Environment and Climate Change Committee
Uncorrected oral evidence: Waste crime
Wednesday 11 November 2026
10 am
Watch the meeting
Members present: Baroness Sheehan (The Chair); Lord Ashcombe; Baroness Coffey; Lord Jay of Ewelme; Lord Krebs; Lord Lennie; Baroness McIntosh of Pickering; Baroness Rafferty; Lord Redwood; Lord Rooker; Earl Russell; Lord Trees; Baroness Whitaker.
Evidence Session No. 7 Heard in Public Questions 115 - 129
Witnesses
Philip Duffy, Chief Executive, Environment Agency; Malcolm Lythgo, Director for Environmental Markets and Enforcement, Environment Agency.
USE OF THE TRANSCRIPT
Philip Duffy and Malcolm Lythgo.
Before we start, I remind everyone that the session will be webcast live on Parliament TV and that a transcript will be taken and made public. Members are reminded that they should declare any relevant interests the first time they speak. I will take the opportunity here to say that I am a director of Peers for the Planet and, when we come to the drought report, that I own a borehole on our home in South Oxfordshire.
Today is a little unusual, colleagues. Before we start, I will let everyone know that, at 11 am, we will stand to observe the two-minute silence in remembrance of the armistice. The committee’s clerk, Alastair, will give me the signal when it is almost time. That is just a heads-up.
We should start business. First of all, Philip Duffy, thank you very much for the letter that we received yesterday. We had been waiting for it for some time, but it is good that it arrived in time for this meeting. The first question that I would like to put to you is to ask you to update the committee on Operation Unite and, in particular, what challenges were faced and lessons learned from this campaign. Please introduce the campaign to us.
Philip Duffy: Thank you very much, Chair. It is great to be back here talking to you about this important subject. When I was last in front of the committee, I flagged Operation Unite as, in essence, an experiment to see whether we could improve the response across the organisation and with our law enforcement partners.
There were three big things that we were trying to achieve. The first was being genuinely intelligence-driven, so not just waiting until we are looking at a piece of rubbish in a field, but thinking ahead about where we think criminals are infiltrating the waste system, and taking a more proactive, targeted approach to where we put our enforcement activity.
The second approach was to look at permits. It is, to my mind and the minds of many who look at the Environment Agency, peculiar that the agency issues permits to regulate all sorts of activity, but that we very rarely revoke or suspend them, which means that you can, in some cases, breach those permits year after year with no great consequence. We want to change that, and so one of the central bits of work that we did over the last 18 weeks was to visit 42 permitted sites, and we revoked or suspended 17 of the permits held at those sites. That sent quite a strong signal to people in the waste sector that we do not regard compliance as optional. It also sent a signal to communities, many of which are experiencing smell, poor odour control, dust and flies from poorly maintained waste sites, that the agency will not be tolerating that year after year. That is exactly what people expect the agency to be doing in its regulatory work.
Thirdly, we were really joining up with law enforcement partners, notably the police forces, the National Crime Agency and HMRC, to apply much more effective pressure on organised criminals. To give a sense of the activity that took place over that 18-week period between April and October, there were 37 waste crime arrests. We also issued 13 restriction orders banning people access to land to dump. We concluded 71 waste-related court cases in that period, of which 52 led to conviction. There were six not-guilty findings, so that is a reasonable performance, I would say.
We have also been trying to strengthen our work on asset confiscation, which was raised with me when I was last here. Waste crime is, fundamentally, an economic crime, with waste and community consequences, and the question that we are grappling with is how best to deny those criminals access to significant profits. The best way of all is to deny them access to the waste stream and to take their permits away, but the second best way is to go after their criminal proceeds.
We launched six criminal confiscation investigations as part of Operation Unite, and £4.4 million of criminal money was identified in those exercises. We also have nine live money laundering investigations with partners coming out of Operation Unite.
The Chair: We will be coming to confiscation orders later on in the session, but, for now, can I just concentrate on Operation Unite? It is taking action against permitted sites. The OEP did a report on permitted sites in May this year, and sent us a copy. One of the things that it found was that, while the Environment Agency aims to inspect all permitted sites at least once a year, 29% of sites were uninspected in 2022. How are those 29% of sites that are not inspected treated?
Philip Duffy: The OEP makes a very good point about the state of performance in the 2021-22 financial year. We are in the process of issuing a long series of control strategies. They are quite short and say, in essence, if you hold a permit with the Environment Agency, how often you can expect to be visited and what level of work you need to do. It will vary because we have some parts of the economy that are very compliant, and others that are very non-compliant, so you would expect there to be a variation in how often they would do that.
A visit once every three years is not an unacceptable level of performance from the agency, because we know that many of these sites are quite compliant and do not require an annual inspection. If, of course, we find or have reports of non-compliance, you would want to move to an annual inspection. If you have a situation in which a site has been D/E/F band compliant for more than one year, you would expect multiple inspections over the course of a year until that is resolved. That is our thinking as to how we are going to approach that in the future.
The Chair: The review found that the 29% of sites that are not inspected by the Environment Agency are automatically recorded as being in band A, which is the highest compliance band. It goes on to recommend that the Environment Agency does not place uninspected sites in band A by default. Do you accept that recommendation?
Philip Duffy: Yes. I agree with that recommendation and we have written back to the OEP to make that point.
The Chair: Will you be making changes?
Philip Duffy: Yes. In a way, they do not have a band because they have not been inspected. We should not assume that they are non-compliant either; that would not be appropriate. We should reserve judgment until they have been visited. As I say, a visit every three years at a minimum is an acceptable level of resourcing. Below three years is a problem.
The Chair: It does skew reporting. Some 97% of the Environment Agency’s permitted sites are recorded as being compliant, but this does not give us the confidence to assume that that figure is real.
Malcolm Lythgo: Our compliance assessment is based not just on our inspections. We receive a lot of data from permitted sites. Even though we may not have inspected certain sites, we will have reviewed their data. We will go through their monitoring data and their data returns, and that gives us an indication as to whether they are taking more waste than they are allowed. We can do some remote assessment, but visits are important and we should do those too.
The Chair: The OEP report also has reservations about remote monitoring. I will not go into that, but will ask how you treat band C sites and the anomalies within that. Band C sites are recorded as compliant with their permits, even if non-compliance has been detected and the site “must improve in order to achieve permit compliance”. That is unbelievable.
Philip Duffy: I do not think that it is unbelievable. You have to have a proportionate and staged approach when dealing with bits of infrastructure that are extremely important for the functioning of the economy. There is an important point to make about understanding that one or several breaches that are minor, such as driving routes or a failure in dust control, would not normally lead to immediate enforcement. We have a whole range of enforcement activities. At the most basic end, it is guidance to an operator to do that, and then we step it up.
Of course, to some degree, there is a judgment as to whether something is a C or a D. We can talk about whether that judgment is right or wrong, and there may be people out there living near a band C functioning permitted waste site who would disagree with the notion that it should stay open, because these sites can be difficult to live nearby. On the other hand, we have to take a balanced view, make sure that our regulation is proportionate and give operators the chance to recover the situation.
What is not acceptable is that we allow operators to stay in D, E and F when we have really quite severe concerns about non-compliance year after year. That was the situation that we had previously, and that is clearly unacceptable. Our simple message here is that, if you are in band D, E or F, you will get an opportunity to improve. If you do not improve, you will be suspended. If you still do not improve, you will have your permit revoked.
The Chair: Operation Unite is targeted at permitted waste sites. We understand that, if a permit is revoked, the operator or waste carrier must permanently cease operations. What happens once a permit is revoked? How many permits are revoked versus how many are suspended in the figure that you gave us?
Philip Duffy: Let us start with revocation. It depends on what permit we are revoking for what kind of activity, because we have not just landfills, but also facilities that process materials and waste handling stations that weigh materials. It will depend on the issue.
If it is a handling situation, the business closes; there is not really much more follow-up to that. The issue is much more severe if we were to revoke a permit on a landfill. We have done that at Walleys Quarry in Stoke-on-Trent during my time at the Environment Agency. That raises all sorts of quite complicated policy and social questions.
Landfill operators are required to post with the Environment Agency a financial bond, which is intended to cover the immediate make-safe costs should, for some reason, the business stop operating, either through insolvency or through regulatory closure. In general, we have found that that level of resourcing enables us to, for example, secure the site with fencing and make sure that the gas management systems are in place to remove gases that could become dangerous or build up on the landfill site.
We do, however, face really serious choices in some landfills around the balance between a peremptory closure on very sound regulatory or criminal grounds, and the ongoing running of that landfill to make sure that it is closed in good order. If you have studied landfills, you will know that it is important to make sure that the shape of the waste is right and the facing of the waste is right. We are very alive to that trade-off that we have to make. We want the criminals and the non-compliance driven out, but we also need to make sure that communities are not left with a landfill that has been unresolved.
There is an issue that we are discussing with the Government, who you will know are taking a very close interest in the whole question of waste crime, about whether this sort of regime is adequate for the future and provides sufficient financial guarantees to make sure that, at the higher-risk levels of landfill, we have enough resources to manage, should the site be closed unexpectedly for any reason.
The Chair: As of yet, you have been focusing on whether a site fulfils its permit and bond requirements, et cetera. Have you also been looking at sites where misdescription of waste and criminal activity may be taking place? Have any of those permitted sites been addressed?
Philip Duffy: It is a great question because the truth is that the largest degree of harm from waste crime is not the visible dumping in fields or poorly managed permitted sites. It is tax evasion and people misdeclaring, while treating the waste in a perfectly compliant manner. The waste itself has gone to a landfill or a treatment centre precisely in compliance with its permit, but the paperwork around it has declared that it was inorganic waste, such as construction material, when, in reality, it was organic material attracting a higher rate of landfill tax. That is the primary source of criminal arbitrage in this sector, not the sorts of offences that the EA is dealing with, and we have a lot of intelligence about that.
One thing that we have been doing in Operation Unite is trying to integrate our intelligence with our partners, particularly HMRC and the police, and thinking about how best to disrupt that sort of activity. You would not disrupt it by revoking the permit, since the permit is in good order. You would have to disrupt it in some other way. How might you do that?
You are then looking at, in essence, law enforcement through forensic accountancy on the part of HMRC, disruption to flows of money, so that the receipts from this tax-evading money are being properly dealt with, and making sure that people who knowingly do business with this tax-evading entity understand that they may be involved in crime. We can do that by calling out those offences, or by making sure, for example, that people face fixed penalty notices for driving waste to sites when they do not have the right paperwork.
The Chair: Have you revoked any permits?
Philip Duffy: No, not for that kind of offence. We would not, because the permit is generally compliant.
The Chair: The other issue that we have heard about is transfer stations, where we are talking about 38 million tonnes of waste each year being diverted. This is on an industrial scale. We are not talking about the odd fly-tipping instance, although that is where a lot of it will start. That waste is diverted and ends up somewhere such as Hoad’s Wood or Kidlington. This is waste that has been treated in some way, we understand, through a waste transfer station. Instead of continuing its journey through the legal sector, it finds its way into our environment and is illegally dumped. Landfill taxes are avoided, et cetera, and the taxpayer is left to pick up the bill, as has happened in all of the cases where you are clearing up the waste. Has Operation Unite done anything to address this particular issue?
Philip Duffy: Your description of the offending is accurate. I do not think that anyone in the EA would quibble with that. The key point of Operation Unite is that, as you say, these flows of illegal waste that are going into the dumps have passed through the legitimate waste system. Some people in that system knew full well that they were handing that waste on to criminals. They may or may not have been corrupted, but they certainly knew they were not exercising due care, as they are legally required to do, over who was taking their waste forward.
A quite simple diagnosis for that particular problem is that we have to make sure that, if you do not exercise due care over your waste, there are very severe consequences. The most severe consequence that is in our immediate gift is to suspend or revoke a permit. There are more things that we did not do in Operation Unite that we should do. For example, we do not have a good, well-developed approach to anti-corruption in the waste sector, in either public and private authorities, so we do not know whether the waste criminals are bribing people to acquire this waste. Focusing, as you have said, on the transfer facilities and the MRFs—material facilities—to make sure that they always routinely understand where their waste is going is the most important aspect of turning this around.
The Chair: Thank you. We will come on to ways in which we can do that.
Malcolm Lythgo: For all 42 of the sites that we visited under Operation Unite, we had intelligence that there was criminal activity happening. We did not inspect them because of their permit.
The Chair: What sort of criminal activity?
Malcolm Lythgo: There was a variety. It would be that waste had been handled legally, but that fraud may be happening, or that waste was being taken from that site to an inappropriate site. Our intelligence pointed us to all those 42 sites, so all of Operation Unite was about going up stream, trying to track that waste, and seeing what happens. I am pleased to say that our intelligence was pretty good. The fact that we can revoke that many permits that quickly means that the intelligence was telling us something, and it triggered 30 criminal investigations off the back of it. All of Operation Unite was very much focused on going up stream and dealing with that sort of criminality, not permit compliance.
Philip Duffy: The point behind the 10-point plan is to attack the problem from every direction that we can. Probably the most impactful thing is the construction of better intelligence capability. I have been very surprised by what we can achieve by bringing together not only covert but overt intelligence. Who is buying and selling land out there? Who has an HGV licence from the traffic commissioners? What address did they give for that? Who is applying for a new carrier, broker or dealer permit? We are trying to bring that together so that the sorts of targeted work that my colleague is discussing can be more effective. We are spending quite a lot of money this year on the IT build to do that, and we have had really good co-operation from partners across government.
The second thing that is important for this committee is transparency. You can sometimes feel like there are all sorts of ways of assessing waste sites and their severity and social impact. We have taken an approach of publishing as much as we can so that committees such as this can have a look at that data and see whether you agree with our judgments—you may or may not, and we will listen to your views on those things—and updating that to make sure that communities can see what we are doing. That is really important for reassurance and public confidence.
We have covered a lot about permits being at risk if you are engaged with criminality. It is a message that I want to repeat here. Behind the scenes, the joint working is really important. We have the joint unit on waste crime. We are getting very strong support from the National Crime Agency, from the constabularies, and from HMRC. I will not go into the details of the cases, but we have seen some of the case handling. We have moved cases between different organisations. We have said, “This is really an HMRC case. This is really an NCA case. We are not the right body” or, “EA should take on this case”, so all those disruptive tools that we can use are there.
It is too early at this point to say whether this has moved the dial. We have anecdotes, because we track a lot of the organised crime gangs, that show that they are feeling the pressure from UK law enforcement and reconsidering their business choices. That is merely an anecdote at this stage, and we have to look at the overall surveys that we are going to do, but we are feeling quite positive that we have gone in the right direction. There is still a huge amount more to do, to be quite clear, but that has been a positive step forward.
Baroness McIntosh of Pickering: Have the powers that you were seeking been granted to you under the police and criminal evidence enforcement powers?
Malcolm Lythgo: The powers are still a work in progress with government. We have gone back with a list of things that we would like to have. Other organisations have been involved in that discussion, and Defra is taking those forward. Some of those, where they are related to secondary legislation, are at a more advanced stage, but Defra is working through what we can do within that and having discussions with Home Office and others on the mechanism for delivery.
Baroness McIntosh of Pickering: So you still do not have powers of entry and evidence at the moment.
Philip Duffy: We had some farcical scenes over the summer, so it might be sensible if I can just highlight for the committee some of the problems that we have with the powers. We need to get restriction orders. We have been saying to our teams, “Get there in 48 hours”, because we want people on the ground quickly. When they find that there is crime there, they want to stop the site being accessed, but we have to have a restriction order.
We have had a case where we just could not get court time. We kept going. It was adjourned. The landowner was unrepresented. That was adjourned. There is no default. We have gone for weeks and weeks when we and the community know that there is a problem, but there is no restriction order in place. We need a system that says that we have a faster response. There is no point in us being there in 48 hours if there is nothing that we can do and we just watch the offending going on, so there are a few things there. The Government are well aware of that, and we are having very constructive conversations with them about what would be necessary to turn that situation around.
There are powers in the tax system, which I envy, about whether someone is fit and proper to hold a permit. I have been quite clear that we would like those in the environmental situation. It absolutely cannot be right that a person who we know through intelligence is involved in offending can apply for a waste permit and the Environment Agency must grant it. That cannot be a justifiable situation to be in. On this issue of powers, we are going to have to keep arguing for that and, clearly, it may require legislation in due course.
Baroness McIntosh of Pickering: It helps us to know that. Could I move on to fixed penalty notice interventions? These were announced by the Government in July 2026. There are two schools of thought here. How successful will tackling waste crime be when previous fine regimes have failed?
Have the fines been set at the right level? Even though they have been increased to £5,000, having heard what you have just told us today, it is thousands if not hundreds of thousands of pounds that the perpetrators can make. If you give them a £5,000 penalty notice, is that a deterrent? Can you then go on and prosecute them if you have the evidence in court?
Philip Duffy: They have a role, but they are not the answer to the problem that Baroness Sheehan has just described of very organised, large-scale offending. However, there is merit in making the lives of organised criminals just harder in general by adding more friction to their lives.
I see a real role for fixed penalty notices in making sure that it is harder for them to hire a driver who is somewhere on the margin. They have been paid some cash to drive a load. They do not know about the overall plot. They do not know about the tax situation. They are just helping. If we were clear that drivers should not drive loads without having proper documentation because they would face a financial penalty, that could dissuade some of these operations at the margins.
There is a role, and a lot of our field teams think that there is a merit to it, because they want to send a signal in real time to people who may be collaborating with dodgy operators that they should not do so. We are piloting it. We have done only 64 since I last came before the committee, which is not very many. We have piloted them in two broad areas: people who are transhipping waste, so sending waste overseas, without proper documentation, and people who are driving without proper waste documentation.
At the minute, that is not issued in the field. We find the offence, take the address down, authorise it and write to the person, and they have generally paid the fixed penalties. We know that timeliness and certainty are massive factors in deterrence. The ability of our officers to issue an FPN in the field and say, “You now owe me this money” will be really transformative. That is our next stage of work and is what my field teams who work for the EA really want to see happen.
As you said, the Prime Minister has said that he wants to increase the level from a few hundred pounds to £5,000. We also need to look at how we enforce those penalties, because penalties that are not enforced are a waste of everyone’s time. It is currently only a criminal offence not to pay a penalty, which would require us to take a criminal prosecution; that is not a brilliant way of running a system. We have some operational concerns that we are discussing with the Government about how you would operationalise a higher fine level. It is a niche role, but quite useful for enforcement.
Baroness McIntosh of Pickering: Could you go on and prosecute? That was not clear.
Philip Duffy: No, not on that offence, I do not think.
Malcolm Lythgo: You would not be able to prosecute on that offence, but you could prosecute them if you caught them committing more serious offences, even though you had issued a fixed penalty notice.
Philip Duffy: I do not think that that is right. We are very keen to use criminal law wherever we can. Let me just provide some statistics or some reality as to what it is like currently trying to prosecute criminal cases. Over the period between April and October, the EA brought 71 criminal prosecutions in court. We got only two immediate custodial sentences and eight suspended sentences from that, and the fine total was £118,000, which is quite small compared to the scale of the offending.
It can take us over a year from arrest to laying charges. If the case is complex and involves lots of evidence, some of which might have closed material procedures, that can take time. Court listings can be very slow; it can take us years to get to one, so you will have to be patient on court cases. There is no lack of will from the EA to bring these cases. We are quite forward leaning.
I would say, though, that permit revocation, going after assets, civil offences and other forms of disruption can also apply pressure on committed criminals. If you were talking to other people from UK law enforcement, they would be saying, as I am saying to you, that you have to look at the complete range of disruptions, including travel bans, asset seizure and proceeds of crime orders, to dissuade criminals who may not be particularly dissuaded by a relatively short custodial sentence.
Lord Rooker: In answer to an earlier question, you mentioned 71 prosecutions. Why is that not referred to in your letter? The word “prosecution” does not appear in this letter. You are claiming that you have made 71 prosecutions. I would have thought that it would have been quite important to let us know about this, rather than keeping it to the last minute. Have I got that right?
Philip Duffy: I hope that you feel that I am being transparent with the committee. I am making sure that you have all the facts that you need about the situation. If you need more facts and figures, I will provide those. Transparency is incredibly important in working with parliamentary oversight.
The letter was really talking about the structural changes that we are making, which are about going after the very serious organised criminality that the Chair has raised. It was not about our current operational prosecution work. I am very happy to talk to the committee at any point on what we are up to in the courts, our strategies, and the outcomes.
I would highlight to the committee that, despite that number of prosecutions and a high level of convictions, the fine total was £118,000. As the committee itself has recognised, we are dealing with multimillion-pound offending here, so I have to question how we effectively respond to an incentive structure that is in the tens of millions, when the fine level that we are achieving in court from all those prosecutions is £118,000. That is something that the committee should reflect upon.
Lord Rooker: I accept that completely, but, of course, the prosecution is on the offender’s record, and that has to be a factor. On your point about the plan, notwithstanding all the plans that you have talked about, is there anything else that is preventing you from being more effective in the enforcement of waste crime?
Philip Duffy: There are many things. First, we have covered the whole issue of getting restriction orders more quickly and making the landowner make the case that they should not have a restriction order, rather than us having to find court slots to do that. That would be very important.
Secondly, we have real problems in the permit system, which is an environmental law that crosses over with the tax evasion and criminality problem here. We need to say, “You can’t have a permit, even if you did comply with the environmental law, because you have criminal convictions and are not a fit and proper person”.
Thirdly, we need to look at who really controls permits. We have seen market manoeuvres where there was a legitimate permit, with a legitimate permit operator, and the company or the asset was bought by someone else. The permit transfers with them and we cannot say, “Hang on. We don’t want that permit run by you”. We have no re-permitting process.
Fourthly, you can find an old permit that has not been revoked and you can reopen the site. In the meantime, the planning authority could have granted homes around the area and people may have changed. That feels like a real problem for communities around the country.
I mentioned anti-corruption. We have a real problem with who is signing off these contracts, either in local government or in the supply chain. Are we confident that we have enough controls to drive out corrupt practices from those areas? Transparency in that area is really important.
Lastly, deterrence requires not only a response but certainty of conviction and a high enough penalty. At the minute, the risk of losing money, going to prison or having a fine is not high enough to deter people. You mentioned criminal records; many people who we are working with here have very long criminal records. If having a criminal record was dissuasive, they would not be where they are now. If you really want to dissuade them, you have to find something else that is going to be more dissuasive. If that is not jail time, what is it going to be? It probably going to have to be financial penalties or loss of assets.
There is quite a lot there, end to end, that we need to look at, and that may require legislation.
The Chair: You have just listed a litany of loopholes, so it is no surprise that the criminals are running rings around the enforcement agencies. Which government department’s responsibility is it to close those loopholes?
Philip Duffy: We are working very closely with Defra, which is the lead department for waste. Under the Secretary of State’s chairmanship, it has called together a cross-government, multiagency group called the Waste Crime Crackdown Group, which met last week. At that meeting, the Secretary of State was very clear to the Home Office, the National Crime Agency, the National Police Chiefs’ Council, senior people from HMRC and Treasury Ministers that this required a whole-of-government effort. We should be adopting the best practice that we see in things such as dealing with tax evasion and moving it into this regime.
That may require legislation, and no one is denying that, but the Government are thinking very hard about that. The Prime Minister has been public that he thinks that this is a serious scandal that he wishes to resolve. There is a lot of work under way within government to look systematically at all the loopholes—I could have gone on; there are more—and make sure that they are being systematically addressed.
Philip Duffy: The answer is that I do not know.
Malcolm Lythgo: I am not sure about prohibition notices at waste sites. At permitted sites, though, we can suspend very quickly and there is no right of appeal.
Baroness Whitaker: How quickly?
Malcolm Lythgo: As quickly as coming up with the paperwork and getting it issued. You would have to go back and look at the permit, and we would run it through the legal team, but you are talking about a matter of a day or so, I would imagine.
Philip Duffy: I have seen this in the COMAH regime for health and safety and industrial emissions, but not in waste.
Malcolm Lythgo: I do not think that there is a stop notice within permitted sites. Similarly, for illegal sites, we do not have that power. We have to go to court to get the restriction order issued.
Baroness Whitaker: Would you like to have something like that?
Philip Duffy: It would be much better for us to have a power that says, “You are dumping waste in this field. You must stop immediately. If you think we have got it wrong, you go to court and explain why we have got it wrong” than for us to have to go to court and say, “Can we please get a court listing to stop this person driving on to a field and dumping waste?”, which is how it currently works. That feels to me very suboptimal.
Baroness Whitaker: I must leave that with you, because I have a different question to ask. The Government gave you £45 million last March, which I expect you found very welcome. What are you doing with it to improve the response to waste crime?
Philip Duffy: The profile of the money is roughly £4.5 million in the first year, and then £20 million in each of the subsequent two years. That is not unreasonable, because you cannot immediately hire people and spend money in year. A large chunk of the £4.5 million so far is going on, in essence, improving the intelligence, so buying IT kit that helps us take in data from other agencies and merge it so that we can see patterns.
I mentioned before that Land Registry data is really significant, because we often see criminals trading land prior to a dumping event. We would rather like to know before the dumping happened that it was likely, so that we could block the site before it got there.
We have also spent money on, basically, plumbing the EA into the other systems of the National Crime Agency, so that we have more licences to access police intelligence, can understand what the tax records are, and can have embeds from those organisations that are working with us to join the dots up on those investigations. There is nothing more frustrating than discovering that you are dealing with an organised crime group and that another government agency that you did not know about was investigating the same group. You want to make sure that you have deconflicted that and are taking a sensible approach. That has been really important.
We are spending more money on field teams, because we want to make sure that we can consistently get this 48-hour response.
Baroness Whitaker: How many more field workers do you envisage there being, roughly?
Philip Duffy: The question of headcount is always a controversial one, because we are trying to, as far as possible, as a public body, become more efficient. We think that we will need anything up to 70 more people across our areas to consistently deliver that service. Whether that is 70 additional people across the agency as a whole, or we find those people from efficiencies in other areas of our business, we are still thinking that through, but that is the level of resource that we put on the front line from our work.
Baroness Whitaker: Would you give intelligence sharing, which you mention in your 10-point plan, higher priority, or more feet on the ground, or both?
Philip Duffy: Baroness Sheehan’s characterisation of industrial-level organised crime is a fair one. You really need to go up stream and stop those criminals getting anywhere near the waste system at all. By the time we have dumping in a field, we are treating the symptom, not the cause. I am not saying that that is not important. It is, but that is not going to fix the problem.
I also want to make the point that a lot of this is both transnational and around the country. The waste in the field did not come from that community. It would have come from somewhere often many hundreds of miles away, so we need to understand how those flows are going.
It is also about efficiency. I used to work in Border Force. If you found that 50% of your stops led to an arrest, you would be extremely happy. We want to raise the productivity of our team by making sure that, when they go to a site, they are finding criminality and really serious problems, rather than finding a wholly compliant site.
Baroness Whitaker: It is a strategic view ahead of a tactical view, which sounds good.
Malcolm Lythgo: I have a personal view that intelligence is front-line work. Quite a lot of our intelligence officers go out in the field. We do not just sit in an office somewhere and look at things that people send us. We have field intelligence officers who will go out and check what is going on. That stops the investigators getting embroiled in things that they do not need to do.
This slightly arbitrary split between front line and intelligence, or some of the other really important parts of the system, just feels unnatural to me. We need to step away from that and say, “There is a system here. How do we invest our resources in the best place to disrupt that system?” Intelligence is huge in terms of being able to do that. As Philip said, if you cannot target where you are going to the best place, the risk is that you are groping in the dark and hoping that you find somebody, which is not where anybody wants to be.
Baroness Whitaker: Am I right, then, that this is because it is a big organised crime that you want to get rid of, rather than some petty person who is chancing it?
Malcolm Lythgo: Yes, that and the flows of waste. With digital waste tracking coming in, it has started. We have hundreds of thousands of digital waste records that we can look at. I do not want investigators doing that when they could be out investigating the criminal leads. What we need is somebody with a really good IT system, using AI, to go through all of those, overlay that with lots of data from, as Philip said, the Land Registry and Companies House, see whether there are signals in that data that give us a clue as to who is doing what, link it back to which companies are moving what, and then use that to target our investigations.
Some of the stuff that we have done already in the first few months is really impressive and will really help us target and attack the parts of the system where we can have the biggest impact.
Philip Duffy: An issue that we see a lot in organised crime is that criminals try to cover their tracks by having multiple entities. Resolving that and saying, “You may have a fresh permit application, or a fresh application for a licence, but you are still the same person. We can track back and resolve that. Therefore, this application should be treated with greater suspicion” is a really important part of our work that we have not been on top of and want to be better at.
Baroness Whitaker: Is that working?
Philip Duffy: So far, yes.
Malcolm Lythgo: It is starting to, yes.
I recognise everything that you have said to me, and the actions that you and the Government have taken. At this point in time, have the actions to date led to a drop in the 38 million tonnes of waste that we are seeing illegally dumped each year?
Going forward, what is next? You have talked a lot about a real need for more legislation, better intelligence and joining-up between agencies. What more is in your plan going forward so that we can continue to make progress on these important issues?
Philip Duffy: It is far too early to make claims that we have turned this round or that this is all working. We do not know, so I do not make that claim. I have anecdote, but no more than that, about how some of the criminals are feeling about all of this. The sector notices a difference, so people are seeing a difference, but we need to do two things, really. We need to develop a properly rigorous deterrence index for waste crime.
Earl Russell: Could you describe what that is?
Philip Duffy: It is always difficult to measure things that are illicit, but it would be a way of measuring how likely you are to be apprehended or disrupted, how quickly you will be apprehended, and how severe the penalty will be. It would give us some view of those three, because we want to track over time whether the criminals think that we are dealing with it well. We do not have that yet, but that needs to be part of our future metrics. We are doing some experimental work, but it is quite difficult to get the numbers, because you have to do survey data and implied data.
Earl Russell: Is that also you then making best use of your limited resources to get the maximum impact?
Philip Duffy: Yes, because we need to be tracking our progress, and our current metrics do not really allow for that. If you look at the waste sites disrupted metric, the more you look, the more you find, so that is not really helping us to give you assurance.
Next year, we will do another survey with the ESA and others on waste crime. Again, it is a survey, but it is on a consistent basis, and that will perhaps give us a refresh on the 38 million and whether that is moving. That will be in 2027, so that will be an important metric.
You ask, “Where next?” This is such an important question. The criminal gangs here are not just taking it. They will be thinking about what is next. We can already see worrying things. For example, we are watching very carefully illegal waste exports, where there are other ways that you can exploit that, such as by mis-declaring what you are exporting and where.
We have seen the European Union put in quite tough controls on the export, particularly of plastics, to non-OECD countries. We could see diversion of their waste flows, including back into parts of the UK, so we need to make sure that we do not just declare victory in this area and allow the problem to move somewhere else. Criminals are, no doubt, in meetings right now, thinking about what their next move will be, and we can already see some opportunities in those areas.
You have to apply cross-system pressure on criminality, or it will just pop up somewhere else, maybe less visibly, and maybe with less harm to our communities, but we should not lightly disregard the really serious global consequences of international waste crime.
Earl Russell: You have talked a lot about the need for more legislation, which I welcome. You are in contact with Defra and across government. The system needs to be improved. This is my personal point of view. Broken systems create broken results, and make it impossible for things to transform and change. I just wondered whether, as an agency, you might be prepared to share with this committee your thinking about ways in which systems need to change, and about needs for legislation, so that we could look at that.
Philip Duffy: I am very happy to do so. I have written to the committee once on some powers issues, but I will have to write again on those, as well as on the system. In essence, the Government are helping because they are bringing in more registration functions.
Earl Russell: I recognise that.
The Chair: I am going to have to hurry you up.
Philip Duffy: You have to apply an anti-crime mindset to a set of environmental legislation to fix this problem.
The Chair: A number of colleagues have indicated that they would like to speak, but we really are up against the clock today.
We note with satisfaction that you have now successfully cleaned up Hoad’s Wood, as well as the one near where I live in Oxford, at Kidlington. There are others that are also very large and potentially on your high-priority list, and I wonder whether you could tell us where you are in the development of plans to clear those up. I understand that the Bickershaw site close to the Prime Minister’s constituency is going to be cleared up, starting in November. Could you confirm that?
There are two other very large sites that are on your high-priority list, at Northwich, with 281,000 tonnes of waste, and at Camborne, in Cornwall, with 50,000 tonnes of waste. That one has been there since 2004, so it is almost a vintage site. Taking those two examples, could you tell us what the longer-term plans are for clearing up these sites?
Philip Duffy: The first thing to say is that we are a parliamentary body, so we exist to do things that the Government and Parliament ask us to do, and we do not have a routine role in site clearance. That is not a role that has been given to the Environment Agency. We have the ability to intervene, which we have done only three times, where we see overriding, imperative emergency reasons to clear up, which was the case at Kidlington. It was also the case at a site called Twyford House, in Stoke. It is very unusual for us to lead on clearance.
However, the Government have announced a pot of money and a process for looking at sites that they would wish to fund local government to clear. We are collaborating with them on those areas. They have also said that they want to establish a framework contract for the UK as a whole, which would enable public authorities of all sorts to get sites cleared without going through a lengthy, new procurement process. There is quite a lot of work going on there, and it is under that framework that an agreement was reached between the Government—not the Environment Agency—and the local authority in Wigan to clear the Bolton House Road site in Bickershaw.
More generally, we have to be quite careful with this, because sites vary enormously in terms of what they contain. Some can be very small but contain extremely toxic material, and that clearly needs to be resolved. Some can be very large but contain contaminated soils and construction waste that is inert. The ecological advice that we would give is not to disturb things that you do not need to disturb if they are not causing leachate, not causing a smell, and do not contain toxic material. We have to verify that and test all those sites, but one of the sites that you mentioned has a lot of former construction waste, which we think is inert. We will check it and carry on studying those things. You have to look at where you are doing it.
In the case of Kidlington, the site not only contained a large amount of organic material, so it smelled bad, but was also going through putrefaction, so we had gas risks that can cause explosive effects. There were a whole range of risks, so that was a site that we really wanted to prioritise.
The issue of clearing requires good evidence and there is a balance. I totally understand why communities desperately want these sites resolved, particularly if they smell bad or cause them inconveniences. There are a slightly deeper set of policy questions about what we do with the land afterwards and how we manage those areas, which we are discussing with Defra. It is a very live conversation with the Government, and they are probably better placed to answer that than the Environment Agency. I do not know whether you want to come back on the two sites that Lord Krebs has mentioned.
Malcolm Lythgo: Specifically, Northwich is soil contaminated with bits of wood and plastic, not contaminated with chemicals. It is a large site, but it is, ecologically, probably not a bad idea to leave it where it is. We are working with the local authorities and others to take that forward, so it may be that clearing that site is not the right way forward.
The same goes for the Camborne site. It is soil and is not causing problems to the environment or to communities. Therefore, it may be that it does not get cleared, and that the right thing to do is to rework it in some way, shape, or form, and make good use of both of those sites with that waste material there. It does not mean that the waste went there legally, but it does mean that, at this point, perhaps the best thing to do is to leave it there.
Lord Krebs: When we are told that those two sites at Northwich and Camborne, along with another 111, are on your high-priority list, what does “high priority” mean if it does not mean that it is posing some risk to the environment or to human health?
Philip Duffy: We are trying to balance a whole series of factors. Because we want to be a science-driven organisation, we quite accept that we could get those wrong. We are making a series of qualitative judgments across all the sites in England, and we are looking at environmental harm. Is it toxic material? Is it leachate? Is it near a watercourse? What is it doing to a river or other protected sites?
We are looking at proximity to social infrastructure. Are there people, homes, schools or businesses affected by it? We are looking at proximity to economic infrastructure, such as roads and railways that could be disrupted in the event of a fire or other problem. We are looking at the scale of the criminality. It may not be an environmentally difficult site, but it may be linked to much more serious criminal offending, and some of the gangs that we are talking about here are involved in some very serious criminal offending in completely unrelated domains.
We have to look at priorities across a wide range of factors. There is a note on our website that explains what factors we take into account. We could have that wrong. We are very open to discussion about it, but we think that we have done a reasonable attempt at gripping all the factors that people have raised with us that concern them.
Malcolm Lythgo: We have prioritised those into three tiers of higher, medium and lower. We are working through all those sites, starting with the higher ones, trying to understand those risks, better manage them, and, I hope, work through sites coming off that list because we have got to a point where we understand the risks, and either they are, in some way, shape or form, cleared up by the local authorities or by the landowner, or we just accept that that is how it is, so we understand the risk, we move on, and they come off the list. We are working through those to try to manage those risks.
Lord Krebs: I have not looked at this on your website, but, if you have a number of domains of risk, so human health, environmental, water quality, criminality and so on, you have a way of combining the risk rating in these different domains. Do you just add it up? If it gets three 0s and a 1, does that count as a score of 1?
Philip Duffy: There is such a methodology for dealing with crime gangs, called the MoRiLE system, in which you get points for different sorts of crime type. We have not done that in our modelling. We could have a go at it. We would be making a lot of judgments, I suspect, about whether a primary school is more or less important than a road, which I am not sure would add a great deal of value to it, but we would be very happy to discuss that.
Philip Duffy: We follow the methodology across UK law enforcement for dealing with organised crime. We map the organised crime gangs and, when we are clear that it is an organised crime gang, it is declared and mapped in partnership with the National Crime Agency. That is how we know about the gangs.
There are some that are mainly in waste, but a significant proportion of them cross over. It could be in quite a minor way. They could be using their sites for other forms of offending. Some are involved in very unrelated forms of offending, so narcotics, weaponry and all sorts of things, and have gone into a bit of this at the margins.
It will vary. We have to keep it under review, because a waste gang could turn into a drugs gang, and then you would transfer how you were handling it. We are talking to the NCA and trying to make sure that we have the right way of looking at it.
At the Secretary of State’s Waste Crime Crackdown Group, we are discussing whether we need to refresh a strategic assessment of the organised crime gangs involved in waste crime to check whether they may have moved in terms of gravity of offending. We last did one in 2021, so this would be after a while.
In response to multiple questions over the years, I had an answer from Baroness Hayman of Ullock, when I asked if the Environment Agency had “finished its investigation into Healthcare Environmental Services regarding disposal of waste in relation to the NHS”. The answer was, “The matter is under an advanced stage of review by the Environment Agency (EA). This is a complex case requiring the consideration of matters arising across jurisdictions and parallel legal proceedings. It is not appropriate to comment further until the EA’s review of the matter has been concluded”.
Mr Pettigrew has been struck off as a company director by a Scottish judge in the Court of Session. What has the Environment Agency decided to do in terms of criminal proceedings?
Philip Duffy: It is a case that has a very long history. As you will know, following action taken by the Insolvency Service, Mr Pettigrew was barred as a director for 10 years in a case recently. There has been no prosecution brought to fruition against Mr Pettigrew or his company, Healthcare Environmental Services.
For lots of reasons, which some members of the committee will understand, it would not be appropriate for me to talk about future legal action in this forum against that specific case. What I will say, though, is that the committee will rightly want assurance that there is not a widespread problem with anatomical waste or NHS waste across the sector.
Since 2023, the agency has done two things. First, it has done 43 audits of NHS sites that treat anatomical and other waste, and found no compliance problems whatsoever with that. The waste can require sterilisation or autoclaving prior to being incinerated. Secondly, we have tightened, because they appeared to be ambiguous, requirements on the storage and transportation of anatomical waste to make sure that you could not store this waste in containers, for example, and tightened the permit.
Baroness Coffey: I am sorry, Mr Duffy, but I am going to intervene. This has been going on for eight years and I wanted to get an answer. Have you yet completed your review? It may be that you have concluded it. Eight years on, after what was a very blatant disregard for the law at the time, I am really sad that we are not at that point, but I am conscious that it is coming up to 11 am.
The Chair: We are on a countdown. In preparation for the annunciator, may I ask everyone to stand, if you are able? We will observe the two-minute silence, starting from now.
Sitting suspended.
The Chair: Thank you, everyone. Please be seated. It is 11.02 am. Baroness Coffey, have you finished?
Baroness Coffey: Yes. I do not think that we are going to get anywhere.
The Chair: In that case, we will move on to the second part of today’s session, which is further questions on our inquiry on the drought report.
Your agency has direct powers and also offers leadership to the water industry and the other regulators involved. Could you, for example, tell us what the policy is going to be for granting additional abstraction licences from rivers and ground aquifers to speed the replenishment of depleted reservoirs?
Philip Duffy: As you say, we remain in a very serious situation on drought. The latest numbers are that our reservoir storage nationally is at 60.1%, which is 17% below average for this point in the year. We have eight reservoirs or reservoir groups that are exceptionally low as of this week.
We would need more than 120% of long-term average rainfall between now and spring to exit this drought, so we face going into next year in a situation where it is inevitable that we will be in drought—and, in some places, severe drought—over the year.
Your question is absolutely right. What can we do right now to reduce the risk to public water supply going into next summer? You may be interested to know that a ministerial direction was issued to the Environment Agency to allow us to use the regulatory discretion that we have to prioritise public water supply in severe drought areas.
In effect, we are translating that by prioritising reservoir recharge in the largest reservoirs that are most strategic and where we have the most significant concerns about refill rates. We can do that in two ways. We can authorise significantly further abstraction when water levels are high, which we have done recently, particularly in Devon. Following recent rain, we have been working very closely with South West Water to maximise abstraction from the River Exe.
We can also, in places, bearing in mind the impact on the natural environment, reduce what is called compensatory flow, which is a proportion of a reservoir’s water flow that goes back into a river. By cutting that, we can accelerate the recharge of those assets.
We have quite a programme. We are doing it using our discretion, so it is mainly under local enforcement positions, but some of that will be regularised through drought orders in the course of the winter. That will enable water companies to abstract more water than normal and put less water back into the natural environment.
All of that is good, except that I do not think that we can be remotely complacent, because, while reservoirs service large parts of the country, elsewhere in the country we are quite reliant upon groundwater for our public water supply, particularly those areas that rely upon artesian systems.
In those areas, we are going to have to think much harder about making sure that we have resilience across different areas, that people are using water wisely, and that we are maintaining restrictions on water use throughout the winter. That is a difficult message to give when it is raining, but an important message that we have to give nevertheless. We are also pushing the companies extremely hard on leakage, which , if you look at our most recent review, went up last year, due largely to the very dry soils causing movement in their systems.
There is a huge amount to do right now. You win or lose a drought in the winter, not the summer, and now is an extremely important time for us to get ahead of next summer’s events.
Lord Redwood: I hope that you will use the extraction system as one of the responses, because, when I walk by the Thames, I see billions of gallons tumbling down to the sea very quickly, and no obvious increase in extraction.
One other option in the London area is the Beckton desalination plant, which had mechanical problems and has not been functioning for a long time. I understand that those problems are going to be resolved before the end of this year, so will that kick in and will you require that to run in order to relieve the pressures on the London supply?
Philip Duffy: We are in discussion about Beckton. For clarity, it is worth recalling that the severe drought situation that we are currently facing is not in London. It is in the system around Haywards Heath connected to the Ardingly reservoir; in Devon and Cornwall with Wimbleball; and in west Cornwall with the Stithians and Drift reservoirs that serve the Lizard and Penzance. Our top priority is making sure that South West Water and South East Water are doing everything possible to maximise recharge of those reservoirs, and have really robust fallback plans should that not be successful.
In London, you are completely right to say that desalination may need to be on the cards systematically in future. Thames Water is making progress on bringing Beckton desalination back into service. It had a problem getting certification for the treatment sheets that it was using. Our priority for London right now is to make sure that the north-east and west reservoir systems are fully recharged by the end of March, and that is what we are currently working on.
Lord Redwood: There are plans for nine new reservoirs as a longer-term solution to this problem. Only two have been given nationally significant status to try to expedite the permissions and to get them up and running. Can you update us on how much urgency is going to be injected into the new reservoir programme?
Philip Duffy: There is now a Defra-chaired infrastructure group focusing on reservoirs. The goal of that group is to systematically identify and remove any barriers to delivery, whether that be from environmental regulation, from planning, or from the financing of those reservoir schemes.
We focus on reservoirs, but they are not the only part of the picture that we need to resolve. There are other water schemes, such as take and put schemes, water reuse schemes and water network schemes, that help us move water around the country. For example, Anglia Water is investing heavily in a pipeline from North Lincolnshire to East Anglia. There is the use of the Grand Union Canal to move water from Birmingham to north London. These are equally important to building a resilient system.
It is abundantly clear that, if you look at what happened last summer, we entered the summer having had a very wet winter and very high groundwater levels. The fact that we have gone from being very well positioned at the end of March to having severe drought declared in some parts of the country by the end of September should remind us that this system is not resilient to our current climate. The Government totally understand that and are thinking very hard about how to further expedite these programmes. There may be more investment required.
I just want to make one more point, if I may, about leakage, which is an important part of this picture. It is 2.6 billion litres of water a day, which is nearly 20% of the water. It has come down by 40% since privatisation, as a matter of fact, but it is still too high, and we are very keen to make sure that companies really are tackling leakage systematically, responding quickly to events, and fixing leaks as soon as they are reported to them.
Lord Redwood: Under Governments of three different parties this century, there has been no new reservoir construction, and 10 million people have been added to the population, so it is not surprising that we are short of water. There does need to be a long-term solution. Pressing you further, I have not heard anything from you to say that there is going to be greater urgency in the new schemes. If you look at the case of the Havant scheme, putting in rather a small additional but useful reservoir in that part of the stressed south, that is going to be delayed by two or three years.
Philip Duffy: A fairer way of putting it is that the Havant scheme is delayed but will be a lot bigger when it opens. That is an important distinction that I would encourage us to make. From our point of view at the Environment Agency, we would completely agree with your position. I have heard people say that the Environment Agency is not in favour of reservoirs, but I want to completely contradict that. All of the major schemes that we work on with our colleagues in Ofwat through RAPID need to be progressed with alacrity.
I should also say that last summer was particularly difficult for farming communities around the country. There is an urgent need to accelerate the construction and filling of on-farm reservoirs, which are another important part of the picture in parts of the country. I do not know how I can convey to you my pro-reservoir position, but we are very supportive.
Lord Redwood: I am delighted that you are pro-reservoir. I am just trying to get some action. The Government are strongly in favour of on-farm reservoirs, but have announced only £15 million in grants, which is not going to help buy many farm reservoirs. Can you tell us how many it is realistic to expect to be added to the stock in the next couple of years?
Philip Duffy: I do not have a number for you, and you will have to ask the Government about the £15 million, but what I can say is that the EA needs to change how it thinks about the problem. We have what is called a hands-off policy in abstraction. If a water level goes below a certain level, as a farmer, you cannot take any water, but there is no hands-on level, so, if a water course is above a certain level, you do not get to take as much water as you can. We have seen instances where the NFU has come to us and said, “We are in flood in this part of the country. Can we take more water?” and the EA said, “It is not in your permit”.
We need better telemetry of our rivers and changes in how we do the abstraction permitting to say that, above a certain level, when a river is in spate, that is fine. That is exactly what we have just done with South West Water on the Exe.
We also need to look at how long abstraction licences last. If you are raising private money as a farmer, you may have a mortgage against the work that you are doing on your farm, so you need the abstraction permit to have the same duration.
We need to look at something that we have raised with MHCLG Ministers, who are listening quite carefully, which is permitted development rights. I had not appreciated that on-farm reservoirs are permitted only if the use of that water is on your own farm. If you had a neighbouring farm, I could not build one and then give you water. I would have to get planning consent for that. This is the sort of grit in the system that is discouraging farmers from doing that.
What did we see particularly in the east of England over last summer? Nearly 1,400 farmers who had surface water abstraction rights, mainly in arable and mainly in the east of England—the Wensum would be a case in point—lost their access to water, which has big food security and economic consequences. Everyone sees the importance of taking that part of the picture seriously.
Philip Duffy: Yes, you are right. We are supporting a campaign called Let’s Save Water, led by colleagues in Ofwat. We have evaluated the effect of that campaign. It is quite a positive evaluation. Unprompted recall of water-saving measures has gone from 17% to 46% in a recent sample, and 80% of people polled said that they recalled seeing a water-saving message recently, so the campaign is going quite well in terms of getting that messaging out to communities.
We are going to have to open a bigger conversation about where we get water from. For example, in Cambridge, we are doing a lot of work to look at things such as rooftop water collection, so that people can water their gardens with a water butt. It is quite a simple thing. It is not expensive and not particularly high-tech, but, if you could drive down per-capita consumption by a few tens of litres, that would be really positive.
There is a big conversation happening both with us and with our colleagues in the Drinking Water Inspectorate about the appropriate and safe reuse of greywater. There are health issues involved with that, but we need to broach that conversation.
Of course, industrial water use forecasting in the UK has a very chequered record. In many parts of the country, we overestimated, in the 1980s and 1990s, the level of industrial consumption of water, which helped us because we had more spare water for domestics than we thought. We are now seeing the wind change somewhat on industrial consumption. We are seeing strong demand from horticulture in the east of England that we had not foreseen. We have, of course, the well-trodden issue of data centres to manage. We have to find a way of balancing and managing those water resources as a whole. It is not just about public campaigns, but is also about making sure that we have those areas.
We also know quite a lot about behavioural science and water consumption. We know that, unlike in other areas of environmental activism, your individual behaviour impacts on water resources in the place where you live. Water does not move. There is genuinely a relationship between how much water you use and whether your severe drought will be continuing. That is an important and powerful message. We have seen, from places such as South Africa, the importance of making that connection when things are really difficult.
People also want fairness. They want to know that, if they are making sacrifices, others are too, and that what people regard as being unserious use of water is not tolerated. We have to be very careful to make sure that any use bans or hosepipe bans are seen to be credible and fair across the whole system in the community, not just arbitrary.
Lord Trees: I was pleased to hear you mentioning moving water in the previous answer. That was one of the recommendations that we made in our drought report, to involve drainage boards, canals, and so on, and we have big systems, but the Government rejected that recommendation. I wonder whether you could comment on that.
Philip Duffy: The way in which water moves currently is, in general, through private law agreements between these privatised companies. There is also then a layer of regulatory activity through a joint unit called RAPID between us and Ofwat, which looks at opportunities for schemes that we can take forward through the price reviews to fund the movement of water. We have some schemes of that sort currently under way.
If the system is under greater pressure—and it is—and if the Environment Agency is, for example, saying to Anglia Water, “You must fill Grafham as quickly as possible” or, “You must fill the west London system as quickly as possible”, some of those agreements may come under some tension because the company has to prioritise its own water assets, and so there is a case for a strategic overview of the system. Where is the water moving between the companies? Is it adequate? Do they make consistent assumptions between the areas? We have sometimes found that they do not have consistent assumptions.
I understand that there is going to be a Bill to look at the reform of the water system, and one of the things that you might see in that Bill, when it is published, is some new capability to look at the system as a whole and ensure that, when we do price reviews, the interconnectors and the balance between companies has been properly thought through. Occasionally, that has not been the case.
Another recommendation in our drought report was that abstraction licensing should be moved into the environmental permitting regime. Can I simply ask that you use your good offices of the Environment Agency in this infrastructure body to which you referred to make sure that we get an urgent date for when this is done?
I am a firm believer that smaller reservoirs are the way forward. We still have not heard from the Environment Agency about the Balmforth review and what is required. I bear the scars of Cow Green reservoir being built in Upper Teesdale when it was not required. Many of these larger reservoirs serve a purpose, but they take 10 years to be constructed, and there is a huge demand for on-farm reservoirs now.
Philip Duffy: I need to say something about this issue of water going to sea, because there is an important counterargument. We are balancing some pretty extreme measures to tilt the system towards public water supply at the current time, and that is cutting the available water for nature. There was a period this summer when the River Exe was running at its 99th percentile of low flow, which has consequences for fish populations and for Atlantic salmon. We may or may not prioritise that, but I need to record that we have a legal obligation to consider those factors in this trade-off. We consider them very seriously, but we are tilting that abstraction in favour of public water supply.
There are limits to how quickly you can pump. You have to have the right pumping equipment and the right set-up for depth, and it can be difficult to pump when a river is in full spate because of the volume and the speed of the water. We are doing our best to make sure that, when we have heavy rain, we are not missing a day of it.
On the question of EPR, I totally agree. Some abstraction permits date from law from the 1960s and are on paper. To operationalise the hands-on within constraints/hands-off system that I have just discussed with Lord Redwood, you would need to have the right technology and a more dynamic permit that was clear that you could change those things really rapidly.
We also have really strange things in our abstraction permits. We have dates, based on historic farming practice, of when you can start or stop abstraction. They often say that you can start on 1 November. That is fine if you were looking at the rainfall pattern when the permit was issued, but it may not be fine for the current conditions. This is an inflexible system. It is not automated. It needs to go into EPR to be fixed. Ministers have heard that from us loud and clear.
I was not quite sure about Balmforth, which is about the health and safety of the reservoir system.
Baroness McIntosh of Pickering: It is the de minimis rule that I understand is a factor preventing smaller reservoirs being built, and yet they tend to be non-threatening to communities downstream. I really think that we need to have an answer to that quite soon.
Philip Duffy: I favour a system that says, “If the reservoir looks like this, it is not going to pose risks, and you do not need to have all this work. If it looks like that, so raised in certain locations, you are going to need to get a safety case”. We saw at Toddbrook how serious the issues could be from reservoirs. We are worried about reservoir safety. We take our Reservoirs Act responsibilities very seriously.
You are also right about on-farm reservoirs. They are sunken, so they pose a risk of people drowning in them and they need to have a fence around them, but an on-farm reservoir in the east of England for arable farming is not going to pose significant flood risk concerns, and we need to be transparent and proportionate in that.
Philip Duffy: There is a lot of innovation in the sector, and you can see that. A number of companies are doing exactly that, using smart mobile sondes to look at the system. Colleagues would correct me if I did not mention the fact that you need some level of leakage in water, because one of the ways that you keep the pipes sterile is by putting chlorinated water through any gaps in the system, so you need quite a high-pressure system.
Lord Ashcombe: How much would that be?
Philip Duffy: It would be a low percentage, and not 19%. Clearly, the judgment reached in the companies has been that the cost‑benefit on further leakage reduction just is not there, because they have access to water and did not need to spend the extra money on fixing these systems. What we are learning is that that cost-benefit judgment could be wrong, and that the cost of providing alternative water, so desalination, very difficult environmental issues, further abstraction and trade-offs with industry, might be so high that you really do need to focus on getting your leakage rates cut further, even though it is very expensive to do so in many areas.
Something that Sir Jon Cunliffe observed in his review of the water regulatory system is this lack of a real understanding of the asset lifecycle in water. When are your assets are going to be life expired? What is the correct level of ongoing maintenance that you need to maintain an effective performance of those assets? Do the regulators, in which I include the EA, have a good enough understanding of the asset lifecycle to point out to the companies, “This needs to be replaced. You need to be fixing this at this point”?
With the new regulator that will arrive, we are trying to build a system that is supervisory. One thing that it should be looking at is, “Do you have the kind of asset lifecycle that you need to show that your leakage is up or down, and where have you priced the marginal pound in terms of repairs to leakage?” A lot of water company chief executives right now are realising that they may have drawn that line in the wrong place, because the cost of meeting their public water supply obligations is going to go up a lot if they do not get the leakage down. It is about half our gap of water supply leakage.
Lord Ashcombe: Do the water companies have a full view of the state of their pipes?
Philip Duffy: Some do and some do not.
Lord Ashcombe: What are you doing about it?
Philip Duffy: We are challenging on it. We are talking to Ofwat about it. We are asking them to take further steps to give us monitoring data. We are also looking, in the context of next year’s legislation, at whether we need more powers to direct the water companies in certain areas. We may do.
Philip Duffy: I do not know.
Lord Lennie: What are you aiming to get it to?
Philip Duffy: If you look at the cost of meeting the public water supply, given what we know about population growth, as Lord Redwood said, as well as hotter summers, which we have also seen, the question is around the most cost-effective way to do that. The view in the industry was, “It’s not leakage. We could build more reservoirs. We could find other ways of sourcing water. We could get desalination”, in the case of Beckton.
We would say that that judgment needs to be looked at again, because the cost of doing this is very high. If you look at the impact on the economy of the water constraint that we see somewhere such as greater Cambridge, you could see real loss of economic output caused by inadequate supply of water, and so you should find every cost-effective way of reducing it further. We are not saying that it should be zero, but 19% is still too high in our judgment.
Philip Duffy: In some of our catchments, we have to make that trade-off every day between our legal obligations towards nature, which requires a certain level of flow to support things such as migratory fish—there are laws passed that require us to think about that in such a situation—our obligation to meet public water supply, what farmers are allowed to have and what industry needs. We have to balance all those factors in our work every day.
This summer, particularly in places such as Norfolk, we saw such low flows in the rivers that we did, in fact, tell farmers that they could not take any more water. They had hands-off restrictions. While they have an abstraction licence, they cannot do that below a certain level of water, because the judgment that we have made is that you would be causing irreversible damage to the natural environment if you allowed the river to run dry. You could make a different judgment and allow it to run dry; that is what the law says currently, but we have to make that judgment all the time.
We completely understand why we need to preserve water supply for farmers. It is very odd that you can have a position in which, if you are accessing water from the public water supply, you can still access water, but, if you are a farmer who has either a private borehole or a surface water abstraction licence, you get your water supply turned off in the same season. That does not feel to us to be particularly justifiable. It is logical, because they come from different sources—the public water supply comes from reservoirs, and this is directly from the natural environment—but we need to see it as a system.
I mentioned fairness of how we do that. Some farmers felt that this was unfair, and I can see why they did. That is an area that we are going to look at very carefully for next summer, because we know that some of these rivers, particularly in the east of England, will be very low next summer.
Lord Krebs: Another thing that we were told was that the price of abstracted water does not necessarily reflect its scarcity.
Philip Duffy: It is not priced currently in that way. There is a fee given to it, and that fee supports a whole range of regulatory activities and environmental support, but you are not charged per unit or for what you are doing with it. It is not a tax. It is a requited fee, in the Treasury’s terminology. Some people are taking water and making a lot of money with it, and some are taking it and making no money with it, but they pay the same fee schedule. There is a perfectly good reason for looking at that. It would be converting the Environment Agency’s regulatory fees into something a bit more like a tax.
You started your evidence on the water session by talking about that swing from flood to drought last year. I am aware that we have a very strong global El Niño at the moment. One thing that we raised in our drought report was multiple-year events cascading into each other. Could I just ask you for a word on your worries, concerns and preparations around an El Niño later this winter possibly causing extreme drought, and what work is being done across and between departments to help prepare?
Philip Duffy: We are working very closely with colleagues at the Met Office on the outlook. I am somewhat hesitant to ventriloquise what they would say, but, in essence, they are worried about a period of very intensive rainfall, possibly pre Christmas, and then a dry, cold end to the winter. It is perfectly possible that we could have quite severe flooding in the same parts of the country as we have severe drought, at the same time. That is a difficult message to communicate to the public, but it is what the science says, and it is perfectly possible we could be in that situation. You could have severe drought in Wessex and Devon, and be pumping on the Somerset levels, in the same month.
From that, what do we learn? First, greater resilience of the system requires us to absorb and store more water. We have covered on-farm reservoirs. We have also covered dynamic abstraction, refill strategies, and interregional networks.
Secondly, it requires us to make sure that the Environment Agency and first responders are match-fit for that, so we are currently completing surveys of all our critical flood assets to make sure that they are in working order. We are looking at our rosters over Christmas to make sure that we have enough people to deal with multiple crises at once.
As chief executive, I am worried about the agency’s capacity to manage multiple events at once. I could add to that wildfire, where our role is to make sure that we have enough water to put fires out and look at how we do that. We had quite a busy peak heat season over the summer as well in the agency.
You are right that this climate whiplash, which is a phrase that I hear used quite a lot, is posing new challenges for us about how we boost our resilience as a country.
The Chair: We certainly do have new challenges.
Baroness McIntosh of Pickering: Chair, I forgot to declare my interests.
The Chair: Please declare your interests.
Baroness McIntosh of Pickering: I apologise. It was in the original drought report. I have small holdings in Pennon and United Utilities.
The Chair: Thank you very much. With that, thank you very much to both Philip Duffy and Malcolm Lythgo. You have been really very accommodating and patient in answering our questions. Thank you very much. With that, I call the public session of this committee to an end.