Built Environment Committee
Uncorrected oral evidence: Maintenance and enforcement in public spaces
Tuesday 3 November 2026
10.35 am
Members present: Baroness Andrews (in The Chair); Lord Bailey of Paddington; Baroness Barran; Lord Bassam of Brighton; Lord Cameron of Dillington; Baroness Griffin of Princethorpe; Baroness Lawrence of Clarendon; Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer; Lord Porter of Spalding; Lord Ravensdale.
In the absence of Lord Gascoigne, Baroness Andrews was called to the Chair.
Evidence Session No. 1 Heard in Public Questions 1 – 13
Witnesses
Patricia Brown MBE, Director, Central; David Milner, Managing Director, Create Streets; Ed Lennox, Director of Operations, Clean Up Britain.
USE OF THE TRANSCRIPT
Patricia Brown, David Milner and Ed Lennox.
Before I ask you to introduce yourselves and put my first formal question to you, I want to put two fundamental contextual questions to you. First, just to be clear, from your experience what would your definition be of the public realm and the public space? Are they the same or different? Maybe you could address that question when you introduce yourselves.
The second question is actually even more fundamental: with the hope of getting a very effective, concise and practical answer, what is the exam question that this committee should really be addressing? I ask you to think about that in the course of the morning, because it is best to come back to it at the end, when we are thinking about the other gaps we might address and issues that might arise. Those are the two questions. In the meantime, can you just introduce yourselves briefly, and set out where your interests and expertise lie? I will start with David.
David Milner: Morning, everyone. I am managing director of Create Streets. We are an urban design consultancy, a town builder and a think tank, so we are a little weird and unusual. We essentially do projects as an urban design practice: we do street design and we write lots of street design manuals for councils up and down the country, such as Surrey, Cheshire, Lincolnshire and, currently, Oxfordshire.
We then take those learnings and put them into policy practice. If we find out that it is really difficult to plant trees in three or four areas, we will work out what policy levers are leading to this. Then, ditto, we have done the same with transport and we are doing lots of work on trams, as well. At the moment, I am a member of the mass transit taskforce, looking at how we make this cheaper and quicker to get our second cities going.
I am personally very interested in decarbonising transport in cities. In terms of personal life I have been doing this for seven years with a passion for making cities more prosperous and sustainable. I was previously in the Air Force for about seven years, so a very different career change.
The Chair: Do you work nationwide, David?
David Milner: Yes. We are actually based across Lambeth Bridge. We have a small office and a team there. Most—I would say about 95%—of our work is nationwide and there is some international work as well.
The Chair: In England or the UK?
David Milner: In the UK.
The Chair: Are you part of the growth argument as well? Do you see yourselves playing into that?
David Milner: Yes, massively so. We are looking at how to get a lot of forgotten cities to use placemaking and street design to support their economic revival; making it a more attractive place for businesses to locate because it is a fun, interesting, beautiful environment for their workforce to come to would be one of our key planks. Then we also do a lot of work on how to densify. We use the phrase “gentle density”, which is more homes on less land, in essence, to solve the housing crisis, in theory, and help more people get to more jobs more quickly.
The Chair: Thank you very much; that was really helpful.
Patricia Brown: It is wonderful to be here and thank you for choosing this subject. I am going to pick up on the last point that David made as a starting point—your question to him about growth—and go back in time to the late 1990s when I was running something called the Central London Partnership that brought together the public and the private sector to improve London. It was a very new, nascent approach to working collectively to do things to make sure that London would prosper and improve in lots of ways.
I was fresh out of the first inward investment agency for London and thinking very much about competitive cities. Among many other things that we tackled—including social equity, or social cohesion as we called it at the time—we were thinking about how we made the public realm or built environment as we then called it, because “place” was not even talked about, to be the stage for people choosing to live, work and invest there. People would live their lives in central London, invest, visit, and choose to spend their leisure time and, crucially, their money in central London, so it was about the future economic prospects of London, and remaining a world city.
We went on to do a huge amount, particularly led by the interest of the business community wanting to be stewards of London, and put their money and investment into being active stewards and improving London. We established the business improvement district movement into the UK. We did an awful lot that I can talk about later around creating walking as a form of transport—I do not mean just a leisure activity but using that in terms of a mode shift—and creating the very first thinking around the idea of a better environmental condition in London by getting rid of cars. We were not getting rid of cars but helping cars find their place. We lobbied for the Trafalgar Square pedestrianisation, for example.
I now run my own consultancy and a lot of the work I do is strategic advice. At the heart of it is marshalling the right thinking and the right people to make positive change right across the country, and I have worked in New York as well.
Ed Lennox: Good morning, everybody. I am operations director of Clean Up Britain, which is the only organisation in the UK focused on littering and fly-tipping. That is our route, but it goes wider than that because the broken window syndrome is very much in play in the UK at the moment. Nothing helps you see this more clearly than if you travel through Europe and then arrive back in Dover and come up the A2/M2; by the time you have gone about three-quarters of a mile you want to start self-harming, it is so appalling and embarrassing.
While we have our roots in littering and fly-tipping there is a danger for us in scope creep. When you start looking into the issues that surround that you find the related issues of lack of maintenance, lack of care, and the appalling slide in standards that we are allowing to surround us. We are becoming immune to seeing falling-down signs, signs that you cannot read, foliage overgrowing, weeds growing out of the pavements and so on. That has really led us into quite a deep analysis of how dysfunctional the state is. I do not want to be pejorative about the way in which tax money is spent creates structures, layers and layers of bureaucracy and legislative opacity between who is responsible for what. But, in the end, if you wanted to design a system that was not going to deliver a well-maintained public realm, we have it.
I want to make it clear that when you actually start to realise what the problem is there is a danger that people perceive that you have some appalling political agenda, and we have none. We just want to see the job done. In too many cases, the job is not being done, and in too many cases the money that is spent to do the job is being spent and allocated by people who simply have no understanding, experience or ability to rationally determine whether that is good value for money or not.
Clean Up Britain specialises in shining a light on what the problems are, and we have some very high-level recommendations. In the end, there is no connection, as there was certainly 50 years ago, between a local problem and a named local individual who had pride in their work delivering good value for money to get that problem fixed. We aim to go some way to getting back to that level where accountability and responsibility are vested in local people, with fewer layers of bureaucracy. At the governmental scale, there are also too many agencies involved in this. That is the problem.
Bearing in mind that we already have enough information provided to the committee to understand the lack of evidence—the impartial, unequal, fragmentary, and inconclusive nature of evidence that makes it difficult to say that something is definitely worse—people seem to think that things are definitely worse. Are they definitely worse? How do we know? What would you say is the state currently? Are we right to be concerned? I will actually again start with David because I am very anxious that we do not miss anything that you have to say before you leave.
David Milner: The current state is certainly below our counterparts and peers in developed economies. It is of importance. We did a policy report called Beyond Potholes, which was looking at everything apart from potholes. Potholes is a galvanising topic that everyone who is trying to win votes will point to, so we thought we would ask, “Okay, what is number two, three, four and five on this list? How far away are they?” We did some polling with Deltapoll, and 14% of people ranked potholes as number 1, so that was overwhelmingly the lead from a list of about 12 things.
Number 2 at 11.1% was pavement quality. Then we asked lots of other questions around cleanliness and graffiti; all these topics are really not that far behind, but they are maybe clouded by this one perfectly relevant, important topic. But we also need to focus on the other parts. In a way, I would wrap up the visual clutter into pavements, bins and rubbish bags. We call them “street scars”: you see a beautiful York stone or granite pavement and then it has asphalt scars going across from where the utilities have come to dig it up, then left it for six months, in theory, but maybe even longer. We do not see all these things as often when we are going to France, Germany and other countries.
The Chair: Do you think things have got worse? I am not asking for evidence at this point.
David Milner: I do not have any evidence that it has worsened. Some cities have become better and I suspect some have worsened.
The Chair: We can unpack some that actually, but are you saying that, from your perspective, what really matters and affects people is the ordinary clutter that they live with on a daily basis, which is dirt and street furniture, battered, in the wrong place and graffitied, safe pavements and the general quality of negotiating the normal town centres?
David Milner: Yes, exactly. You could spend a lot of money on the shopfronts, have done this incredible piece of regeneration and maybe even put in the nice pavements. To Ed’s point, as we do not seem to have one owner or one person who is accountable in our high streets, you might then just have a bunch of binbags on that pavement that are leaking out, damaging the stones permanently. Or you have a phone box in the middle of where everyone wants to be walking, which does not work, is graffitied and rubbish. It is that sense of what we call everyday competence, within that town.
Patricia Brown: Can I go back to one of your questions, which is the definition of a public realm and space?
The Chair: Please do.
Patricia Brown: I wanted to ask you about that. I was thinking about the sense of where the whole of the realm is not in a private space; whether that is our home, a school or inside a commercial building. I think of where we congregate, interact, live our lives and walk to places as our public realm and public space. That also goes to things like playgrounds. It is wherever we can spend time and need to be in order to go about our daily business, and that is roads as well as what lots of people think as actual public space, which is a little pocket park or a little pavement area that has been designed and thought about. Everything is really part of it.
I think deeply about this and I have created an initiative called London 3.0. I witnessed and actually worked on the improvement of public space and getting that concerted management, whether that is through business improvement districts or other measures, to have that ownership of the public realm, to think and to worry about the details, and to enforce the things that need enforcing.
Several things happened: it was going up Maslow’s hierarchy of needs and then place actualisation. We really did incredibly well. Then along came austerity and budgets were cut dramatically. Attention turned away from those small things that Ed has especially talked about, and a whole range of things such as the way we run waste services, which I am sure Ed is expert in. It is bonkers that we have a system where people take their rubbish and put it on the streets. That rubbish could be full of coffee grinds and grease. We expect people to negotiate their daily lives around binbags that are leaking rubbish and, in some cases, toxic fumes on to our public realm. Then we expect the highways authority or the local authority to pay to clean them.
We need a fundamental rethink and a fresh look. The reason I call this London 3.0 is because we made all these changes and we went up, but now we are going down. In the face of many changes, including urban innovation such as hire bikes, dockless bikes and delivery drone things that are delivering to people in some parts—a whole series of things that are taking space—the private sector is actually monetising our public space. Local authorities and business improvement districts are trying to keep up with that.
Then there is a cultural aspect, which is that you need to want to care about these places and you need to have ownership and a sense of care. Much of this comes down to having people who do not sweat the small stuff in our built environment. It is really important to focus on the details and to actually have a management structure and a funding structure that allows people to be on the streets to enforce these things. We need that and a cultural change in the public. Much of that has gone wrong since the 2000s, from what I call the takeaway/leave-behind culture. If you go to Venice, where there is only one McDonald’s, you will not see a Caffè Nero cup and somebody’s cigarette packet sat on somebody else’s window ledge. Why have we created a culture that enables the public to think that it is okay to take something away and leave it behind? I have more to say, but I am going to leave it there.
The Chair: These are very interesting and profound questions indeed, about behaviour, difference in cultures and so on. Whether we get to the bottom of it may be beyond the scope of this committee but thank you for giving us that start.
Ed Lennox: The built environment in the public realm has deteriorated in the opinion of 77% of people. I am not going to start referring to notes here as I can furnish them later. All the research shows that the perception is that the public realm is disintegrating in front of our very eyes. In fact, there is evidence even across Lambeth Bridge, if any of you want to go and look at it. I dare say there are different agencies responsible for different parts of that bridge. If you walk along the roadside of it, rather than swim underneath it, the roadside is quite well painted. But, if you look at the side of it and underneath it, I can almost guarantee, just by looking at it, it has not had any maintenance done on it from the riverside and from the underside for at least 15 years. It has faded and there is rust showing. We have completely lost our ability to live by the old adage of “a stitch in time saves nine”, which makes me sound incredibly old, but it is true. Preservation is better than cure. We have lost that.
As Patricia said just now—I cannot remember the exact words, forgive me, but somebody will have a record—
Patricia Brown: The takeaway/leave-behind culture?
Ed Lennox: We have that, but we are not investing in trying to create the culture that we want through our children. We do not have public service broadcasting anymore. We do not have message reinforcement that littering is disgusting and unacceptable; we have therefore become tolerant of litter piling up everywhere and it has become normalised. Until we realise that we have to invest in society, we will not have the public realm that we want to see. We have a laissez-faire attitude of, “Oh, we think everybody will behave right”. They do not.
It is a criminal offence to drop litter. It is a criminal offence to fly-tip. There were 1.3 million fly-tips in the last full year for which there is reporting available, and fewer than 1,500 prosecutions, most of which were not successful. The average fine was £600, which does not even go close to addressing the issue. The point is that you have almost no chance of being caught doing the wrong thing, none at all. The penalties are tiny, and we do not invest in doing the right thing.
Until we actually grasp that nettle and are honest with ourselves, we are going to live in an increasingly decrepit, ugly, dirty, filthy, embarrassing country. That is not to say that there are no areas which are beautiful. Around here is a lot better than most, let me tell you. The thing that really bothers me most about the built environment is that we have inherited in this country some incredibly beautiful structures from our forebears, who built things to last a very long time. Stone bridges are a particular passion of mine. I do not accept this austerity thing, because most councils are terrible at spending money and I can give you examples of it. They have no clue how to negotiate a contract properly and get good value for money. There are endless examples of that in Clean Up Britain, but stone bridges are one that really bothers me, being a particular passion of mine.
If the roads are not swept, the debris, detritus, leaf mulch and what have you accumulates on the side of the road. It grows deeper and deeper. When it gets to a certain depth, trees can grow in it and they do. I could take you to at least 50 bridges around the country where there are trees growing out of stone bridges with roots going into the beds of those bridges. These are things that we have inherited, and we are absolutely failing to look after them on a grand scale. We know the cost of everything and the value of absolutely nothing. If you buy cheap, you pay twice, and we are probably paying four or five times, because we will have to rebuild a lot of the environment.
The Chair: I am going to stop you there. We will take the next question from Lord Cameron, which is about whether different parts of the country are different.
My question, as the Chair just said, is how the quality of public spaces varies from region to region. In addition, how do the solutions vary in terms of the existence of bodies that might be focused on the problems, either regional bodies or even very local bodies? I suspect that the very local ones are the more important ones. Is there a difference in the money that might or might not be available to put in to provide solutions from region to region or town to town?
Secondly—sorry that this is rather a long question—is there a difference in approach between cities and market towns or rural, smaller communities? The University of Portsmouth came up with a study in 2024 indicating that rural and green spaces were more likely to contain litter than urban areas. I just wondered whether we may be looking at city solutions, when actually these market towns are really important as well. Let us start with Ed, from the other end, this time.
Ed Lennox: Yes, it is a lot easier to sweep roads and pavements than it is to pull litter out of ditches. Your question is incredibly comprehensive. The simplest way to answer it is that in rural, semi-rural areas and market towns there is much more butting together of different agencies that hold the responsibility for any given situation. For example, the strategic road network is managed—I use the term loosely—by National Highways. Some signage is the responsibility of the local authority; some is the responsibility of National Highways. Some verges belong to parish councils, some belong to county councils and some belong to National Highways. Those bodies love more than anything else to have an argument about whose bit of the area needs cleaning up.
That is a complete nonsense. Very often one agency will say, “Oh, we are doing something about it”, which means it is holding a meeting with 39 people, none of whom has a decision or a budget or a clue what is going on. They just endlessly bat around letters and emails between one another. Yes, of course, it is much simpler to keep urban areas clean.
There is not a north-south divide. There is quite a lot of evidence that I have in my pocket—I am not going to start reading it out; we do not have time because it would take me ages to find it—that shows that the level of deprivation and socioeconomic activity all play a part.
In the end, we are not making enough effort as a country to make any area visually appealing and looking as if somebody cares. When it looks as if those that we are paying our tax money to do not care, this is a real problem for all parties of any persuasion. When people start to feel on a grand scale that their tax money is not enabling them to live in a nice place of which they can be proud, it spirals: there are mental health costs and other, visitor attraction costs. Everything starts to go into a negative spiral of decline. I am afraid that is where we are in a lot of areas, not all, obviously.
Lord Cameron of Dillington: Patricia, do you want to have a go at answering my rather rambling question?
Patricia Brown: It was a great question. The answer is that there is no consistency: you get good right across the country and you get bad right across the country. There are an awful lot of bad parts of London and there are some wonderful parts in Cornwall and Northumberland and right across the country.
The problem we face is that that is often by accident rather than by design. I spend a lot of time in Cornwall and suffer from having to pick up nappies from the lay-by where people have parked to go and enjoy the beauty of the Land’s End and Sennen Cove walk; yet they think it is acceptable to leave a nappy when they have changed a baby. People throw coffee cups on to the verges. The last Costa Coffee in the country is in Penzance, and I feel I should collect them and take them back to the shop to ask them to do something about it.
What Ed is talking about, and that he is really trying to tackle this, is music to my ears. He is talking about what we do to public space, but there is also how we design public space and create more spaces for people—the beautification of the civic realm. Often those two things come together: if you create beautiful places, people often treat them well.
I am very involved with Historic England and I was on Historic England’s high streets heritage action zone board. That was one of the most heartening things I have ever been involved in, because I saw the pride of place that people have. It was actually made even more special for people because of heritage, but also because we had a very strong cultural programme. People came out and owned that, and the places were improved in the ways that people wanted. I would be very surprised if those places are degraded because they belong to the people. It is about how we give places to people and who creates those.
Ed talked about the dysfunction of the different overlapping authorities, but sometimes it is the community. I want to shout out to Penzance, where you could eat a meal off the floor it is so clean. Much of what has happened in Penzance is down to strong civic leadership from local people. A particular woman, Susan Stuart, has leveraged in many, many millions of pounds for Penzance to restore heritage buildings and to work with the council. I am not saying that it is only Susan and only the community, but it is that partnership where bringing the local authority in—and holding the local authority to account as well—has been really critical.
I have a final thought that goes back to culture and what I was talking about earlier. I once asked the Danish ambassador why Denmark is so beautiful, and so perfectly designed and thought through. His answer was that the Danish grow up being given a civic realm that is theirs. As young children, they know that the spaces and places that they grow up in, the nurseries that they go to and bike lanes that they cycle along—from the age of nothing, virtually—are theirs to enjoy and take care of. They grow up with a sense of ownership and aesthetic of what they have inherited, and they care for it and want to continue that. That continuity of care is absolutely vital across generations.
David Milner: To clarify, I am going to talk about the not-rubbish part, so the street furniture.
Lord Cameron of Dillington: You are quite right; it is about the sphere.
David Milner: It is not that that is not important, but we have experts on that here. To your first question, yes—there is massive regional differentiation. I do not think it is necessarily systemic for everything, but there is a tendency for one part of the country to be far better or far worse. I would almost put it into categories, which is systematic of the fact that we have so many different complex systems governing everything from the bench, to the phone box, to the shopfront, to the public realm and materials.
It starts from that begging-bowl funding and council funding that we have had for quite a long time. Maybe we are starting to see some that change a bit more with devolved funding being passed through to some areas, but not all. This means that you need really strong, entrepreneurial council leaders. There are some very good council leaders and very good officials as well, but we are making it really difficult for them to do nice things, whether it is through procurement processes, the cost or difficulty of planting a tree, or changing the public realm material.
We have good examples. Darlington had amazing public realm improvement in its centre, within the ring roads, though it was about 20 years ago. Bradford has just had a huge new public realm scheme in the centre; I have not seen it personally, but it looks great from the photos and from what I have heard. Lots of people might have seen the changes that have happened to Pavilion Road in London, and that is extending to Sloane Street and other places. That is relying on that entrepreneurial way of going out to different pots and moving bits of money around in a complex way.
You might have systematic improvements where you have some more devolved funding. Coming back to accountability, the person who holds the purse strings also has control of the highways, which is a really small part of our country. However, highways is an area that I would really encourage people to look at. Yes, you might be a market town or a local planning authority—you can do everything in terms of what you permit or do not permit some of the shopfronts to do and so on—but, unless you are a unitary, you do not have control of the highways. That can therefore just be scarred, changed, barren, asphalt-laden, devoid of trees and you have no control or power on that.
When you look at highways authorities, for example, they see a lot of these nice things we are talking about—the bench—as a liability. Their only duty from the Traffic Management Act 2004 is free-flowing traffic. They do not have another duty, and yet actually highways is our public realm. Highways includes pavements as well.
An example where I have seen that improved would be Lincolnshire. It put its highways team within a growth authority—coming back to the earlier point on growth—where it is also incentivised to have the upside from planting the tree, such as putting in natural drainage. This low-level planting actually does a really important service of absorbing water. It could be planted with nice flowers and greenery, and it sees the advantage of that.
The Chair: I am going to force the pace a bit, because I know you have to go, David, and I would like to get through a few more questions before you do. If Patricia and Ed can stay after you have gone, we will suspend the sitting then start again, so we will get through all the questions. If you could, keep your answers slightly shorter and, Members, keep your questions slightly shorter as well.
Ed, there is one area that has improved since I started work in London in 1979, and that is dog poo. At this time of year, you could not walk along the pavement for fear that under every leaf there would be dog poo. That, oddly, has much improved and I feel there must be some lesson there that we could learn for the rest of this.
I was also heartened by your reference from all of you to civic leadership and the importance of that. Actually, when questionnaires are given by councils as to what is important, rubbish collection is still right up there, as it was when I was a council leader. My question is how you get that link into the public mind between your parish council or town council—whichever layer it is—spending money on first design, then maintenance, then the better outcomes that you have already described for the community.
Ed Lennox: That goes to the very heart of the issue that we have in the country at the moment: most children now leave school without any idea of how the state functions; who does what, where, why, when? My stepson is 19, nearly 20, and is completely baffled by how politics at all levels—local up to national—works; he does not really understand anything. We have shied away in the education system and the reinforcement system from trying to find a way to educate the next generation on how the state works and what you can do for your country, not what your country can do for you, to coin a phrase. We have just lost that ability to connect and educate people.
Your example was about dog poo bags and things like that. That was done by absolutely unceasing reinforcement, and we do not have that anymore. When I grew up, we had endless things about keeping Britain tidy. It may surprise you that Keep Britain Tidy still exists, but it has failed because Britain is not tidy, in the main. We need to find a different way of getting these messages reinforced. There are some high spots, but the way we make the culture change is by investing in the next generation. We have to be honest about that. We need to drive that message home from a young age, similar to the Danes; if we have a laissez-faire attitude to making this happen, what will happen? Nothing good—laziness.
Patricia Brown: I agree with what Ed just said. We have to continually invest in the spaces that people are in and show that we care about them and their experience, which was my approach in Central London Partnership. I wanted London to put its arm around people in a subliminal way and say, “Welcome”, by making it an easier place to be and to walk in, and very subliminally making the facilities clearer. Legible London, the wayfinding system, was part of that. It helped people to navigate around London, because it was not easy for people who knew only the mental map of the Tube, for example.
We have a situation where Jubilee Bridge, the bridge that used to be called Hungerford Bridge, has probably not seen a jet wash in most of its life and there are inches of dirt accreted over it. We are telling people that we do not really care about them. There is something fundamental about the message we are giving out. Why? This is one of the most important spaces in London in terms of the River Thames and the amount of tourists who go across there, but the lift is insanitary, if it is used at all.
So there is a degradation in lots of places, not everywhere—witness Penzance—but lots of other places are well maintained. It is as Ed said; it needs constant reinforcement, then eventually you can pull back from that constant reinforcement and enforcement. As everybody said, you have to sweat the small stuff constantly.
We also have the situation, which has been alluded to, of the maintenance of the pavement. We did a lot in central London in terms of utilities digging up the road and reinstatement. If you have what Create Streets called “street scars” on what was once a very lovely set of granite steps in—say, Monmouth Street in Covent Garden, which was a particularly famous example—you have a low-level sense of “We don’t care about this and we don’t care about you”. Invest in the management and the enforcement, and through that you are subliminally investing in people.
Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer: David, just before you reply, as you are involved in the design, can I ask you also to include in your answer the implication that people are not walking or cycling as much? Perhaps that has contributed to the culture of not caring because they are driving past. Is that something that you have seen?
David Milner: Yes. I was not going to mention that, but actually it is a really good prompt. There is a really good phrase, which is “driving architecture and walking architecture”. I am talking about buildings here: if you go past at 50 mph. it does not really matter if it is an Amazon warehouse-style building or if it is very bland, passive or a dull material; there is no kind of detail because you are not going to see it. Whereas if you want to walk, you want to have the kind of variance in the shop fronts, the facades, the verticality that change subtly; it sort of rhymes, is a little different but is not too jarring. A lot of our built environment is screaming to you as if to say, “Do not walk here. We do not care about looks; we do not want this to be an interesting experience”.
One of the phrases I also really like is “cherry blossom moment”. You could probably have a slightly longer commute that is not very nice for 75% of the time, but it is all right because you are going to work. But, if you have one moment where you are maybe cycling or walking through a park and the flowers and cherry blossoms are out, you will feel good about that. That is your brain’s peak, basically, the bit you will remember, apart from when you are walking through the office door. I think that is a really important point.
The first of my two points on this would be that the culture can be downstream of the built environment. Since you mentioned cycling, lots of people talk about Amsterdam and the culture is different; they all cycle. Back in the 1960s, they did not. If you look at the pictures of all the streets there, they are very congested and busy. An oil crisis led to them changing the way they built their streets, then the culture went downstream of that. I might say the same for the littering now: if you have a culture in which there are bags outside, the system would be saying, “Put the bags outside; this is how we do our rubbish refuse in London in particular”, then other people will assume that is what you can do with a Costa Coffee cup and can just pop it next to it. Or if a phone box is not used anymore, and has loads of posters and graffiti on it, you might as well just put some binbags next to it as well, even if you are not meant to.
You asked about solutions and we are looking at a couple of things. One is street design codes. Back to street scars and the asphalt being ripped up, one of the arguments from utility companies is, “We can’t find the materials to put it back”. I am not sure if I necessarily agree with that but, if you have a countywide code which says, “Here are good, better, and best materials”, we will know that everyone is going to use them. We could have three stores of these in a couple of centralised locations, so there would be no excuse for a utility company to take six months.
To answer the very first question around why this is, I would make an argument about the hidden lever and the hidden wiring theory. Lots of policy and legislation leads to these systems being in place. One would be the New Roads and Street Works Act 1991. This sets out the fine for a utility company, which is £2,500. That was in 1991 and it has not changed, so the cost to them of not repairing this York stone or granite is a business decision that incentivises them not to do that. It says, “You have six months to do this”. Six months is too long a time because we know that there are continuous repairs; that could really be brought down to three months or two months.
The Chair: I am going to move on because of time. Can I just ask Patricia to write something for us in particular? You mentioned the BIDs, which is a really important initiative in relating to this question about how a decent environment created or helped to foster the notion of a business district. Could you send something in writing—some homework—about the relationship between these issues and what it took to create the BID itself? Is there a lesson that can be learned there that is transferable? I am going to move on to Lord Bailey; we are coming on to bigger political issues now, then can come back to solutions towards the end.
I want to add that there is a tension here because, to my mind, there are different types of public spaces. There are utilities such as a road; you need a road. There are beautiful spaces, such as the White Cliffs of Dover, and then more managed spaces such as King’s Cross, for instance, which is a public square. How does the way that those three different worlds appear affect how people talk about the state of the country? One of the ugliest things that ever happened to London is cycling lanes, by the way. Patricia, could you start, please?
Patricia Brown: It plays into political narratives and drives how people think they are thought about in places. I go back to my earlier answer: if our streets and spaces are not maintained, it says that the people of those places are not being considered. One person’s view of what good looks like is very different to another’s, so I do not think it can be a blanket response or answer.
Take Oxford Street, for example: I have never seen so many column inches about the temporary pedestrianisation of a street as I have about the 1 km of Oxford Street that has been closed off to the public. Many people love that space and it is driving one narrative, but many other people do not like the pedestrianisation and it is driving another narrative. Oxford Street has been a really interesting political football for 30 years.
It is important in terms of local democracy that the people who are representing you listen to what is important, whether that is anti-social behaviour in public spaces or littering, which is also anti-social behaviour. That is my answer to you.
David Milner: Yes is the answer that I would give to this one. I will use train stations to illustrate my answer. Think about arriving into St Pancras; I would call that a public ground or public space. It is one of our train stations. It is probably easier getting off the Eurostar than getting on, with the queues, but once you are off you are into a beautiful environment and an absolutely incredible station. We can and do poll people on whether they like it and find it attractive. I agree that everyone has different views. If we ask everyone their views, we can start to find some consensus in what people like and what people do not like. Seeking to find consensus in a public space makes sense for me.
Contrast that to arriving on the West Coast Main Line into Euston and how you might feel, especially as a tourist or a visitor, local or international. Your first impression dictates a little how you feel about that country. We see the same with airports as well. It has an impact on the wider discourse of whether people think this country is succeeding, failing or middling.
I also point to all the bits that I have raised—bins or litter—as a sign of state competence or everyday competence. I use the analogy that, if you are going into someone’s living room, they might have very nice furniture and carpets but, if there is a big stain, it is ripped up or there is a litter bag in the corner leaking, you know that there is a failure of ownership going on.
Lord Bailey of Paddington: Before I come to Ed, I want to put another thing there. Bins or no bins? London used to be awash with bins and now there are no bins at all. Are they a good thing or a bad thing?
Ed Lennox: That is a cultural question; that is very good. On the first bit that you said, all the political class needs to be very careful about what is going on at the moment. There are cost of living pressures and it is constantly reinforced that we are being taxed more than we have ever been taxed before, and then you see the public realm, visibly in too many places—not everywhere—being uncared for. Unfortunately, Clean Up Britain does not often get people calling up saying, “This is great. Come and have a look”. It is always, “There is something falling down”. That really puts a huge distrust not just in the political leadership but in all levels of government and local authority.
This is not a political point but you do have to be aware, and I am choosing my words carefully. Michael O’Leary had never run an airline until he ran Ryanair. He is a very good operator. Local authorities are not places where people in the private sector go to find incredible entrepreneurial talent. It has never happened. I do not think a chief executive of any council has ever been poached by a private organisation for their incredible entrepreneurial go-getting spirit. That is a problem. Most of these people complain they do not have enough money. They do not have enough money because, honestly, the wastage in local authority is unbelievable: it is unacceptable. It is dreadful. This is the unseen thing that people do not talk about. There is enough money being spent on running this country; it is just being spent incredibly badly. We can talk about the role of the National Audit Office as well.
Back to bins, as that was your punch line. There are virtually no bins in Japan. We all saw the Japanese football fans picking up litter after the football matches. It is cultural. I do not know about the Danish and whether they have lots of bins. I went into a lay-by last night where there was a bin. It was an empty bin and less than three paces from the bin was a pile of rubbish. We are again allowing and permitting people to get away with being unbelievably selfish and lazy. I know teachers will feel put upon but school is the only time you can reinforce the behaviour that we need to have. Clearly, there are too many parents who are not giving children the grounding they need. As a judgment, for me there should be a cross-party consensus that one should never, under any circumstance, reduce the education budget. The investment in the next generation should only ever go one way, only ever up; otherwise, we are just going to build up problems for the future. We need to nurture children to behave in the way that we want them to behave in the future, and we are not doing it. Then we do not need bins.
Lord Bailey of Paddington: I want to quickly end on Patricia because one thing you realise when you are in Parliament is that lots of people’s self-belief is based on treating everybody else as if they were a victim. I come from a very poor community; almost nothing that was good was foisted on us. We came up with it ourselves. To what extent should we be challenging the public, local people, to take charge of the environment they are in? There is littering; I fully get that. I used to live on an estate that was an absolute mess, and we had lots of crime. We petitioned to get lights and we made the young people make these mosaics. Wherever we put the lights and there was a mosaic, behaviour was transformed. We keep talking about what the Government should do and where local authorities have failed or succeeded. How do we build that trust by saying to people, “You have a stake in this and you should do it as well?”
Patricia Brown: It is such an important point, thank you. Agency is really important in everything we do in life. It is also an educational thing, whether parental or people who help raise a child. To believe that they have agency is really important.
Some years ago, I was walking up an escalator in Westminster when a very well-heeled man put his coffee cup on the top of the escalator and I asked him to take it with him. He turned to me and said, “It will be cleared up”. I said, “We have to pay for that”. He then said, “Are you a schoolteacher?” He took his cup. People assume that if you want something to be done that is better or different, you have a position of authority.
What we are talking about here is a bit of a complicated thing because it is a product of success. We have made so much difference to our public realm over the past 25 years and that should be celebrated in what we are talking about. We have not made a difference to how that public realm is managed and how we all act within it. We have been too successful in actually taking the litter away and managing the litter despite what I said earlier about the leave behind culture. We have taken away the sense of agency that I grew up with because I was fed on Keep Britain Tidy campaigns, as Ed has already alluded to.
David Milner: To add on to a really good point, we need to allow local people to do more in the public realm. We push them out. One thing we are looking at is a right to plant. Talking about growing up in different estates, we hear so many stories of people who put pot plants, decorate, or try to green up their little areas and they get letters straightaway saying, “Fire regs say get rid of this”. It is a massive space and you cannot do this. The Dutch do have a little strip just outside their front garden or the boundary of their house, and they are allowed to put whatever they want in that. We again see case studies of little mews streets where people have put some plants out and they get told, “Take it away”. There is over-regulation in not allowing local people to do this.
On trust, we planted some trees in Grimsby and we were told that they were going to get ripped down—tiny little trees, and everyone would vandalise them. We actually got the kids, the football team and a few other people to plant them and then they had ownership of it. People do not think they are allowed to.
I am sorry about this, Ed, but you are going to have to be able to supply some evidence to suggest that local government is awash with money on the basis that 87% of the pounds that go into local government get spent on adult services, children’s services and homelessness. Finding anything in the remaining 13% is the devil’s own job to do, and I could not go by without letting somebody at least try to defend my colleagues in local government even though I am no longer part of it. Can we all please remember that the rubbish on the streets is not put there by anybody in the state; it is put there by people who live in the country.
The Chair: Thank you, Lord Porter. Could you make a very short reply to that or would you—
Ed Lennox: You are absolutely right. I meant the generic tax take provides us with enough money. I am aware that adult social care is an enormous drain. The issue that I hope we will be able to address is the whole way in which we fund more or less everything. You need to have much more efficient connection between where the money needs to be spent, somebody who needs to get and do the job, and local accountability. We can hopefully come back to that. Thank you for the clarification.
The Chair: Thank you for that exchange; that was really important.
Ed Lennox: The totemic issue goes back to potholes, for example. We should not even be talking about them because if we had a proper maintenance programme for the roadway, the drainage, and the associated verges and everything else, you would not get potholes. It is back to what I said at the beginning: if you maintain something very well, it will look after you for a long time. I am about to move into a house that is 550 years old. It is only still standing because it has been maintained well enough to make it last.
We see that here in London with bridges closing, and some being closed for a very long time because they simply tried to scrimp and save on maintenance over the period. They were perfectly good and they could have been kept up to a good standard. I do not accept that this is hearsay and nonsense. I could give examples of signposts that have rotted through on their legs, which is bizarre. Some big signposts on the side of the road—I do not know how much you drive the motorways—are in danger of toppling over on to vehicles, blowing into the roadway.
We have somebody listening to this session, Sean, who is behind me. There are certain motorways where the central reservation is awash with ash trees. Those roots are going to wreck the carriageway and nothing is being done to chop them down and preserve things. I gave the example about the stone bridges; I could go on and on. It does not matter what the public realm item is: it could be a bridge, a sign, a building, a roof, or dare I say even the Houses of Parliament?
Baroness Lawrence of Clarendon: You are saying that it is forward thinking.
Ed Lennox: Yes, it is short-termism. There are certain things in this country where we need connectivity and continuance between Governments of whatever colour. They need to sit way above party politics because they are part of the fabric of where we live—to what you were saying about the Danes. I find it incredibly depressing that too often they are party-political issues because they should not be.
David Milner: I do not have a robust dataset to say there is a huge amount of evidence that this is a problem but we have a large quantity of conversations to point to it. We have a charity that goes up and down the country, the Create Streets Foundation, to work with community groups where there is no state capacity to make their places nicer, to put in nice and attractive designed pavements or public spaces, and it comes up again and again in conversations with them. Whether it is litter, the quality of the pavement, or park, or the lack of greenery, it is impacting their lives. I have to accept that and value it as a piece of evidence.
There is something around the temporary nature of a lot of the work that we have been doing for a while in terms of our public realm, which is important to look at if you have a smallish budget to try to improve a city. I might use Oxford as an example actually. The quality of the public realm in Oxford is quite low if you think about it as the second most visited city outside London. It should be one of our crown jewels, and I know it is trying to do stuff about it. You could try to do a little across the whole city and that is what we have been doing, just spreading the butter a bit too thin—whereas, if we do not have the money, which we do not at the moment in terms of that capital pot, we need to be looking at a couple of hundred metres this year, and then next year, and then the next year, but up to a level of quality that is going to maintain and survive and not be redone in five years. That applies to potholes as well. It is probably not about pothole filling; it is about changing the way you build them when you re-do these roads. I am not a road expert but I know that we build them slightly differently to those in France or Germany.
Baroness Lawrence of Clarendon: That will come down to whose responsibility it is. If you talk about Oxford as not well maintained, would you say that is part of the council or part of the environmental? Who would you say is more responsible and should be taking more action?
David Milner: Oxford is interesting. It is non-unitary so you have city council planning and the county council looking at roads, and in a couple of years it is going to change and become a mayoralty. It is because you have lots of different owners of these spaces. One of the big arguments the council justifiably asks is, “Why are the colleges with all this long-term investment not getting more involved?” That may be to Lord Bailey’s question around how we have more agency for individuals. We should have more agency of businesses as well because if the businesses are helping to create a nicer place, they are going to see their business stakes go up. We need to try to bring in a bit more of that finance support and ownership of these streets to the point where children know what bits councils and Governments run. I do not think most adults know who runs bits of councils and Governments. It is very opaque and therefore you assume someone else is going to sort it out for you.
Baroness Lawrence of Clarendon: Patricia, you were talking earlier about ownership around streets and various areas; I wanted to ask the same thing about responsibility. A few weeks ago, somebody dumped a bag of rubbish in front of my house. It was in front of my car so in the end I had to move it out of the way and there were bottles and all sorts of things in this bag. I moved it to one side thinking the road sweepers were going to come and clear it up as they do their daily or weekly work. It was there for about three or four days and nothing happened. It was just sitting there. Of course, when I was moving it there was dog faeces and stuff in there. It was a nasty thing. It comes down to responsibility, and when it comes to the local authority one thing they talk about is how much funding they have. Is it my responsibility as a home owner to clear up that rubbish or is it down to the council or the environmental people to make sure our streets are kept clean?
Patricia Brown: It is down to the council but in that sense somebody has made that problem your problem to deal with; it should strictly speaking be the council. I would imagine it depends on your street cleaning regime.
I want to also pay tribute to local authorities that manage the streets as well as they do on very limited budgets for the reason we heard earlier in terms of the demands of adult social care and everything. Where I spend most of my time in Southwark, that bag would possibly sit on the street for quite some time because it does not fit into the cleaning regime. I am probably the one who would phone up the council and ask if they could actually get a van round to pick it up. It just goes back to that agency again, does it not? We have a house of multiple occupation, a very well maintained one, on the corner of my road, and recently they had some new tenants who were not doing what they should do with the bins. They were bad for about four weeks. It was me who phoned up the manager. I am not saying, “Am I not wonderful?” But it is all of us having some form of ownership in this. You should not have to deal with the rubbish but you could phone up the council.
David Milner: Is it okay to make one more point? A lot of this is also the system working as we have designed it. One example would be Bond Street. We did a project with Central District Alliance. Talking of bits, there are 47 private operators that collect the business waste. That obviously generates a huge amount of vehicle trips, which is a side environmental point, but the council will expect this to be the case. How can you expect them to know that this is operator 37, this is 12, and when they are going to go? What they did is club together to have a consolidation—essentially a refuse club. They all pooled together and actually negotiated and reduced the price. We need to see more examples such as Camden doing that.
They also looked at phone boxes. This is actually an area where you can use AI. You have this very complicated bureaucratic process so how can we expect citizens to know it? Well you can automate a lot of this, so we produced a very simple application called Booth-Buster. Basically, you take a photo of a phone box. There are five or six different types of regulations but it will tell you which one and generate an email to help the council and say, “You can use this and this power to get rid of this blight”. There are some really effective things to do.
The Chair: I am afraid we have to stop momentarily for David to get to his other meeting. We are going to stop for five minutes to have a bit of a reset. We can continue this with Patricia and Ed but we have to say goodbye to David. I am very sorry David; you have been a wonderful witness. I am going to ask you to reply to our other questions in writing.
Sitting suspended.
The Chair: Welcome back. Ed, would you like to respond to Baroness Lawrence’s question?
Ed Lennox: Yes; thank you for the opportunity to cut in on that question, which raises a good spotlight on the legislation. When somebody dumps rubbish inside the curtilage of your property, you have had a fly tip on your property. It is then legally, according to the laws of the land, your problem. It is your problem to clear up. You are a victim of a crime for which you are expected to pay. This is a big problem for the National Trust, Forestry Commission and farmers. It is disgraceful. For a cash-strapped council it is almost, “Oh phew, it has gone on somebody else’s land”. That is an appalling thing. The minute you then go and put it out on the street, you have legally committed a crime because you have fly-tipped. That is an absurdity. That is a tiny example of where the legislative framework mitigates against people doing the right thing and helping.
To the point we were talking about earlier, we need to get into a mindset where all authorities need to be enablers for people who want to do the right thing. They are not. They will throw every legislative thing they can. Clean Up Britain put cameras all over the place with some on the strategic road network. National Highways actually wrote to us threatening us with legal action when we caught somebody banged to rights fly-tipping in the lay-by. They did not do anything with the evidence we supplied; it was collected legitimately and legally. There is a blocker on people who want to make a difference. We should embrace with open arms anybody who is willing to help and contribute to the country, obviously within frameworks. It is just so turgid trying to get stuff done in this country. It is terrifying.
Baroness Lawrence of Clarendon: There is a law about cameras. I have a camera outside my house but the camera can only face on my property. It cannot go to my neighbours. My neighbours have said, “You have a camera, can you tell me what—?” I cannot. The camera must be faced on my property and if it goes across my boundary I am in trouble.
Ed Lennox: I will give you another little grey area: if you have a dash cam in your car then that is admissible evidence but nobody knows it is there. It is crazy.
The Chair: I am sorry but I will have to stop the conversation there but it was very important points. I want to come to Lady Barran who is joining us online.
I just wondered if you were both clear in your minds what one or two things would be the catalyst to unpicking some of this complexity to start to address the range of deterioration in the public realm that we have seen? Is there something that would get things going? Obviously some of what has been talked about is longer-term legislative change and simplification. That does not happen overnight. If you were to think about a plan that ran over five years, what would be the two or three most promising places to start?
The Chair: I am sorry, but Lord Bassam is also online and is waving frantically.
Lord Bassam of Brighton: The way Baroness Barran has phrased this leans into the question you asked me to ask—
Baroness Barran: I apologise.
Lord Bassam of Brighton: No, not at all. They are very adjacent. In answering Baroness Barran you could probably answer my question and speed us along. What steps does government at all levels take to create and maintain higher quality public spaces? What Baroness Barran has said, in phrasing her question, leans into that one as well. What can we do? What can Governments at all levels do?
The Chair: Excellent, that is a very creative approach. Well done. Two questions are in parallel; they support each other. Answer them as you think fit.
Patricia Brown: Back in the pre-Olympics, I went to see a man called Chris Allison. He was the assistant commissioner of the Metropolitan Police but he was also gold command of the whole of the policing for the Olympics. He was in charge. Whether it was policing and safety in Weymouth, Newham or wherever, it was his neck on the line in terms of the responsibility for safety on anything to do with Games’ activity and environments. On his wall was a T-shirt that said, “SPOB”. SPOB stood for single point of blame. He explained that he was the single point of blame, and what that really meant was he was the single point of responsibility.
One thing that I would really like, whether it is legislative or down to civic leadership and local authorities having the right mindset, is for there to be a simplified ownership of this where somebody is responsible for things that happen within the civic realm, with the type of organisational structure, the budget and the staffing resources to be, in the Jane Jacobs’ phrase, “The eyes on the street”. Too much has been discharged in the enforcement world to cameras. We lobbied for transport operational command teams in London to police the red routes in order to stop cars from lingering, all with a view for expeditious movement of traffic to keep buses moving speedily. Eventually the people who did all the enforcement work were taken off the streets and we now police our red routes and bus lanes by cameras, so those cars still remain there; they just get fined for remaining there. It is a good example of how we have outsourced too much to technology.
We need people back on the streets who have a job to care about this and to do something about it with the systems in place. That is my answer to you both. Some of it is legislative, some is budgetary and a lot is simply about civic leadership. I will point to an example from the early noughties. When Sir Simon Milton became leader of the City of Westminster, he looked at it with fresh eyes and realised why we were setting up business improvement districts in order to get private sector funding into managing Westminster streets. He agreed with us, joined forces and wanted to use that private sector mentality, entrepreneurialism and willingness to fund. He went down to great detail about what needed to change and how he was going to change it. You just have to keep going at it.
The Chair: Would either Lord Bassam or Baroness Barran like to ask follow-up questions specifically to Patricia at this point?
Baroness Barran: Patricia, I know you just said that this addresses what I would call the smallest possible thing that makes the biggest possible difference, such as what is the thing we can do tomorrow. I felt, if I may, that it was slightly more focused on Lord Bassam’s question, which is entirely valid. On having a single point of blame and having a clear sense of accountability, if we are going to have that—presumably based on the conversation we have already had—we would want to remove multiple other lines of blurred responsibility. That feels to me like a slower but important legislative task. I wonder what one could do pretty much immediately that might help and be a catalyst to those other things? What is the thing that is going to change that mindset?
Patricia Brown: It is a tricky question. My answer, which might not be perfect, is actually spotlight where it is working and show what comes from it working: finding examples, going to see those examples, helping other people, peer pressure and support in that. How did somebody do something better than what was there? That would be one way of doing it.
Another answer to the question that I have not already said is somewhere in the mindset/legislative frameworks. We need a mindset change around the future-proofing of our spaces and understand how spaces change over a period of time. We did not know we were going to have to accommodate electric bikes and Deliveroo drivers hanging around our city centres. Things change. I would like us to be able to create an environment where our spatial planning is done in a way that means we have very speedy post-evaluation occupation, and we keep an eye on what is changing in society as well as the physical way our spaces are used.
Ed Lennox: Can I answer both your questions? There is obviously no silver bullet but I could suggest three things that would make a profound difference quickly.
First, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs is too big and cumbersome. That is a massive brief. It is absurd. Quite a lot of them do not necessarily tie in very well. I accept that the Cabinet cannot be expanded exponentially all the time; that is the worst thing in the world that could happen. We need to find space at the Cabinet table for a Minister in charge of the public realm who can act as the enabler. They need the focus to make stuff happen. That is the first thing.
Secondly, I would go down to the local level and reintroduce the concept of the lengthsman, which you may or may not be aware of. Back in times gone by, until the mid-1970s when they started to die at pace, there was an individual named person responsible for a given stretch of road. Everybody knew who they were and, if there was a drain blocked, they would unblock it. If there was a public building falling down, they would say what was wrong with it. There was a connection between somebody who would be the local enabler to make stuff happen. In the middle, I would suggest this is beyond essential and might be a good starting point.
For the uninitiated, the National Audit Office is supposed to be the arbiter of whether money is spent well, is spent at all or has followed process. That is all fine in large, but I will give you a very practical example. During this discussion, we talked about temporary road furniture: signs, sandbags and stuff—rubbish left behind after road works. My view is that, unless there is an independent body that goes to any and all roadwork sites and says, “Yes, that is acceptable and they can be paid out the last bit of the contract”, we are doing ourselves an enormous disservice. They perhaps should be involved in contractual negotiations as well. I can cite that there are tens if not hundreds of thousands of items of road furniture left all over the country. Clean Up Britain makes freedom of information requests to all local authorities and National Highways and there is no record of one sign out, one sign back. They are not under any obligation to do that. This is monstrous. There are tens, hundreds, thousands and millions of pounds’ worth of signs discarded everywhere in this country. It does not happen anywhere else.
At the top we need a Minister in charge of the public realm; at the bottom we need lengthsmen, or lengths people or whatever you want to call them to be correct in that manner. We need that role so that there is a real connection. When somebody local thinks there is a problem, they go and talk to whoever it is and they can make a difference in their area. We have to get control of these public works contractors who, frankly, when they clear a site, are not clearing the site. There is no accountability and we are paying them.
I will give you a very specific example, and I have to go in a minute because I have to be in Cambridge shortly. There were some road works near me where they painted the white lines on the side and up the road. They did it in heavy rain. This was 18 months ago. They have all come off. I approach the council and go, “Why have you paid these people, because I know you have, and when are they coming back to put it back?” They will not be back. They will never be back. We have grown to accept such appallingly low standards in this country. Until we address it, such as along the lines I have suggested, we are in a troublesome spot.
The Chair: I hope you can stay for Lord Ravensdale’s question.
Baroness Barran: May I come in and follow-up or do we not have time? We do not have time.
Ed Lennox: You are persuasive; I will stay. I will go at 12.15 pm.
Baroness Barran: It was just two remarks, if I may, rather than a question. One thing that is a technical constraint on the committee is that we can only make recommendations, as I understand it, based on the evidence we have heard. If we are going to reintroduce lengthsmen we need to know what that would cost. I do not think we can say things without working out the cost. If you have that secretly squirreled away, it would be helpful. That obviously applies more broadly.
You mentioned earlier six different organisations responsible for bits of the same thing. I just worry about bringing in an independent body because that feels to me like a seventh. Why on earth would you not have contracts, as you would if you were doing major works on your home, that say, “We are not paying you the last 10% until we are sure everything is done and dusted”. For what it is worth, these are not really questions but just gentle pushback.
Ed, you said the perception is that the public realm is deteriorating and I want to drill into that a bit more. I agree that is the perception but I am interested in digging into what the reality is. For example, if you ask people about violent crime they would probably say the perception is that violent crime is increasing but actually, if we look at the evidence, violent crime is at its lowest since records began in 1981. Obviously perception and reality can be two very different things. Can we say anything about what the reality is in terms of the public realm? Has it deteriorated? If not, how do we gather that data to say what is going on with the public realm?
Ed Lennox: I am not good at looking up the notes but Keep Britain Tidy does quite an extensive survey. The last one is two years old now but 90% of locations surveyed across the country had an extensive litter problem in them. That has never been the case; it has been creeping up and up by year. Litter is a very visible manifestation. It is obviously not the only thing as buildings could fall down, et cetera. Here in London, we have two bridges shut at the moment, one for forever and a day, because they have not been maintained properly. I bicycle around London and I drive a car. If you hit a pothole on a bike, it is not fun. I bicycle in the countryside; if I hit a pothole, it is not fun. We have situations where we see one pothole being filled over there and the one over here being ignored at the same time. They do not understand that the truck roll is the significant expense when filling in a pothole. We are not doing a very good job. We used to be great at making, fixing and maintaining things. Now we are not. Until you admit that there is a problem, there is a problem. Yes, the perception is very real and evidenced by facts. Obviously, I am not giving you boring reams of fact but I will make a submission to the committee.
Lord Ravensdale: Yes, anything you can follow up with on the evidence behind that would be very useful.
Ed Lennox: Of course.
The Chair: Ed, could you just stay for Lady Griffin’s question, because it is quite important? Then we can let you go.
Ed Lennox: Yes.
To come back to what you were saying; lack of responsibility in one place is a real issue. I have represented the north-west in various guises over 35 years, and we were largely unitary. I am now in Leamington Spa and I cannot find out who is responsible for things when I try to do something that is community spirited. There is a lot in this about legislation, what we are doing about devolution and trying to marry this together in terms of governance. As my dear friend the Chair would say, my question is the exam question: are there any unexplored or underrepresented areas of this topic that we should investigate? What are these aspects that have been overlooked? What have we not asked you?
The Chair: You can write in, if you would prefer.
Patricia Brown: We need to look at equity, the lived lives of people and the different experiences that people have. I talked earlier about sometimes things being accidental. For example, you just happen to have the right person in the right place who can tap into funding resources. There are places where, when we have been talking about evidence and attitudes, people have probably never been asked what they feel about their spaces, and do not necessarily think about it because no one has ever encouraged them to think they could do something about them.
Under the Bloomberg Administration in New York they created a plan. I can send you PlaNYC. It was a plan for making New York a greener, greater place with a strong economy. They wanted to ensure that no New Yorker would live less than 10 minutes’ walk from a green space. They mapped green spaces across the whole of the five boroughs of New York and then overlaid it with social circumstances and incomes. They started in the most deprived spatial and income deprived spaces to give people access to green space. We need to care. I do not particularly like the term “every postcode”, but we need to care about every part of the country. That also goes for mobility inclusion and things of that nature. Maintenance often means that people who have mobility problems or visual problems are completely designed out of that space by neglect.
Ed Lennox: I have had time to consider my answer. The exam question that is missing is: how can the country rebuild trust in the agencies of government that we can maintain the public realm properly? The truth of the matter is, as a taxpayer, the Government are a monopoly. The Government of the day are a monopoly. If the Government were a business, would I be happy with the taxes that I am contributing to this country and the visual amenity that I see around me? Of course, Westminster is beautiful. I would be very happy if I was wandering around here. The short answer is I would never come back. You would have lost my custom years ago and I would be somewhere else. That is a bad position for a democracy to be in because trust is breaking down on a regular basis.
Baroness Barran said that we do not want another agency, and I agree completely, to audit whether something should be signed off. They need rationalising right down to the minimum number of agencies possible so that there is this proximity between a decision and action. In the end, the supplementary to the exam question is, how can the agencies of government become enablers for people to do the right thing?
The Chair: I am going to have to suspend the session for Ed to leave now. We will suspend for one minute.
Sitting suspended.
The Chair: Welcome back.
Patricia Brown: Thank you. I would like to give you a tangible example of something I am working on at the moment in the new epicentre of our country, otherwise known as Manchester. There is a public space in Manchester called Piccadilly Gardens: I hope it will not mind me mentioning that it has been problematic for a very long time. It has suffered from the accretion of a whole range of things; there are many homeless people and people who are either selling or using drugs. It is a place where people do not want to go. At one stage, it was the equivalent of what Times Square was to New Yorkers; you avoid it like the plague.
Manchester is redesigning this public space, but the former council leader, Bev Craig, was absolutely determined that it was not going to be redesigned only to bring back all the same problems. At the moment, I am advising Manchester City Council on what it should do differently, working across the council and the private sector, including people who are landowners in the adjacent area. My advice—and what we are working towards—is about unpacking everything that has happened there over a long period of time and is still happening. It is nobody’s fault: a lot of layers have appeared for different reasons. It is a transport hub, and it is now a very, very busy transport hub.
How do you remove everything—mentally, not literally—and then bring it back in the right way? There is an analogy with houses: it is like taking everything out of your living room to decorate and then bringing things back very slowly and in a considered way. “Does this need to be here? Do I want this to be here? Is it harmonious?” A large part of this will be about how we design the management of the space, how the police and the adjacent building owners work together, and so on. It will be a new form of management: we do not know what that is yet, but the exam question is, “What are we going to do to make this an enduring space and ensure that in five years’ time we won’t be needing another redesign and another commission to deal with Piccadilly Gardens?”
Patricia Brown: There is hard evidence: I do not have the statistics at my fingertips, but I can send you links to reports. What I can talk to is the work that I led when I was running the Central London Partnership. In talking about this, I actually use the phrase, “It’s the economy, stupid”, with a picture of Clinton. As chief executive, that was the message I promoted in order to attract the investment, time and energy needed to make this an agenda item. It took a long time, but by presenting it as an economic competitiveness issue, it got traction.
One piece of work commissioned by the Central London Partnership in 2003 was on the economic impact of quality walking environments. When Ken Livingstone became mayor, Transport for London was newly minted. It had a budget line of zero for anything to do with walking; in the first budget business plan there was £1 million for cycling. That went up to £3 million in 2003 but was chopped to nothing in the 2004 business plan. I persuaded TfL to give me £50,000 so that we could research the economics of good quality walking environments and then made the case to TfL to increase the funding. A few years later, the budget went up to £9 million. We did studies that brought literally tens of millions of pounds into TfL to be given to local authorities to improve the walking environment. You only have to talk to the walking and cycling commissioner in the current administration to understand how important that is. That is just one example.
When New York did the Plaza programme, which increased pedestrianised space, the highest profile was in Times Square. It was believed that people in cars would spend more because they stop and load their cars up, but an economic study showed that was not true. In fact, people walking and cycling were spending more, by a considerable multiplier. I can get you those statistics.
Finally, our work in the Central London Partnership was predicated on what we called—to the right audience—walking wallets. Legible London and the wayfinding system were designed to give people the confidence to get lost, in the knowledge that they could be found again. They could go off the beaten track and explore: they found coffee shops and little boutiques and places they did not know about, and more money was spent in those places. It is a very solid evidence-based area of work.
Lord Cameron of Dillington: It would be great if you could send us that, please.
I wanted to come back to two important questions. We have been talking this morning about the public realm and its ownership. My first question is: does the term “public realm” invest this issue with more dignity, responsibility and accountability than if we simply use the term “public spaces”? That is going to be important, not least for the title of our report and how we go forward.
I have a second, subordinate question. You talked about character, heritage and the work you do with Historic England, which I much appreciate. One of the things we have not explored—and should—is the extent to which the character of the public realm enables people to have a greater sense of belonging, pride and therefore responsibility. Do you think those are avenues we could pursue?
Patricia Brown: They are really important. I gave the example of the high street action zone and heritage high street work, and how those generated a sense of community engagement and a sense of pride. People care significantly about the character of individual places and have surprising views on them. Historic England has a lot of evidence on that. There are also organisations such as the Architectural Heritage Fund, which funds some really good projects across the country, for instance in Penzance. It is a very rich seam.
“Public space” is a friendlier term than “public realm”. The term “public realm” does a lot of heavy lifting, as I have noted myself. But it is the realm, and the most important thing is to explain your wording when you introduce the term.
The Chair: That is very acceptable. Thank you very much—
Patricia Brown: Can I end with an anecdote? It is not mine, but I love it, and it makes me quite emotional. One of the things I really care about in the civic and public realm is the way that it is lit. We do not understand enough about light, and we do not light our places sufficiently well: you might like to consider that. We overlight things because we think it will be safer, but that is not necessarily the case.
Peabody was doing a light-touch regeneration of a small housing estate in east London, which included relighting the space: it worked with Light Follows Behaviour, a lighting design company. One night a gentleman came out when a consultant was testing the light levels and asked whether she was responsible for the lighting. When she said she was, he said, “I’d like to thank you because it makes me feel rich”. That is a great example of how investing in a community gives its members—as I said earlier—a sense of being cared for.
The Chair: You have used the term “agency” throughout your evidence. In many ways, we have been talking about agency—where it lies and where it could be replaced. Agency and accountability are very close, and you have done us a great service today in helping to unpack the elements of what goes into good decision-making and where responsibility lies. On behalf of everyone, I would like to thank you very much, especially for staying until the very end in splendid isolation. You have been terrific.