coleraine and Derry. Prior to 2015 UUSU did not take a position on abortion law reform in Northern Ireland, although some students participated in external pro and anti-choice campaigns respectively.

              Like other students’ unions on the island of Ireland, UUSU Students’ Union Council adopted a position in favour of limited abortion reform when it voted to support the Amnesty International My Body, My Rights campaign in 2015. UUSU then adopted policy in favour of the full decriminalisation of abortion in 2016, before QUBSU and NUS-USI.

              Sabbatical officers at UUSU supported and processed students’ applications for travel bursaries as part of NUS-USI’s Home to V8te campaign in May 2018.

 

Further Education (FE) colleges

 

NUS-USI represents more than 150,000 students across all further education colleges in Northern Ireland (see table below).

              FE college students’ unions in Northern Ireland typically have tight budgets and cannot afford to develop autonomous campaigns on the same scale as NUS-USI or higher education students’ unions. Belfast Metropolitan College is the largest further education college in Northern Ireland and the only college that has a paid officer role (President) within its students’ union.

              Further education college students’ unions have produced many excellent pro-choice activists. FE students have been active in shaping NUS-USI policy in favour of abortion reform and have participated in the broader civil society campaign to decriminalise abortion.

 

Total number of students at FE colleges in NI (all affiliated to NUS-USI)

 

College

Campus locations

Number of students

(enrolments per year)

Belfast Metropolitan College

5 locations across Belfast

37,000

College of Agriculture, Food & Rural Enterprise (CAFRE)

  •                    Greenmount
  •                    Enniskillen
  •                    Loughry

1,800

North West Regional College

  •      Derry
  •      Limavady
  •      Strabane

10,000

Northern Regional College

  •           Ballymena (2 campuses)
  •           Ballymoney
  •           Coleraine
  •           Larne
  •           Magherafelt
  •           Newtownabbey

13,652

South Eastern Regional College

  •                    Ballynahinch
  •                    Bangor
  •                    Downpatrick
  •                    Lisburn
  •                    Newcastle
  •                    Newtownards
  •                    Carrowdore
  •                    Holywood

31,199

South West College

  •                    Cookstown
  •                    Dungannon
  •                    Enniskillen
  •                    Omagh

24,215

Southern Regional College

  •       Armagh
  •       Banbridge
  •       Kilkeel
  •       Lurgan
  •       Newry
  •       Portadown

34,000

TOTAL

151,866

 

 

 

The implications for students of the lack of access to abortion services

 

The NUS-USI Trust Us campaign briefing concisely explains why abortion is a student issue (i.e. an issue concerning students’ rights and welfare) in Northern Ireland (see “Why is access to abortion a student issue?”, Appendix C pages 5-6). The implications of the lack of access to abortion that apply to young people and people on low incomes naturally apply to students, who often belong to both of these groups. The following account will describe the issues discussed in the Trust Us briefing in greater detail, in order to reflect oral histories gathered from current and former elected student officers, including my own experience as a pro-choice student activist at Queen’s University Belfast and Women’s Officer at NUS-USI.

              For as long as Northern Irish students’ unions have had student welfare systems, students with crisis pregnancies have approached officers for information on accessing abortion. Students often approach officers about their pregnancy because they do not feel safe to tell their GP or family members that they intend to end their pregnancy. This fact is well known within the NI student and women’s movements but rarely written about because abortion stigma casts a wide net and officers often fear that supporting students in crisis might attract the attention of anti-choice protesters or the police. We are conscious of section 5 of the Criminal Law (Northern Ireland) Act 1967, which creates a legal duty to report knowledge of a crime. This law puts student officers in a very difficult position in a region where abortion is almost completely illegal.

              Student officers (particularly those in welfare or women’s officer roles) regularly receive messages or calls out of the blue from students asking for information on how to access an abortion in Northern Ireland. Officers will provide non-directive support to students seeking an abortion by signposting them to sources of further information such as the Abortion Support Network or Alliance for Choice websites. Although it is not illegal to provide information on abortion in Northern Ireland, the criminalisation of abortion makes officers and students’ unions very cautious to share direct links to websites where abortion pills can be ordered. NUS-USI has decided to share a list of relevant organisations in the Trust Us briefing (“If you need an abortion in Northern Ireland”, Appendix C, pages 9-11), so that any student or officer can use this list for themselves or to support someone else. We know from the anonymous stories shared by the Abortion Support Network that people with crisis pregnancies may engage in self-harm to try to end a pregnancy.[17] We want to help prevent this by providing students with information on how to access safe abortion if they need to. We trust students to know for themselves whether they feel able to continue a pregnancy and when asked, we will signpost them to organisations that can provide support.

Student officers of the 1970s-1990s referred students asking for abortion information to telephone directories printed on the back of local women’s publications. These included the telephone numbers for the Ulster Pregnancy Advisory Association, the Family Planning Association and the British Pregnancy Advisory Service. These directories sometimes included the telephone numbers for abortion clinics in England.[18]

              Young people between the ages of 20 and 29 are the most common overall category of people travelling from Northern Ireland to England to access abortion services.[19] Aiken et al report that Women on Web supplied abortion pills to 1,438 women in the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland in 2015.[20] Women on Web have reported receiving daily requests for help from women across the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland.[21] The rise in people travelling from Northern Ireland to England for abortion since the introduction of the new funding scheme suggests a link between access to abortion services and socioeconomic class.[22]

              International students and students from Great Britain often do not realise that abortion is not accessible in Northern Ireland until after they arrive.[23] Jo Gowers, NUS-USI Women’s Officer 2015-16, wrote in 2016:

One month after I turned eighteen, I moved to Belfast in Northern Ireland for university. I have no doubt in my mind that it was one of the best things that ever happened to me. I will leave Belfast after graduating with the belief, legally speaking at least, it is the worst place in the UK to be a woman. When I moved there, I quickly learnt that abortions were hugely restricted in NI. As a Christian I’m unsure if I would ever want an abortion, but I never imagined still living in the UK and it not being available. By the end of first year I had also learnt that by registering to a GP surgery here I lost my right to an abortion from the NHS in England too.[24]

 

Hamsavani Rajeswaren, an international alumna of Queen’s University Belfast and the current Equality and Diversity Officer at QUBSU, wrote earlier this year:

It is not uncommon for international students to fall pregnant during the course of their studies – both undergraduates and postgraduates. The troubling this is that very often, it’s only upon finding out that they are pregnant that these students find out that they are unable to access reproductive healthcare here should they wish to. To make matters worse, the criminalisation of abortion in Northern Ireland also means that they are unable to receive advice from their healthcare providers, or university.

              These are incredibly vulnerable students that we are talking about. They have no family here, no one to support them, or show them where to go or what to do in the event of a crisis pregnancy. Should they have to travel for an abortion, that’s an added financial burden that they would have to bear on top of the already extortionate costs of their education. Some of these students may also come from incredibly conservative cultures and/or religions and families, so they can’t contact their family for financial and emotional support regarding having an abortion. Even if they did procure the funds to travel for an abortion and go through with the procedure, they wouldn’t necessarily have the support and after care that a home student would be able to access with ease.

              […]The UKVI rules that international students are bound by, only allow them a leave of absence of up to 60 days (or fewer in many circumstances, depending on the immigration status, type of visa, course of study, sponsorship – the list goes on). While up to 50 weeks of maternity leave is granted to domestic students at QUB, for international students, our visa rules supersede this. The only way an international student can take time off their course for longer than 60 days is to terminate their visa and leave the country, then reapply for a visa when they are ready to return to their studies. This is far from a solution to a crisis pregnancy – where an international student is forced to leave the country to access an abortion, or leave the country to go home and have the child and be faced with the financial implications of travel, visas, not to mention healthcare and consequently childcare. This coupled with the complicated conservative cultural and religious norms some students may come from puts them in a very vulnerable situation.

              UKVI’s current visa regulations are limiting and not fit for purpose. They don’t take into account pregnancies as is. Let alone in the case of students in the North of Ireland, where the law demands that they stay pregnant, but international student visa rules don’t allow them to take the necessary maternity leave should they carry on with the pregnancy. We are putting our international students in vulnerable positions, by failing to provide them the vital support they need in situations like this. Becoming pregnant, or caring for a child should not become a barrier to anyone’s education.[25]

             

The new funding scheme to provide access to free abortion care on the NHS for people from Northern Ireland will not necessarily cover international students or students from Great Britain who have to travel outside Northern Ireland for an abortion. The scheme eligibility requirements exclude people who do not reside in Northern Ireland. It is unclear whether students whose family homes are outside Northern Ireland will meet the residency requirement, therefore students who become pregnant while studying in Northern Ireland might have to pay privately for abortion care if they travel to England. In these circumstances, an early medical abortion with pills ordered online is the most financially accessible option.

              Anti-choice legislators or activists might claim that the law prevents people from having abortions. Student officers know from experience that the law does not prevent abortion, it sustains a status quo where a safe but illegal abortion with pills is often the only abortion that a young person in Northern Ireland can access. Young people, including students, have always had illegal abortions in Northern Ireland.[26] In June 1979, a 21-year-old woman from Sandy Row named Charlotte Hutton died following a backstreet abortion.[27] Marie Therese McGivern observed in 1980 that “it is likely that Northern Ireland has a significant backstreet [abortion] business”.[28] McGivern describes a pattern in the 1970s and 1980s that student officers and pro-choice activists see today: it is young people and working class people with little money and support that have no option but to rely on illegal abortion. Geraldine Quigley wrote of illegal abortions taking place in South Belfast in 1992.[29] The difference between the situation today and the death of Charlotte Hutton in 1979 is that an early medical abortion with pills the typical method of illegal abortion in Northern Ireland in 2018 is safe.[30]

              Abortion stigma, poor sex education and limited access to aftercare further compound the negative impact of the lack of access to abortion. Many young people in Northern Ireland have received sex education via religious providers that promote abstinence and demonise contraception and abortion.[31] When they enter adult sexual relationships during college or university, students raised with poor sex education have very little knowledge of how to deal with a crisis pregnancy. The criminalisation of abortion deters students from accessing aftercare following an illegal early medical abortion with pills. The recent prosecutions of a 21-year-old woman and a mother who procured abortion pills for her 15-year-old daughter are a reminder that it is not safe to disclose an abortion to either medical professionals or housemates.[32]

              The law on abortion in Northern Ireland has harmed thousands of students and young people over the last 50 years by forcing them to travel to access abortion or risk prosecution or health complications by having an illegal abortion. Increasing numbers of students from outside Northern Ireland are coming here to study: the current abortion law strips those students of the bodily autonomy they had in their home countries and leaves them with very little support if they fall pregnant in a new country. The current law on abortion has a negative impact on student welfare and can harm individual students’ academic performance by forcing them to miss class to travel for an abortion, or to have an illegal abortion by taking abortion medication without medical supervision.

              NUS-USI will fight alongside its member unions and fellow abortion reform campaigners to achieve reproductive justice for anyone who can become pregnant in Northern Ireland, for as long as is necessary. Regarding abortion law reform in Northern Ireland, NUS-USI recommends that

(i)                      abortion be completely decriminalised; and

(ii)                    measures be introduced to ensure that abortion services are available on a free, safe, legal and local basis to anyone in Northern Ireland who needs them.              

 

December 2018

 


 


 


APPENDICES

 

 

Appendix A: ‘Home to V8te’ campaign materials

 

Appendix B: Current NUS-USI policy on abortion

 

Appendix C: NUS-USI ‘Trust Us’ campaign briefing

 

Appendix D: Images of pro-choice demonstrations at Queen’s University Belfast, 2018


APPENDIX A

 

‘Home to V8te’ campaign materials, April 2018

 

  1. NUS Connect website, ‘#HomeToV8te – support the right to choose in Ireland’, 24th April 2018 < https://www.nusconnect.org.uk/hometov8te>

(Accessed 7th December 2018)

 

See screenshots below:

 

 

 

APPENDIX A (cont.)

 

 

  1. ‘Home to V8te’ campaign briefing, April 2018

 

(see next 4 pages)

 


APPENDIX B

 

Current NUS-USI policy on abortion - ratified during NUS-USI Conference, 28-29 March 2018.

 

DECRIMINALISATION OF ABORTION IN NORTHERN IRELAND
 

Conference notes the following:
 

  1. Abortion is available in Northern Ireland only where there is a risk to the life or long term mental or physical health of the pregnant person, which excludes cases where there is fatal foetal abnormality, or a pregnancy as a result of sexual crime. In most circumstances, abortion is a criminal offence punishable by a maximum sentence of life imprisonment under the 1861 Offences Against the Person Act. The 1967 Abortion Act was never extended to Northern Ireland.
  2. On 10 February 2016, the Northern Ireland Assembly voted against reform to allow lawful access to abortion in cases of fatal foetal abnormality and sexual crime. As a result, the abortion law in Northern Ireland remains the most restrictive in Europe and incompatible with minimum human rights standards.
  3. The Northern Ireland Public Prosecution Service has initiated criminal proceedings under sections 58 and 59 of the Offences Against the Person Act for unlawful procurement of abortion and abortifacient medications in a minimum of three separate cases since 2016. An April 2016 case resulted in a suspended sentence of 3 months’ imprisonment, and in January 2017 a couple received formal cautions for attempting to procure an abortion with Mifepristone and Misoprostol.
  4. In October 2017, the Department for Women and Equalities announced that it would cover the cost of treatment for pregnant persons who travel from Northern Ireland to England for abortion care. As a result, pregnant persons lawfully resident in Northern Ireland will now be offered free abortions at the point of access if they travel to England to exert that right.
  5. Scotland’s Chief Medical Officer announced in October 2017 that she will enable persons, for whom it is clinically appropriate, to take Misoprostol to complete an abortion at home. This change brings Scotland in line with French and Swedish health policy, which allows patients to take one or both abortion pills at home.

 

Conference further notes with great concern that:

 

  1. In early 2017 the PSNI implemented a crackdown on the procurement of Mifepristone and Misoprostol to induce abortion.
  2. These medications appear on the World Health Organisation's list of essential medicines and are already used in NI hospitals for miscarriage management and a very limited number of lawful medical abortions. However, Mifepristone and Misoprostol are regarded as ‘poison’ under the 1861 OAPA for the purpose of criminalising abortion.
  3. Although people who travel from Northern Ireland to England to access a termination are eligible to receive free abortion care on the NHS as of November 2017, the cost and logistics of arranging transport, accommodation, time off work and childcare continue to present practical barriers to accessing abortion outside Northern Ireland.
  4. Obtaining an early medical abortion by purchasing abortion pills online is a method of abortion which is frequently relied upon by persons who face additional barriers when travelling to access abortion, or find it impossible to travel altogether. Victims and survivors of domestic violence, people with disabilities and people with caring responsibilities can find themselves in this position.
  5. The criminalisation of abortion in Northern Ireland deters people from accessing aftercare, for fear of being reported to the PSNI if they disclose that they induced an abortion with medication.

 

Conference believes that:

 

  1. Individuals who make the decision to terminate a pregnancy should be supported and cared for in Northern Ireland, rather than disempowered and isolated by having to travel elsewhere to do so.
  2. Access to reproductive healthcare is a student welfare issue: students can face crisis pregnancies which have an adverse effect on their personal and academic lives. The inaccessibility of safe and legal abortion in Northern Ireland places an undue burden on these students in an already distressing situation.
  3. Abortion should be governed by the same robust regulatory and ethical frameworks as all other medical procedures.

 

Conference thus resolves:

 

  1. To campaign for reproductive justice for all and the removal of barriers to abortion access in Northern Ireland.
  2. To work with organisations such as Alliance for Choice and Gender Jam in advocating for abortion reform in a manner which is inclusive of women, trans men, non-binary and gender fluid people.
  3. To support the introduction of legislation which supersedes Sections 58 and 59 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 and has the effect of ensuring full decriminalisation of abortion in Northern Ireland.
  4. NUS-USI Women’s Conference will support legislation to decriminalise all aspects of abortion healthcare, including: to save the life of the pregnant person, to preserve physical and mental health, in cases of sexual crime, where there is a diagnosis of a fatal foetal abnormality, for socio-economic reasons, and at the request of the pregnant person.
  5. To support the campaign for reproductive justice and decriminalisation of abortion worldwide.

 


APPENDIX C

 

NUS-USI ‘Trust Us’ campaign briefing, October 2018

 

(see next 13 pages)


APPENDIX D

Images of pro-choice demonstrations at Queen’s University Belfast, 2018

  1. Project Choice demonstration on International Women’s Day, 8th March 2018

 

APPENDIX D (cont.)

 

  1. Amnesty International QUB student action, 26th November 2018

 

 

 

 


[1] Most abortion rights activism in NI in the late 20th century took place outside the political sphere. Anti-choice protesters targeted the Brook Clinic and Family Planning Association, making progress on reproductive rights feel impossible: Jennifer Thomson, Abortion Law and Political Institutions: Explaining Policy Resistance (Palgrave Macmillan, 2018) p116

[2] See Ciarán Hanna, ‘The Organisation and Development of NUS and USI in Northern Ireland – 1970-1990’ and ‘A brief political overview – 1972-2012’. Both available at <http://nus-usi.org/who-we-are/history-of-nus-usi/>

[3] Suzanne Breen, ‘No Choice, No Debate’, Fortnight, Issue 338 (April 1995). Accessible online via Linenhall Library ‘Divided Society’ archive (from now on, ‘D.S. archive’).

[4] NUS-USI, ‘Abortion information: Euro ruling’, Women’s News, Issue 56 (October/November 1991). D.S. archive.

[5] The Society for the Protection of Unborn Children Ireland Ltd v Stephen Grogan and others [1991] 3 CMLR 849. See also Maxine Brady, ‘Here we are in 1992…’, Fortnight, Issue 304 (March 1992). D.S. archive.

[6] Amelda O’Neill, ‘Right to Information: SPUC versus Irish students’, Women’s News, Issue 45 (December 1989/January 1990); Kevin Magee, ‘Border Hopping’, Fortnight – Issue 283 (April 1990). D.S. archive.

[7] The clinic was recently renamed Common Youth. ‘Demonstration in support of Brook Centre’, Unity, Vol. 3, No. 44 (December 1991); ‘Abortion by the “back door”: Brook means abortion’, Alert (July 1992). D.S. archive.

[8] ‘Abortion legislation must protect women says NUS-USI Women’s Officer’, NUS-USI press release (January 2016) < http://nus-usi.org/2016/01/14/abortion-legislation-must-protect-women-says-nus-usi-womens-officer/> (accessed 9 December 2018)

[9] Pete Hodson, ‘Conversation with Dominic Doherty, Deputy Director of QUBSU’, The Gown (3 March 2015)

 

[10] Reproductive Health and Law Advisory Group, ‘Briefing Paper: Northern Ireland and Abortion Law Reform’ (September 2018) <https://reproductivehealthlawpolicy.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/gb-briefing.pdf> (accessed 9 December 2018)

[11] CNR = Catholic/Nationalist/Republican; PUL = Protestant/Unionist/Loyalist; Pete Hodson, ‘Conversation with Dominic Doherty, Deputy Director of QUBSU’, The Gown (3 March 2015)

[12] ‘Abortion by the “back door”: Brook means abortion’, Alert (July 1992). D.S. archive.

[13] Tara McAvoy and Tyler McNally, ‘QUBSU delegate to USI Congress to face Council following “breach of mandate”’, The Gown (7 May 2013) <https://thegownatqub.wordpress.com/2013/05/07/qubsu-delegate-to-usi-congress-to-face-council-following-breach-of-mandate/> (accessed 9 December 2018)

[14] Brendan Hughes, ‘Belfast student reps wear Repeal jumpers during Leo Varadkar visit’, The Irish News (5 August 2017) < https://www.irishnews.com/news/2017/08/05/news/belfast-student-reps-wear-repeal-jumpers-during-leo-varadkar-visit-1102642/> (accessed 8 December 2018)

[15] QUBSU Campaigns: Project Choice
<http://www.qubsu.org/change/Campaigns/ProjectChoice/> (accessed 8 December 2018)

[16] Jason Ashford, ‘Medical Students for Choice hold panel discussion in Belfast – “It’s not about being pro abortion”’, Off the Record NI (4 December 2014) <https://web.archive.org/web/20141223023546/http://offtherecordni.com/2014/12/its-not-about-being-pro-abortion-medical-students-for-choice-hold-panel-discussion-in-belfast/> (accessed 8 December 2018)

[17] ‘Meet the pro-choice crusader changing the lives of women’, Marie Claire (24 March 2017)

<https://www.marieclaire.co.uk/reports/abortion-support-network-changing-lives-486221> (accessed 9 December)

[18] ‘But Why, Mummy, Why?’, Women’s News, Issue 55 (September/October 1991). D.S. archive.

[19] Fiona Bloomer and Lesley Hoggart, ‘Abortion Policy – Challenges and Opportunities’ (February 2016), Knowledge Exchange Seminar Series <http://www.niassembly.gov.uk/globalassets/documents/raise/knowledge_exchange/briefing_papers/series5/dr-bloomer-and-dr-hoggart-version-2.pdf> (accessed 9 December)

[20] Abigail Aiken and others, ‘Self reported outcomes and adverse events after medical abortion through online telemedicine: population based study in the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland’, BMJ (2017), 357

[21] Lesley Hoggart and Sally Sheldon, ‘Women’s experiences of abortion’ (November 2016), Knowledge Exchange Seminar Series <http://www.niassembly.gov.uk/globalassets/documents/raise/knowledge_exchange/presentations/series6/hoggart161116ppt.pdf> (accessed 9 December 2018)

[22] James Tapper, ‘Rise in women travelling from Northern Ireland to England for abortions’, The Guardian (21 July 2018) <https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jul/21/women-travelling-from-northern-ireland-to-england-for-abortions> (accessed 9 December 2018)

[23] Amelia Gentleman, ‘“It was the scariest thing I’ve ever done”: the Irish women forced to travel for abortions’, The Guardian (31 October 2015) <https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/31/abortion-ireland-northern-ireland-women-travel-england-amelia-gentleman> (accessed 9 December 2018)

[24] Jo Gowers, ‘It’s time to decriminalise abortion’, NUS Connect (September 2016) <https://nusconnect.unioncloud.org/articles/it-s-time-to-decriminalise-abortion> (accessed 9 December 2018)

 

[25] Hamsavani Rajeswaren, ‘International Students and Abortion Rights’, Project Choice Blog
(10 April 2018) < https://projectchoicequb.wordpress.com/2018/04/10/international-students-and-abortion-rights/> (accessed 9 December)

[26] Stephanie Williamson, ‘Me, my mum, and our abortion stories: why Ireland must vote yes’, Dazed (24 May 2018) <https://www.dazeddigital.com/politics/article/40150/1/me-my-mum-and-our-abortion-stories-why-ireland-must-vote-yes-repeal-eighth> (accessed 9 December)

[27] Avila Kilmurray, ‘Women in the Community in Northern Ireland: Struggling for Their Half of the Sky’, Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review, Vol. 76 No. 302, p180 <https://www.jstor.org/stable/30090857> (accessed 9 December 2018)

[28] Marie Therese McGivern, ‘Abortion in Northern Ireland’ (1980), The Field Day Anthology of Irish Writing Volume 5: Irish women’s writing and traditions (2002), Bourke, Kilfeather, Luddy, MacCurtain, Meaney, Nic Dhonnchadha, O’Dowd and Wills eds., pages 390-91

[29] Geraldine Quigley, ‘The case for abortion law reform in Northern Ireland’, Fingerpost - Women’s Issue (March 1996). D.S. archive.

[30] Abigail Aiken and others, ‘Self reported outcomes and adverse events after medical abortion through online telemedicine: population based study in the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland’, BMJ (2017), 357

[31] Anna Cafolla, ‘I Get Called A “Child Killer” And A “Satanist” – What It’s Like To Be An Abortion Chaperone in Northern Ireland’, Grazia (5 March 2015) < https://graziadaily.co.uk/life/real-life/abortion-northern-ireland/> (accessed 9 December 2018); Amnesty International, ‘Northern Ireland: Barriers to accessing abortion services’ (2015) p21-22

[32] ‘Girl “taken from classroom to be questioned by police over abortion pills”’, Belfast Telegraph (6 November 2018) < https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/northern-ireland/girl-taken-from-classroom-to-be-questioned-by-police-over-abortion-pills-37497844.html> (accessed 9 December 2018);
Deborah McAleese, ‘Why we reported abortion pills girl to Northern Ireland police’, Belfast Telegraph (6 April 2016) <https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/northern-ireland/why-we-reported-abortion-pills-girl-to-northern-ireland-police-34602857.html> (accessed 9 December 2018)