Submission from Birmingham City Council (FDC30)

 

Introduction

 

  1. The leadership of Birmingham City Council strongly welcomes this inquiry as an opportunity to put over the case for fiscal and financial devolution.  The inquiry is timely in view of the joint Centred Cities campaign on these issues by the Core Cities, the GLA, the Mayor of London and London Councils. That campaign is in turn based on the work of the London Finance Commission, which included our Chief Executive Stephen Hughes amongst the commission members.  Attached to this submission is Stephen’s most recent article for the Local Government Chronicle which gives further thoughts on these issues.
     
  2. As a member of the Core Cities group we fully support the group submission and this short document is intended simply to add further detail and examples from the perspective of Birmingham and Greater Birmingham.
     
  3. The specific policy options being considered in this inquiry need to be seen in the context of the wider need for radical reform in how we fund and organise our local public services and as part of a wider consideration of the future role of local government and its contribution to economic policy.  In Birmingham we are developing a new model for “city government” involving a “triple devolution” to city regions, cities and neighbourhoods.  The full realisation of this model will require devolution of funding, new freedoms and flexibilities and integration of public services.
     
  4. The financial crisis facing many urban authorities in the next few years has been brought about because government has tried to force significant cuts in funding through an essentially unreformed system.  As a result those areas which are most reliant on government grants have seen the largest cuts, to an extent that now threatens the provision of even statutory services, whilst others are able to maintain services through council tax and retained business rates.  This situation means that reforms of the sort being considered by the committee are now not only desirable but essential as part of a wider reform to secure the future sustainability of local government. 
     
  5. Put simply, if government wishes to run local public services at a significantly lower cost then it must implement the radical reforms necessary to make that achievable (or face the consequence of ending many statutory services). If the aim is to move towards more autonomous councils, less dependent on government grants, then government has to legislate to provide sufficient freedoms to generate the local income needed to finance an acceptable level of services.  If we want to rebalance our economy and ensure that our great cities perform to their potential then we must enable the enterprising local leadership this will require.  The inquiry is an opportunity to make these points to all the political parties and to begin an honest debate about the way forward in the run up to the 2015 election.

 

Answers to specific questions in the call for evidence

 

How devolved areas would be defined geographically and set up

 

  1. In our new model of city government we recognise that cities must be governed at three different levels and the role of leadership is very much about linking these together effectively.  The appropriate geography will depend on the funding being devolved or the freedoms being granted. 
     
  2. Governance and accountability needs to be considered alongside the question of geography – some funding and powers may be appropriately given to fairly informal partnerships, but usually a formal level of government will be required.  There is scope for debate about where policy should sit on the spectrum from optional “deals” agreed with each city to the creation of new governance structures, as was the case with the London reforms of 2000.  Realistically any radical devolution will probably require strong accountability and governance structures, rather than temporary or specific agreements between cities and government.
     
  3. The role of investing in infrastructure, supporting the local labour market and planning strategically for housing and land use will primarily be carried out at a metropolitan or city region level.  In the case of the cities this will commonly be the conurbations or city regions previously covered by metropolitan counties (as with the London case) or the combined authorities now being developed by most of the cities.  However if this level of governance is less formal then accountability will have to rest with primary local authorities – in this case the individual districts within the metropolitan area.
     
  4. Financial reforms designed to support more integrated public services will be focused initially at the district level, though there is scope to rethink these on a city regional basis, for example health and social care or community safety work with police services already operating on a larger scale.

 

How public services, including employment, skills and welfare should be organised to complement devolution

 

  1. Our new model of city government echoes the Core Cities call for more integrated public services at both city regional and city levels, with Place Based settlements for each area allowing us to plan the provision of all public services in a joined up way.  This is not just a question of creating nominal budgets and partnerships at the local level.  It will require Whitehall to operate in a new way, with budgets allocated by the Treasury to places as well as functional departments.  Departments would not be able to access funding unless they are signed up to this locally integrated approach.  This will be essential to the success of these reforms, as separate departmental budgets would mean that they continue to determine how money is spent in a silo based approach.

 

How devolved areas should be governed, including the role of business in decision making; how devolved areas would be held to account

 

  1. We have partly covered this question in paragraphs 6 to 9 above.  We believe it is important for the business community to be closely engaged in decision making related to how we support economic growth, the labour market and skills.  The LEPs have been very variable in their effectiveness and in the strength of their partnership with councils.  We have had excellent business leadership in the Greater Birmingham and Solihull LEP, but even the best business leaders cannot replace the democratically accountable role of the local authority and do not have the resources to support the range of services required, so the larger city councils have tended to take on most of the support to these partnerships, including the accountable body status for holding large amounts of public money.  Therefore we need to maintain the benefits of close partnership working with business but place LEPs in a consultative role, as is already the case in London.
     
  2. Combined authorities seem to be the best available model for governance and accountability at the city region level.  But we believe there is a good case for exploring the development of stronger government structures around this model, including the possibility of replicating the GLA and elected mayor model in the other cities.
     
  3. Genuine local accountability must be based on freedom of local choice about the level of taxation and how funds are spent.  This means that the effective cap on council tax increases should be removed and further steps should be taken to remove ring fences around specific budgets.  Central government must stop trying to “have it both ways” by using the language of localism and freedom whilst imposing formal and less formal restraints on local choice.

 

The strength of the evidence that devolution would lead to economic growth, local improvement and better governance, including examples of what areas could do with their new powers such as use them to invest in infrastructure and local services.

 

  1. The Core Cities submission provides a good summary of the compelling evidence that greater freedom and devolution for cities leads to greater economic growth.  The future economy will be based on a global network of cities competing and collaborating with each other and the success of any nation will depend even more on the performance of its major cities.  Nations that give more freedom to their cities tend to have cities performing economically at above the national average, to the benefit of the national economy as a whole.
     
  2. As we mentioned in the introduction above, the case for reforming the funding of our local public services is even more critical.  The current system provides no freedom of movement for councils to raise the resources necessary to provide adequate services.  The council tax does not provide buoyancy and the banding system and valuations are decades out of date.  The tax is effectively capped and has been frozen for years and it provides only about a tenth of the spending of cities such as Birmingham.  Despite recent reforms, business rates are still basically a national system of taxation.  Innovations to provide for incentives for local growth (such as the New Homes Bonus) are in fact redistributing money from more deprived areas to those already experiencing growth.  The current system leaves too many councils dependent on government grants, whilst a lucky few are able to fund services from local resources.  The radical reform of this system is now long overdue and without reform it will be impossible to maintain adequate provision across the range of statutory services.
     
  3. Through our work with Lord Heseltine on the Greater Birmingham Project (following his report No Stone Unturned) we also made the case for a significant single funding pot for infrastructure, skills and economic development.  The report makes the case by reference to a) the increased speed of decision making and implementation that can be achieved at a local level, b) the benefits of joining up funding to create an integrated, flexible and place focused approach, c) improved accountability for local delivery and d) the potential for additional leverage of private sector funds through local partnerships and flexibility. 
     
  4. Specific local projects and programmes which the Greater Birmingham Project identified included:

 

 

Whether reform of the existing system (e.g. re-banding council tax, revaluing business rates, community budgets, government grants, formulas and taxes such as stamp duty) would be a precursor to, or run along with, large-scale institutional change

  1. We support the approach suggested by the Core Cities group submission – it is unrealistic to expect an entirely neat and orderly transition to a more devolved approach and we should not delay actions that can be taken immediately by waiting for structural changes or legislation that may take some years to arrive.

 

What changes should be made to devolved authorities borrowing powers?

 

  1. As pointed out in the Core Cities group submission, the Prudential Borrowing legislation means that there is no need for additional regulation of borrowing, such as a cap.  The slight relaxation of the cap on HRA borrowing announced in Autumn Statement 2013 should be seen as a very small first step towards a freer and more locally accountable borrowing regime.  The argument for this is particularly strong in the area of infrastructure investment, where a future asset is being created through borrowing.  In this area government should also take the initial provisions for Tax Increment Financing to the next stage quickly, by allowing more radical investment schemes, along the lines of those available to cities in the US.

 

The scope for areas to introduce new taxes and funding methods such as bonds and crowd sourcing, fees and charges.

 

  1. The basic principle should be to create a significantly greater level of fiscal autonomy and accountability to the local electorate.  Some reforms will be designed to underpin the delivery of basic local services, while others may be tailored to specific economic development purposes and (as with Business Improvement Districts) developed in partnership with the local business community.  One example is the work we are doing in Birmingham to develop a Tourist BID model.  This would fund investment in local environment and facilities and a city’s cultural and entertainment offer through contributions from hotels – possibly then leading to the development of a local bed tax, subject to legislation.
     
  2. A more sustainable finance system will also need to allocate resources much more efficiently to prevention and investment and away from funding the “costs of failure”.  Much more work should be done in partnership across government to establish the potential for innovative ways of shifting funds from future savings to the current investments that can generate them.  There may be considerable scope for innovations such as social investment, crowd funding and payment by results.  There should be much wider adoption of the “earn back” or “gain share” model that has now been agreed for the Greater Manchester City Deal, whereby economic growth provides returns for the local area and not just savings for the Treasury.  In Birmingham we have put forward a more specific earn back proposal related to the jobs to be created through our Birmingham Energy Savers programme.

 

 

What taxes might be devolved – for example council tax, stamp duty and business rates?

 

  1. The aim of the reform of local funding and taxation should be to create more buoyancy in a system that currently has very little.  That is the only way in which areas currently struggling economically and with a high level of service needs will be able to sustainably become more independent.  So, in addition to the proposals put forward in the London Finance Commission report and the Centred Cities campaign (and echoed in the Core Cities submission), we also suggest that it is worth exploring the case for and practicalities of a local apportionment of VAT going to local authorities.  VAT is much more responsive to local economic activity than property taxes such as business rates.
     

January 2014

1