Written Evidence Submitted by Mrs Alice Wright [SH0 0035]
• Do the schemes Shared Ownership and Right to Shared Ownership provide good value for money for the potential users of the scheme?
The property is a 4-bed semi, built in 1907, and occupied now by Mr and Mrs Wright, both in their sixties.
We bought a 25% share in the property in September 1994 under a shared ownership scheme in operation at the time called ‘Do it Yourself Shared Ownership’ (DIYSO) This scheme is no longer in operation. Although the house was in a poor state of repair in 1994, we were in a desperate situation following relationship breakdown leaving Mrs W with nowhere to live with her five children. The DIYSO scheme seemed to be our only chance of getting suitable accommodation. The situation meant that we did not pay attention to the implications of shared ownership, the 99 year lease, the poor condition of the property, and the difficulties of re-sale, nor was this made clear to us by the conveyancer or by the Housing Association.
Before we could buy our share, and before contracts had been exchanged, the Housing Association (Equity Housing) insisted that we carry out the following repairs:
o Retile the roof
o Replace the wood frame that held the tiles
o Overboard the kitchen ceiling because of damage caused to the ceiling by a leek in the toilet in the bathroom directly above the kitchen
o Repair the leek in the toilet
o Remove the drylining in the cellar which had caused damp
o Replaced bricks in the cellar walls which had expanded and crumbled
o Overboard and plaster the cellar ceiling because of horsehair slats
o Remedy damp in the ground floor front lounge by taking the wall back to the brick work, plastering and replacing the skirting
The repairs to the property and the 25% share was funded in cash with help from parents as at the time we did not qualify for a mortgage.
We have now been in the property for almost 29 years and still have only a 25% interest. The costs of running a large family and the running costs of the property, in particular high energy bills, strained our income to the limit leaving no opportunity to raise money for a further share.
For us, the scheme has not provided good value for money for the following reasons:
• The property did not meet standards when it was purchased. It was only because we were cash buyers that we were able to provide our share. A mortgage company would not have lent the money, given the condition of the property.
• We should not be expected to keep in good repair a property built in 1907 and which had inherent defects for which we should not have been responsible. The full repairing lease could be varied to reflect the age of the property and its condition on purchase.
• The existence of the DIYSO scheme at the time encouraged us to buy a property which it was beyond our means to maintain.
• What challenges are associated with repair costs being covered by those utilising the Shared Ownership schemes?
In common with all Shared Ownership leases our Lease is a full repairing lease. From 1994 to date we have maintained the house and garden to the best of our ability including replacing doors and windows and partially refitting the kitchen. The housing association will profit from a large slice of the increased value through improvements to the property and 28 years of maintenance and repair funded entirely by us. We consider this to be unfair.
We did not fully understand the implications of the full repairing lease until damage was caused to the property by extensive and major works carried out on the adjoining property, a property which is not under the scheme and is privately owned. We were not aware of the provisions of the Party Wall etc Act 1996 and, although notifiable under the Act, the works were carried out without any notice to us and in some part without the requisite Building Regulations approval. We asked the neighbour about the work being done but he consistently refused to give us information and denied that work was being done. Ultimately we had to resort to legal advice, incurring solicitor and barrister fees, structural engineer reports, surveyor reports, flue survey reports etc. We discovered, through an application for disclosure of documentation, that the work included basement extension and substandard underpinning causing structural instability to our property, removal of two chimney breasts without building regs approval, and installation of an en-suite bathroom in the roof space, making the adjoining property four storeys high. We repeatedly asked the Housing Association for help but they merely referred us to the ‘full repairing lease’. They said that we should take the neighbour to court and would get the money back that way and that if we could not afford to repair the property we would have to sell up. We did not have the money up front to pursue the matter to a conclusion and we still have outstanding legal fees of thousands of pounds. The HA’s insurance did not cover the damage to the underpinning as it did not come under the head of ‘subsidence’.
We consider this whole situation to be wholly unfair. We felt that the Housing Association should have leant their weight to Court proceedings which would have helped us to protect a property owned by them in which we had purchased a right to live.
• How viable is full ownership through the Shared Ownership scheme and/or the Right to Shared Ownership Scheme?
In 28 years we have not been able to purchase further shares in the property. Shares continue to rise in value year on year, taking them further out of reach. This increase in value is, in part, due to our maintenance of the property over the years so we are in effect making it harder for ourselves by maintaining the property.
August 2023