Conservative Friends of Israel – Written evidence (TUP0009)

 

Conservative Friends of Israel works to promote its twin aims of supporting Israel and promoting Conservatism in the UK.

 

Executive Summary

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1)      What difference would an opt-in policy make?

 

  1. Between 1927 and 1946, following the repeal of the 1927 Trade Disputes and Trade Union Act, union members were required to opt-in rather than opt-out of the political levy. This was reversed in 1946 by the post-war Labour Government, but retained by the Government in Northern Ireland.

 

  1. The present system does not give union members an active choice. They may not wish to contribute to the political fund of their union but are either unaware of the ability to opt-out or find it difficult to do so. Their fees may therefore be used to fund campaigns that the member would prefer not to support.

 

  1. If union members were required to opt-in rather than opt-out, they may examine more closely how their money is spent and decide against opting-in if their money goes towards supporting campaigns such as BDS and those indicated in Annex A.

 

  1. By implementing an opt-in policy, as set out by Clause 10, members would be able to exert greater control over their union membership fees, and monitor the political expenditure of their union.

 

Evidence

 

Unite

 

  1. Unite the Union, the biggest trade union in the UK, with 1.42 million members, supports BDS, and specifically supports: “the boycott of any goods produced from illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank; divestment from financial holdings in any companies, funds or organisations complicit in the ongoing illegal occupation and oppression of the Palestinian people; sanctions against Israel for its continued illegal occupation, flouting of international law, and construction of an apartheid regime”.[2]

 

  1. A motion passed at the Unite conference in 2014 stated: “Conference notes that the Israeli government continues to govern as an apartheid state and is guilty of the crime of apartheid. The oppression faced by ordinary Palestinians at the hands of their colonial oppressors and the way in which their plight is used as a political bargaining chip cannot be allowed to continue as it has done for so many decades…[3]

 

  1. Unite donated £5,000 in June 2015 to Richard Burden MP, a Labour MP with well-documented anti-Israel views. Burden repeatedly accuses Israel of apartheid and uses Twitter regularly to attack Israel.[4]

 

  1. Unite donated £3,000 in June 2015 to Jim Cunningham MP, an anti-Israel campaigner in Parliament. Cunningham regularly denies Israel’s status as a democracy and dedicates a section on his website to expressing his anti-Israel views.[5]

 

  1. Unite donated £3,900 in June 2015 to Louise Haigh MP, the Vice-Chair of Labour Friends of Palestine and the Middle East.[6]

 

  1. Unite donated £4,000 to Lisa Nandy MP (Shadow Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change) via Wigan Constituency Labour Party in March 2015. Nandy is the Vice-Chair of Labour Friends of Palestine and the Middle East and campaigned strongly for the Labour Party’s boycott of G4S (due to G4S’s contracts with the Israeli Government).[7]

 

UNISON

 

  1. UNISON, one of the UK’s largest trade unions, with 1.3 million members, supports the BDS movement.[8]

 

  1. In June 2015, UNISON launched a campaign to press local government pension funds to divest from companies “associated with the occupation of Palestine”, including security contractor G4S and defence manufacturers. UNISON instructed members to “make sure that [their] pension scheme doesn’t invest in the occupation”.[9]

 

  1. A campaign pack was made available to UNISON members entitled “Palestine: Is your pension fund investing in the occupation?”[10] Also made available was a model presentation for branch meetings and further information on the BDS movement.[11]

 

  1. This campaign, funded by UNISON members, undoubtedly cost a significant amount of money. There is no clear spending review or published breakdown of costs of UNISON’s political campaigns; members are not informed on how their fees are spent.

 

National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers (RMT)

 

  1. The National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers (RMT) has over 80,000 members and supports the BDS movement; encouraging members to boycott all Israeli goods.[12]

 

  1. RMT boycotts all Israeli goods: “Our union has a clear policy for the boycott of Israeli goods as one of the ways that we can register our outrage and horror at the massacre that has been unleashed on the Palestinian people”.[13]

 

  1. RMT donated £4,000 in June 2015 to Grahame Morris MP. Morris is a staunch anti-Israel campaigner in Parliament and Chair of Labour Friends of Palestine and the Middle East.[14]

 

  1. RMT donated £2,500 to Lisa Nandy MP (Shadow Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change) via Wigan Constituency Labour Party in March 2015. Nandy is the Vice-Chair of Labour Friends of Palestine and the Middle East and campaigned strongly for the Labour Party’s boycott of G4S (due to G4S’s contracts with the Israeli Government).[15]

 

National Union of General and Municipal Workers (GMB)

 

  1. The National Union of General and Municipal Workers (GMB) has 631,000 members and supports the BDS movement.[16]

 

  1. In 2013, GMB banned its members from visiting Israel and the Palestinian territories with Trade Union Friends of Israel (TUFI). It voted in June 2013 to uphold a 2011 decision to ““take a lead in driving forward the boycott and divestment initiatives of “companies who profit from illegal settlements, the occupation and the construction of the wall”.[17]

 

Conclusion

 

  1. Clauses 10 and 11 of the Trade Union Bill have the potential to deliver transparency and accountability and would be well-received by a public increasingly cynical of powerful but opaque institutions.

 

  1. Currently, trade unions use their political funds to gain influence within Parliament, with many donating money to specific MPs as well as directly financing the Labour Party.

 

  1. The financial support provided to a number of MPs inevitably aids activity favourable to the trade union; in this instance the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement has been highlighted as a major cause for concern.

 

  1. Though the trade union leadership have objected to the proposed policy changes put forth in the Trade Union Bill, Clauses 10 and 11 are in the interest of all trade union members as well as the wider public who stand to benefit from such constructive change.

 

  1. In no other walk of life would it be considered acceptable to have to opt-out of donating money to a cause or organisation. Donation to a cause or political party by a member of any organisation should be an act of individual choice. The current opt-out system of the trade union political fund fails to provide this choice and does not offer transparency to a union member.

 

  1. Trade union members should be made aware of how their contribution to political funds is spent; many members may currently be unaware that the political fund of their union is spent supporting campaigns such as BDS and may choose to opt-out if a breakdown of expenditure (as required by Clause 11) was provided.

 

  1. The Conservative Party Manifesto stated that these transparent processes would be put in place during this parliament; it is in the interest of transparency that these changes are delivered.


ANNEX A

TRADE UNIONS: Anti-Israel Activity (2010-2016)

 

Unite

GMB

Unison

Communication Workers Union

USDAW

UCATT

BFAWU

ASLEF

TSSA

Fire Brigades Union

RMT

TUC

Unite

 

 

Unite reminded their activists that ‘London and Eastern region is expecting a large turn out from members in a show of solidarity with the people of Palestine’ (Unite the Union London and Eastern News, 24 July 2014, link).

In the briefing pack that Unite created for trade unionists, they said the Israeli ‘regime tramples on human rights in sites supplied by G4S’ and said that ‘evidence of G4S complicity in the suppression of Palestinian rights is overwhelming. G4S can carry on until someone stops them. Most trade unions in Britain…have strong policies of solidarity. What are we waiting for?’ (Unite the Union Stop G4S, accessed 4 February 2016, link).

 

The motion called the union to ‘vigorously promote a policy of divestment from Israeli companies’ with a boycott of Israeli goods and services ‘similar to the boycott of South African goods during the era of apartheid’ (The Jewish Chronicle, 4 June 2010, link).

 

They said: ‘Unite further calls on the UK government to demand the Israeli government halt its military action and to make it clear that should it fail to do so then a move for international sanctions will be launched within the United Nations Security Council and the European Union…

Unite is clear about its understanding of the current situation. This isn’t about rockets from Gaza. It’s about Israel fighting to maintain its control over Palestinian lives, and Palestinian land.

It’s about Israel feeling able to commit war crimes with complete impunity. It’s about the world media indicating that Palestinian lives are worth less than Israeli lives. It’s about the fact that Palestinian children are being killed at the rate of one every three days. It’s about millions of Palestinians living under illegal occupation. It’s about the brutal siege on Gaza, and the third military assault on a trapped population in less than 6 years. It’s about more than sixty laws that discriminate against Palestinian citizens of Israel.

It’s about Israeli-state racism and apartheid. It’s about ethnic cleansing. It’s about colonisation, and over 500,000 settlers. It’s about Israel’s systematic violations of international law and Palestinian human rights’ (Unite the Union News, 11 July 2014, link).

 

 

 

        ‘Raise awareness, build support, campaign and lobby for a free and independent Palestine;

        Highlight the suffering, and support the Palestinian population in Gaza living under siege; Palestinians living in the West Bank who are seeing their land illegally seized by Israeli settlements and are forced to navigate checkpoints to go to work, school and hospital and in Israel, where they are treated as second class citizens and subject to racist laws;

        Work with other NGOs and all other supportive bodies in the UK and around the world and develop a Unite campaigning and leverage strategy around BDS within the next 12 months. Notably against complicit companies involved in the occupation, the apartheid wall and the illegal settlements (such as Veolia, G4S and Sainsbury’s) through workforce pressure, contracts and pension funds;

        Encourage members to call on supermarkets and retailers to stop using companies which export goods from illegal settlements;

        Continue to support and offer practical help to the Palestine Solidarity Campaign, and encourage all branches to affiliate to PSC;

        Encourage branches and regions to send representatives on delegations to Palestine, to further strengthen the solidarity with Palestinian workers;

        Organise and facilitate with other union bodies and campaigning groups, a national speaking tour to include lawyers and child prisoners/families in the next 12 months;

        Raise the issue and table motions for support of the BDS campaign in the European and Global Federations;

        Organise and facilitate national or regional delegations to be sent to Palestine at least twice a year;’

(Unite the Union: Israel and Palestine Global Solidarity & Peace, accessed 4 February 2016, link).

 

The focus would be particularly on companies involved in ‘the occupation, the apartheid wall and the illegal settlements’ (i24 news, accessed 4 February 2016, link).

 

The letter also called for the Prime Minister to ‘impose immediate sanctions and an arms embargo on Israel until it complies with international law and ends the blockade and the occupation (The Guardian, 7 September 2015, link).

GMB

 

 

 

 

They also banned its members from visiting Israel on delegations organised by the Trade Union Friends of Israel. The measures included a compromise amendment condemning Hamas as well as Israel (BDS News, 11 June 2013, link; The Jewish Chronicle, 17 September 2009, link).

 

Unison

 

Communication Workers Union

 

 

 

USDAW

UCATT

 

BFAWU

 

ASLEF

 

 

 

 

TSSA

 

 

 

Fire Brigades Union

 

 

 

Before the vote, their activity prompted Unite and Unison to back BDS (The Jewish Chronicle, 15 September 2009, link).

 

RMT

 

TUC

(N.B. the TUC is the umbrella group for trade unions in the UK. About seven million workers belong to the 58 unions which pay to affiliate to the TUC. (BBC News, 28 August 2008, link).

The statement welcomed ‘the creation of a unity government for the Palestinian Authority, which necessarily involves both Fatah and Hamas’ and urged ‘the UK Government and the European Union to support this development’.

It also called on the Israeli state to pay for humanitarian assistance and rebuilding Gaza and urged unions and their members to give to international trade union humanitarian aid funds aimed at providing assistance to the people of Gaza (PSC News, 10 September 2014, link).

Its significance cannot be underestimated. Thanks to this statement, it is now official TUC policy to campaign for an arms embargo on Israel, a suspension of the EU-Israel Association Agreement and to push forward the campaign to stop companies profiting from Israel’s crimes.

This is a huge boost to the solidarity movement, and is strongly welcomed by PSC, which continues to work with the UK’s unions in the struggle for justice for Palestinians’ (PSC News, 10 September 2014, link).

10 February 2016

3

 


[1] Ian McNichol, Evidence to  Select Committee on Trade Union Political Funds and Political Party Funding, 4 February 2016

[2] http://www.unitetheunion.org/news/statement-of-solidarity-with-the-palestinian-people/

[3] http://www.unitetheunion.org/uploaded/documents/UNITE%202014%20composite%20Israel%20and%20Palestine%2011-18858.pdf

[4] http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmregmem/160208/160208.pdf

[5] Ibid.

[6] Ibid.

[7] Ibid.

[8] https://www.unison.org.uk/content/uploads/2015/07/2015-National-Delegate-Conference_Decisions_Booklet_20150702.pdf

[9] https://www.unison.org.uk/news/article/2015/06/palestine-is-your-pension-fund-investing-in-the-occupation/

[10] https://www.unison.org.uk/content/uploads/2015/06/On-line-Catalogue23247.pdf

[11] https://www.unison.org.uk/content/uploads/2015/05/TowebPalestine-Pension-pack-appendix-3-presentation.pptx

[12] https://www.rmt.org.uk/news/support-for-demonstrations-to-stop-the-massacre-in-gaza/

[13] Ibid.

[14] http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmregmem/160208/160208.pdf

[15] Ibid.

[16] http://www.gmb.org.uk/assets/media/documents/congress/congress2013/GMB%20CONGRESS%202013_%20DAY%203.pdf

[17] Ibid.