Written evidence submitted by Tenants Union UK, Garden Court North and Greater Manchester Law Centre [IOC 155]
We write further to the invitation for written evidence issued by the Committee on 17th April 2020. Our response addresses the final point of your call – what action is needed to deal with the immediate post-lockdown impacts on those in the private rented sector. As a collective of organisations committed to protecting renters from homelessness in the wake of the pandemic, we have come together to set out pragmatic and realistic proposals for the reform of primary and secondary legislation. These reforms, we believe, will provide renters with a basic safety net and help to prevent a significant spike in evictions during the period of disruption caused by COVID-19.
The starting point of our paper is a shared belief that many renters will have accrued, and will continue to accrue, significant rent arrears during this period. Though we believe that further policy thought has to go into dealing with those arrears, our proposals have one central aim – to ensure that renters do not face eviction as a result of this public health crisis.
Our full proposals, including the legislative detail required to implement these measures, are detailed in the report below. Our main recommendations are:
Protection from eviction for private rented sector tenants following the Coronavirus pandemic
Background
The Coronavirus pandemic
Section 21 evictions
Alternative means of eviction on grounds of rent arrears
Recommendations
Changes to primary legislation
The Rented Homes Bill
Housing Acts 1985 and 1988
(a) Ground 1, Schedule 2 Housing Act 1985:
Rent lawfully due from the tenant has not been paid or an obligation of the tenancy has been broken or not performed. For the purpose of this ground, “rent lawfully due” does not include any rent in respect of which arrears have arisen where those arrears arise from or relate to the period of disruption caused by coronavirus.
(b) Ground 8, Schedule 2 Housing Act 1988:
Both at the date of the service of the notice under section 8 of this Act relating to the proceedings for possession and at the date of the hearing—
(a) if rent is payable weekly or fortnightly, at least eight weeks' rent is unpaid;
(b) if rent is payable monthly, at least two months' rent is unpaid;
(c) if rent is payable quarterly, at least one quarter's rent is more than three months in arrears; and
(d) if rent is payable yearly, at least three months' rent is more than three months in arrears; and for the purpose of this ground:
(i) “rent” means rent lawfully due from the tenant.; and
(ii) “rent lawfully due” does not include any rent in respect of which arrears have arisen where those arrears arise from or relate to the period of disruption caused by coronavirus.
(c) Ground 10, Schedule 2 Housing Act 1988:
Some rent lawfully due from the tenant—
(a) is unpaid on the date on which the proceedings for possession are begun; and
(b) except where subsection (1)(b) of section 8 of this Act applies, was in arrears at the date of the service of the notice under that section relating to those proceedings.
For the purpose of this ground, “rent lawfully due” does not include any rent in respect of which arrears have arisen where those arrears arise from or relate to the period of disruption caused by coronavirus.
(d) Ground 11, Schedule 2 Housing Act 1988:
Whether or not any rent is in arrears on the date on which proceedings for possession are begun, the tenant has persistently delayed paying rent which has become lawfully due. For the purpose of this ground, “rent lawfully due” does not include any rent in respect of which arrears have arisen where those arrears arise from or relate to the period of disruption caused by coronavirus.
New notices: changes to secondary legislation and prescribed information
Assured Shorthold Tenancy Notices and Prescribed Requirements (England) Regulations 2015.
(a) the How to Rent Checklist is updated to include information on the financial protections afforded by the government to tenants and landlords during the pandemic, and the extension of the pre-action protocol to the private rented sector (see below);
(b) Regulation 3 is amended either by:
(i) removing Regulation 3(4); or
(ii) inserting a new paragraph that requires a landlord to provide their tenant with a copy of any How to Rent checklist updated during the course of the pandemic; and
(c) the prescribed information is further defined to include a precedent Early Notification letter and Early Notification Response to be sent alongside any How to rent checklist amended during the course of the pandemic (see Annex 1).
For all notices where proceedings have not yet been issued: pre-action protocol for possession claims
(a) If a tenant falls into arrears, the landlord should contact them as soon as possible to discuss:
(i) the cause of the arrears;
(ii) the tenant’s financial circumstances and their entitlement to benefits; and
(iii) how the tenant can repay the arrears in a way which is affordable to them.
(b) A landlord should work with their tenant(s) to resolve any Housing Benefit or Universal Credit (housing element) problems.
(c) Bearing in mind that rent arrears may be part of a general debt problem, a landlord should direct their tenant(s) to seek assistance from the CAB or other debt advice agency.
(d) In any case where a notice of eviction is served and a more recent version of the How to rent checklist takes effect before proceedings are issued, the landlord must:
(i) provide their tenant(s) with the most recent How to Rent checklist; and
(ii) comply with paragraphs (e) and (f) below. Any letter sent in compliance with (f) may take the same form as the Early Notification Letter to be provided alongside the How to Rent Checklist.
(e) After serving a notice of eviction, a landlord should:
(i) continue to communicate with their tenant(s) about the matters outlined in (a) and (b);
(ii) agree to postpone issuing court proceedings where current rent is being paid and a reasonable amount towards the arrears.
(f) Before issuing proceedings, a landlord must:
(i) write to their tenant(s) to explain their reasons for seeking possession;
(ii) offer their tenant(s) the opportunity to tell them about any personal circumstances or matters that they wish to be taken into account, and give them at least 14 days to do so;
(iii) offer advice and assistance to their tenant(s) to enable them to sustain their tenancy drawing on the advice contained in the How to rent checklist;
(iv) consider any representations their tenant(s) make; and
(v) explain their reasons for continuing to seek possession.
(g) When issuing proceedings, a landlord must include with the claim form a schedule stating:
(i) whether they invited their tenant(s) to make representations;
(ii) whether and how those representations were considered, and with what outcome; and
(iii) brief reasons for bringing the proceedings.
Changes to the Civil Procedure Rules
Sanctions for failure to comply with the pre-action protocol
Presumption in favour of ADR in section 21 claims
(a) it increases the chances of preserving the landlord-tenant relationship and producing a satisfactory outcome to everyone;
(b) it is a much cheaper alternative to litigation if successful;
(c) it reduces pressure on the courts at issue stage;
(d) it does not prevent either party from accessing the courts should agreement not be possible;
(e) it prevents arbitrary evictions where the issues between the parties could have been amicably resolved; and
(f) in doing so, it reduces the pressure on Local Housing Authorities to find suitable alternative accommodation where demand far outweighs supply.
The court’s duty to consider whether non-court dispute resolution is appropriate
Changes to HMCTS court forms
Claim form
(a) all claim forms for possession which involve a pre-action process should be strengthened to require applicants to demonstrate that they have engaged with their tenant(s) to attempt to resolve the issues giving rise to the prospect of eviction; and
(b) all claim forms that may be used for the purposes of section 21 claims should be amended to require the claimant:
(i) to append the Early Notification Letter and/or pre-issue correspondence to the claim form, and any response; and
(ii) to provide a statement addressing the matters outlined in paragraph 35(g) above; and
(iii) to confirm whether they have engaged in or are willing to consider ADR and, if not, why not.
The claim form should make clear that there is a presumption in favour of ADR and provide a non-exhaustive but limited list of acceptable reasons why ADR might not be appropriate.
Defence form
(a) they have received the Early Notification Letter and/or pre-issue correspondence;
(b) they responded and, if so, whether their response is appended to the claim form;
(c) in their view, their landlord has complied with the pre-action protocol; and
(d) they have engaged in or are willing to consider ADR and, if not, why not.
Directions Questionnaire
Existing court proceedings
(a) confirm whether they wish to continue with their claim;
(b) outline the steps they have taken to ascertain the current circumstances of the tenant and/or to reach settlement;
(c) confirm whether they are willing to engage in ADR; and
(d) provide any other relevant information, including any exceptional hardship that they will suffer if the claim does not proceed.
If the landlord fails to respond within a set time, the proceedings will be struck out automatically.
Summary of recommendations
(a) That the Housing Acts 1985 and 1988 be amended so as to provide a consistent definition of rent ‘lawfully due’ from the tenant which excludes any rent arrears arising as a result of the period of disruption caused by the pandemic, as drafted in paragraph 27 above.
(b) That the Rented Homes Bill be amended to include provision for the immediate abolition of section 21 evictions from the date on which the Bill is passed.
(c) Alternatively, that the Assured Shorthold Tenancy Notices and Prescribed Requirements (England) Regulations 2015 in the following ways:
(i) the How to rent checklist is updated to include information on the financial protections afforded by the government to tenants and landlords during the pandemic, and the extension of the pre-action protocol to the private rented sector;
(ii) Regulation 3 is amended either by:
(A) removing Regulation 3(4); or
(B) inserting a new paragraph that requires a landlord to provide their tenant with a copy of any How to rent checklist updated during the course of the pandemic; and
(iii) the prescribed information is further defined to include a precedent Early Notification letter and Early Notification Response to be sent alongside any How to rent checklist amended during the course of the pandemic.
(d) That the pre-action protocol for possession claims by social landlords be extended to the private rented sector and require private-rented sector landlords to take the steps outlined at paragraph 40 above.
(e) That the sanctions that may be imposed on social landlords for failure to comply with the pre-action protocol apply equally to private-rented sector landlords and include provision for the court to direct a stay for a period of one month to allow the parties opportunity to negotiate.
(f) That there be a greater emphasis on ADR in the pre-action protocol.
(g) That Part 55 CPR be amended to reflect the court’s powers to impose sanctions for failure to comply with the pre-action protocol.
(h) That Part 55 CPR be amended so that any section 21 claim may not be issued unless the landlord has attended an initial mediation meeting or is exempt from doing so.
(i) That Part 55 CPR be amended to enable the court to direct the parties to consider non-court dispute resolution in section 21 claims.
(j) That the claim forms for possession proceedings be amended to strengthen the requirement on landlords to engage with the pre-action process and, in section 21 claims, to require the landlord to append and/or include the information outlined at paragraph 58(b) above.
(k) That the defence forms be amended to require tenants to confirm the steps taken by their landlord to comply with the pre-action protocol, as outlined at paragraph 59 above, and to provide details of any other person living in their household and any known vulnerabilities, medical conditions or disabilities for the purposes of section 6 Equality Act 2010.
(l) That the directions questionnaire for all tracks be amended to require parties to state the reasons whether they have engaged in or are willing to consider ADR and, if not, why not.
(m) That the court issues a direction following the lifting of any stay under PD51Z requiring the landlord to provide details of the progress of the claim, any correspondence between the parties and/or change of circumstances as outlined in paragraph 62 above.
Annex A: Early Notification Letter and Early Notification Response
Example Early Notification Letter
Dear [Tenant],
I am writing to inform you that I am considering serving you with Notice Seeking Possession. My reason is
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
I enclose an updated version of the How to Rent Booklet which contains information for tenants about assistance available to tenants who have had difficulties paying their rent or face other hardship as a result of the COVID-19 crisis.
I also enclose a reply for you to send back to me that will enable me to consider your current circumstances and any alternative suggestions you would like me to consider.
Please send the Reply form back to me within 14 days.
Yours sincerely,
[Landlord]
Example Early Notification Response
Dear [Landlord],
Thank you for your letter, which I received on ...............................................
I am writing in response to tell you about my financial circumstances and the circumstances of my family.
As a result of the Coronavirus pandemic, I am having additional difficulties making rent payments because
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
My household income is ............................................... [per week/ per month]
I have to spend money on
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
The amount of money I am having to spend on these items is ………… [per week/per month]
I have taken the following steps to try to improve my financial circumstances
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
I have made the following applications for help:
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
I live in the property with [give details of the people you live with and the impact that eviction would have on them]
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
In order to avoid court proceedings, I would like to reach an agreement with you [set out details of any payments that you can make now, whether you expect to be able to increase payments in the future and how you will be able to repay the arrears over time]
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................
I hope that you will consider my circumstances and that we can agree a way forward.
Yours sincerely,
[Tenant]
April 2020
[1] See, for example, the executive summary of the Homelessness Monitor: England 2019. London: Crisis
[2] ‘Overcoming the Barriers to Longer Tenancies in the Private Rented Sector’ (April 2019) and ‘A New Deal for Renting’ (July 2019)
[3] ‘Solving Housing Disputes’ (JUSTICE, March 2020) at §3.29
[4] ‘ADR and Civil Justice’ (December 2018)
[5] ‘Solving Housing Disputes’ at §3.31
[6] ‘Solving Housing Disputes’ at §3.33
[7] ‘Solving Housing Disputes’ at §3.47