Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee
Environmental Audit Committee
Oral evidence: Work of the Department and its arm’s length-bodies, HC 217
Wednesday 11 November 2026
Ordered by the House of Commons to be published on 11 November 2026.
Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee members present: Helena Dollimore; Ben Goldsborough; Terry Jermy; Josh Newbury; Henry Tufnell.
In the absence of the Chair, Helena Dollimore took the Chair.
Environmental Audit Committee members present: Julia Buckley; Jonathan Davies; Cat Eccles; Barry Gardiner; Sarah Gibson; Sojan Joseph; Manuela Perteghella; Adrian Ramsay; Sammy Wilson.
Questions 180 - 253
Witness
I: Lisa Tennant, Government’s preferred candidate for Chair of the Environment Agency.
Witness: Lisa Tennant.
Chair: Welcome, everyone, to this joint meeting of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee and the Environmental Audit Committee. Before I come on to the business of today’s meeting, I would like to remind everyone that, at 11 o’clock this morning, we will observe a two-minute silence for Armistice Day. When the Division bell rings, the sitting and the recording will therefore be suspended for five minutes.
Today, we are looking at the candidate for chair of the Environment Agency. Welcome to the Committee, Lisa. Could you introduce yourself for the benefit of the Committee?
Lisa Tennant: Hi, I am Lisa Tennant. I am the preferred candidate for chair of the Environment Agency. I am currently chair of the Scottish Environment Protection Agency and chair of the NHS pension board.
Lisa Tennant: I have been passionate about environmental issues since I was a child. I grew up in an area of former heavy industry, with ironworks, coal mining and a chemical factory. I grew up on a council estate, and every weekend my parents would take me out of town to the countryside to spend time in nature. I swam in clean rivers and learned the names of all the plants and animals. It was a real escape for me, and I have been passionate about it since then.
I have worked on environmental issues throughout my career, both running sustainable businesses and sitting on and chairing boards. My motivation for coming to the Environment Agency is that I have been doing this role for three years in Scotland, chairing the environment agency there. I think that I can bring the skills and experience from that to bear on the Environment Agency, where the scale is larger and some of the issues are similar.
Lisa Tennant: I came into the Scottish Environment Protection Agency with the remit to transform the agency post cyber-attack. That transformation is now almost complete: we have restored the public register after the cyber-attack; we have made cyber a board issue, not just an IT issue; we have rebuilt confidence in the agency; and I feel that I have completed the task that I came in to oversee.
The agency will be merging with Zero Waste Scotland and NatureScot. I have been heavily involved in that public service reform agenda for the past two years, helping to ready the agency for the merger. I think that now it is time for someone else to come in and see that merger through from start to finish.
Chair: If you are successful in getting this position, do you commit to serving the full term as chair of the Environment Agency?
Lisa Tennant: Yes, I do.
Lisa Tennant: The first thing that I would like to do is learn more about the EA, its work and its partners. Similarly, when I started at SEPA, I spent my first 100 days listening, building relationships and travelling the country to see the work on the ground. I would expect to do the same here. There are a lot of similarities in the challenges facing the agencies—for example, water, sewage and farming. There are differences, including the mayoral authorities. I would be very interested to find out more about that, to visit with mayors and understand their work, and to visit the regional offices of the EA.
Lisa Tennant: Apart from the scale, the privatisation of water is a clear difference. Also, responsibility for flooding and flooding infrastructure is different between Scotland and England.
Lisa Tennant: There are 190 regional offices in the EA, and staff are located all over the country. There is good relationship-building potential in all those areas. I would like to visit as many of them as possible and find out what is happening on the ground. The EA is running a board recruitment exercise at the moment, and I am keen that one of the new board members comes with local government and community expertise.
Lisa Tennant: Only a friend of mine who thought that I would be good in the role. I actually applied for the position myself; I was not headhunted.
Chair: We are now going to move to some questions about your vision for the agency, which will be led by Barry.
Lisa Tennant: First and foremost, I think that that approach is one of partnership working. It is really key to work in partnership with Parliament, to understand from those reports what Parliament is looking for, and to work in partnership with other agencies. In terms of PFAS, there are thousands of chemicals in the environment and they will last for a very long time. It is a pressing issue. The EA’s role in that is to monitor, research and enforce around those chemicals. It is at the forefront of European practice in that.
Water companies are an area of increased scrutiny, and I will expect the board to look at that very closely. The EA is improving performance on water companies and monitoring. Personally, I—
Lisa Tennant: I think I need to look into that more when I start in the role. I do not have all the information to hand. I am happy to come back to you on that. I am, however, interested at the board level in how these outputs and activities translate into outcomes on the ground and what the public see as those outcomes. I would also say that rivers take years to clean up, so those outputs and activities will not have an effect over months; it will take years, but be assured that I want the board to be focused on that area.
Lisa Tennant: I would call those “safe”, “clean” and “grow”. “Safe” is about keeping communities safe from flooding and drought. “Clean” is about keeping our water and air clean and free of major pollution incidents. “Grow” is the mission to support sustainable growth. Those are the three areas that I want the board to be focused on.
Lisa Tennant: The environment is the No.1 priority. If I might talk a little about my experience at SEPA, I have a particular interest in outcomes-based performance measurement, which I have already talked about. I have a specialist qualification in outcomes-based performance reporting. When I came to SEPA, one of the issues the board was facing was the performance framework and the KPIs. I do not think performance reporting was robust enough and I do not think the KPIs were outcomes-based enough. That is something we worked very hard on together as a board and executive. You have picked up on some successes around that area.
At the EA, I would start that exercise to see where the KPIs are now and how meaningful they are. How do the outputs translate to outcomes? Are we being risk-based and proportionate? No agency has the resources to deliver everything. Where is the Pareto principle? Where is the 80:20? How do we see where we have the greatest effect and how do we measure that we are delivering that?
Lisa Tennant: For me, there are two things here. The first is that the agency must listen to Government and Parliament to understand those demands. I feel that a key role of the chair is to build those relationships and understand what is being sought from the agency. Secondly, the agency is data science and evidence-based and must comply with law and regulations. When it comes to that, I see total independence for the agency from Government and from policy.
Lisa Tennant: I am very happy to speak those scientific truths. They come from an evidence base. If I might give an example from Scotland, SEPA identified over 150 unregistered, unregulated private reservoirs in Scotland, which carries a real risk for Government. Those reservoirs had the potential to flood 5,000 properties. SEPA staff were raising that issue with Government for two years and we did not have the funding and resources to deal with it. That was raised to the board. When the board became aware of it, as chair of the board I encouraged the board to write to the Scottish Government and to our Cabinet Secretary outlining the issue. We presented the data and evidence on the risks and what was needed to remediate the issue. The Scottish Government gave us a £1 million uplift in our budget last year to address the issue. We are now part-way through a programme of remediation on that.
Barry Gardiner: Congratulations. Thank you very much.
Lisa Tennant: Fundamentally, for me, that relationship is about holding to account and scrutiny. That is the first area that I will be looking at with the board when I come in—to understand how that holding to account has been performing. For me, a relationship with a chief executive is about the right level of challenge and support. That varies with the circumstances and the personalities involved, so I would want to understand that more before commenting further.
From my experience at SEPA, there was a lot of work to do on building trust between the board and the executive. It has been a real focus of my board development programme after the last three years. That trust has really started to develop: we can see actions on the ground, the executive bring issues very early to the board and trust that the board will support those issues, and the board feel that they can speak frankly with the executive and deliver that challenge and support.
Chair: We will now move to some questions about major changes in an organisation, which will be led by Manuela.
Lisa Tennant: If I might start with what I have learned, I have learned that it is challenging. There is no one right answer for these situations. Part of my experience comes from overseeing the working group, which delivered the Scottish Police Authority merger of the nine police forces in Scotland. It was a major transformation programme under political and media scrutiny, and it faced opposition from the public and from the unions. In terms of managing the risks and challenges, for me, that is about very robust processes and having a clear delivery plan and milestones. Supporting staff and culture through the process is also really important, and managing expectations is key.
In terms of more recent work on transformation, I have been working for the last two years with the Scottish Government on plans for public service reform. In the First Minister’s programme for Government, he recently announced that SEPA would merge with NatureScot and Zero Waste Scotland. I founded and chaired the public service reform chairs cluster group within Scotland. That brings public chairs across sectors together to talk about common issues and have a voice with Government, and to act as a conduit for Government to talk and relay with the chairs easily.
Lisa Tennant: The No. 1 cultural issue for me is clarity and what staff want is clarity. Sometimes, it can be very difficult to give that clarity. When the merger was announced at SEPA, we immediately had an all-staff call with a Q&A and committed to publishing every question we were asked, which we have done. That does not mean that we always have the answers to the questions, and some of that clarity is not there.
As a chair, I have been clear—so have the board—that there are principles that we can work to through periods of change, and one of those is transparency and honesty with staff: giving staff sight of information as soon as we have it, so that what we know, staff will know, when we know it. It is also about understanding concerns about building up confidence in the organisation and keeping it an attractive place to work. At board level, it is about understanding the transition plan, really clear milestones in delivery and keeping on top of that.
Lisa Tennant: It is a big question. For me, there are two buckets of risks. There are those risks that we do not mess around with. An audit committee would say those are our core strategic risks. Our risk appetite on those is very low and the board is going to keep close oversight on them. Then there are areas where our risk appetite can be different, and innovation is one of those.
I am very keen not to have a risk appetite statement that we leave in a drawer, because I see that happen quite often. The challenge in public agencies is to bring that risk appetite to life. It is one thing to say that we want to take risk and be innovative, but it is another to enable a culture and processes that actually allow that to happen.
Lisa Tennant: It is not for me to say what that regulatory landscape should look like. The relationship with the EA should be very strong. I want to build those relationships early and understand more about what is planned. I want to keep those relationships strong through the process. The EA should be a trusted partner in the new organisational design, and I expect that the EA will continue to be a partner after the reform.
Lisa Tennant: I might go back to my example about Scottish policing. We worked very closely with the unions, particularly through our human resources and people committee. Again, for me that is about early engagement—really understanding what the core issues are, listening and then working in partnership to address them.
Again, in my experience, unions are looking for clarity for their staff. As soon as we have more information, we have a duty of transparency to pass that on so that people know what will happen with their jobs. Again, I am very happy to work in partnership with the unions.
Chair: We now turn to some questions about balancing environmental protection and economic growth, which will be led by Sammy.
Lisa Tennant: I think No. 1 for me is environmental protection; that is what comes first. I do not believe that that cannot enable economic growth. That economic growth can be enabled in a win-win situation as long as environmental protections stay intact. An example of that is faster permitting. Simple permitting cases should be able to go through much more quickly. I see from the figures that that is starting to happen now.
Complex cases are taking too long—they can take thousands of hours. For me, the complex cases are where the environmental risk lies. I want to understand more about why those are taking so long to process and what we can do about it to enable that faster growth. I see planning decisions and planning advice going through more quickly. Both are above 90% now, so that is on an improving trajectory.
In terms of sustainable growth, I would give the example of SEPA working with the whisky industry. The whisky industry brought to the board’s attention that they wanted to use by-products from their processing to produce renewable heat and energy for their plants. They were actually being hampered from doing that by the regulations in permitting that SEPA had put in place.
We took the board on a visit to one of the whisky distilleries and saw the process happening in front of us. We got to understand it, and we were able to change the permitting framework to speed up those decisions. That is the kind of win-win that I am thinking about.
Lisa Tennant: I think that companies and investors need certainty for growth, and I am very alive to that. Again, at SEPA we simplified that: we took eight laws into one and simplified the permitting and regulation process through our integrated authorisations framework. I would like to look at something similar within the EA. We have thousands of laws and it is very complex. I see that some of the reports have said that that process should be simplified, so if there is any way that I can support that as chair, I am very happy to.
Lisa Tennant: What is really key for me is the right person in the right role. That does not always mean that that person must have environmental experience. It means that they have the key skills and values to excel in that role. I have seen great people come from financial regulation into environmental regulation. What is important for me is the principles of a regulator. Can this person work in a risk-based way? Can they take decisions around that constrained discretion? Do they have the right mindset to do the job? I think those are more important than environmental credentials.
Lisa Tennant: I think we both agree that it is a trade-off, and it has to be traded on a case-by-case basis. I think I would want to understand more about the current situation in England to give a good answer to where the trade-off should be. I would go back to protection of the environment as No. 1. Nature-based solutions in natural capital are extremely important, and one thing I have been clear about at SEPA is that climate change is a huge issue, but so is nature and biodiversity loss, which may affect us even more than climate change. That is where nature-based solutions can really step in and help. I do not think that is the solution everywhere; we need to understand that local area and work out what those trade-offs are and what the best solution is in a regional context. Nature-based solutions are preferred where they are the best option.
Lisa Tennant: I have not yet had discussions about those, but I fully expect to. It will not surprise you that I am a fan of the outcomes focus in the Corry review. Again, an example from Scotland would be our work on the River Leven, where we worked in partnership with other agencies and Government to restore the River Leven catchment area. I visited the site with the First Minister when the works were complete, and it was one of the best visits I have ever done.
You can see from that example that the outcomes-based approach does not deliver just an environmental benefit. I watched people from the local area walking up and down footpaths that did not exist before and fishing in a river where fish did not live before. Children came on a school trip to see the river that had been restored and the nature around it. For me, that is where outcomes-based comes to life for people on the ground.
Lisa Tennant: There are a couple of things on that. The first, which I picked up on earlier, is a cultural issue: regulators tend towards the risk-averse. It is about changing the culture to say that we can take appropriate risks and use constrained discretion, but that has to be brought to life for staff. They have to see that in practice, maybe by going to one of the projects and seeing where it has worked. They also have to know from their line managers that that is expected and acceptable.
One of the things I have encouraged at SEPA is that where we want to change this kind of culture, we can change the performance metrics for our staff to say, “We reward innovation and creative thinking.” That has helped to start making the culture less risk-averse.
Lisa Tennant: I will be able to better answer that question when I have been in the role for a while. I am very happy to come back with my thoughts on it. I repeat: regulators tend towards being more risk-averse. I feel that the agency has had some difficult times in public as well. When that happens to an agency, confidence tends to dip and people retreat back to enforcement of regulations and taking less risk. That is certainly what we saw at SEPA after the cyber-attack. Staff morale and motivation was low. When confidence is low, people are not in a frame of mind to take calculated risks. I would want to understand more about where the agency is currently and how we get it to where we would like it to be.
Chair: We will now have some questions about operational issues led by Terry and Ben.
Lisa Tennant: At the Scottish Police Authority, we had oversight of an organisation with 25,000 staff, and I have sat on the board of an NHS trust with thousands of staff, so I have overseen staff at scale. For me, it is key for staff retention that the board understands the culture of the organisation and the risks around retention. SEPA has a people committee, which I changed to a people and resources committee. I felt that the focus on people needed to be much more tied to outcomes and to the resources needed to deliver for people. One of the first things I did was instigate a staff survey. That is how we find out how people within the organisation are feeling. I would be keen to find out where that is at within the EA.
For me, retention is about making people feel that they are valued in the workplace. They need to be able to see career progression. Again, that is something that we looked at within SEPA. When you are in a technical specialist expert position, sometimes the only career progression is into a management role where you manage a team of people. That is not always attractive to people with that skillset, so we have looked at alternative pathways for retention and how people can be promoted into expert roles that do not always carry line management responsibility. However, where roles do carry that responsibility, we have provided an enhanced programme of training; we do not expect people who have come from a technical background suddenly to manage a team of 10 people without leadership experience and training. That has really helped with staff retention.
For me, it is also about bringing new talent and younger people into the organisation. At SEPA, we have a great programme of apprenticeships. However, I see that the EA is a Times Top 100 graduate employer, so I am interested to find out more about that.
Lisa Tennant: I do not know enough about the issue yet; I am very happy to come back and talk about that when I understand it in more depth.
What I would say is that it is important that people feel they are paid fairly for the roles that they do, and the EA needs to be competitive in attracting talent. Matters of policy around pay are for Government, but I am very happy to have those discussions.
I have farmers in my constituency whose extraction licences are up for renewal next March, but they need to make financial decisions now to buy the seed that is necessary. It is an incredibly risky situation. What will you be doing to improve performance and offer us more timely service? Given the importance of both food security and economic growth, performance around licences and permits is absolutely crucial.
Lisa Tennant: There have been some improvements and 40% of the backlog in permitting has been cleared. However, I appreciate that it is difficult for people in your constituency who are in that position and I do sympathise.
For me, one of the solutions to this is technology. Again, I would like to understand more about that once I have—hopefully—started in the role. I think that digital solutions can really help to drive speed around some of those complex cases, so it takes the focus away from having to recruit more specialist skills in. Again, I would need to understand more about it.
I undertook a ministerial review last year into McCloud remedy delivery within NHS Business Services Authority. A key part of that was similar; it was looking at these really complex pensions processing cases. There is a shortage of specialist skills to deliver those cases and a big part of the solution to that is looking at the technology that will enable those cases to be delivered more quickly, particularly around AI.
I see that there are AI pilots going on within the organisation, but I am keen to understand more about those and to see where AI can be applied to backlogs.
Lisa Tennant: I do not think that I have had a role where I wasn’t delivering in a challenging budgetary environment. [Laughter.] It will not surprise you to hear my approach to that is prioritisation, and it is risk-based. For me, the big risks at the EA that we want to prioritise budget around are risk to life and serious risk to the environment, such as flooding, drought, flood protection and major pollution incidents. Consequently, I would want to understand how funding is being channelled towards those areas.
Going back to technology, that is usually a huge lever in reducing costs and duplication within an organisation, and in freeing up budgetary funds to go towards those areas where the board thinks they can have the biggest impact. At SEPA, we have been able to conduct a programme of transformation without any extra funding from Government, partly by delivering on those technological transformations, but a programme of cutting duplication and red tape has also freed up resources for people to work on the areas of greatest focus.
Lisa Tennant: I think it is both. I am sure efficiencies can be made, particularly around technological transformation. I will be looking very carefully at that. It is incumbent on all public agencies to deliver as efficiently as they can.
On the extra funding uplift that we secured, that is on a case-by-case basis. We had a unique case that we had evidence for. If something similar happened, I would take a similar approach, but it is for the agency to work within the budgetary constraints that it has.
Added into those issues are budgetary constraints and not being able to do the permitting as quickly and efficiently as my farmers would like. What would you do to improve the situation on the ground between those stakeholders and the EA?
Lisa Tennant: This is one of the reasons why I am keen on the idea of travelling the country to hear what is happening regionally and why I am encouraged by the EA’s regional approach. Those regional partnerships help us to understand the context and to have the back and forth communication.
For me, communication needs to be clear and repetitive—usually more repetitive and clearer than you think it needs to be. I looked at the farming rules for water. I am not a farmer, but they are quite complex in their own right. I am encouraged to see that the EA is putting more farming advisers on the ground, taking that advice-first approach and recruiting people from a farming background. That advice-first approach is key to helping people understand what they have to comply with. Progress has been made on clarity around comms, but I will be interested to see how we can improve that.
Again, to give an example from SEPA, the board requested a stakeholder engagement strategy, which has now been delivered by the executive. That is a very clear mapping of every organisation that is a stakeholder with SEPA, showing what our three core messages to each of those audiences are, what the three key messages coming back to us from those audiences are, and who will manage those relationships, whether it be a board member, myself, the chief executive or our regional colleagues.
Lisa Tennant: In the role, I will need to understand more about how that currently sits. Again, I am very happy to come back on that.
Going back to my experience in Scotland, when we implemented our new integrated authorisation framework we did not just want to know about compliance and non-compliance. For those who complied and went above and beyond, we wanted to call out that good behaviour, and our new framework allows us to do that. We publish details on who is excelling in compliance. We have business awards every year to call out and celebrate those who have complied and gone above and beyond in what they have been doing.
For the worst offenders, who are a small minority, we now have a more punitive regime. We have doubled enforcement and fines over the last couple of years, and we are also calling out those offenders. That is the key to this. Sometimes the work that agencies do is not terribly visible until it goes wrong. One of the things we have done at SEPA is a social media campaign on polluter pays and fines. We will often say, “Here’s a situation, here’s a behaviour and here’s the fine”, and that also starts to act as a deterrent.
Chair: The next section is on data and transparency, and it will be led by Henry and Julia.
My question is about the key things in the culture of the organisation that you might be leading. Campaigners have voiced concerns that they see the Environment Agency as an opaque organisation, and there are reports of staff being frightened about showing the true extent of what is going on. What do you think about that? Does that concern you? Is that culture within the organisation something you would be looking to change or alter?
Lisa Tennant: I have not studied the FOI figures—again, I am very happy to come back on that in due course—but the trend in all public sector organisations is for more and more FOIs, which puts a huge burden on the organisations to deal with them. Rightly, the public expect transparency, and transparency will be a key goal for the board.
To fully win that public trust, the agency needs to be transparent on its data. It needs to share the data early and in an understandable format. Going back to what I said about clear communications, the public need to be able to understand the data they have access to. I will certainly be encouraging that culture of transparency, as I have done on the other boards I have chaired. For example, one of the values of the NHS pension board is giving transparency to members on their pensions.
Lisa Tennant: I am encouraged to see that self-monitoring is reducing and being phased out, and I think the EA has a key role in that monitoring. As you know, inspections have gone up, with 3,000 breaches reported over the last year. For me, one of the key things that I think the board also needs to look at is announced and unannounced inspections, and I would like to see an uptick in unannounced inspections. That is an area that can give the public a lot more clarity on performance.
Lisa Tennant: I have a couple of things on that. If I go back to my ministerial review of the McCloud remedy, part of that was understanding compliance within the pension scheme and the pension administrator. There is something similar for me here in understanding where compliance currently sits. I am not familiar with the issues that you have raised around that, but I would certainly want to be looking into that. For me, the board perspective is about quality and quality assurance.
I would expect the board to look at that as a whole, but there is a role for the audit committee in understanding that compliance and assurance around quality. For me, trust is about being open and visible. It is also about being firm, which we discussed in terms of penalties and enforcement. Also, there is something about agencies admitting mistakes when mistakes have happened and owning up to that. That is part of building trust by being open, visible and firm.
Lisa Tennant: I would say that is where the approach needs to be risk-based and targeted. No agency can do everything, and no agency has unlimited resources. It is about understanding where those resources need to be deployed to the greatest effect to address risks.
Lisa Tennant: This was one of the key areas that the board looked at in terms of compliance. I go back to my comments on the audit committee overseeing that compliance and quality. We have board champions who look at compliance data. I have seen improvements on my watch, certainly in terms of compliance. As I said, we have doubled our performance on penalties. One of the key things I have done as chair is to build on that openness and transparency, both with the public and between the executive and the board. I have done a lot of work around that over the past few years, and I am assured that compliance is now where it needs to be.
Lisa Tennant: My latest briefing said that the public register has been restored and is fully working.
Julia Buckley: That is breaking news.
Lisa Tennant: I will go back and check with my executive and let you know if that is the case. My understanding is that it has now been fully restored. I do not know if the Committee is aware of how catastrophic the cyber-attack was. I came in after it happened to help restore confidence around that. It was really devastating for the organisation. It has taken time to rebuild the register and rebuild confidence around that. I am assured that we have now made positive progress. My philosophy has always been not just to rebuild, but to build something better for the future.
Julia Buckley: That’s great. Perhaps the lessons learned can be fed through. Of course, we are in an age of increasing cyber-attacks on all our agencies.
Lisa Tennant: I think that one of the ways we can deal with this issue is through the responsible use of AI within the agency and our Government organisations. This goes back to the conversation on risk and risk aversion. I think the agency will have to take an innovative approach towards the use of AI. We have started to do that in SEPA. I do not want us to be in a position where we are answering every FOI request with our own AI, but I think there is a role for AI in some of the less complex work. It would still need to be checked by a human, but that could speed up some of the process.
Lisa Tennant: Going back to clear communication, it is always good to communicate clearly around the issues. How much effect that would have, I am not sure. It is a double-edged sword. AI is an enabler that allows people to exercise their right to transparency and their right to make a complaint. I am supportive of that, as I think it helps the public. I understand that it places more of a burden on organisations, but I would say that the appropriate use of AI and technology to deal with that burden should improve processes.
Chair: We will now move on to some questions on inspections. I remind everyone that we will shortly pause for the two-minute silence. Sarah and Sojan are leading this section.
Lisa Tennant: I think so. Again, this is an area for me to understand more about, and I am happy to come back on it once I do. The key to this is that risk-based approach. Understanding those risks is the difficult part, and it is for the board to work on understanding that risk-based approach before it can hold to account on that. I understand that the public are frustrated with some of this. We have gone through the stats, and inspections have gone up and are finding more breaches, but it is something I want to understand more in the role. It is definitely one of the priorities.
Lisa Tennant: I watched “Dirty Business” at the weekend with my children, and it was quite a difficult watch. For me, the key thing with the water companies is investment, monitoring and enforcement. We need to be sure that the investment plans are in place and are being actioned; again, it is that risk-based approach. Is the money being spent in the right area to give the greatest effect, appreciating that the effects will take years, not just months? The phasing out of self-monitoring is welcome and, again, I think having more unannounced inspections will be helpful, as will understanding the balance of those. Enforcement is key, and we need to have stiff penalties where regulations are broken.
Sarah Gibson: Coming in fresh to the Environment Agency, is there an opportunity for you to encourage more joined-up thinking so that, where you detect an issue and a breach, rather than asking the water company alone to deal with the problem at the end of the stream, as it were, you can use your role to encourage other stakeholders?
Chair: Sarah, I am going to pause you there.
The Committee observed a two-minute silence.
On resuming—
Chair: We are recommencing this joint session of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee and the Environmental Audit Committee on a pre-appointment hearing for the chair of the Environment Agency. Sarah, could you repeat your question from where we left off?
Lisa Tennant: I am very supportive of that collaborative working process. We spoke before about culture change, and sometimes some culture change is needed to develop that collaborative approach. I will not know whether that is the case here until I am in the role and I know more about it, but I certainly would encourage that collaboration. For me, the structure is less important; what is more important are the outcomes that are being delivered across a partnership. We know that rivers are in catchment areas, and that is why partnership working is so good for those.
To give another example from SEPA, we did a pilot on something called outcomes-based collaborative regulation, which was a pilot of a new form of regulation. We did that in Grangemouth, which you will know is an area of heavy industry, with loss of jobs and questions about local people’s wellbeing and nature recovery, so it is much wider than the SEPA’s remit in terms of regulation. The pilot was fantastic; I visited the site on the ground. The involvement of all the partners—local authority, NHS and local community groups—really helped us to devise an approach to regulation there that was based on those outcomes and the partnership working that you are talking about. That definitely delivers more benefits to the local area. I would say that it can be more resource-intensive and it can make a process take longer, so I think back to the balancing act of this potentially being an approach that we take as a pilot and that we take in certain places where we understand the delivery models around that.
The EFRA Committee has called for clearer standards for inspections, setting out how often and how thoroughly assets and companies should be audited. Will you explore that?
Lisa Tennant: Yes. It is one of the areas I will find out more about as I take on the role. Certainly, having that clear framework around inspections, their frequency and the publishing of data goes back to being open, visible and firm to enable trust from the public. I am very supportive of that approach, and I can find out more about it and come back in due course.
Some enforcement work, particularly for waste crime, involves working with other organisations such as the police and local authorities. Can you explain how much experience you have with working with a multi-organisation approach to enforcement? What would you do in a situation like Hoads Wood? What would your reaction be?
Lisa Tennant: This goes back to my priority around “clean”, “safe” and “grow”. For me, a big issue for “clean” is waste crime, and it will obviously be a focus for the board going forward. In terms of my experience around that, SEPA has worked in partnership quite successfully on waste crime in Scotland. We work in partnership with HMRC and the police on organised crime, which is obviously a large part of waste crime.
We have developed advanced technology, which I think the EA is using. I would be interested to find out more about the effect of that and whether we can improve it. On drones for monitoring and satellite imagery for early detection, I think one of the key things is the early detection you alluded to on Hoads Wood. The earlier we can detect the issues, the quicker we can move to enforce against them. I will be looking at it as a key priority.
I think people found it quite extraordinary that that scale of illegal waste dumping could go on for six months and the Environment Agency did not even step in and lock a gate until so much damage was done. From what you have seen, do you think that was a clear failure by the agency?
Lisa Tennant: I was not here at that point—
Lisa Tennant: I cannot change the past, but I can change the approach going forward. I would say that one of the key things for me, which I did not mention in answer to the previous question, is also the inputs. Areas such as digital waste tracking will help to reduce the inputs here. I go back to my points about early detection: it is key and it will be a priority for the board and for me. I want to understand where we currently are with this situation, how we can prevent it and how we can get that early intervention in.
Lisa Tennant: I would want to understand more about that and come back to the Committee. I do not understand the intricacies of the situation and the legalities around it. There may have been reasons why it took six months that I am not aware of.
Lisa Tennant: Yes.
Lisa Tennant: Again, I think it is very important that the Environment Agency is visible, particularly in communities. I would want to understand more about how that is happening, if there are any failures. I am happy to write back to the Committee on those. I am not aware of that particular case, so I am happy to pick that up in writing, but visibility is important. It is important in ensuring that communities feel a sense of trust, and it acts as a deterrent.
Lisa Tennant: It is a very complicated landscape. For example, with flooding, I am not sure that people in an emergency want to be looking up an organisational chart to work out who to call about the flood. I think there is work to be done there. Going back to clarity of communication, I think it should be very simple to know who to call and what people are responsible for. I want to make sure that those messages are very clear. I think social media has a role to play in that. Reaching people in the medium that they are used to using will be key for the EA in publicising that.
Lisa Tennant: My initial reaction was empathy for the parents of Heather Preen. It is a difficult programme to watch with your children who are the same age as the person affected in the film. It gave me a greater understanding of why the public is so angry about these issues. As I said, one of my priorities is to ensure clean water. That is not an overnight job, but it is very high up my agenda. That is about investment in water companies, monitoring, being transparent about the information that comes forward, and accountability.
Lisa Tennant: I think improvements have been made since it came out. We talked earlier about the 10,000 inspections and 3,000 breaches identified. I am confident that the EA is on an improving trajectory, but I accept that there is still work to be done.
Chair: Josh will now lead questions on farming.
Lisa Tennant: At the wider level, SEPA has forums as part of our stakeholder engagement strategy. We have a close working relationship with the NFU and other farming bodies. Our chief executive recently spent two days at the Royal Highland Show, talking with and meeting farmers and representatives of the NFU. A few months ago, we took our board on a visit to a local farm for the day. I think that was very well received on both sides. It gave small local farmers the chance to interact with the board of SEPA and talk about the issues that they are facing. We got to see some projects on the ground, where we saw success in joint working.
That kind of real-life relationship engagement is really important. Most farms are small businesses. There are 100,000 of them across England, covering 70% of the land area. It is a huge population. I am quite encouraged by the EA’s relationship managers and their regional efforts to go out and meet farmers. I support that advice-first approach to working with farmers.
Lisa Tennant: The key issues for farmers, as ever, are constrained budgets—like everyone else—and the predictability and simplification of regulation. Our simplification of that has helped farmers. We take that advice-first approach in Scotland, too, and I think that that is appreciated. It is a challenging place for farmers and for the country in terms of food security. I take those issues seriously.
Lisa Tennant: My understanding is that the law around the EA allows the EA only to permit on pig and poultry intensive farming, but that there may be a move towards the regulation of beef and dairy through permitting. I would support that.
Lisa Tennant: I definitely think that both can exist. Part of being a modern regulator is moving beyond a carrot and stick approach to an approach in which we can be a collaborative partner, but one that is always alive to the risk of regulatory capture.
Lisa Tennant: For me, this goes back to the example I gave about the whisky industry. If it is very clearly to the benefit of the environment for a change in policy or regulation to come about, I will support it. Obviously, we need to look at more winter storage, and farmers have a part to play in that. Across the wider water-sharing catchment approach that I would like to see taken, that is a positive move.
Lisa Tennant: I think so, and that is something I have certainly encouraged at SEPA. We always want to make sure that we are fully compliant and are protecting the environment, and that is the No. 1 goal, but where we can enable these partnership-working approaches, I am very supportive of them. I am happy to look at that.
Chair: Do any other Members have questions on farming? No. In that case, we move to Jonathan, who will lead questioning on air pollution.
Lisa Tennant: The EA has a key role to play on air pollution, which comes under one of my three priorities for “clean”—clean water and clean air. I am saddened to see the figures around air pollution and the deaths related to it. Figures have been improving since the 1970s, and air quality has been improving. Where the EA has the remit for larger industrial emissions, I will be interested to find out more in due course about our performance in that area and to ensure that it is where it needs to be.
Again, for me, air pollution is an area of partnership working—working with local councils, which have responsibility for local air quality and road emissions, and with other partners to understand it. It is such a complex issue, and I feel that we cannot see air pollution in the way that we can sometimes see water pollution. I think it is an area that needs to be higher up the agenda, and I certainly want the board to be looking at air pollution as a key part of that clean strategy.
Lisa Tennant: That is again an approach that we have taken through partnership working. I think that we need to improve the science and regulation around fine particulates, and to be working on research to really understand their effects and to measure them clearly. I am happy to write to the Committee with further detail on the work that we have undertaken in Scotland, if that is useful.
Lisa Tennant: I do not have that information to hand, but I am very happy to write with it.
Lisa Tennant: In anything that furthers partnership working, particularly with local councils, I do see a role for the EA. I think it has been performing well on the planning advice that it gives to local councils, and if that can incorporate more around air pollution, we should be able to prevent more of it in the future.
Lisa Tennant: It always is a question of balancing responsibilities. For me, PFAS come under one of those three priorities: “clean”. We still need to understand more about PFAS. For me, in the EA, it is not just about monitoring; it is also about being that centre of research. The evidence base around PFAS still needs to be built up. I would be interested to visit sites. I know that many PFAS come from earlier industrial sites around aviation and firefighting, and I would like to make a regional visit to understand more about that and how they affect the local area. I definitely think there is a role for the EA in enforcement around PFAS.
Lisa Tennant: Once I start, I would like to understand more about where the staffing is being allocated. That is something that I did with the board at SEPA: looking at the staffing across the whole organisation, where staff are being allocated and how that lines up with the strategic priorities that the board has agreed with the executive. Sometimes there are areas where that is not quite lining up. Going back to that risk-based approach to priorities, I would want the board to look at whether we are actually deploying staff in the areas that we need to in order to deliver on those priorities. Understanding more about that will be key.
Lisa Tennant: I understand that there is now more of a lead regulator approach on some projects. I think that has merits. I have spoken a bit about the partnership working that I have undertaken at SEPA and chairing the public service reform chairs group and hearing that perspective from other chairs across other sectors has been really helpful. Again, I would hope that the EA could take leadership in that role around PFAS, but also in collaborating with others around it.
Lisa Tennant: Again, it is understanding more about that issue. I think that we cannot say that we need more research before we take action. We need to be taking action on what we do know in the meantime in the ways that I have spoken about while we are undertaking further research. We should not delay because of that. At SEPA we have worked very closely with European partners and the heads of the other agencies that we meet with frequently, and we take on that best practice from around the world. Sometimes we are delivering the best practice and sometimes we are learning about it from other people. Those strong international relationships are important and key.
Lisa Tennant: I would say that the climate is subject to increasing volatility, and the pace of change has outpaced the management of risks in this area. It is a key role for the EA and it comes under my heading of “safe”—keeping people safe from drought and flooding is really important. I think that the EA has been improving its work in this area. Again, for me, this is about a risk-based approach to the deployment of resources and asking what areas are most at risk from flooding and drought and deploying and making sure that the resources are being put to best use in those areas.
Lisa Tennant: One of the things that we have to be is realistic about that. Again, this goes back to clear communication with the public and partnership working with others. The risks are increasing and I do not think that the resources to deliver against those risks will be able to increase at the same level. For me, the answer to that is clear prioritisation based on evidence and data.
Lisa Tennant: This is something that we did a lot of work on at SEPA. Historically, what has happened within environment agencies is that people who work in the agency have become, if you like, emergency responders, in their spare time or as part of their role. I think that with these increasing risks that we have identified, what we need to do is professionalise that emergency response. The EA is a category 1 responder, and it needs to be set up as a category 1 responder to be able to handle those responses. I know that work is under way to accomplish that, just as it is at SEPA. I am encouraging that work at pace to be able to deliver that emergency response. Going back to clear communications, there should be a clear port of call in one of those emergency situations and someone leading on that response to ensure co-ordination across all the agencies.
Lisa Tennant: I am a big supporter of nature-based solutions and their being deployed where it is practical to do so. I think we need to look at the evidence base carefully for where those evidence-based solutions work best. They do not work everywhere, but I think where we can deploy them, we should.
Lisa Tennant: You know, I am not even going to answer with an endangered species, because I do not think that it is an endangered species, but what I miss seeing is buddleia bushes covered in butterflies. That is one of the things I remember from my childhood, even in areas of environmental degradation—on those former industrial sites or along a railway, buddleia was growing everywhere and it was just covered in butterflies and moths. It was a real joy to watch them and I cannot remember the last time I went on a hike and saw the buddleia bushes covered in butterflies and moths. It is not a particularly glamourous endangered species, but it is one of those things that I often notice.
Lisa Tennant: It is not something I have prepared for the Committee, but I am certainly happy to look at it. It is frustrating when we have these issues where it is not clear where they sit, as I said about the reservoirs issue in Scotland. I have a business in Argyll, near the Rest and Be Thankful pass, on the A82, where there are regular landslides, so I understand the impact that has on rural communities. When there is a landslide there, that road is closed and there is no way round, so I understand the seriousness of the issue and I am very happy to look into it.
Lisa Tennant: My personal reflection would be to go back to my children. The question of what kind of world there will be for them to inherit is one of the motivations for the work that I do. My take on it is that variability is increasing, unpredictability is increasing and volatility is going up. I think that there is a human tendency to think that that will last for a period then things will settle down or go back to how they were. I believe that this volatility in climate will carry on now. What I have said that I personally believe is that nature is just as important as climate, and nature recovery and biodiversity recovery are a key priority for the Environment Agency, too.
Chair: I am looking to see whether colleagues have any last-minute questions, and they do not, so thank you, Lisa, for your time and attention to the Committees this morning.