Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee
Oral evidence: Climate adaptation and emergency response, HC 68
Tuesday 17 November 2026
Ordered by the House of Commons to be published on 17 November 2026.
Watch the meeting
Members present: Mr Alistair Carmichael (Chair); Charlie Dewhirst; Helena Dollimore; Sarah Dyke; Ben Goldsborough; Terry Jermy; Josh Newbury; Dr Roz Savage; Henry Tufnell.
Questions 183 - 260
Witnesses
I: Paul Tompkins, Deputy President, National Farmers Union; Tracey Garrett, Chief Executive Officer, Flood Forum UK; and Katia Sanhueza-Pino, Co-Director, Flooded People UK.
II: Phil Garrigan, Chair, National Fire Chiefs Council; Councillor Matt Boughton, Chair, Safer and Stronger Communities Committee, Local Government Association; and Andrew McGill, CEO, Water Management Consortium.
Examination of witnesses
Witnesses: Paul Tompkins, Tracey Garrett and Katia Sanhueza-Pino.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: Thank you. Good morning. I am Katia Sanhueza-Pino. I am Co-Director at Flooded People UK, and I have supported flooded communities for almost a decade.
Paul Tompkins: Good morning. My name is Paul Tompkins. I am primarily a dairy farmer based in York. It is very cold up there today, I can tell you, but it is great, isn’t it, that I can arrive from my farm back down here to find some warmth and more rain. I am in the juxtaposition of being in a drought, but it is also raining as well—perhaps something you will cover. The rest of the time, I am also Deputy President of the National Farmers Union, a role I am enormously proud of.
Tracey Garrett: I am Tracey Garrett, CEO of the National Flood Forum. We are a charity that supports people who have flooded or are at risk of flooding.
Paul Tompkins: Glad you have such influence on the weather. I might be calling on this Committee in the future.
Thank you for your attendance. I want to start with a very broad question to the three of you about how flooding impacts on communities. In this regard, I am looking for the whole range of different impacts. There will be business impacts. There will be health impacts, economic impacts, and wellbeing impacts as much as anything else. From the perspective of your respective organisations, tell us how you are affected. Katia, I will start with you again.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: Thank you. It is important to say that the damage that you see after a flood is the smallest part of a flood event. For communities, it is life-changing. For any household, and for any business as well, it is a life-changing event. It causes trauma and anxiety, and it is a long process of recovery. For many, there is no going back to normal. That is something they will live with forever. From what we hear from people on the ground, there is a lack of co-ordination. There is a lack of specific information and guidance on where they can get support. It is often communities that step up in the response, filling gaps in the formal provision that may be there. There are areas where it works really well, but we see that there is a lot of pressure on communities to act in the response.
It is a financial impact as well for many households, not just for the uninsured but also for the insured. Also, where there is financial support available, sometimes it arrives too late so there is an upfront cost that people have to face before any grants are made available. That has an impact on families and businesses. We have the wellbeing impact as well. We know that two-thirds of flooded people face mental health problems and only about half of those who are flooded receive any practical or wellbeing professional support, so there is a significant impact on people’s lives.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: When the emergency services—which do an immense and excellent job—retreat, that is often when we hear the most praise from communities. It is often an unknown as to who steps up to take on the recovery process, and that recovery process is long living. That is where there is a gap of who provides that very specific support that covers the whole range of aspects that people face.
Paul Tompkins: It will not come as a surprise that flooding can have a disastrous impact on flood businesses around the country. Also, of course, repeated floods have serious impact on soil degradation and can take many years to recover from.
I would like to take a moment to consider the economic impacts of flooding. We survey our members on a regular basis, and they tell us that over the last 10 years, on average, our farming members are spending around £40,000 on responses to climate events, such as flooding. When we are operating on such thin margins, that is quite a bill for us to absorb into our cash flows.
If I expand a little bit further—as you have offered to think about—when I have been out to talk with farmers about the impacts of flooding on their farms, while they talk to me about the logistics of moving cattle around, of changing cropping rotations or of the financial implications, I don’t need to scratch far below the surface before they start telling me about the emotional impacts of what it is brought to their lives, their families and how they respond. I would like to make sure that, as a Committee, we are aware that these are people at the heart of the problem here that are trying to respond to an emergency situation.
To finish on slightly positive note, farmers are part of the response to flooding events as well. I know you are going to hear later from community responses to events such as flooding, but farmers are ready to be part of the solutions too. They want to not only help mitigate the effect and the possibility of floods, but also help respond towards them. As we mentioned earlier, we have seen really good examples this summer, and I see them during the winter months and flooding times too. So financial implications, and emotional ones, but we stand ready to support the response to floods.
Tracey Garrett: Flooded people face a huge amount of trauma. They talk about not being able to sleep when it rains. They do shifts to watch the water levels. Home does not feel like home anymore. Their sense of safety is completely eroded. There are financial impacts. Even though they may have insurance, there are a lot of out-of-pocket costs that they never get reimbursed for. They may have to take extensive time off work. Work might not be that understanding about taking a million calls regarding drying out your home or putting it back together.
There are also health implications. We worked with one community that was 12 years post flood and their homes had not been dried out properly, so they were all suffering with respiratory diseases and illnesses. There are a lot of health implications as well as the mental health implications, such as 36% of people suffer from PTSD.
Just to go back to the financial cost, we did a study in Shrewsbury of the financial cost for businesses, and it was almost 50% more than the official figures recorded, so there is a huge impact on businesses as well. The effects of flooding go on for one to three years and for some people it goes on for a lifetime, so it is a lifetime sentence.
Tracey Garrett: There really isn’t that much, to be honest with you. Even if there has been some mental health support, the "stories after the storm" research show that people found it very difficult to access that support with only 10% actually managing to access support. If there is any support—which there generally isn’t—it is very difficult for people to get it. With the upcoming refresh of the Flood and Coastal Erosion Risk Management Strategy, I hope that there is an opportunity there to address some of the issues that communities face, particularly the mental health support.
Tracey Garrett: Not necessarily. If you flooded once, it tends to be that that is how you feel about it. Those people who have spent tens of thousands of pounds on protection, are still mentally impacted every time it rains. I don’t think it is particular to one particular type of community. It is just if you have flooded or almost flooded.
Paul Tompkins: It still needs improvement, Chair. You are absolutely right to suggest that, in order to provide proper water resilience all year round, we need to be able to store water in the winter months and then use it in the summer. That requires three pillars: investment, planning and then also the ability to fill those reservoirs. We really do urge the Government to open their water infrastructure grant, which was suggested back in August would be open to farmers to start building more reservoirs. We know that there are up to 200 farmers that are ready to start building if we can bring together the three parts to that plan.
Paul Tompkins: We have from a national level, and I think we might touch on this some more. While we recognise that the national planning policy framework is trying to undo some of these issues, when we translate it into local authority understanding of permitted development rights, there are some challenges. Therefore, we do need to see expanded permitted development rights for on-farm reservoirs, but also better understanding inside local planning authorities.
Chair: That takes us on nicely to the questions of communication with affected communities. Sarah, you are going to lead our questioning there.
Paul Tompkins: The NFU wholly supports this Committee’s views—which I know you have reached conclusions on before—that in the event that farmers are holding on to flooded water, then they should be adequately compensated for doing so. Absolutely, that is a given.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: Thank you. Yes, I think flood warnings are massively important for flooded communities. Nobody would want to be without them, and I think there is an ambition to improve the messaging within that.
For those properties that flood, awareness is really the problem, as are those that are at risk who we want to address as well. I think it would help if the messaging contained a more actionable and accurate details on where to get information and what to do. However, we always risk that that message will cause panic or raise the question of what can be done to prevent this from happening.
With the increase in climate impacts and increased storms, we see a whole range of communities and areas that are now at risk that were not at risk before, so it does need careful targeting and messaging, especially where specific actions are detailed and are specific to a location, as well as where people can get support when they are facing an event.
If I may go back to the catchment-level approach, in terms of looking at catchment-level plans combining green and grey infrastructure, there is a great example such as the Severn Valley Water Management Scheme, which is being developed, working together with landowners, farmers and communities, but also looking at all the benefits that transport, infrastructure and all the multi-infrastructure levels can see from this. It is a combined puzzle that we need to look at, both in terms of messaging and warning those on the ground who may see the impact, but also in terms of what is being looked at and what is being done holistically to prevent this.
Paul Tompkins: As Tracey contributed earlier, it is often when communities have experienced flooding events that we see the best plans come into place afterwards. I think you are right that, while Somerset has been unfortunate to suffer flooding events, that is often where we can learn about where to do best going forward. I have seen a similar approach in Lincolnshire. When I speak to farmers around water, I have a clear message that, “Either quality flooding or drought is coming to a catchment near you very soon”. Therefore, we have to learn from each other.
Where we do see local resilience plans working well, that is the key to the future, but this is our challenge: while we might have recognition that food production and flooding events are important for our critical national infrastructure, translating that to local resilience plans is often a challenge.
Where I see communication working well is when farmers understand the sensitivities of the catchment in which they farm and, therefore, what the potential implications are going to be, whether that be a flooding or drought event. The challenge is that that is not always seen everywhere. I have seen that work well in Somerset. I have seen it work well in Lincolnshire. Where I have not seen it work so well is around Peterborough and Cambridge—sorry if we have representatives in the area.
The challenge there is that communications are still happening through informal WhatsApp groups, where the people who may operate sluice gates are waiting for a call to come through at 9 o’clock in the morning from a decision that has been made two days ago about whether the sluice is going to be opened or not. Those informal structures are not working well, so we must make sure we understand more from where it is working well in the country and formalise local resilience plans in order that we can make real difference to how water is being managed as it comes in deluges.
Do you think that the Government should back community-led monitoring units like this and link them into official flood warnings? All of that data would help to close the gap between warning people about what they know, because Tracey has already talked about that risk, that people know when those black clouds roll in, and the reality of what is coming so that they can prepare. Tracey, would you like to pick up on that?
Tracey Garrett: Yes. I will go back and answer the previous question as well in a second, but I think there is a lot that can be done to utilise and work with communities, but none of that comes without investment. What we see when we work with communities is a lot is asked of them, which isn’t particularly well supported through the funds or the means to help them.
I think there are mechanisms by which that could improve. The LRFs could work a lot more with communities. The RFCCs could work a lot more with communities, but also organisations such as ours and Katia’s. We could also act as third parties working and supporting communities. I think there is a lot of will to do that. Therefore, yes, the answer is communities absolutely could support that, but it needs to be supported.
To just go back to your previous question, it can be a lottery depending on where you live and the personnel who work at your local agencies, even right down to the personality of those personnel. A lot of people are working extremely hard in local agencies and care deeply about their communities but cannot do so much because of resources or restrictions. We see that one third of people who are at risk of flooding in England don’t have any idea, so there is a huge piece to do on awareness. I would suggest that organisations like ours can support that awareness piece.
When you talk about warnings, people report that a lack of resource at the Environment Agency has led to warnings not being quite as well interpreted as they were before. They used to get a human interpretation, so local areas had a much better understanding of whether they were going to flood or not. Now they have to do that for themselves or look at gauges or run out into the night to look at water sticks, so there is that. Then often people and communities tell us that they do not see anybody. They do not hear from anybody. They are very lucky that, if they need emergency support, that tends to arrive.
With other agencies, if it is midnight on Saturday night, it is very difficult for them to support that, so neighbours support neighbours. One of the overriding comments that comes back from communities is that they have no idea who to contact. For them, it does not matter whether it is surface water flooding or river flooding, but from an agency perspective that is really important because you need to get to the right person. They report very little communication at that point, so for me it is about improving the awareness among those people who are at risk and have not flooded yet, investment to support communities to support themselves and utilising third party organisations like ours.
Tracey Garrett: Yes, it would certainly help, but it does not always have to be a government agency that runs that. It can be supported in other ways. Having one single point of contact for all flooding would really help, but it does not have to be an agency responsibility. It can be delegated if you will.
Paul Tompkins: Sarah, can I add to that?
Sarah Dyke: Yes, of course.
Paul Tompkins: A single point of contact can be helpful because it can be a resource that is available at all times, but what we just have to be a little bit cautious about is—as Tracey rightly pointed out—there are some really effective local agency staff that are the best people to help somebody through a flooding event, so we must not replace one with the other. I would suggest it is a dual approach. We need one point of contact in order that data is collected in one place, but we must make sure that local farmers are able to access local agency staff too.
Paul Tompkins: Yes. I am tempted to not use the word “devolved” because that seems to be the buzzword at the moment, but the devolved understanding of flood management is so very important, but I recognise the importance of single contact national frameworks working too.
Sarah Dyke: Thank you. Katia.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: Thank you. Yes, I think that Flood Action Online addresses a lot in terms of awareness of risk and preparedness, but it perhaps falls short on the recovery pathway, which often overlaps with the response immediately after the emergency ends.
For ordinary people on the ground, one place of contact or a place to receive information that is consistent and co-ordinated would be useful. If that is led by the Government, it is then an authoritative position that is trustworthy and people can read it and trust it. However, that needs to filter down to local authorities that have local knowledge and need resources to activate and mobilise their teams and the plans that they have that are adapted to the local area. It would be helpful for residents and businesses to have that, as long as it is consistent and co-ordinated and not confusing anyone in terms of what it actually is they have to do.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: Like I said earlier, people who have experienced flooding are as prepared as they can be. Those who have experienced flooding will always be on edge and looking for those triggers, and sometimes the flood warnings are received after the levels they use as triggers to prepare have already been reached.
It is those communities that are at risk but have never experienced flooding that we need to consider. So, perhaps there needs to be a targeted exercise in emergency planning to understand how we can communicate, how we can reach those communities and what it is that they can do.
We need to understand that a community’s ability to respond and prepare will be different. It depends on the demographics, on the availability of leadership, the ability to volunteer, levels of deprivation and marginalisation, so we cannot assume that all communities have equal capacity to respond. Where there are gaps and we identify that there is no reaction on the ground, we need to prepare for that, and we need to make sure that we do not leave the most vulnerable behind.
Tracey Garrett: Yes. I think there is awareness for those people who have never been flooded before and, as we said, a lot of people do not even know that they are at risk, so there is quite a job to do there in raising awareness. Then also, if somebody is aware that they may be at risk and they sign up for a flood warning, so many people do not know what to do if they get an alert or at what point to take what action. I think there is quite a bit that we would need to do around supporting people to understand, or giving very clear instructions on the types of things you might do depending on the level of alert or warning.
Some of the feedback that we get about warnings is they either come too late and they are already stood in water, or they come too early. This is a very difficult situation because if they come early, and people go ahead and prepare and they put all their furniture up and they take all the actions that they need to take, and then it does not happen it is a very big emotional burden to carry. However, it is also difficult because if you had not warned them and it came it would have been even worse, so there is a challenge around that and we accept that.
The warnings either come too late or too early and people really do miss the local interpretation that gave them a much better idea of whether they were truly at risk or not. If you look at the warning sites and the gauges, they are often not that accurate. It is very hard for people to make the right decisions.
Paul Tompkins: We have a communications lag problem with the Environment Agency at the moment. The agency conducts continual reviews of its assets to ensure they are in good condition for flooding events. That happens on a continual basis, but it has only published the asset condition of our flood protection up until June of this year. I am worried that the prolonged dry weather that we experienced right through the summer has undermined some of our assets. Yet we have no sight of what that might be and, therefore, we cannot start taking action on the ground.
If I have one ask of the Environment Agency at the moment it is that we have a timely publication of the condition of all of its assets in order that we can find where there may be problems and then address them.
Chair: That is just a question of updating a website. Right. Thanks. Ben, do you want to come in on this?
Tracey Garrett: I was actually referring to support for communities, but I think we all know that we need more investment in our flood protection. The Climate Change Committee thinks that we are not spending anywhere near enough for the flood risk that we face now and into the future with climate change impacts, but what I was specifically referring to was investment to support communities to do more if we want them to help with a warning system, even to help make their community more supported and more able to respond to flooding, or even to raise awareness around it.
I think we ask so much of communities, particularly in the flooding world. People are in flood action groups. They also work. They also have illnesses. They also support people and have caring responsibilities. They do all of that. If we are going to ask them to do more, we need to support that in some way.
Trying to prepare for the worst-case scenario and you are getting advice from, maybe in this case, six or seven boards, how do you navigate that? Katia, if we start with you and work down the board, that would be great.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: It is very tricky for communities to navigate that. In terms of preparedness, we have excellent examples of communities that do the work on the ground, the flood wardens that go out and warn the neighbours or deploy barriers or the road closure signs and schemes that we are trying to support communities with. All that takes time. It takes time to hand over that responsibility to communities from local authorities. It requires really good collaboration from local authorities with communities, and it needs trust and it needs resource in the community that is willing to do that. It is a time cost but also then the cost of that. What are the resources that are needed? Are there specific plans to fund those?
There are also downsides. Sometimes I have been called into areas where flood wardens were struggling, where they felt quite isolated or they felt under-resourced and under-equipped, or where the only flood wardens who volunteered to support were people who were flooded themselves, so they could not look after their own homes and households while at the same time volunteering and supporting others.
In terms of the financial cost, it has already been mentioned that the economic cost to businesses is immense and there is very little support for that. There are consequential damages to flooding from businesses but also to households, and people, families lose income. According to a Zurich report this year there is an average loss of £3,000 per household. So there is a significant impact beyond just the actual damage to materials and goods within the property.
In terms of wellness and wellbeing, it has been covered a lot especially in the report of the National Emergencies Trust. There are significant gaps in that, which has an implication for people’s wellbeing and their ability to continue to work and function within society. The cost that you invest in preparing a community and equipping a community and avoiding flooding is less than the damage that we see.
Paul Tompkins: Yes, good points. The problem with a multi-agency response to flooding events is that the impact on farm businesses gets diluted or deprioritised because we see acute pressures often in more urban areas. The way in which we can go about resolving this is ensuring that the Government have a standard methodology for understanding the impact of a flooding event on our food production systems. That in itself will demonstrate the importance of mitigating flooding events for our food production and what that might then translate to the consumer. If we have that broad understanding and recognition, we will be able to raise the profile and the importance of flooding events on farms to those multi-agency responses.
Tracey Garrett: Preparing can cost thousands. We talk to people who have spent tens of thousands of pounds in PFR and not everybody has that resource available to them, so there are some people who will never be able to prepare in the way that they might need to. It is a cost for those people who are at risk. If they do flood, recovery can cost thousands and thousands. Even if they have insurance, there can be lots and lots of costs that they are not able to recoup. I think, when it comes to the emotional and physical cost, it is probably incalculable because the impact is so far reaching, lasts months and years in most cases.
For me, awareness is raising the awareness for those people who currently do not know they are at risk and preparing those people who do know that they are at risk. That is where the real saving is because for every £1 invested in preparation, it saves £8 in future flood cost, so it is really key.
Paul Tompkins: As we have heard, local resilience plans have to be the key to unlocking the farmers’ ability to navigate a flooding event. It is crucial that the farming voice in those local resilience plans is well heard. If there are too many—as you have suggested—that could dilute that effect, but I want to recognise that each of those agencies probably have roles to play. It is just that we need to make sure that they do not drown out the farmers’ voice in those decision-making processes.
Chair: We are going to move on to look at issues around surface water flooding. Charlie.
My experience of it is that you do have the drainage board, Yorkshire Water, the Environment Agency, riparian owners, and yet there is that lack of co-ordination. Are there examples that you have come across in the role of the NFU where you have seen really good practice in terms of working together?
Paul Tompkins: There is not enough, Charlie, is the answer to what we must improve. You touched on something that is really important here and that is around the role of internal drainage boards who are key to ensuring that we have proportionate and effective flood resilience. Internal drainage boards that have been around now since 1937 do an amazing, unrecognised job of ensuring that we do not have significant flooding events. However, they were set up in 1937 and, therefore, we do need to make sure that they are fit for the future too.
I know that you will hear from other contributors who are far better versed in this, but if there is one point I can make sure you do speak to ADA and others about is: what is the regulatory framework that needs to change? What statutory instruments do we need to get through this House to ensure that our internal drainage boards become effective resource managers rather than just pumping agencies? That is something that we really do need to get over the line.
Where I have seen good examples—not just in Somerset, so I am not going to return there for Sarah’s benefit now—and what I would lean on is where we have seen the storms more recently run through Lincolnshire, the response to that programme has been very effective. The local resilience plan that has been built there is something that I think we can translate to other parts of the country.
Paul Tompkins: Yes, and you will know from locally as well that the IDBs are willing to take on some of the work of the Environment Agency. They want to be part of it. They might need to amalgamate to be more effective. However, the cost of underinvestment that has happened on some of our rivers because the Environment Agency has not invested for the last few years, makes that transition very difficult. That is something that we need to try to unlock in order to see a more proactive way going forward where farmers, through IDBs, have a more direct responsibility for effective flood management.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: Yes, absolutely. Going back to catchment-level plans, they are essential to look at tackling flooding from all sources. That includes fluvial flooding, but also the impact on surface areas. Inner-city and dense urban areas are really challenging to address, from warnings and alerts that cannot go out because it is very hard to forecast where the water will fall, to then looking at the drainage network, which in many places is under stress and over capacity. Therefore, we need to look at all the measures that are further upstream, whether that is with sustainable drainage systems but also with natural flood management in the upstream catchment. I think that is where—and I repeat myself—in terms of going into grey and green infrastructure, catchment-level planning is key here, with joint targets at catchment-basin level.
Tracey Garrett: Yes. I think rural flooding can be as important as flooding anywhere and, in particular, because of the food impact, the farming impact, and also these rural and often isolated communities, if they flood on a repeated basis, there is a compound impact for them, so I think it is really important.
With regard to surface water, just more generally, it is very difficult to predict it. Even the Environment Agency risk assessment is very unclear who is at risk, who is not at risk. Is it future risk? Is it now risk? Particularly from a community perspective, moving into perhaps more urban areas, they do not know who to talk to about it and they get passed from pillar to post around it, so it is a very difficult experience for them.
Chair: Moving on then to questions around volunteer and community responders. Terry, you are going to lead on this.
Tracey, I want to go back to local resilience forums because we have spoken about them quite a bit this morning. Obviously, it is a very formal process led by local authorities, a role for government. Then we have all of these wonderful people in the community volunteering, just getting on with it in my experience. Do you think there is enough co-ordination between those two distinct groups?
Tracey Garrett: No. Again, it comes down to where you live and which local resilience forum. The resilience forums are very much focused on organising organisations and different agencies and much more of that approach at a higher level. I think communities experience local resilience forums differently in different areas. Some have a stronger relationship with their local resilience forum. When I was researching this, some of the feedback was that communities did not even bother with their local resilience forum because it felt impenetrable, it felt far away and distant, so they just got on with it on a very local level.
Tracey Garrett: There is always opportunity to do more when it comes to learning. I suppose it is: who is your audience? I am not clear on what communications local resilience forums have between themselves. I do not know how much communication goes on there, but my own personal view would be that more communication about really good examples is absolutely a way to go.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: As you said, yes, there are very good examples, and volunteers are doing an excellent job. They are community volunteers who perhaps have not been flooded themselves. So, where there is capacity, where there is leadership and where they want to do that, we should equip them with the resources, the training and the powers they can have, but they are not currently responders. It is a very delicate issue whether we make them statutory responders. Again, in communities where that capacity isn’t there, we need to prepare for that eventuality and make sure that we take them along with us and invest in emergency planning that addresses their needs as well.
We spoke earlier about farmers being compensated for land given over for flooding, but often it is the farmers that do the proactive work, raising the alarm or responding to flood incidents. Should farmers be compensated or financially supported to undertake that work? In the Welney example, this farmer spends hours and hours looking after this particular area for free. Should they be compensated more?
Paul Tompkins: We must recognise that if we are going to address the issues that are facing us around climate resilience, whether it be a flooding event today, a wildfire tomorrow, it is only going to be a community response to those events that actually is going to be effective. Farmers are at the heart of those rural communities, and they stand ready to support. I have also seen examples of where farmers feel curtailed or unable to interject for fear of reprisals, whether that be that they can store flood emergency flood defences on their farms, but might not be able to move them when they can spot that there has been a breach just slightly further up the channel. They are often the first to see it as well.
In wind events that we have seen in the past, in high winds, they are the first to spot where the cables have come down and, therefore, where the response might need to be. We are the eyes and ears on the ground. We want to be part of the response to it, but we are not always is able to, so empowering our local communities to be able to be part of a community response will help us be more resilient to whatever the event that we are going to look into in the future.
Then lastly, Tracey, I just want to go back to what you were saying at the start. I was struck by your comments about the emotional impact on people that have been involved in flooding. I was conscious that we put quite a lot of pressure on flood volunteers. Are we too reliant on their support? We take it for granted in lots of cases, certainly Governments and local authorities. Are we too reliant and do not recognise the human impact on their volunteering?
Tracey Garrett: That is probably quite difficult because a lot of those people who volunteer do so because they are impacted and not doing it would also be a challenge. But I would say, yes, we do not support communities enough when they help. As Katia said, she has spoken to flood wardens. I have also spoken to flood wardens who are receiving abuse for closing down roads that are flooded and not necessarily getting the support that they might need as volunteers. So, yes, more support is absolutely key, definitely, to protect them, the ones that we currently have, and increase them.
Terry Jermy: That includes emotional support.
Tracey Garrett: Absolutely, yes.
Paul Tompkins: Land access, so accessing the flood asset that might have been breached. Environment Agency control, so who owns that asset and, therefore, who has response to it. Insurance. There are a multitude of reasons why it might not be appropriate to drive your JCB.
Chair: It is this issue of empowerment, just to have the ability to do what needs to be done in the moment that it needs to be done.
Paul Tompkins: Absolutely.
Chair: Henry, you are going to lead us in the final section for this part on recovery.
I want to begin by asking whether you think that communities are efficiently supported following the recovery and whether there is sufficient awareness of the available support that is there for them in that event? Shall we start from the left and then work it down? Is that okay?
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: Thank you. No, they are not sufficiently supported in terms of recovery. This is one year on, and this will last for many months, if not years, with their wellbeing still being impacted. I think there are two aspects to recovery. We have the immediate recovery, when the blue lights leave, and that opens up a gap as to who takes over the recovery support, with nobody stepping forward to do that. Recovery is so specific and deeply personal and individual that we need to acknowledge that this needs to be delivered by experts who know what flooded people need, from practical support to wellbeing and emotional support, but also financial support.
Like I said earlier, the blue lights receive the highest praise, and they do an excellent job during the response work, but then there is a big gap, and we know that there are many gaps to address in the recovery process. It needs to be something that is delivered in co-ordination and collaboration with experts who have lived experience and know what flooded people need, and it is something that needs to be long-term.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: Yes. Accessing financial assistance involves navigating a labyrinth of paperwork and bureaucracy around when it is activated and where people can access that financial support. Local authorities are often left with the duty to administer the grants, but they do not have extra staff to administer them. That causes a time lag, so that the person who needs it most is left with a gap and has to cover the costs of drying equipment or temporary accommodation. Especially for those who are uninsured or underinsured, that leaves them in a very dire financial situation. So, yes, there needs to be better co-ordination and deployment of that financial assistance for everyone immediately after a flood.
Paul Tompkins: I think recovery means different things to different people. Building on what Katia just said there around blue lights, when blue lights leave, but also when roads reopen in order that trucks can reach supermarkets again, that is often perceived as we have resolved the issue, where actually the long-term impacts on food and farming have not necessarily been taken into account.
Where I think the Government can do more for us here is give us a clear understanding of what matrix is used to determine when there will be financial support for a flooding event. If that is clear to farmers, we can plan around it. At the moment we have an unknown vacuum in that it will only be at the discretion of a ministerial decision should any sort of support head our way for an emergency event. It would be much more proportionate if we had an understanding of how that decision making is made and what matrix is used to make that decision.
Paul Tompkins: I am always going to advocate that the farming voice and the implications of our food production are always enhanced here because that matters for both people who live in rural communities and urban communities where their food is coming from. What we must make sure, as I mentioned, is that the immediate response to recovery isn’t left at just the immediate one because the implications for farming are longer term and, therefore, need to be considered for a much longer period.
Paul Tompkins: For those who are recipients of it, I think they very much welcomed that there was an intervention and some support offered. We also know that some farmers in some catchments—who still experience the same flooding event due to the same rainfall at the same time—were not able to access that fund. That does not seem like a fair and proportionate way, so would it not be better if we had a plan in place now that the Government were very clear on what metrics are used, and when they would intervene in a flooding or they would help in the recovery of a flooding event on farmland so that we are all very much in that clear picture.
Here is a challenge. We have a Prime Minister who is going to deliver a 10-year resilience plan before Christmas. Would it not be good if food features as part of that plan?
Tracey Garrett: I think awareness of any support is very, very low, if there is any support available. Support seems to be very limited immediately after flooding and people tend to have to rely on their own resources. I think that particular stage of flooding immediately afterwards is where third party organisations could really support, add value and help recovery.
If people have no insurance they have to try to recover all by themselves and finance that. If they do have insurance—we have a helpline and over 95% of calls to our helpline feature insurance at some point or another. We are only talking to people who will have problems with their insurance company, generally speaking, but they feature disputes over the type of flooring, these kinds of disputes. They can be about anything, but they go on for a really long time, up to one year, two years, and people become really frustrated because they are just in this endless, vicious circle and they cannot seem to move forward in their recovery and get back into their restored home.
That really impacts people having to deal with insurance companies. They end up being the one that is going between the contractors and the insurance company, and they are basically project managing the whole thing, as well as recovering emotionally and physically from a flood, going to work and any of the other responsibilities that they may have. It impacts on their mental health as well as just being flooded.
To just talk about grants for a second, I would absolutely back Paul up. There is no transparency on when grants will be activated. We should perhaps look at it as severity on the individual homeowner, but I totally agree we need some hard and fast rules about when it is going to be activated, because communities and local authorities sit there waiting and waiting and waiting, and they just do not hear anything because it is it is not going to be activated, so I think there needs to be some real clear transparency about that.
Tracey Garrett: Well, it comes down to it is not very clear cut. It does not always come down to a number of houses. There still has to be an agreement for that to go live, so that is really challenging.
Paul Tompkins: There might be, say, 50 houses for example, and 50 houses is obviously very impactful in an urban area, but you try to translate that into a rural setting, and it has to be a much bigger flooding event.
Tracey Garrett: It might be better to do it on impact of flooding. As well the responsibility for the grant administration when it falls to the local authority, it takes up all its flood risk management resource and that makes it hard for it to do other things for communities.
Tracey Garrett: I have been here for four and a half years, and I do not think that Bellwin has been activated in my time.
Henry Tufnell: Katia, you wanted to—
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: To add to that, the Bellwin scheme activates for emergency costs to local authorities, but where the property flood resilience grants or emergency grants or council tax rebate costs are reduced or put forward to communities or activated, that still needs a lot of bureaucracy and paperwork for communities to access that. What we hear from flooded people is why is this not made available every time that somebody has flooded and there is no minimum that councils have to declare or have reports that come through to their dashboard or to their email inbox to count and prove how many people have flooded, especially repeated floodings. They often see that there are constraints on whether they will get any grants or not. If the property flood resilience grant has been spent or given before and they fall short this time, they are not allowed to get that funding again.
With increased cost of flooding and by having resilience and recoverability measures in your house, it does not mean that when you flood again that damage is less. The damage and the cost is still there and circumstances change to people’s lives, so I think it is only fair to ask for that to be available every time.
Tracey Garrett: Do you mean for new builds? Is that the gap you are talking about?
Henry Tufnell: We have talked about how there are delays in being able to contact your insurer in the event of flooding or that perhaps there have been delays in loss adjustors attending properties. That is assuming that the insurance is there in the first place. As we have seen increasing flooding risk, I wonder what that means in terms of people not being able to access that insurance and what that will mean going forward.
Tracey Garrett: At the moment, the Flood Re scheme supports thousands and thousands of households. When that scheme comes to an end in 2039, that will not be available. The intention is that the market will support the exit of Flood Re from the insurance market. If it does not, that will leave thousands and thousands of people without the ability to get insurance. One of the gaps that we see with the Flood Re scheme at the moment is any homes built after 2009 are not eligible for the Flood Re scheme. They will not be offered flood insurance necessarily, and that is a problem for places like Yatton where the decision has been made to build 190 homes in a higher risk flood zone. None of those homes will be covered for flood risk insurance. There is an increasing risk in two ways: first, that the scheme will come to an end and if the market has not caught up that is a problem; and secondly, all the new-build properties that we are putting in areas of higher flood risk will not be able to access flood insurance, thereby putting at risk all those people who have spent their life savings and investment into their home.
Katia Sanhueza-Pino: Adding to that, yes, we see a lot of concerns from people who are having issues accessing mortgages as well because they are not able to cover flood insurance. With Flood Re, I think we all would agree that we are not ready for that to stop in 2039. What we see is also inconsistent and very high contributions to Flood Re, but also to then have the Build Back Better scheme that at the moment gives up to £10,000 for recoverability and resilience measures on people’s properties if you have Build Back Better within your insurance policy. That should be streamlined and mainstreamed for everyone who has flood insurance cover. Up to £10,000 often falls short. The average cost to reinstate a home after a flood is £30,000, and that is money that is not available for everyone. If there is a safety net behind there, reinstating and flood proofing or making your home more resilient to flooding, the minimum should be £10,000, if anything. Yes, there is a big gap in insurance and how they can support flooded communities.
Paul Tompkins: Very briefly, Henry, French farmers are supported with premiums for flood risk where it is prohibitively expensive. I think many English and Welsh farmers envy that assistance. In Australia, there is a drought and flood resilience plan, which helps farmers invest in their farms to help mitigate some of the effects of either event. Again, it is something that we look on with envy.
Chair: Well, that concludes the questions that we have for you. Thank you for the very comprehensive evidence that you have given us. In particular, thank you for just bringing home the very real community and human impact that these incidents have had. It is not all about agencies and procedures and insurance claims and whatever else. It is the impact that it has on individuals, and we are grateful to you for having brought that to us.
We will move on to our next panel of witnesses. I am not going to suspend if we can do this quickly, but I will just remind my colleagues that their microphones remain live because I have not suspended. I can see that we have the other members of the panel ready to come forward.
Examination of witnesses
Witnesses: Phil Garrigan, Councillor Matt Boughton and Andrew McGill.
Andrew McGill: Thank you very much. Good morning. I am Andrew McGill, the Chief Executive of the Water Management Consortium. It is a group of four drainage boards running on the east coast from Gibraltar Point all the way up to Cleethorpes and then moving across to the centre east of Doncaster, along the Ouse, down the Trent, all the way down through Retford, Newark, and right down to Ratcliffe-on-Soar. It is all the low-lying land in those areas.
Councillor Boughton: Good morning. My name is Matt Boughton. I am Chairman of the Safer and Stronger Communities Committee at the Local Government Association. I am also Leader of Tonbridge and Malling Borough Council in Kent.
Phil Garrigan: I am Phil Garrigan. I am the Chair of the National Fire Chiefs Council. It is good to see you all again today.
Chair: Yes, welcome back. We have had you for wildfires, now for flood. When we get the inquiries into famine and pestilence, you will have had the full gamut.
The emergency response arrangements are what we are going to be looking at next. We have some questions around co-ordination challenges, and Josh is going to lead us in the questioning for that.
Phil Garrigan: I think the panel previously referenced the speed and effectiveness of the emergency response, and that is not to suggest sometimes we do not get those things wrong. I would say that we are pretty effective in how we mobilise resources, how we convene through local resilience forums, and how we prioritise the response.
I suppose the bit that I would say has started to get a bit more difficult over that period is that we transitioned from the response phase and into the recovery one. I think that has been evidenced as part and parcel of the previous panel’s submissions.
In regards to the operational co-ordination, strategic co-ordinating groups and the decision making and prioritisation around risk and risk mitigation at the time, it is very much a co-ordinated effort but recognising that some of that arrangement should be put in place in advance through the planning and the exercising of such events and ensuring that they are robust so when the events play out we are able to respond very effectively. I think as part and parcel of that transitional change, that is where some of the co-ordination and the handover of responsibility becomes a little bit more difficult to administer and resource and support in the longer term. Again, as has been evidenced by previous colleagues, the emergency response is one thing; the recovery is significantly longer and requires significantly more time, resource and effort, I would suggest.
Councillor Boughton: Currently, the multi-agency arrangements work particularly well where there is an established relationship that has built up, particularly at a local and sometimes at a hyper local level. We certainly find from colleagues in the blue light services and all other partner organisations that there is no one who is unwilling to work in terms of co-ordination during any emergency.
Local resilience forums have an effective framework, albeit there are challenges there and there is a patchy nature across the country in terms of their effectiveness. Strong relationships and clear responsibilities are particularly important, and those that perform better are those where the relationships are much deeper embedded.
The challenge, I think, around particularly resilience forums is that they are not a legal entity as such, and therefore that explains why some of them do not work perhaps as effectively as others. That creates issues around governance, accountability, data sharing, all the things that in the heart of an emergency you do not particularly want to be spending a lot of time on.
The other point I would make on that is that there can often be a little bit of a difference between category 1 and category 2 responders under the Civil Contingencies Act, particularly the fact that infrastructure and utilities providers fall as category 2 responders rather than category 1 responders. The outcome of that means that sometimes getting their input, particularly where there is impact on infrastructure, which often is the case, can be more challenging than with other category 1 responders.
Councillor Boughton: Funding is important, but when it comes to the readiness of local resilience forums to actually put into place the actions that they have been discussing, preparation is key and critical in that regard. Where you have established relationships working together across the organisations and they have been built up over time when you are not in an emergency situation, that is much easier to stand everyone up at that point.
The challenge in those that do not work so well comes down to, first, not having those established relationships. Secondly, the lack of accountability of local resilience forums means that sometimes there is a genuine dispute or disagreement about what the best outcome is and that can result in different parts of a local resilience forum or different partners around the table going off and doing different things. Because it is not a legal entity you cannot be forced to be part of that collective solution as such. Therefore, a lot of good will is required in order to make it work, and it just simply is the case that you cannot get that everywhere when you have these localised structures.
Andrew McGill: If I think back to the flooding of Wainfleet, which was one event that I was involved in, the internal drainage boards were working round the clock at that point, along with the Environment Agency folks. Then we had this breach and the fire brigades and so on turned up and did an excellent job. The actual emergency was dealt with superbly well and I think some of that stems from in Lincolnshire there is a very strong flood risk management partnership that meets regularly at several different levels, from the strategic down to the operational level. We have people from, for instance, the internal drainage board sitting in with gold, silver and bronze command when these events are running. It is one example where things actually work well.
What then happens is what has been mentioned previously. You then shift to the recovery phase and the fire brigade have many more responsibilities, particularly in emergency situations, than staying with that event. Then it is left to the local folks to crack on with. It still can be quite a Herculean task for those that are left behind. What’s more, you begin to see that the rules and the procedures of normal life in certain organisations begin to kick in. That begins to restrict the can do attitude of, “Let’s get on with it and let’s get the job done” to, “You can’t put the water from this field back in our main river unless it is tested”. That is someone switching back into peacetime in their mind when actually we are still in chaos and we also need to get ourselves ready for the next event. You have this separating of minds.
I think there is still more work to do. Even where it works well, there could be much more achieved in how we approach these things.
Andrew McGill: Certainly, thinking of areas of special drainage need where drainage boards operate, it comes down really to the Environment Agency and the IDB. I feel that there is a cultural change required in the agency in order to get it to that point where we can pragmatically approach an issue while still meeting many of the thresholds that it wishes to achieve, but applying common sense to the situation we are faced with. We find that quite frustrating at times.
Andrew McGill: I would suggest that there needs to be greater trust and confidence in the abilities of the internal drainage boards within her area. Not every board is the same size or has the same resources, but certainly in the Lincolnshire area they are substantial. We have quite a lot of expertise in-house. We act very responsibly and within all the environmental regulations and laws of the country. This is not always recognised. The level of trust between the agency and the board’s abilities is significantly reduced by its apprehension to allow us to undertake the work.
The thing is that due to the cost restraints that they face, some of the lower and medium consequence rivers are no longer being maintained, but they still wish to have all the criteria in place for anyone else to go in and maintain it. The difference between us and them is the fact that they are interested in flood risk, which focuses directly on to properties largely, whereas we are looking at the water level management across the whole area and for the benefit of the whole area. These watercourses that have been there for hundreds of years have a purpose in order to sustain life in that area.
Andrew McGill: I don’t think everything has to be legislated. It can be a cultural change from within the organisation to entrust and empower some of the agencies. Many of the people I work with are very capable, very intelligent people who, if they were allowed to apply their skills to a good level, we would be able to overcome these things. It could be done for minimal cost and have a significant improvement in these areas with special drainage need.
They have been willing to have the conversations. I have spoken to DEFRA about it. I have spoken to the head of infrastructure about it. Only two weeks ago I had a meeting on becoming a trusted partner approach rather than the public sector corporation, which is a public sector contract agreement. They undertook to go away and see if there was a simpler way of allowing another risk management authority that is competent to undertake this work. It has not been particularly successful. They said they would come back in two weeks and it has been four weeks. We had something that was not exactly startling as a result of that, so we need to go again. I think there are those in there who trust us. They work really hard. They have to bend the rules within the organisation to assist us to achieve greater maintenance on the ground, but there is somewhere in among that agency that is preventing this common sense, pragmatic approach that keeps everything within the law from being initiated and I do not know where it is.
Councillor Boughton, from a local authority perspective, have you had any experiences within your own council or have you heard from other councils that you are speaking to as part of the committee on the Environment Agency’s role? How much of a help or a hindrance, perhaps, is it in that post-flood response?
Councillor Boughton: It is interesting because, of course, the structure of the Environment Agency is regionalised and it depends a lot on the effectiveness of the Environment Agency and local authorities in how they are in that region. If I use my own area as an example, we have significant co-operation with the Environment Agency because we have a huge number of communities at risk of flooding. We have the Leigh flood storage area just on the border, too, which effectively protects thousands of homes in Tonbridge and Malling from flooding.
We have a good, long-standing relationship with the Environment Agency, and we have been working with it on various property-level protection schemes that have been broadly successful and localised mitigations, too. Where the Environment Agency has done particularly well in recent years, I think, is in its warning system, flood warnings, flood alerts and so on, which are getting increasing sign-up. Its communications have been much better.
Where the challenge comes is in the emergency phase and making sure that the decisions that it is taking are justified and that we and other responders have the ability to know what the implications of it would be. Again, using my own authority, we know that if it is to effectively start impounding at the Leigh flood storage area, then that causes issues with flooding further upstream while also defending downstream. Therefore, our resource has to look at what happens upstream perhaps more so than downstream. If it does not impound, then we know that there is the likelihood of further flooding downstream instead. That is where the communication is critical from the Environment Agency. It has worked in our area because we have spent the time building up those relationships rather than because of any particular rules or regulations or statutes around it.
Councillor Boughton: Yes, absolutely. If we look forward a little bit, I think there is a big danger here that when local government reorganisation happens and we have bigger councils across the country, what is going to happen is that those communications will become much harder because the local authority in a bigger area will, by its very nature, be looking at different flooding events at the same time and trying to react. As a district council, we can do so. We are small enough to care about that, but there is a risk with local government reorganisation in the medium term.
Councillor Boughton: It is peace time that is critical to this, making the most of it in peace time to understand, frankly, who the decision makers are within the Environment Agency. As soon as you understand that, you break down a load of barriers when you need to do it. You are right. Generally, with local authority staff you have less of a turnover than you do in the Environment Agency, but that is not to say that the employees of the Environment Agency are not skilled or know what they are talking about. It is just important that we ultimately know who the person is who will be making the decision as to impounding at Leigh or whatever it is that is needed in a particular locality. Through the various informal forums that you have, with a commitment on both sides, that can work but it requires two to tango.
Phil Garrigan: Only in relation to, I suppose, understanding the capacity challenges. Sometimes it is quite easy to be critical of other departments or other functions until you walk in their shoes for a little while and you understand the implications placed on them around their role, responsibilities and capacity to deliver against all our ambitions.
I think role and responsibility is quite important. When you look at the role of the Fire and Rescue Service and the lack of statutory responsibility around flood response, that can have some challenging outcomes at a more local level when you are responding and not clear on the statutory duty that lies with the Fire and Rescue Service. We cannot do some of the preventative work that we do to support the Environment Agency. Then in the response phase it becomes more challenging. For a long time, we have sought to ensure that a statutory duty was imparted on the Fire and Rescue Service in regards to flood response and rescue in the immediate phase, which then allows us to understand our role and responsibility and how then you transition into the Environment Agency taking over the recovery phase as part of the response and then how the local authority would move into a longer-term recovery. I think clearly defining roles and responsibilities is a key component part for all organisations but particularly within the Environment Agency and how it would interface with ourselves.
Councillor Boughton: I think there is a real problem here that local resilience forums are not functioning as they were initially expected to do. The consequence of that is you will get some that are much more proactive than others. There is, frankly, a lot of good will and gaffer tape that is needed to make the system work, and that is where you get into the cross-boundary problems. Suddenly, you can see where the boundaries are not coterminous one local resilience forum is doing something slightly different to the other. There is no accountability of the local resilience forums because, of course, it is representatives from organisations that are going there so no one can actually say, “It is your job to do this because it has worked well”, effectively. There may well be good reason for that or there may not be good reason for that, but it means that local resilience forums end up in a very difficult and tricky situation, sometimes of their own making.
It was notable actually in the Government’s resilience action plan that they said they would strengthen accountability to local democratically elected leaders of local resilience forums, which is music to my ears. It will be interesting to see how that moves forward, because I think having some greater oversight of how local resilience forums are operating would enable local government to take much more ownership of it, using the power of convening that local government has to ensure that when an emergency happens and when a particular area is flooded you are able to deal with those cross-boundary issues much more effectively.
Phil Garrigan: If I just put it into a little bit of a fire context in the first instance, we have discussed wildfire. Flood is very similar. It crosses boundaries in the same way as wildfires do. We find it is the ability to co-ordinate nationally in regards to prioritisation of demand and the co-ordination of Fire and Rescue Service assets as much as anything else. Are we sending them to this particular flood or this particular wildfire, or does it have primacy over another one? Where you get the similar demands and competing demands within local resilience forums, my view is that there is some national co-ordination required about where that resource is allocated. We have talked probably at length about national resilience co-ordination and how that fits into the structures. In a very similar vein, over the recent wildfire seasons we have had to consider that from a fire perspective. How do we ensure that we are prioritising one area over another and what factors do we take into consideration, from life risk right the way through to critical national infrastructure to property to environmental considerations? There is some thinking in regards to how you then manage a competing set of demands at a national level that is affecting local resilience.
Chair: I hope you all feel better for having got that off your chest but we need to move on because we are under a bit of pressure for time. Helena, you are going to lead us on resourcing and funding questions.
Phil Garrigan: I could not be certain that that is what it relates to. We have certainly seen an increase in the number of incidents that we are responding to. Probably over the last five to 10 years we have seen an increase of 20% of the number of incidents that we are responding to, flood-related events.
Phil Garrigan: No, that is something I would have to come back to you on.
In 2023, in Hastings, we had an incident where the entire town centre flooded. Many shops and businesses and homes were under water. I was there—it was before I was the MP—and literally saw local East Sussex fire service carrying people out of their homes. It was a very scary situation. The water rose very quickly. That incident was found to have been caused by Southern Water, and the town centre was very quickly overwhelmed. To this day they insist on parking a yellow digger on our beach, apparently to prevent future flooding incidents, so they do not really seem to have gotten on top of the problem. I did a freedom of information request at the time about how much that response had cost the fire service because there was no one from Southern Water on site, just the fire service, as ever first on the scene: £27,000 for that incident in response to the FOI request. That is just one incident. I know of many others in my own constituency; I am sure in colleagues’ as well. It strikes me that therefore the fire service is having to spend quite a lot on responding to incidents caused by the water companies and utility companies, but it is not as clear to me what the mechanism is by which the water companies pay you back for that. Do you have any comment on that?
Phil Garrigan: There isn’t, as far as I am aware, a mechanism for us to recover the costs in relation to the causal factors linked into a flood in this regard. It is no surprise to me that the Fire and Rescue Service was first on the scene in regards to its response and the rescue of your residents and communities and keeping them safe.
I suppose it comes back to a little bit of statutory responsibility and duties placed on the Fire and Rescue Service. I know there was reference to schemes available to recover costs, which you may lead on to in a short while. Self-evidently, the Fire and Rescue Service responded to 17,000 flood incidents last year, which is a significant increase in the events that we had experienced previously. More often than not it is very difficult, if at all possible, to recover any of the costs associated with that response. That is on the back of years of austerity and significant reductions in firefighter numbers, too.
Phil Garrigan: Yes, I do. The Bellwin scheme was mentioned and the Bellwin scheme obviously has some triggers attached to it as much as anything else, but it is quite difficult to negotiate and to be able to evidence, so it comes at the extreme end of an emergency response.
Phil Garrigan: Yes, absolutely.
Phil Garrigan: Absolutely.
Phil Garrigan: As you have alluded to, it is 18 years. The Pitt review made recommendation 39, which suggested a statutory responsibility and the role of the Fire and Rescue Service being enhanced in relation to that. We are 18 years on and we have not seen that come to fruition. We are very positive about the comments that have been made more latterly by both the Prime Minister, the Secretary of State and the fire Minister, but again, if I took you back to 2008 when the Pitt Review first made that recommendation, it was agreed and it was not enacted. It needs now to be enacted to assure the Fire and Rescue Service and the communities that we serve that we have the statutory responsibility to respond to rescue under certain sets of circumstances, flood being one of those.
Phil Garrigan: Yes, I think they should and I also think from an emergency services perspective around water supplies and access to water supplies, they should address that particular issue, too. If I may just seize on one opportunity, you have referenced expanding. I know we are focussed in on flood response particularly, but there is a gap in the response and the statutory responsibilities for inland water, too. The Fire and Rescue Service responds to rescues, but it does not have a statutory responsibility to and cannot—or can but is unable to tackle that from a preventative perspective as well. We had 100 people dying in inland water as well as being exposed to the flood risk that you have alluded to.
Phil Garrigan: I think we need to have a statutory duty in the Fire and Rescue Service response to flooding and in response to inland rescue, from a response and rescue perspective but also from a preventative perspective, supporting others to communicate the messages across to particularly young people, because we lost far too many of them over the last 12 months.
Phil Garrigan: You have Coastguard and other agencies for sure that would take responsibility and that is fine, but they have the responsibility. No one has responsibility for inland rescue and that for me is a huge statutory gap.
Phil Garrigan: I will comment from personal experiences. Under a crisis when we know we are saving communities and communities are at risk, certainly the blue light responders that are probably first on scene co-ordinate effectively. In fairness to local authority colleagues who come probably on to scene a little bit after the initial phase, we are all working collectively through the local resilience forum to deliver better outcomes. I think the intent is there, but the capacity becomes a challenge in the longer term. That is where it starts to stray into recovery and how you can sustain a response for a particularly protracted period of time. The emergency phases is okay. It is well co-ordinated through strategic co-ordinating arrangements. The local resilience forum should have got ahead of that and should be able to take it on. The Environment Agency comes into play at that particular point in time, dependent on circumstances, and then the local authority in regards to recovery.
It is well practised, but the transitional change for a member of the community, for the people, they do not want to see gaps in the transitional process and neither do they want to feel as though it was great during the emergency response when we were all there and then it dissipated over time. That is capacity. It is a capacity challenge for the local authority to sustain that level of focus and care.
Councillor Boughton: Yes. After the initial phase of an emergency is over, the local authority does not go anywhere. Obviously, the blue light responders will go off and do their thing, but the local authority is left to deal with the consequences and to co-ordinate the response. That is something that all local authorities take extremely seriously because, ultimately, if that response is not perfect, then the ongoing problems are ones the local authority will end up dealing with.
A lot of it comes down to what work has happened before to understand what is likely to happen. In big flood events, for example, the amount of work that is needed after the bigger flood event is all dependent on how the emergency response was. To give you an example of this—and again I will use my own authority—in Christmas 2013 we had severe flooding in parts of Kent. What had happened was that we had very successfully at the time set up emergency rest centres. They were set up in exactly the right places so obviously residents could move there. The outcome of that was that once the floodwater had subsided and it was safe to do so, residents could move back in and the rest centres would just carry on their daily use as a leisure centre or village hall, effectively. That works really well, but where that work had not been done in place to identify those particular buildings, as has happened in some instances, then suddenly you end up dealing with issues afterwards around insurance claims and access and all that stuff that you want to avoid.
The second part that I would mention from the local authority point of view would be to look at the examples that have happened particularly in Yorkshire and Calderdale around 2015 time, where I think there were six bridges that had collapsed. The work that had happened in advance prevented another six bridges from collapsing, so it could have been even worse. I think it is a really good example to use as to how the co-operation and the co-ordination between agencies has made the recovery much better than it perhaps could have been.
That is obviously three years ago. In the three years since, the local residents have been trying to get the different people together around the table to try to plan to avoid a future incident. They have asked me to step in and help co-ordinate that. East Sussex County Council, despite weeks and weeks of notice, is refusing to send anyone to that meeting. From an LGA point of view, do you think councils need to step up and take responsibility?
Councillor Boughton: Yes, councils are there to convene and should be convening. That is certainly the expectation. Obviously, I do not know the specific circumstances in your constituency, but I know Keith Glazier very well, who I remember talking to about this beforehand.
I think a lot of the issues come down to ensuring that you have the right organisations that would be represented at the table that those residents would wish to see. I think this is where we fall down in the differences between category 1 and category 2 responders. The Civil Contingencies Act is very clear about what category 1 and category 2 responders are required to do, and ultimately infrastructure operators and utilities, in our view, should be considered to be part of category 1 responders. Because as flood risk increases, whether that is flood risk arising from Southern Water’s failure—and I also deal with Southern Water so I know how you feel—the responsibilities must lie with Southern Water as much as they do with the local authority.
Ultimately, it is its failure that has caused the particular issue. While the local authority will and should step in and play that convening role, if Southern Water is not going to be able to do this itself, and there are plenty of examples where that particular company has been unable to do it, then greater responsibility through the Civil Contingencies Act would force it to co-operate and ultimately deliver what your residents need much quicker than has happened so far.
Helena Dollimore: Thank you. That is all my questions, Chair.
Chair: Okay. Henry wants to come in on this.
Phil Garrigan: No, it is not an active conversation with Government, but it certainly can be based on your observations.
Phil Garrigan: Yes, absolutely.
Chair: Roz, welcome to the Committee.
We have probably covered most of the questions that I was going to ask, but there is something that I would really like to pick up on. This is addressed to all three of you. There is clearly a lot that could be going better in flooding response and it seems that at the moment it is not really a learning system. There is not really that opportunity to have a debrief after there has been a flood event to see how things could be handled better the next time between the various different agencies and the communities. I would think that for the people who have been victims of the flood, that could actually be quite supportive for them to have the opportunity to feed back into a process that may or may not benefit them directly but would certainly benefit other people. Hopefully, the agencies would also find that helpful to identify those lessons learned. Do you think that a review could and should be a legal requirement to make sure that we learn how to respond more effectively?
Andrew McGill: I am not necessarily certain it has to be a legal requirement, but it is certainly something that should be written into something somewhere. For instance, the Wainfleet flooding that I mentioned at the beginning was 2019 and there was a meeting on that last week with members of the community, the local councillors, the Environment Agency and the drainage board, talking about what further measures we can do to assist them and to ensure the maintenance to protect the communities goes on. There are still worried people turning up on the banks when there is heavy rainfall because the psychological effect when you have been flooded is long lasting.
Yes, it is an ideal thing and we do make some headway. It keeps us true to making a difference in sustaining the maintenance throughout the future times rather than drifting away from it. It is a very valid point.
Andrew McGill: We have some very positive results, coming back slightly to what was being spoken about before, with lead local flood authorities. Working together with them we have produced quite a few schemes to protect local villages. The board undertook one at Edmonton. It was only about £335,000 to have the whole thing designed and built. Again, the lead local flood authority in Nottinghamshire is taking up NFM work, the natural flood management stuff, which is going to greatly enhance the slowing of the water coming into the board’s area and so on. We are joining in that and sharing the costs of that. That has come from those community forums and trying to seek a way to resolve it. I have a huge list of them where that has been working quite well, so there is hope out there, I think.
Councillor Boughton: I do not think the current recovery arrangements are particularly flexible, predictable or responsive to the increasing frequency of flooding events. We as local authorities are expected to support that and we step in. Certainly, most councils would, as you would expect them to do. To do that debrief while at the same time trying to prepare for future incidents creates additional pressure on local resources. If this were to become a statutory duty, then it will not be a surprise for me to turn around and say we need to be funded to deal with that accordingly. The frank reality and fact is that emergency planning teams are increasingly stretched with the amount of emergencies, whether it is water shortages or too much water and flooding events or wildfires or any other emergency that you can think of.
Ultimately, from our perspective, we will step in there and do what is needed because that is what a good local authority should do, but response, recovery and community engagement are all aligned at the same time. I think it has to be recognised that while we would be dealing with reviewing the response, that work is going on in parallel to prevent it happening again.
Councillor Boughton: Yes, and flooding is quite a good example of it because it is highly localised. If I look in my own borough, for example, I can go from village to village and the impact is going to be very different simply dependent on where the rain falls. I live in a flood zone 3 area, so I know that I can watch the weather forecast and I may or may not be flooded, depending on my house. I can put in place my property-level protection that I have because of where I live. However, the best thing for me is simply to go down to the river before it says it is going to rain and see how high it is. Ultimately, the localisation of the response to flooding means that the co-ordination is done at such a local level and it means that you are reliant on local authorities and parish and town councils, too, to help co-ordinate that and be able to cascade that up to local resilience forums as and when needed. There is an important matrix that we are involved in in preparation for these events.
Councillor Boughton: I think the challenge, as I said earlier, with the LRF comes down to essentially whether it is functioning as it was originally intended or not. Ultimately, if LRFs are to be effective, they need to be able to receive that feedback. Certainly, the local resilience forum I am familiar with in Kent meets often, but because it deals with all the issues down at the Port of Dover and Eurotunnel, it means that relations can be strained at times and there is a real accountability problem. The impact of some of the decisions that are taken around that table is very live, certainly to communities in East Kent. I think part of the issue is that because there are question marks about the accountability of local resilience forums, communities feel that the impact should be cascaded up to them but it is very difficult for them to know how much of that has been taken into account when preparing for a future emergency scenario. That to me is why the role of local resilience forums is incredibly important to define in all this, because they could have the opportunity to do something that is very impactful but it needs a far better audit trail than perhaps exists at the moment.
Phil Garrigan: I would not disagree with the latter comments there in relation to the significance of the role of the local resilience forum. The high-performing local resilience forums would do exactly what you are describing without a statutory responsibility. I would suggest that maybe that is not a necessity, but it was probably something you said, maybe purposefully, when you talked about repeat events. If things are repeating themselves, you would want to be assured that you are learning from the first, the second, the third and subsequent events to prevent them happening in the first instance.
I think as organisations, as the Fire and Rescue Service, probably as other main services and the local authority, we may well debrief our own response to a particular set of circumstances. I think the local resilience forum on significant events, and maybe that is something to be defined, would trigger a multi-agency debrief to draw the learning in. My one comment on that would be that more often than not that is public sector organisations or cat 1 and cat 2 responders coming together to share what they experienced and not necessarily the community itself. An important facet of what you have said there is the community experience, how the community have felt during that period. How did the Fire and Rescue Service handle that particular set of circumstances in those events? Was it to the satisfaction of the public? The public should be able to hold the mirror up and comment on our response and how effective it was and that should inform the things that we do in the future.
It may well be something that just needs to be developed and finessed based on whether it is a statutory requirement or something that is notable and good practice and encouraged, but certainly creating a mechanism where the community can feed into the process to inform practice moving forward I think is fundamental, I absolutely do, and I think that is the role of the local resilience forum.
Dr Roz Savage: Thank you. Yes, I think that would be very well received.
Chair: We have some questions around IDBs and funding. Ben is going to lead us on this.
Andrew McGill: Quite rightly, you have given a great example of how challenging it is to fund an IDB. If we go back to 2022, the biggest impact on local councils, which made everyone sit up, was the increase in power and standing charges. For instance, just to give you a quick quantum on that, our expend on electricity at one board was £344,000 over a year in 2022-23 and in 2023-24 it was £1,000,063, so a significant impact. That cost largely falls upon the district council. We met with them. I wrote to Victoria Atkins at the time when we saw the increase coming, and then we met with the district council and then the special interest group that the Local Government Association formed. You have no doubt heard and been involved in the meetings they have had up in Parliament to try to raise this issue.
The grant in aid system, again from an IDB area it is geared for properties and there are not so many properties in those areas. Therefore, while we would all protect properties and the people who live in them without question, I think there needs to be a rebalancing of how that sits and how it is seen, particularly if you start looking at items such as food security and feeding an island nation. I think we all understand how vulnerable we can be in terms of lines of communication at this time with what is going on in the world.
With regard to obtaining those funds, such as grant in aid, it can take 200 man hours to complete the form, which is a laborious effort for what we are going to do, not replace the pumping station. Is that really a good investment of someone’s time when they could actually be using it more constructively for the benefit of people and flood risk and the water level management in the area? Yes, I think it needs an overhaul. I think it needs rebalancing and recognition. Agricultural areas is not a dirty word. Agriculture really is factories without roofs and we all depend on it enormously. In the IDB areas it is superb farming land. It is extremely flat, very high grade. It is not quite like some of the farms I grew up on, where they were struggling to make any living at all. The critical part of that is that the importance I do not think is quite getting the recognition and the mechanism for releasing the funds is too complex.
Ben Goldsborough: Chair, do you want me to come to a conclusion on that?
Chair: No, if you have more to ask. We are going to run a bit over but we just have a couple of questions from number 9.
Councillor Boughton: I do not think it is sustainable. If you look at it across the country, levies have increased from £38.9 million in 2022-23 to £54.1 million now. I always dread as a borough council leader with two IDBs in my borough the email I get around January each year telling me how much they are going to charge us. Of course, we can do absolutely nothing about it other than factor that into our budget-setting process. If we have been out for whatever reason, because ultimately the IDB has decided to do something else, then it causes major headaches for district councils, my own and particularly those authorities that have a much higher levy that they have to pay.
We recognise the role that the IDBs do. They perform an important function. Accountability is important, too, and we have the opportunity—and we certainly take that up—to have representatives from the district councils on the boards. Generally, that helps to prevent the shocks. Ultimately, though, I do not think this is sustainable in the long run. We are not seeing a situation in which there is more money coming in to local authorities to account for the additional requests that IDBs are placing on it. Ultimately, it means that local authorities are having to make cuts elsewhere in order to fund the IDBs. Without additional money coming into the system, it is local authorities and particularly district councils that are left with the financial problem in a sector that has, frankly, had enough financial headaches over the last few years.
Chair: Henry has a couple of questions in relation to the infrastructure.
Councillor Boughton: I don’t have direct experience of it. I am happy to write in with some good examples from local government if that would be helpful to the Committee. We can definitely do that.
Given that flooding is not often an issue in isolation, it can disrupt transport, energy and water infrastructure, and that is ultimately why the national risk register of the Government places flooding so high. Given the locality of some flood events, it could, for example, have an impact on access to health facilities. If it is particularly close to a hospital, that has problems arising from it. Again, it is something that we need to recognise is much more likely to happen and we will definitely share with the Committee some of the best examples.
Phil Garrigan: Not particularly. I will only pick up the effect on critical national infrastructure and the implications that has from a UK perspective. Self-evidently, if not managed effectively, then that is the ramifications of the events.
Councillor Boughton: I agree. That is my comment and I say that because it is a problem that we face. Ultimately, the requirements on infrastructure providers are not the same as it is certainly on us and the fire service and other blue light services. We saw last Friday when we could not access our emails all morning that the slightest bit of damage, whether that is cyber or physical damage, to key critical infrastructure can cause significant problems in society. That is one of the reasons why we advocate for a greater responsibility being placed upon infrastructure providers, and I use that term loosely and deliberately.
Councillor Boughton: Ultimately, I think it comes down to the difference between category 1 and category 2 responders in the Civil Contingencies Act. I think there is definitely a case that the responsibilities and the requirements that we have as category 1 responders for infrastructure and utility companies should be mirrored. If it is not and if they are not category 1 responders, then we will end up in the situation that you describe where getting their co-operation is increasingly difficult.
Phil Garrigan: I think that goes beyond co-operation. I think it is a requirement. Would I expect them to be part and parcel of the exercising of particular plans to ensure that they are effective through the local resilience forum? Absolutely.
Councillor Boughton: I would love them to take on all local authority recommendations, but sometimes that is not the case.
Councillor Boughton: It is very difficult to get engagement. I have had some good instances and a lot of it depends on the importance to the utility company of the particular infrastructure that they have in a particular council area. We have had the situation too many times across the country, and certainly in my own authority, where we are trying to deal with utility companies and it has become increasingly difficult to get their input into preventing these happening again.
I will use my own example in Tonbridge and Malling. We have had massive issues over the summer with water supply loss, with South East Water, which I know you have done some work into in the past. Certainly, at the start, getting its input into how we can help it was very difficult. The new leadership has helped, I have to say, and that organisation is definitely turning a corner, but as a result it is very patchy across the country. Unless there is a requirement for infrastructure providers and utility companies to engage with local authorities, to take on board seriously the recommendations that local authorities are bringing forward, then ultimately you are reliant on that good will, and sometimes it is very difficult to build up good will with organisations that are consistently failing the public.
Andrew McGill: I will just add very quickly that the IDBs, on behalf of many of the district councils in these IDB areas, undertake protection of those utilities. For instance, in our Trent board there are four power stations. In the Isle of Axholme there is the M180, and the A1 runs all the way up. Our systems are protecting those assets, not all the way but sufficiently to close them down very quickly if we do not undertake the work. We manage to crack on with that.
Andrew McGill: It works well, but I think there is still more to be done to protect with the flooding that is coming. I think that is where you were going with that.
Andrew McGill: We are not any form of category responder. Unfortunately, we are not.
Chair: You deal with the consequences, though.
Andrew McGill: We deal with the consequences and we integrate very closely with those who are those responders.
Phil Garrigan: From a personal point of view, I still think that works because it defines roles and responsibilities. To some degree, when you are looking at the co-ordination and response, you do not necessarily always need a cat 2 responder in the room to secure an outcome. What you do is more often than not a category 1 responder. I think it works. As you have said, the Civil Contingencies Act is over 20 years old. Is it worth taking a look at whether it is still fit for purpose? I think that would be sensible, but from a personal point of view, having dealt with it for over 37 years, certainly over its introduction it has been effective in dealing with the aftermath and the response.
Councillor Boughton: I definitely think there is scope for the Government to review the responsibilities that are placed on category 1 and 2 responders, particularly category 2 responders because they are operationally involved in a number of civil contingencies, in the preparedness, the response and the recovery phase. Therefore, it is certainly our view that for category 2 responders that needs to be reviewed, frankly, given how much time has passed. We know that flooding and other events are becoming more frequent.
Phil Garrigan: I agree with that point and it probably plays back directly into the comments and questions earlier around expectations placed on individuals to attend and participate in exercises. That probably needs to be stipulated and strengthened in any refresh.
Chair: Thank you for that. Somebody else can do it the next time. We are unfortunately out of time. We are slightly over time, in fact. I genuinely appreciate your attendance, your engagement and the quality of your answers. It has been enormously helpful for the Committee. We shall return to this, no doubt, in the not too distant future, but for the moment that concludes our business for today.