Written evidence submitted by Achievement for All
Achievement for All 3As Response to the Education Committee’s call for evidence on the impact of COVID-19 on education and children’s services
Achievement for All welcomes this opportunity to provide evidence on the impact of COVID- 19 on education and children’s services. Achievement for All (AfA), an education charity, working across England and Wales, was founded in 2011 by Professor Sonia Blandford; the recommendations of the Lamb Inquiry-Special educational needs and parental confidence (Department for Children Schools and Families, 2009)- became the foundations of the Achievement for All charity programme. This followed a successful DfE funded pilot (2009-2011) in over 450 primary, secondary and special schools, along with PRUs. In 2012, the government announced extended funding for Achievement for All to include looked after children and those receiving free school meals. In 2014, the Achievement for All approach was recommended for all schools in the SEND Code of Practice:0-25 years (DfE/DoH, 2014, updated 2015). To date we have worked with over 5000 schools, colleges and early years settings.
Too often, being poor or having a special need will define the futures of our young people. This need not be the case. We know that disadvantaged children and young people can thrive given the right educational support and opportunities. We exist to ensure that all children have the right to achieve regardless of their background, challenge or need. We achieve this by working in partnership with teachers and involving parents, to break down the barriers to each child’s learning. We believe that the COVID-19 crisis has pushed the learning and consequent life outcomes of vulnerable and disadvantaged children and young people towards a precipice and we believe an immediate response is needed.
Schools and Colleges have reported very low engagement rates despite reaching out to troubled families; PRUs are reporting disturbing new trends such as coughing in the face of staff to trigger exclusion processes; children and young people with social emotional and mental health problems are being retraumatised in abusive family environments or through cyber-bullying; and school leaders are facing the prospects of jump-starting their school communities that were unprepared for the societal upheaval that lock-down has caused.
Never before has the social and emotional health of an education setting been more important nor valued.
Schools supported to remain open for children of critical workers
Whilst schools have remained open for ‘The implementation of the critical workers policy, including how consistently the definition of ‘critical’ work is being applied across the country’ - these include children of key workers and vulnerable children (those with an EHC Plan, those who have a social worker and others identified by the education provider or local authority) - attendance of these groups of children has generally been lower than anticipated, particularly amongst the vulnerable groups. Across the country, many children and young people from vulnerable groups have not attended school and have not carried out work set by schools.
In addition, we know that some children lack good parenting and loving relationships, which make a big difference to their development and social mobility. Some parents, be it through lack of employment, ill-health, or through their own negative experiences of school, lack the resources and/or personal capacity to provide this, which is even more stark in challenging times.
Poor mental health - particularly of the mother - is a significant impact factor for a child’s development of social and emotional skills. During the current challenging times, this reality can become heightened as pupils operate in isolation when we know that even in the best of times, too many children and young people have no one to talk to at home when they are worried or anxious.
Never before has the social and emotional health of an education setting been more important nor valued.
The capacity of children’s services to support vulnerable children and young people
The reintegration of children and young people back into education will be a monumental challenge. That is why Achievement for All, for the foreseeable future, will place wellbeing at the heart of learning.
Achievement for All’s high impact offer to support learning communities (from 2 - 24 years old children and young people, their teachers, and their families) with a range of classic and COVID-19 bespoke improvement programmes during these intensely challenging times.
Never before has the social and emotional health of an education setting been more important nor valued. The stresses and challenges that Covid-19 has placed on teachers, learners and all their family members have been profound and unprecedented:
The effect of provider closure on the early years sector, including reference to:
By September 2020, children in pre-school will have missed almost half a year of learning at a very critical phase of their educational development. This will mean more children ‘unready’ for primary school in September and the opportunities it has to offer; more children with unmet needs in their physical, social, emotional and behavioural development, including unidentified SEND or health factors and others presenting with issues impacted by social deprivation; and with loss of learning over almost half a year, teachers will have less knowledge of where the children are in their learning.
Transition activities are usually undertaken in the Summer term, comprising of a series of meet the teacher, visit your new class type events; where evidence from the Achieving Early programme (Achievement for All) shows that transition points are part of a journey for children, not an event. Good transition is about aligning practice, ensuring change is smooth and that each new stage or phase builds on what has gone before, ensuring individual needs are fully met. In the challenging times of today, transition for many children, along with teachers, will be a harsher experience.
The effect on disadvantaged groups, including the Department’s approach to free school meals and the long-term impact on the most vulnerable groups (such as pupils with special educational needs and disabilities and children in need)
The COVID-19 crisis has exasperated the existing attainment gap between disadvantaged groups and their more advantaged peers. This has been further hindered through digital disadvantage, including the digitally marginalized (those without access to a computer), those who have no experience of using online learning platforms or video conferencing and others whose school has failed to provide guided online learning along with regular video conferencing of lessons.
Although local authorities are overseeing how schools in the state sector are providing online learning and communication, this has been inconsistent across local authorities, exasperating the relatively significant divide in digital leaning between the state and independent sectors.
Schooling cannot fail to overlook the important place of the teacher in day to day interactions with pupils for their learning, wellbeing and future life chances. Independent schools have been significantly more likely than state schools to speak to pupils regularly through audio or video conferencing (including lessons via Zoom/ Teams along with tutorials), arrange online enrichment activities and provide formal opportunity for pupils to socialize virtually. Turning to the future, schools- primary, secondary and special schools, along with alternative providers, need to look towards blended learning programmes. If pupils and teachers are not experienced in this approach to learning, they are not going to use it effectively and efficiently in a crisis similar to what we are experiencing in the current pandemic; it is anticipated that some post-16- pupils may not return to education.
What contingency planning can be done to ensure the resilience of the sector in case of any future national emergency
The present moment is the right time to develop a more consistent child-centred approach to transition, with standardised expectations for the process, along with materials/ resources and strategies to ensure continuity in learning and development, with support and development online. With inconsistent opportunity for online communication across settings in England, teachers and practitioners have limited means to provide children and their parents/ carers with the support and direction needed and few may be thinking beyond what they normally do at this time of year.
A robust evidence base, built over decades, shows that attending good quality early years provision benefits children’s later outcomes, and that disadvantaged children can benefit in particular from this effect (DfE, 2015). More recent evidence shows that investing in focused professional development activity in the early years, to improve skills and practice in the existing workforce, can lead to rapid improvements in setting-level quality, children’s cognitive outcomes in language and numeracy development and their socio-emotional development (NSW, Department for Education, 2018). This approach needs to be available digitally.
Achievement for All works with schools and settings and has a workforce skilled and experienced in leading and embedding change. Having run a successful pilot project on Transition (Early Years), AfA is successfully supporting schools and settings so that they can make arrangements for September.
We continue to develop and sustain support for our learning communities (from 2 - 24 years old children and young people, their teachers and their families) with a rich and varied provision of classic and COVID-19 bespoke improvement programmes during these intensely challenging times:
AfA can also provide a diagnostic tool for checking teacher and pupil wellbeing.
In a project that has run since the start of COVID-19 in South Korea, AfA partner Dwight School Seoul, the following points summarise key findings; these should be considered in future learning. At the centre of on-line curriculum delivery and wellbeing support, sustainability is the key:
- How online learning impacts on the lives of staff and students
- Use platforms that are already used – do not roll out new IT programmes
- Google hangout and Microsoft teams work well
- Parent and carer wellbeing, what part do they play in their child’s learning?
- Do all students have a place to work, what is the learning environment at home?
- What other support is needed? (Safeguarding, Pupil Premium, English as an Additional Language, Education, Health and Care Plans)
- Good pedagogy and teacher fatigue, producing endless power points is not good pedagogy and causes teacher and learner fatigue
- How much time is healthy for students of all ages to be looking at a screen?
- Parents, carers, teachers, and students need fresh air
- There is no shortage of devices that can access learning
- High levels of enthusiasm for technology and learning needs to be maintained
- Parameters need to be in place, boundaries need to be set (GDPR, safeguarding rules).