Joint Committee on the Draft Conversion Practices Bill

Uncorrected oral evidence: Draft Conversion Practices Bill, HC 741

Monday 16 November 2026

4.20 pm

 

Watch the meeting

Members present: Olivia Bailey; Danny Beales; Baroness Brown of Silvertown; Baroness Browning; Lord Hope of Craighead; Lord Isaac; Baroness Prentis of Banbury; Lord Scriven; Naz Shah; Sir Jeremy Wright.

In the absence of the Chair, Lord Hope of Craighead took the Chair.

 

Evidence Session No. 4  Heard in Public  Questions 127 – 187

 

Witnesses

I: Baroness Cass, Chair, Independent Review of Gender Identity Services for Children and Young People; Professor Gillian Leng, President, Royal Society of Medicine, President, Medical Protection Society.

II: Dr Arun Chopra, Chief Inspector of Mental Health, Care Quality Commission; Andrew Smith, Deputy Chief Executive, Health and Care Professions Council; Mark Swindells, Assistant Director for Standards and Ethics, General Medical Council.

 

USE OF THE TRANSCRIPT 

  1. This is an uncorrected transcript of evidence taken in public and webcast on www.parliamentlive.tv. 
  1. Any public use of, or reference to, the contents should make clear that neither Members nor witnesses have had the opportunity to correct the record. If in doubt as to the propriety of using the transcript, please contact the Clerk of the Committee. 
  1. Members and witnesses are asked to send corrections to the Clerk of the Committee within 14 days of receipt.

Examination of Witnesses

Witnesses: Baroness Cass and Professor Gillian Leng.

  1.    Chair: This afternoon, we are holding an oral evidence session on the draft Conversion Practices Bill. This Joint Committee has been appointed to consider and report on the Government’s draft Bill, which sets out provisions to prevent and criminalise abusive and harmful conversion practices. We offer our thanks to our witnesses for attending this session. I am sure that I do not need to remind everybody that we are dealing with very sensitive matters, and we appreciate that this can be a challenging area, especially for our witnesses.

I will begin by asking our two witnesses to introduce themselves. Baroness Cass, would you be kind enough to introduce yourself, please?

Baroness Cass: I am Hilary Cass. I was the chair of the independent review of gender identity services for children and young people, which I foolishly allowed to become eponymously named after me. I need to declare that I am now an independent adviser to DHSC on gender services for children and young people.

Chair: Thank you. Professor Leng?

Professor Leng: Thank you for inviting me. I am the president of the Royal Society of Medicine, a multi-specialty body, and the fairly new president of the Medical Protection Society, a defence body. I also come with 20 years of experience at NICE, developing guidance or guidelines for the NHS. I therefore come with breadth but not depth in these subject areas.

  1.    Chair: May I begin by putting a fairly general question to you, Baroness Cass? You have welcomed the draft Bill; I think you said that, compared with previous drafts, it gives a clearer definition of what conversion practices are, but also of what they are not. Do you think that the Bill’s definition of abusive conversion practices is clear enough to do what you have been saying?

Baroness Cass: No, I am afraid I don’t. I should clarify that. I met with Liv Bailey when she was Minister, and she explained to me the principles of how the Bill would operate. It was encouraging that there was indeed more clarity about what it would cover and would not cover, but I had not actually seen the Bill, and I said that I could not give a statement until I had. Unfortunately, I was not sent the Bill until about 15 minutes before they wanted the press comment, so I gave a statement on the principles that I had been told about, but said that I was looking forward to pre-leg scrutiny, because clearly I needed to read the Bill.

Having obviously now spent a long time thinking about it, I unfortunately do not think that it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.

  1.    Chair: Others will be questioning you in more detail on this, but could you summarise very briefly where you see the weaknesses?

Baroness Cass: Yes. Although there is a health carve-out, which I did welcome, the problem is in the definition of what it means for a person to fall “far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position.” At the moment, we do not have clear standards. Moreover, standards are highly contested in this area, and there are many who disagree strongly with the approach recommended in my review.

The jeopardy, particularly for healthcare professionals, is that it is very easy for a young person who is understandably distressed after what is inevitably a painful discussion—possibly angry and upset that they have not, for example, got on to the medication pathway that they want—to feel, and report, that the professional has behaved in what they deem to be a very negative way.

The further challenge is that unfortunately there are also malign actors—I have seen social media quotes from them—looking to exploit young people who may feel that they have had an adverse experience, in order to pursue some of the people working in this field. That is a significant problem. Many people are being called conversion therapists: myself, the right honourable Wes Streeting, clinicians working in the new gender services and other clinicians you have heard from on this Committee, who are just doing careful, exploratory work with teenagers. That is one whole area.

My second concern relates to parents. I know that there is absolutely no intention for them to be caught up in this, but that is unavoidably a potential risk of the way in which the Bill is framed. Things like not agreeing to change your child’s pronouns, or restricting money if you think they are going to use it to get a breast binder or hormones—all those things could fall within the reach of this Bill. Those are significant worries, I think.

  1.    Lord Isaac: Thank you, Baroness Cass; that is really helpful. May I start by asking whether you still stand by paragraph 11.5 of your report, which says that “no LGBTQ+ group should be subjected to conversion practice”?

Baroness Cass: I absolutely do. Moreover, throughout most of the review, we had a statement to that effect on my website, saying that those practices are abhorrent and are not something that anyone would condone. I have obviously thought about this for a very long time. I have racked my brain as to how, and have spoken to Ministers in the previous Administration and this one as to how one might enact a Bill that protects the people it is supposed to protect but does not accidentally entrap those you do not want it to.

  1.    Baroness Brown of Silvertown: May I ask a follow-up? Baroness, are you aware of any of the other legislation passed by other legislators in this area? Do you think any of those make a better Bill than the one that is in front of you?

Baroness Cass: Yes. In fact, the GMC, which you will hear from next, has done a much more thorough review of legislation in other jurisdictions, but the problem is that it is all relatively new. I understand that no cases have been pursued yet, and I also do not know whether it has had a chilling effect or not, so I am not sure that I can say anything very useful on that.

  1.    Lord Isaac: Can I come back to the very helpful amendment that you sponsored to the Health Bill? I think it perhaps addresses some of the concerns that you have identified this afternoon and a way forward, and I am quite keen to explore some of that.

Over the past few weeks, we have been looking at questions of what is or is not a health professional. In your amendment, you very helpfully talk about somebody who is registered but also somebody who meets the standards reasonably expected of a person in that position. It would be good to hear your view on that.

The second area for us has been exploratory conversations that take place in a therapeutic or medical context. You very helpfully talk about how those conversations could take place exploring the person’s distress but without presuming any particular outcome. We have been asking questions about affirmative therapy. Could you help us with those two areas? That will certainly expedite some of the questions that we have this afternoon.

Baroness Cass: Yes. This was an attempt—it was obviously a probing amendment—to see whether one could tighten this up, and I have shared it with the clinicians in the new services. Suffice it to say that there are four new hubs, and it is worth saying where they are. In London, that involves Great Ormond Street, Evelina, which is Guy’s and Tommy’s, and the Maudsley. In the north of the country, it is Liverpool—Alder Hey—and Manchester. Then there are Bristol and Cambridge, which has just come on. You can see those are very impressive children’s hospital centres. They have responded as a group with their concerns, and many of them have phoned me individually and I have shared this with them, but that has not really allayed their concern that you could still be the subject of a vexatious complaint. As you know with these things, the issue is not so much whether you are found guilty; it is the whole process of the inquiry. As colleagues behind me from the GMC will know, there are people who commit suicide while awaiting the outcome of a GMC referral. The chilling effect is not theoretical; it is real, and it is here today.

  1.    Lord Isaac: Do you think your amendments go some way to address those concerns?

Baroness Cass: I am trying to be helpful to this Bill, obviously, but it is still not allaying people’s anxieties that they could still be taken through a process, even if they are exonerated, or a private prosecution. The problem about this area is that it is hard to recruit to, and it is hard to retain staff. It is a sort of sellers’ market if you are CAMHS professional—as you know, we are very short of them—so why would you work in this when you could work somewhere else?

  1.    Lord Isaac: I certainly understand that, but can I ask one final question? You gave some examples earlier of anxieties and the chilling effect. Those examples still have to meet the test of being abusive and causing serious harm. Do you think that all the examples that you gave meet that threshold?

Baroness Cass: Staff have given me some real, practical examples. A mother says in relation to a child who is a biological male and now a trans female that the father said, “I couldn’t have tolerated him being gay. I’d have beaten it out of him.” If you have a discussion with that young person about whether things might have been different if they had not grown up in that environment, that could be very triggering and traumatising for the child. It may meet the threshold of impacting their functional—a lot of the children and young people being seen are not functioning very well anyway. Those are the sorts of judgments that—

  1.    Lord Isaac: Lots of statements are being made. You have made the point about the debate being weaponised—

Baroness Cass: On both sides.

Lord Isaac: On various sides. Do you agree that some of those do not meet the threshold?

Baroness Cass: I think the problem is not whether something would meet the threshold, but whether somebody would still report the individual, with everything that goes with that—which is highly problematic.

Lord Isaac: I understand.

Chair: There will be questions from Baroness Browning and then Olivia Bailey. Professor Leng, I am very sorry that you have been overlooked so far. May I ask the two questioners to put their questions and then come back to you for any comment? Is that all right?

Professor Leng indicated assent.

  1.    Baroness Browning: I should perhaps declare that Baroness Cass and I know each other, but not in this context. We have regular conversations, mainly about autism—

Baroness Cass: And vaccinations.

Baroness Browning: Yes. I declare that now.

The Cass review, on page 150, talks about exploratory therapy. That has come up in the evidence we have taken, particularly as far as clinicians and professionals are concerned. But your report stated: “The role of psychological therapies…has been overshadowed by an unhelpfully polarised debate around conversion practices. Terms such as ‘affirmative’”—which we have heard a lot about—“and ‘exploratory’ approaches have been weaponised”. Now that you have read the Bill and seen the language used in it and the explanatory notes on it, are you still concerned about that?

Baroness Cass: Yes, I am still concerned, because unfortunately the polarisation is worse now, I think, than when I first came out with my report. We had a honeymoon period after my interim report, when things settled down a bit, and then the environment became more hostile, on all sides. It is obviously profoundly unhelpful having—I am not sure whether I am allowed to say this in a Committee—President Trump, on the other side of the pond, being very aggressive towards trans people. That pushes the polarisation even more.

It is very clear that there are still malign actors on both sides, but there are those who feel that the exploratory approach that I describe in my report is conversion therapy. That is what they label it as. There is definitely a wish to push back on the changes that have come about because of my review, and this is one way to potentially undermine it. That is troublesome. I do not know how we get out of that problem.

  1.    Olivia Bailey: I should declare just for the record that—as you have mentioned, Baroness Cass—we met when I was a Minister, during the creation of this legislation.

I want to return to some of the themes that Lord Isaac has explored with you. In particular, you said that your concerns about the Bill were, on the healthcare exemption—please correct me if I get any of this wrong—that there is not enough clarity on what below an acceptable level is and you fear that people will be subjected to vexatious complaints. Then, on parents, you mentioned some examples, such as a parent not using pronouns or not being willing to buy a breast binder, as reasons why they might be affected by this legislation. Subject to further clarification from Lord Isaac, we have then established that you accept that people’s perception of the law is not the same as what is actually in the law.

If you accept, as you just have, that you think there should be a ban on abusive conversion therapy, would clarity on both those points for parents and healthcare providers satisfy you? For example, for healthcare providers, guidance on what is below an acceptable level could be useful, and perhaps some sort of provision around protecting against vexatious complaints. Would that satisfy you and enable you to continue to support a ban on the abuse of LGBT people?

Baroness Cass: The devil is in the detail; I would need to see the text of it. Let me give you an example of what happened to a parent. I ran listening sessions through my review, so anyone could talk to me if they had what I considered to be skin in the game. In other words, they had to be a young person, a young adult, a family or carer, or a professional working in some respect in the field, which could have been health, education or social care, but I was not prepared to hear from people who came from a purely ideological stance.

This is one of many stories, but a mother was in an abusive relationship with her husband. The daughter was going through anorexia and then had some medically unexplained symptoms. The mother and father broke up, and the father left the family home. The daughter then began identifying as trans male. The father, who was still in contact, was initially hugely negative about that. The mother tried to be supportive but was doing what I spoke about—not using the other name and not using the pronouns that the young person wanted. The father, who was still very angry with his wife, or was very acrimonious, reported her to social services for not supporting this young person’s gender transition. At the time she spoke to me, she was 11 months into an investigation by social services, and the younger brother had developed bed-wetting and was no longer going to school.

I think that was the father being vexatious, but he could now, on this, just as easily report her to the police, for example. People who are angry have the potential to do the wrong thing, and it is about how we try to guard against that. Believe me, as I said, I have been trying to think of forms of words on this whole issue for a number of years, but the devil is always in the detail.

  1.    Chair: I think the question, if I can put it this way, is whether the Bill would be improved if there were a provision for statutory guidance. Obviously the devil is in the detail, but we do not have that in the Bill at the moment. Would the Bill be improved if it were there?

Baroness Cass: Potentially, yes. As I say, I cannot think how you would frame it, but one would have to look at it. There is always room for improvement. When I spoke to the current Minister, he was really clear that everyone is looking to improve the Bill, but it is very hard to prejudge changes that we have not yet seen.

  1.    Chair: Yes, of course. Professor Leng, do you have any comment to make on what you have heard so far?

Professor Leng: I think it is really important to remember that the scenarios we are probably considering are not people who are absolutely clear about what they want; it is those who are distressed and unhappy and need to have open, honest conversations in the healthcare scenario, so let’s focus on that. We therefore need clinicians who feel absolutely empowered to have open, honest conversations, where they are asking questions, they are safe to explore and they are not directing an outcome.

We already see a lot of defensive medicine being practised in this country. Sadly, it has changed a lot since I qualified. I worry that the breadth of this definition at the moment encompasses a conversation that might, albeit that it was exploratory, upset someone because of the circumstance that they are in.

I think we will see clinicians shying away from having those conversations that people need, and—knowing the way the world works these days—people will go online to find answers. We know there are abusive practices happening online, and it may well make that scenario worse. I am not sure whether the Bill is intended to encapsulate what happens online, but that is a place where abusive conversion practices are more likely to happen than in healthcare, which is a highly regulated environment.

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: A lot of what I was going to ask has already been covered, but I am very struck by the language that you have been using: “weaponising”, “hostile”, “malign actors”. Just to summarise what I think you have said: in this field, even if we say that statutory guidance must be given, there will be a real chilling effect from the very fact of passing legislation. Is that your real worry?

Baroness Cass: Yes, I am afraid so. This is such an extraordinary area that during the course of my review I could not get people on opposite ends of the spectrum into a room together; it just was not possible. There is so much anger and distrust on both sides that it is not feasible. Dr Hutchinson, whom you have heard from before, has had to have security with her when she has given talks. That is not normal, in any area of medicine.

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: No. Are you also concerned that it might have a chilling effect not just on the provision of healthcare but on whistleblowing, which was relied on in the Tavistock case, for example?

Baroness Cass: Yes, and I am sure members of the Committee will be aware of what happened in Sarah Redvers’s case in Brighton. Are people aware of that?

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: Could you summarise quickly?

Baroness Cass: Yes. This was a GP called Sam Hall, who was giving out both puberty blockers and masculinising and feminising hormones in a way which an investigation has demonstrated to have been extremely dangerous. Dr Redvers was the safeguarding GP for the area. People came to her with concerns. She raised those concerns—

Chair: May I interrupt you? Is this sub judice at the moment?

Baroness Cass: What I am saying is in the public domain.

Chair: It is in the public domain—okay. We have to be very careful not to comment on something that is sub judice, so do be careful with what you are saying.

Baroness Cass: Okay. Anyway, the upshot was that Dr Redvers ended up having to leave her job, and the current case in point is an employment tribunal that has been brought by Dr Redvers as the whistleblower.

Chair: We must leave it there,  I think. I call Baroness Browning—sorry, Baroness Brown.

  1.    Baroness Brown of Silvertown: Brown, yes. I did not get the extra “ing”: we obviously couldn’t afford it.

Can I ask whether you think there are any risks in our not passing something now that criminalises conversion therapy? Do you feel that we would leave people unprotected? Having gone this far, as long as the Bill tightens up on the areas that you have spoken about, do you feel that it might be worrisome not to proceed to the end and pass it?

Baroness Cass: Yes. This is the game that is medicine as well: what is the greater risk, and how do you evaluate it? Medicine is a game of risk reduction. We can never eliminate risk, so the question is whether the risks are greater from passing the Bill or from not passing it. It is a really difficult one to call.

I think the other thing is that although this is a Bill that covers the whole LGBT community, the complexities are greater for trans-identifying children and young people than for LGB people. It is that particular part of it that is so complex. We know that some children with gender dysphoria or gender incongruence or who are trans-identifying—however you want to term it—will continue to be gender-incongruent into adulthood. For them, a medical and/or surgical transition may be the best outcome. But we know that many young people express psychological and physical distress through gender dysphoria and that if you prematurely medicalise them, that is a huge price to pay; whereas, whatever the risks of medical treatment, if you have a long-standing trans identity, the risks and side effects are trivial compared with the pain of not being able to live in your identified gender. That is what we are balancing. It is much more complicated for that group of young people.

  1.    Danny Beales: Thank you, Baroness Cass, for your evidence. You are describing the challenges that people currently experience in a contested space and a number of the issues that health professionals are already weighing up and experiencing. Is it your view that any Bill including healthcare professionals that does not have a kind of universal opt-out would cause concerns? Are you suggesting that there needs to just be a universal exclusion for healthcare professionals from criminalisation through conversion practices?

Baroness Cass: Well, that is one way forward, which would also have pros and cons. We would still have the question of what constitutes a healthcare professional. The other way of doing it would be to accredit centres or organisations. So I don’t know. Nothing is without risk, is it?

  1.    Lord Isaac: Baroness Cass, I thought your amendment was very helpful, because in it you tackle some of these things. I can see that you are trying to put forward various ideas. The carve-out that you talk about does not apply to conduct that involves physical force, threats or coercion. I think that that allays some of the fears that we are talking about today. I thought that was helpful. Do you have any further reflections on that?

Baroness Cass: Yes, that was what I was trying to do, although plainly those things are always going to be inappropriate under any circumstance.

Chair: I will call Naz Shah next. After she has put her question, I am going to ask you, Professor Leng, whether you have any comments. I am very conscious that you have not been contributing very much, but it is not because we do not want to hear from you. I will ask Nas Shah to put her question first, and then we will come back to you.

  1.    Naz Shah: My question is to both of you. The Cass report says: “Parents and families need support and advice about how best to support their children in a balanced and nonjudgemental way.” I take it that we all agree with that. Do you believe that this Bill would help to achieve that? Specifically, how concerned are you about the prospect of private legal action under the draft Bill? Do you think that there should be any changes there?

Baroness Cass: Yes, I do think that private legal action is a risk, because it is not at all clear how that bar would be set. Obviously it will be difficult enough going through the CPS, but if you can go direct to a private prosecution, I think that that is a further risk.

On your point about parents getting balanced advice, the challenge that parents face is that at the moment they still do not get very rapid access to medical care, so they are having to make complex and difficult judgments. As the Bill currently stands, it is very hard for parents to avoid potentially falling foul of its provisions. Lord Macdonald has already raised the point about it being unclear to parents whether or not they are crossing a line.

Professor Leng: You asked Baroness Cass whether there should be a universal opt-out for healthcare. We agree that there is a balance of risks here. My view is that the risk is probably greater that people will not get the care and support that they need, unless there is a universal opt-out, say for regulated healthcare settings. For me, that would probably make sense. We know what has happened, dare I mention it, in relation to people who are reaching the end of life and are struggling to have conversations with healthcare practitioners about not wanting to eat or drink, say: the clinician will just shut down that conversation because they are afraid of being caught up in helping somebody to die. We have seen that happen elsewhere—that is why I am bringing in that example—and I fear it would happen here.

Regardless of that, I think a good guideline would really help to reassure practitioners. We know that that happens in other areas, and that if they are required to defend their practice, it really helps if they have followed a guideline and have had clear training and accreditation in the field. Regardless of whether there is a universal opt-out, those professional guidelines would really help.

  1.    Chair: What do you mean by “universal opt-out”?

Professor Leng: At the moment, the draft Bill says that it “is not a conversion practice unless the person acts in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position.”

  1.    Chair: So it would be qualified by a reference to the standard. I wondered whether you were just saying that they should be completely exempt. That would be taking things long-distance. Are you suggesting that?

Professor Leng: We need to bear it in mind that we have to think about what problem we are intending to resolve. Most of the problems here are not in the healthcare setting; it does happen sometimes, but it is rare and rogue, and there are already ways of dealing with healthcare professionals who cross that line. Conversion practices are banned, if you like—I am using that word informally—by NHS England, and are not recommended by the colleges. It is not the setting that is most at risk here, by any means. That is why I mentioned the balance of risk: I expect that having it in the Bill will increase the risk to the people who need help. That is what we need to think about and keep at the centre.

  1.    Naz Shah: My final question is to you in particular, Baroness Cass. In response to Lord Hope, you said that the definition was not clear enough. There has been plenty of media coverage—it was even in yesterday’s report—saying that you supported the draft Bill originally. Given what you said earlier, I want to be really clear. I know we all want to end abusive, coercive conversion practice. Do you support this Bill as drafted?

Baroness Cass: No. As I said, I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then Minister. I had said that I would not comment until I had seen it. It was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release, and 15 minutes before I walked on a platform to give a talk, so I tried to give quotes based on the principles that I had been told about, but without seeing the Bill as drafted. Maybe I should not have done that, but, as I said, I am supportive of trying to do something about conversion practices.

None the less, having seen the Bill, having spoken to the many families who have emailed me and having spoken to my colleagues, I cannot support the Bill in its current form.

  1.    Sir Jeremy Wright: I wonder whether it might be helpful to unpack the structure of the Bill a little. We have talked about the healthcare exemption. The stage at which the Bill asks us to consider whether a conversion practice is happening is the point at which the healthcare exemption operates, is it not? At that point, if you meet the requirements of that part of the Bill, you are lifted out of consideration under any further stages.

I think what you are saying to us is that you are concerned that the Bill is drafted to require that, in order to benefit from the healthcare exemption, someone must not be acting “in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position.” You are concerned that that might be problematic. Can we park that for a minute and think about the other stages? If we go to the last of them—the question of whether “serious harm” or “serious alarm or distress” is caused—I think, Baroness Cass, you were saying earlier that that is not a high enough hurdle. I see that you are nodding, Professor Leng; I will give you the chance to agree with that, if you would like, but I will take the nod as assent.

The other hurdle is that the behaviour is abusive. If you do not qualify for protection under the healthcare exemption, because it is considered that your actions fall far below the standards expected of someone in your position—if the Chair lets me, I will come back to some of those questions in a minute—you then face the question whether your behaviour was abusive, in the terms of the Act. Did it cause alarm, distress or harm? You have said already that you do not think that the last of those is a big enough hurdle. Do you think that abusiveness is a big enough hurdle, as it is defined in the Bill at the moment?

Baroness Cass: I am not clear how abuse, in this setting, is defined. It is defined as the serious harm, which is alarm, distress and so on. It does not seem to be defined separately from that.

The other thing that one has to be really sensitive to is that there are two people in the room: the clinician and the young person. When people walk out of a room, they have a very different perception of what happened. We have all the same issues as in rape, for example, about what intent is. I think it is very difficult to be absolutely clear about whether what the clinician actually said has caused that distress, or whether it has thrown up for the young person some kind of deep-seated distress and they therefore perceive that that was the fault of the therapist. Does that make sense?

Sir Jeremy Wright: It does, and of course the distress does not have to be intentional, as the Bill is drafted.

Baroness Cass: No.

  1.    Sir Jeremy Wright: Would it help if it did have to be intentional, or at least in circumstances where the person causing the distress should have realised that they would do so?

Baroness Cass: Realising that a discussion is going to be painful is probably not a reason why a healthcare professional does not have that conversation. Otherwise, you cannot make progress in trying to address some things. If a young person, for example, has been sexually abused, any discussion about it is going to be incredibly triggering, but you cannot therapeutically work through it without any reference to it. That is the problem.

I am not suggesting this as a solution, but maybe we need to find some way to think very specifically about young gender-questioning people, because that is the whole thrust of the problem. When you evolve your sexual orientation—some people are very clear about their sexual orientation from very young; for some people it takes longer and more experimentation—it is not something that can be a way that you feel purely as a result of a whole series of other, kind of, traumas. For example, I spoke frequently to parents where the young person had gone through a significant mental breakdown, was on the autistic spectrum, had gone through eating disorders, had gone through cutting or had gone through medically unexplained symptoms and then presented with gender distress. All those things were a function of something else that was causing that young person to be very distressed. That is a very different situation from that of somebody who works their sexual orientation out over a period.

We are treating as a stable belief something that is both developmental and, in some cases, part of a completely different presentation. That is what makes this so difficult. I am not sure if I am being clear about that.

Sir Jeremy Wright: No, you are. I think that what you are saying is that it is intrinsically distressing to discuss, perhaps seriously so.

Baroness Cass indicated assent.

  1.    Sir Jeremy Wright: Professor Leng, do you have anything to add?

Professor Leng: I would just echo that these things are intrinsically difficult to discuss, and intrinsically difficult for parents to discuss. They are also upset. I have two friends whose daughters have transitioned from male to female, and I saw through them how they actually were going through a grieving process.

Going back to what we need here, we need supportive environments where all concerned can have sensitive conversations. I like evidence; you can tell that from my background. You look for reviews in this field, and you get reviews of things like aversion therapy, hypnosis, spinal cord cauterisation—all sorts of awful things—and those things are absolutely banned. But we have to be very careful when it comes into the context of having conversations in a healthcare supportive environment, because that is not what we want to criminalise; that is what we want to support.

Baroness Cass: I can read you a quote from a parent, if that is helpful. This is from somebody whose daughter identified as transgender and then gradually desisted over time. She said, “We all experienced significant distress and were impaired in our day-to-day functioning. It’s a very stressful experience to have a beloved child suddenly insist you call them a different name and use different pronouns, when they themselves are self-harming and pleading for hormones, binders and breast surgery.” This young lady then overdosed and the parents were investigated by social services. She said, “I felt bullied and experienced the encounters with education and healthcare providers as the psychological abduction of my child.” Yet some years later, when the young person desisted, she said that what she saw as her mother not understanding her and causing her pain and distress, she now sees as having protected her.

Of course, there are many cases that will come out differently, and the young person may go on to have a stable trans identity and a very successful life as a trans adult, but these are the ones that are the challenge.

  1.    Lord Scriven: I want to ask both of you about something that Baroness Cass said. I declare an interest: I know Baroness Cass as well.

You have said that there are no clear standards, or that standards are highly contested. Based on where we are and what the Bill says, what kind of standards do you think the bar will actually be? Will it be specific standards or will it be generic standards about medical practice? What are the standards, as the Bill stands, that somebody would be tested against?

Baroness Cass: Well, that is the $64,000 question, because, strange as it may seem, not everybody agrees with what I think are the right standards. WPATH, which was deemed to be the industry standard and which is largely American-based, has—let’s call it—a more affirmative approach than mine, although they do say that there should be a proper assessment of the child or young person.

I think people could make the case that we should refer to other standards. However, the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges has been commissioned to pull together a multi-professional group—not just doctors, although they are the medical overview body—to develop a competency framework and training materials. That is why I put that into my potential amendment. One option is that one could take that as certainly a standard of training and working.

Having said that, other professionals could say, “My professional organisation says this and it is different,” and unless we say, “Well, within the law, you have to adhere to this standard,” there can be contest about what the appropriate standards are for that particular professional. I do not know whether you can throw any light on it, Gillian.

Professor Leng: You talked about competency and training standards; I am keen on a guideline to inform best practice as well. Ideally, you would put that together in a multi-professional group, but also include patients. In this case, we would want to include the views of young people, which would be obtained separately because of their age. You would want to include parents as well. You would want to make sure that all perspectives were captured.

A guideline is important, because it draws on evidence but also has a consensus element. It is a guideline, not a tramline, so it would not necessarily mean that everything had to be followed, but if a practitioner did not think something was relevant, as long as it is documented and they have explained why they have done what they have done, it is pretty defensible should something go wrong. I think that in this rather fraught area, having a guideline to inform practice could only help.

  1.    Lord Scriven: Would that cover both regulated and non-regulated?

Professor Leng: Most guidelines—I am thinking of NICE guidelines; I don’t want to give my new colleagues at NICE a job to do here—are generally considered essential by the GMC and regulators. You must follow best practice guidelines, so it definitely applies to regulated practitioners. Unregulated is a different field, and there is a lot of challenge around unregulated professionals in all sorts of areas at the moment. There needs to be a solution to that that is probably cross-cutting, not just about this.

  1.    Chair: We are more or less up against our time, but I would like to ask a question that takes us to the ultimate situation, which I hope would not arise: a criminal prosecution.

In the end, the prosecutor would have to prove that, say, a child had suffered serious harm. As prosecutor, I would be concerned whether I would be able to prove that without leading evidence from the child herself. This raises an issue that I think the New Zealand legislation has addressed; I think it makes it an absolute offence to subject a person under 16 to conversion practices and abuse, without having to prove serious harm. It is simply assumed that there is serious harm, and you do not have to lead that evidence. Do you have any view on that, Baroness Cass?

Baroness Cass: That is right: I do not know how you do this without taking evidence from the child. But the other thing that I was struggling with is subsection (5): “The question whether conduct amounts to an abuse of the individual is a question of fact to be determined by reference to all the circumstances of the case, including in particular the nature of the conduct.” I am not sure how a clinical professional could manage that. If, for example, they knew that the child had been sexually abused by a parent who was no longer in the family home or had died—in any event, who was not there any more, so there was not a current safeguarding issue—and if that framed part of the discussion with the child, the practitioner would then be breaching confidentiality in talking about it. What could the practitioner talk about without breaching the whole family’s confidentiality, particularly if there were other children who did not know about it? That makes it quite difficult for the practitioner to defend themselves, as well as the point you made about what pressure you put a child under in a judicial proceeding.

Chair: It is a problem for the prosecutor as well, who has to lead enough evidence to persuade a jury beyond a reasonable doubt that the offence has been committed.

I think we will have to leave it there, because we have another panel to come.

Baroness Cass: I am afraid I probably made that less clear than when I walked in the room.

Chair: Thank you both very much indeed. If either of you has any points that you would like to elaborate on in writing, please feel free to do so; we would very much welcome anything more that you would like to add. We will pause proceedings for a moment while we change witnesses.

 

Examination of Witnesses

Witnesses: Dr Arun Chopra, Andrew Smith and Mark Swindells.

  1.    Chair: Good afternoon to the three witnesses before us for our second panel. I would be very grateful if you would introduce yourselves.

Mark Swindells: Good afternoon. I am Mark Swindells, the assistant director for standards and ethics at the General Medical Council.

Dr Chopra: Good afternoon. I am Arun Chopra, the chief inspector of mental health at the CQC.

Andrew Smith: Good afternoon, everyone. I am Andrew Smith, the deputy chief exec of the Health and Care Professions Council.

  1.    Chair: Can I put a general question to you first, to set the scene? Can you say how successful current regulatory approaches are in upholding the standards across gender and sexual orientation healthcare services? Tell us about the present state of play, the general standards and the way they are being applied.

Mark Swindells: I have a few thoughts on that. It is fair to say, certainly in recent years, that we do not have a large number of complaints pertaining to doctors—we also regulate physician associates and anaesthesia associates in this area. We set standards of professionalism, and as you heard the previous panel say, we will look to the prevailing clinical good practice out there, which is obviously important for this context.

If I can potentially give some reassurance for doctors about some of the areas of concern that have come up so far in the evidence, we set lots of guidance, for example on consent, about the professional expectation that falls on doctors precisely to lean in and explain the risks and benefits of different medical procedures. I think that that is different from someone’s identity, but where that presents us with something to go on a medical pathway, I think that, from the GMC’s perspective, that would be good practice.

Dr Chopra: A couple of observations from me. We regulate services against the fundamental standards set out in regulations. These include things such as patient-centred care, consent, dignity and making sure people are safeguarded and not victims of abuse. There are a range of services in this space that we regulate. We regulate NHS services, both those that provide care to children and those that provide care to adults. There are some providers in the independent sector that we regulate, but there are others that we do not. That is just part of how the regulations have been set out.

We have taken action where we have seen standards below what we expect in gender services. For example, we rated one provider as inadequate because of various different failings we had seen, including in whether holistic assessments were being made, whether governance was being followed and whether services were as safe as they could be. There is provision for us to take regulatory action in some of these areas, but not all of them.

Andrew Smith: Much like colleagues at the General Medical Council, we set outcome-focused standards. That covers the behaviours and conduct and the skills and competencies that we expect of the people on our register.

We see very few concerns raised with us about areas of this nature. I am not aware of any concerns reported to us by anyone about our registrants working inappropriately around conversion practices. We see low numbers, similarly to the General Medical Council. Our standards are designed to be outcome-focused and to look at what is in the best interests of patients and service users.

  1.    Naz Shah: I just have a quick question, building on what you have said, Dr Chopra. We have heard that gender identity healthcare services are a particularly polarised area of medicine. You have just said that the regulations are not always there. How will regulators go about deciding what reasonable standards look like in such a contested area?

Dr Chopra: That is what we heard Baroness Cass set out as the $64,000 question. I think there are standards we can draw upon that would create the space for clinicians to be able not only to undertake exploratory work, but to ensure that people are safeguarded and that these abusive practices are ended.

There are national service specifications for what we would expect children’s services and adult services to deliver. Indeed, that is what David Levy assessed services against. There are changes that need to be made to those national service specifications, in line with what Baroness Cass and David Levy have said. There are also professional standards that operate, and there are standards that are set out by colleges and other areas. There is then a memorandum of understanding that many organisations have signed up to—I am a psychiatrist by background, and my college signed up to that—and there are expectations and standards there. You could draw upon those sources of guidance.

NHSE has accepted the recommendations that Baroness Cass and David Levy have set out. Certainly, when we go out to inspect adult gender services—we have started a programme of doing that—we are drawing upon those existing frameworks, and the standards that are set within them, to understand whether services are operating in a way that not only allows clinicians to practise safely, but makes sure that no abhorrent practices are taking place.

Mark Swindells: Similarly, if a concern were raised with us about conversion practices, we would look to the prevailing best clinical guidance. As we understand it, the academy is working on some guidance designed to span different professional groups, and NICE is also working on it. We agree with what the previous panel said. It strikes us that the clinical guidance at the moment is very contested. The expert opinion that we would look to would also include the service specifications.

  1.    Lord Scriven: I have a very technical question. At this point, for transparency, I declare that I know Dr Chopra not through the Committee, but through correspondence that we have had regarding a personal family matter.

All three of you said that you have carried out a very small amount of regulation, if any at all. When you have such complaints on your database, is there a tag for this? Has it been hard for you to do a trawl? I want to understand that.

Mark Swindells: The context is that we get over 10,000 concerns raised about a doctor in any given year, so we have a database with various different allegation categories into which we will put things. They tend to be at a slightly higher level than this. The straight answer to your question is no, but we have done some work manually to look through those cases to establish that, so I am relatively confident in the small number.

  1.    Baroness Browning: From what you have said and from what we have already heard, among different professional organisations and regulators there are standards and practices in which there may be some variation between all of you. Given that the Bill relates specifically to conversion practices, and we know that it does not preclude private prosecution, do all of your standards and practices not have to come up to the bar of clinical negligence, so that you can be safe from being prosecuted in private prosecutions?

Mark Swindells: Our guidance for doctors, PAs and AAs is about good practice, rather than being linked to either a civil or a criminal process. It links through to lots of different powers that we have as a regulator, but it includes fitness to practise, which is different from a criminal or civil assessment of negligence. It describes good practice and includes all areas of a doctor’s practice, whether NHS or private provision.

To clarify, I do not think that there is a huge division among us on the professionalism side of things. It is not the GMC’s role to set the clinical guidance; we set the professional standards, but we look to royal colleges, the academy, NICE or others—even internationally, which I think is relevant in this space.

Dr Chopra: I would agree with that. We would draw upon the guidance—the standards that are set out for England, which is where we are regulating health and care services.

Andrew Smith: The same. We would look to our professional bodies and other organisations for the clinical expectations of what would and would not be acceptable.

  1.    Sir Jeremy Wright: I suspect that you heard me discuss with the previous panel of witnesses the structure of the Bill and the way in which the healthcare exemption works. I want to ask you all two questions about the breadth of that exemption. I do not expect you to have the Bill in front of you, but so that we are all clear what I am talking about, it is clause 1(3) and the definition subsection, which is clause 1(9).

As you will appreciate, at the moment the benefit to a medical practitioner of being exempted from the effect of the Bill if doing something that does not fall far below the required standards—we have talked a bit about what those standards might mean—applies to everyone in the healthcare professions, regulated or not. Is it your view that the protection offered should be limited to those within regulated professions?

Dr Chopra: Yes.

Sir Jeremy Wright: That’s the best answer we have had all day. [Laughter.]

Dr Chopra: The exception is set out very broadly. I understand that the purpose behind that is to make sure that as many people as possible feel the protection. However, the risk is that that brings into play people—I will reframe this another way. I think that the important point to note is that it is those people who are providing legitimate healthcare whom we want to ensure we protect. That might mean those people who are working in regulated providers, which the CQC regulates, or those professionals who are working in that space, regardless of CQC regulation but on PSA accredited registers. I appreciate that standards are contested, but we have said what the English or UK-based standards are, so that would ensure those people who are working to those sorts of standards are the ones benefiting from the exception set out in the Bill.

Andrew Smith: My interpretation of the Bill is that it is designed to mitigate the potential chilling effect. I guess that that is the balance that has been drawn here, about how wide we have that exemption to mitigate that risk, but I would agree that having some definition about the groups of people involved in that might prevent people who may look to exploit the exemption but are nothing to do with legitimate healthcare practice, where people are having difficult, evidence-based conversations. It would be tightening that up to refer back to statutory-regulated professions. PSA accredited registers and possibly services covered by the CQC might be a step forward.

Mark Swindells: The GMC would agree, too. I think that that is the benefit of regulation. In a sense, in terms of public protection, people can be assured that someone on a regulator’s register or on one of the accredited registers has some degree of education and training, with an ongoing commitment to professional standards to remain registered, and that, were there to be an issue, there can be a form of investigation about it. I have one slight caveat to that: our dry, technical reading of the exemption is that it is not necessary—that is arguable, at least. I do not think that we would advise doctors to rely on it, bearing in mind our reading of the threshold of the Bill, which is the serious harm and intent. However, it is impossible to ignore the scale of the concerns that the Committee has heard, so I understand the rationale.

  1.    Sir Jeremy Wright: As we discussed earlier, if you do not benefit from the exemption, you still have to meet the thresholds of abusive and of serious harm, or alarm or distress, but we will perhaps come back as a Committee to whether those are the high hurdles they claim to be. In any event, my second question is linked to what you have all just said.

The definitions provision of the Bill says that “health care services” means “(a) all forms of health care services provided for individuals, whether relating to physical or mental health”—that sounds fairly comprehensive—“and (b) procedures that are similar to forms of medical or surgical care but are not provided in connection with a medical condition.” In relation to paragraph (b)—in other words, those things that are not medical care but are “similar” to it; the word “similar” is not defined—do you have concerns about the inclusion of that second paragraph, either on its own terms or in connection with whatever the relevant standards would be for people in that second category?

Dr Chopra: Standards have been set for referrals on from psychological interventions towards medical interventions and then further—towards surgery. Surgical specifications have been set. These are the standards within which people are expected to practise. That is where I see that second paragraph. Most of the concern that I have heard from colleagues who have been working in this space relates much more to the first aspect, rather than further down the pathway.

  1.    Sir Jeremy Wright: Everyone in the fields that you respectively regulate would come under paragraph (a), I suspect. Paragraph (b), as I say, is about procedures that are “similar” to forms of medical or surgical care but are not provided in connection with a medical condition. My question is about the breadth of that second paragraph and about what you think are the relevant standards that apply to those who are not within medical professions but are conducting activities said to be “similar” to medical activities. Mr Smith, do you have any thoughts on that?

Andrew Smith: I might answer it with a question: what is the mischief we are trying to protect against? I am not entirely clear from that, but I am not a lawyer—

Sir Jeremy Wright: Nobody’s perfect!

Andrew Smith: Or a CPS prosecutor. I wouldn’t say I am clear on exactly what that is trying to catch or rule out.

  1.    Lord Scriven: Would it follow from your answer about regulated provision, individuals and services that the second bit would not fall into any regulated service or individual?

Dr Chopra: That is a good question. I am trying to go through the regulated activities in my mind as a list and I think that is probably right. I may need to write in.

Lord Scriven: If you would, that would be helpful.

Sir Jeremy Wright: Mr Swindells, did you want to add anything? You don’t have to.

Mark Swindells: No, that is fine.

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: Maybe you cannot answer this, but do you have a sense of what proportion of therapists working in this area are not regulated?

Mark Swindells: No, we wouldn’t have that information.

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: You cannot, from your experience, give us any idea at all?

Mark Swindells: No. I don’t think it is the kind of information the GMC would hold, necessarily, because I don’t think people using those services would come to us.

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: This is the problem: if you don’t know, it is hard for us to find out. How usual is it for healthcare professionals to face a criminal investigation as opposed to a regulatory one?

Mark Swindells: It is not unheard of. It would typically be—there is gross negligence manslaughter, for example. You will be familiar, through the criminal court process, with the fact that there are various stages: establishing a duty of care, establishing that that was egregiously breached and establishing that it was foreseeable that harm would happen. So, without wanting to comment on any one case, it strikes us that it is a very high hurdle. I think the intention of the Bill was to match some of the wording from that, which is why we came to the conclusion that it is a relatively high hurdle. But that is not to dismiss—I repeat this—the concerns you have heard from doctors.

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: Dr Chopra, you regulate England. The Bill applies only to England and Wales. Does that cause you problems?

Dr Chopra: As the CQC, no for the services that we regulate in England. However, there is a difficulty, in that some providers in this space actually work outside England, are online only and are registered overseas. They may be providing psychological therapy with practitioners who are based in other jurisdictions in Brazil. We do not really have any remit over them. NHSE has put out information to colleagues working in this field about particular providers working in the primary care space who do not fall under CQC regulation because they are online-only and registered outside England. That would be the difficulty—not for us as a regulator because we do not have a remit. In terms of the people we are trying to protect here, that is an issue.

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: Is that practice widespread?

Dr Chopra: I cannot say whether it is widespread or not. There are a couple of instances that I am aware of, but they are high profile. There may be others. We would not have that data because they are not required to register with us, so we would not know the scale of this difficulty. There is more and more provision. Baroness Cass talked about international standards and how it is contested. We can talk about what standards apply within the UK, particularly for England and Wales, but what is happening outside that jurisdiction and what standards people are applying does not really fall under our remit.

  1.    Lord Isaac: Can I clarify the case in relation to your regulatory guidance? As I understood it, you were confident that some of the conversion practices would be caught and addressed—perhaps the extreme examples that I referred to when asking Baroness Cass questions. How would your regulatory guidance deal with the more tricky conversion practices or alleged conversion practices that we have been discussing? I am worried about a blurring of the threshold in the draft Bill and the impact on regulatory guidance.

Andrew Smith: In about 2022, we put out some guidance for our registrants around conversion practices not being in keeping with our standards. If a registrant was involved in conversion practices, we would take regulatory action. I am happy to provide the Committee with that.

  1.    Lord Isaac: And there is no definition of that.

Andrew Smith: We used and referred to the MOU and the definition in that at that time. We have been clear on that point. If the Bill came into effect and the definition changed, that is something we would keep under review, but we have been clear since 2022 that it is not acceptable or in keeping with our standards for registrants to engage or work in conversion practices.

  1.    Lord Isaac: So, depending upon where the threshold ultimately sits and how the Government react to our recommendations, you would have to revisit the guidance.

Andrew Smith: We would say conversion practices in any form. The Bill is talking about creating a criminal offence where that is an abusive relationship and results in serious harm. Our view is that conversion practices in general are not in keeping with our standards.

Mark Swindells: Just to clarify, if hypothetically the Bill passes and someone is convicted in the future and they are on our register, we would not need to retest that. We have a route through our fitness to practise process that accepts that the conviction has happened, so it is not re-prosecuted in that sense. I do not think the issue is there. I underline that the kinds of guidance we set at the moment across a doctor’s whole span of practice include things like making sure there is a solid evidence base for any approach they take and making sure their personal beliefs are not interfering with the advice they are giving to their patients. There is plenty we say at the moment that supports exactly what Andrew was saying about our guidance being incompatible with conversion practices.

  1.    Lord Isaac: A quick question: would the draft Bill mean that you would have to revisit your guidance?

Andrew Smith: It would not affect how we operate as a regulator. If the Bill came into effect, I do not think it would change how we operate if we received a complaint, because we have already been clear that it is not in keeping with our standards. The Bill would create a criminal offence, with abuse and serious harm being the factors, so it would not affect how we would regulate. It is looking at criminal prosecutions.

Dr Chopra: I agree. From my perspective, conversion practices are wrong. We do not agree with conversion practices. There is an issue around definition here. When we talk about regulated activity that is related to this, it is treatment of disease, disorder or injury. If someone is presenting with dysphoria due to gender incongruence, that is the sort of area where someone might work with that person, whether they are young or old. That is the scope of the activity we are talking about that is under our regulation, but the MOU, to which the college I belong to is a signatory, said we wanted to end conversion practices. We do not actually agree with them, in the way that colleagues were talking about.

  1.    Danny Beales: I have three quick questions. You have talked about introducing the MOU into your guidance and applying it. Obviously, we have heard a lot of concerns about vexatious complaints that might come forward from legislating on conversion practices. Have you seen any increase in vexatious regulatory complaints since applying the MOU on conversion practices? That is my first question.

Mark Swindells: We support the MOU. We are not actually a signatory of it. I would not overread that; it is simply because it is not within our remit to set clinical guidance—it is not precisely that, but no is the straight answer to your question. We have not seen an uptick. We do have a vexatious complaints policy to be able to handle that. Of course, it is always a matter of judgment what passes that test or not.

Andrew Smith: I would also like to clarify that we refer to the MOU in our guidance, but like the General Medical Council, we have not signed up to it. We do not sign up to documents of that nature, but we sort of signpost and refer to it.

  1.    Danny Beales: Since referring to it, have you seen an increase in vexatious complaints?

Andrew Smith: Not on this subject, no.

Dr Chopra: It is a no from us as well. I ought to clarify that the CQC is not a signatory to the document at this current time, but next time it is up for review, we could definitely look into it.

  1.    Danny Beales: That is helpful; thank you. My second question is: based on what you see in the draft legislation, and the fact that you have seen very few complaints in this area, as you have indicated in your evidence so far, what is your view on the level of increase you would be likely to see of complaints to regulators if this legislation were applied as drafted?

Andrew Smith: It is difficult to predict. I suppose it heightens awareness of the subject. The offences created are criminal offences, so people may start with referrals for criminal investigations, but it is a fair question to ask whether we might see increased referrals of this nature, given that the numbers are very low at the moment. I am afraid I cannot really answer that question. It is very difficult to look into the future in that way, but it will certainly raise the public attention on this subject. It is certainly an area that has been in the media for quite a number of years, and we have not seen numbers of referrals so far in this area.

Dr Chopra: It is difficult to say, from my perspective. From speaking to colleagues who work in these services, they certainly are saying to me that they are concerned that there may be a rise. I have been informed about that, but it is very difficult to say.

Mark Swindells: I would give a very similar answer.

  1.    Danny Beales: Thank you. Finally, I appreciate that you regulate in England and Wales—in a domestic context. Do you have conversations with other regulators internationally where this legislation or similar legislation has already been applied, and have those networks expressed any challenges with regulating health services in those contexts that already have conversion practice legislation?

Mark Swindells: We have not had direct conversations. We did an exercise to look at the different pieces of legislation. I think there are 27 or so across the world, all with various different powers and exemptions and so on, but no, we have not directly spoken to the other regulators. I should add that the GMC regulates across the UK, including Northern Ireland and Scotland.

Dr Chopra: Not yet from our perspective.

Andrew Smith: The same position as the GMC for us.

  1.    Chair: Can I ask you to help with how this scheme that the Bill presents us with will work out in practice? If, for the sake of argument, I put myself in the position of the victim, who do I go to? If I believe that I have been abused and suffered serious harm, my instinct would be to go to the police, and then that leads to a prosecution. But then you have somebody who falls within the healthcare exemption, and I suppose that is something that would have to be introduced into the prosecution as a defence. Somehow, it would have to be established that the healthcare professional has not fallen below the standards and therefore has the benefit of the exemption. But how is it actually going to work out in practice in court? Do you have any idea?

Mark Swindells: There are various important points to make. If someone on our register is charged with a crime, we expect them to inform us. That can open up the conversation so that we are able to track the case. We would not complicate it by doing a separate parallel investigation usually in those circumstances. We would defer to the criminal law taking its course. Hopefully, that makes that kind of scenario a bit clearer.

  1.    Chair: That is what I thought you would say—that you would pause any investigation because it is now in the hands of the DPP. But it still raises the question of how the healthcare practitioner is going to mount his defence without being able to establish that he is within the structure that the exemption lays down.

Mark Swindells: Their defence, I suppose, would be for them to mount and I think that is behind some of the concerns. But are you saying that there would be a regulatory input to that?

  1.    Chair: But anyway, you would not expect it to come to you for any sort of regulatory process until the criminal proceedings had either been abandoned or had reached a conclusion.

Mark Swindells: Very usually, yes.

  1.    Lord Scriven: Can I just come in, because I think your point is important? This Bill makes the criminal opt-out—or not—based on the standards far below the standards. I think what Lord Hope is trying to get at is that this is quite unusual, where the standards become the threshold, or far below—so we are trying to work out how those two things would interplay. Do they interplay already in what you do, or is this slightly different in terms of how your interaction with the criminal law would be, because it is the standards that would fall far below what is expected?

Mark Swindells: There are two halves to it. The clearer half is the professional standards, which depends on which body the person was registered with—if it was HCPC or ourselves, if it is a doctor. That is very certain. It is very clear—we set them out. I would say they describe good practice, so when we look in our fitness to practise guidance, it is not true that any single departure is made automatically. In fact, far from it. We would make a more fulsome assessment.

Coming back again, I think the real missing bit of the jigsaw in this area is a degree of consensus on the right clinical guidance. I would hope that that is what we can collectively move further towards, in terms of healthcare regulation.

Andrew Smith: If I could build on that as well, my reading of the draft Bill and the explanatory notes was that the phrase “far below the standards expected” is trying to draw from criminal negligence and criminal law, in which case regulatory standards might be one source of evidence that the court might look at. They might also look at other things. That “standards” is with a lower case “s” in that instance.

It is not my reading of the draft Bill that it was all to be solely on one document, as it were, and that to be a regulatory document. That might be more of an area of concern if it was just pinned on one document rather than looking in the broader sense.

  1.    Sir Jeremy Wright: All of these are real problems. There is an additional one, which is that someone will have to decide what “far below” means. Just below is not good enough. That is a contrast with some other of the legislation in this space in other countries. There is a distinct prospect, is there not, that somebody in the professions you regulate—or you—will have to give evidence as part of the prosecution case in order to demonstrate that the particular behaviour did fall far below the requisite standard, once we have agreed what the requisite standard is?

Andrew Smith: It does not happen very often, but I know I am listed to give evidence in a criminal case next year. It does happen occasionally—thankfully not very often.

Lord Isaac: That is why I was keen to ask about how fundamental the regulatory regime then becomes in determining the acceptable standard.

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: Talk us through what happens. You are giving evidence that it is far below the standards reasonably expected, so you would have to give quite a lot of comment—let me put it that way—on whatever the conduct was. Is that something you feel equipped and able to do in this area?

Andrew Smith: No, what we would give evidence on is clarity around what our standards say and where we might expect a registrant to go—royal colleges, professional bodies, or maybe other national guidance. I would provide evidence based on what our standards say, but they are outcome focused; they are not going to cover specific scenarios such as this.

We would be providing that kind of framework for the court to consider. We would not be providing that kind of clinical judgment on what is acceptable or falls below the standard. I do not know whether the Committee has had input from the Crown Prosecution Service. They will be providing that view about what meets the threshold.

  1.    Baroness Prentis of Banbury: Have you discussed internally how you would answer the need, if you were called upon to give evidence?

Mark Swindells: I think in the scenario you are describing it would be more typical that the defendant would have their own independent expert witness, rather than coming to their regulatory body to give that sort of evidence about whether they had or hadn’t. We would not take a side, in that sense. It is exactly as Andrew was saying: we would offer the court the best assistance we could about our professional standards, but we would not go to bat for one side or the other about whether they had or hadn’t. That is the court’s job, I think.

  1.    Lord Scriven: Can I ask the question slightly differently? Does any of you fear—whether it be about the individual or the organisation—that the way the draft Bill is written moves you away from being a regulator of standards to being a potential arbitrator of law through the standards? Do you worry that that could happen based on some of the questions we are asking, based on the potentials for the Bill?

Lord Isaac: Or that at best they are blurred, as I asked earlier.

Mark Swindells: I do not think so. Our powers on fitness to practise are set out in the Medical Act, and that is being amended at the moment, so I cannot immediately see that this Bill would interfere with that process. As I said, there is already an established process for where there is a criminal case. It is not extremely common, but it does happen, and we are able to navigate those—on gross negligence manslaughter, for example.

  1.    Chair: Can I pursue my hypothesis a step further? Let’s assume that there has been an acquittal. The jury does not give reasons. Is that the end, as far as you as regulators are concerned—or, because the bar is set at a very high level, does that still leave a question for the regulator as to whether the regulations have been breached and some steps should be taken by you to deal with it?

Mark Swindells: Potentially, because our assessment is not the same as a criminal test with a different threshold; it is a prospective assessment of whether that doctor, PA or AA is safe to practise for the future. We have a slightly different framework that will take on board—do not over-read into what I am about to say, because I think it is potentially peculiar in this context, but if the person has shown insight and remediation, that will count strongly in favour of their having understood whatever had occurred. It might be that we would not take action in that sort of hypothetical scenario. Like I say, that is in general terms. I am not trying to relate it to conversion practices.

Dr Chopra: I have been listening carefully to my colleagues. From our perspective, as a regulator of the provider, if we are informed of concerns about a practitioner working in one of those providers, we would share that information with the appropriate body. We would take safeguarding action. If it is a provider that we regulate, we would perhaps use that information to determine whether we might go out and inspect, or whether it is information that we need to think about from our regulatory perspective. But mostly, because this is about the individuals and we are the provider regulator, we would probably be referring to professional regulators.

Andrew Smith: Just building on what my colleague from the GMC has said, if you had a failed criminal prosecution, obviously from our regulatory standards we are looking much more broadly than that—looking beyond. Was it abusive? Was there serious harm? We would be looking at it in a broader context, so it could be that in a certain set of circumstances we may take regulatory action even though someone has not been convicted of a criminal offence.

  1.    Baroness Browning: I think this is a question for Andrew Smith. The Bill, as you know, involves children as well—quite young children, in fact. I am concerned because in 2024 the UK Council for Physiotherapy withdrew from the memorandum of understanding on conversion therapy, which was brought out in 2022—the guidance—over its application to children. What effect has that had, and do you still rely on it?

Andrew Smith: I would not be able to comment on that now. I would have to look into that. I am happy to write to you, though. I do not quite know the detail of the case you are talking about.

Baroness Browning: Fine. Thank you.

Chair: If there are no further questions, we will finish the session. Thank you all very much indeed. If there is anything that you would like to add after you think over today’s proceedings, please write in. We will be very grateful for what you have to say.