Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee
Oral evidence: Work of the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, HC 48
Wednesday 11 November 2026
Ordered by the House of Commons to be published on 11 November 2026.
Members present: Ms Abena Oppong-Asare (Chair); Sagal Abdi-Wali; Mr Jonathan Brash; Lewis Cocking; Andrew Cooper; Chris Curtis; Ashley Dalton; Mr Lee Dillon; Mr Will Forster; Mr Gagan Mohindra; and Alan Strickland.
Questions 1 to 65
Witnesses
I: Rt Hon Angela Rayner MP, Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government; and Tom Riordan, Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government.
Examination of witnesses
Witnesses: Angela Rayner MP and Tom Riordan.
Tom Riordan: It is week six.
Chair: Week six—you’re an expert. I ask Committee members to introduce themselves.
Mr Mohindra: I am Gagan Mohindra, the MP for South West Hertfordshire.
Lewis Cocking: Lewis Cocking, the Member of Parliament for Broxbourne.
Mr Brash: Jonathan Brash, the MP for Hartlepool.
Mr Dillon: Lee Dillon, the Member of Parliament for Newbury.
Mr Forster: Will Forster, the MP for Woking.
Alan Strickland: Alan Strickland, the MP for Newton Aycliffe and Spennymoor.
Chris Curtis: I am Chris Curtis, the MP for Milton Keynes North.
Sagal Abdi-Wali: Sagal Abdi-Wali, the MP for Holborn and St Pancras.
Ashley Dalton: Ashley Dalton, the MP for West Lancashire.
Andrew Cooper: Andrew Cooper, the Member of Parliament for Mid Cheshire.
Chair: We have a series of questions. I will ask you to be very brief in your answers. I may interrupt you at times, but it is nothing personal; it is just that we have a lot of questions to get through and we are keen to get the most out of this session so we address the issues in your portfolio.
As you know, today is 11 November. We will be pausing to remember and observe the two-minute silence.
I will kick off the questions. One of the commitments that you made when you first became Housing Secretary when we came into government was about the 1.5 million target. You have indicated that it is unlikely that the Government will be able to meet that target by the next general election. On Tuesday next week, I have seen that you are convening your first national housing delivery board, which will essentially examine regulations, standards and the planning framework, and will look at other challenges in terms of construction’s efforts. What is now your realistic target? Why have there been delays in meeting the agreed target?
Angela Rayner: I refer to my first part of the role as album 1, and this is album 2—to make it easier for people. In album 1, when we created the target of 1.5 million homes, the situation was that the media were particularly saying that it was impossible and we could not do it, so we knew it was a difficult target then. In album 2—since I have returned—we obviously now have the war in the middle east that has increased costs, so construction costs have gone up by 40%, and the cost of living is having an effect on people’s finances.
There have been challenges in meeting that target, but I am not giving up on it. I refuse to admit defeat on it. I think it is important to continue to do the work. You referenced the national housing delivery board, which I will be chairing next week. That is about bringing the sector together to look at what more we can do.
We have built 437,900 homes since we came to power. New starts are up by, I think, 20% compared with the last year. We always knew that the changes would take time to come in. The biggest wave of social and affordable housing investment that we have put in, which is £14 billion[1], the changes to the national planning policy framework, and the housing Bills that we have going through Parliament are all the measures through which we are trying to ensure that the delivery ramps up and is sustainable beyond this Parliament and into the next.
Angela Rayner: You invite me to concede defeat on the 1.5 million homes target. I refuse to. I am realistic about the challenges we face in meeting it. You refer to exceeding the target of additional planning officers, which will support and help what we are doing.
The changes to mandatory housing plans—the local plans—will help to deliver on the housing we need. Again, I think the additional money that the Chancellor announced at the Budget as part of the affordable homes programme will help. The changes that we are making through right to buy will hopefully ensure that councils keep 100% of their receipts, so they will be able to retain council housing stock and therefore build more. We have also extended low-cost loans so that people can apply for them.
There are a number of changes, including bringing the sector together with the national housing delivery board, which I am putting in place not only to continue what we started in album 1, but to recognise in album 2 the difficult financial and economic global situation that we find ourselves in, and to work with the sector to deliver the homes that we need. I do not accept that I need to readdress that target.
I know it is a challenge. I know that people will come to me at the end of this Parliament and say, “You haven’t met that target,” if I don’t meet it. I am determined to do everything that I possibly can to meet that target, and I think that is reflected in the work that my Department is doing, because we have over a million people on social housing waiting lists in this country and we have a housing crisis. I refuse to temper my expectations. I am incredibly pleased with the Government, my Department and other Departments that are working at pace to continue to try to meet that target.
Does that reflect a change of policy in the Government, shifting more towards council house building rather than delivery through housing associations? If so, how do you expect that that will affect the share of allocations through the remaining years of the social and affordable homes programme, as they might be split between councils and housing associations?
Angela Rayner: That is a very good question, Andrew. I think you touch on the competing nature of having a council house building revolution, which the Government wanted to do right from the start, as album 1. When I campaigned for a Labour Government, I was very clear that we want more council housing. That is why, in album 1, we took a lot of decisions that meant councils could start to rebuild and we could increase the capacity.
Notwithstanding that, in album 2—as you will have seen—one of the first decisions I made was to get the social and affordable housing £10 billion grant out of the door. That was tilted towards councils and housing associations. We recognise the valuable contribution that housing associations make to the housing stock, but we want a significant increase in council house building as part of the programme. I would not say that there has been a change of policy, but it has been tilted more heavily towards supporting councils in building the council homes that they need.
If we are tilting more towards councils for delivery, what assessment have you made of councils’ capacity to do that? A lot of councils did a stock transfer to housing associations in the 2000s and do not retain the kind of development capacity that they might previously have had. Is there a risk that we slow down social housing delivery if we tilt too much towards council housing?
Angela Rayner: That would be a risk, and that is why I have eliminated that risk. Of the allocations that were given to social housing from the £10 billion that I announced in album 2, a lot went to social housing providers. We recognise that social rents are the most crucial thing—we need more homes for social rent—and therefore, housing associations make a vital contribution.
You also touch on some of the challenges. Some councils—local authorities—have not been building council housing. We asked them about that. Some of it is because they do not have the capacity, and some of it is around the funding. Some of it was due to challenges from changes to right to buy because if the council built a house, the house went, so the council building more social homes was not cost-effective. That is why we have brought those changes forward.
Only 50% of councils currently have a housing revenue account. It is a challenge for other councils; we are working with them. We have increased the number of council homes that each local authority can build. From the feedback that we are getting in the Department, there is a lot of appetite out there and we have committed funds to help to build that capacity: I think it is £63 million through our capacity build programme to support councils in ramping up council house building.
I would not say that our programme for council house building is to the disadvantage of social housing providers, because actually, we are not building enough. We delivered over 10,572 homes last year, which was the biggest number since records began in the early 1990s, but we know that we need to ramp that up.
Chair: Sorry, Secretary of State, but I am going to have to stop you there, because we have quite a number of questions.
Angela Rayner: The Government have not made any announcement on plans to replace the current council tax system. The Chancellor is the person who would make announcements on that; he has not come forward with anything and we have just had a Budget. The Government are committed to the council system being fair for taxpayers and local authorities, and we will continue to keep taxes and all elements of the local government finance system under review.
We announced at the Budget that we are going to give people in council tax bands A to D £100 to help them with their energy costs, but the Chancellor does not currently have any role in changing the council tax system. We have made some changes, as you will know, when it comes to the higher bands and higher-value properties, but other than that no changes have been made.
Angela Rayner: Well, a few months ago, there was a different Prime Minister and a different Secretary of State. I am telling you, as the Secretary of State today, that I am not working on any plans at the moment to change the council tax system, other than what has already been announced and already been changed. We are obviously supporting people with the cost of living crisis, and that remains one of our key focuses as a Department and as a Government, as you will have seen from the announcements from the Chancellor. That is where we are at. I am not doing any work behind the scenes on council tax. I know this is an issue that keeps raising its head, but it is not something that I am currently focused on.
Angela Rayner: The biggest problem, and what I challenged and tried to fix, was the unfair local government funding system. Under the previous Government, the then Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak, once said that he was taking money away from the most deprived areas in local authorities and giving it to the more affluent areas—those were their words, not mine. When I came in, in album 1, I was really clear that we wanted to fund areas on the basis of need.
I recognise that local authorities went through a significant period of austerity under the previous Government. I declare an interest, as I was a Unison official who represented 200,000 public sector workers across the north-west—I started off with single redundancies and ended up doing hundreds of them—as councils like Hartlepool, and Tameside, my borough, lost significant amounts of their funding.
I refocused my efforts on to ensuring that there was a fair funding formula so that councils were funded to provide the services. In some areas, in the most deprived areas, council tax was going up by the highest amount allowed under the cap, whereas other areas were able to charge lower council tax because the funding formula—the baseline funding—was not fair.
Angela Rayner: I support areas being funded on the basis of need. I have raised this, and under the devolution agenda we are going to make sure that there is a fair system for business rates retention for areas that could not meet the other areas.
Look, I recognise that local government has been through hell and back over the last decade or so. If we want a devolution agenda, and if we want to put power back in people’s hands, local government is critical to that and needs fair funding. That is why I have given it additional money since I came into office. I recognised that it needed a single pot, so I looked at reducing the number of little stingy pots that people get, so that they could get the economy of scale. And I recognised that we needed to do more across the board, working across Government.
That is why you have seen No. 10 North and the Cabinet Office working on a total place basis. It is so that the sum of our parts—there is the record investment going into Hartlepool, for example. It is a case of making sure that they all work and connect together, so that we can see Hartlepool, for the people of Hartlepool, as a distinct place, instead of each Department looking at it in separate silos. That is what we are trying to achieve.
I recognise the challenges of over a decade of areas being starved of the resources they need. That is what this Government agenda is about—giving those areas the power and the resources to make their decisions and to do well.
Tom Riordan: Chair, I will briefly—
Chair: We will be covering devolution soon. Is it related to that?
Tom Riordan: It is related to the question. There is £4 billion of extra grant funding, as the Secretary of State has said, in the multi-year settlement and 45% more funding per head for the top 10% most deprived areas. We estimate that, by the end of the multi-year settlement, nine out of 10 councils will have had their funding in relation to assessed relative need. So we are in the middle of a process of shifting towards what the Secretary of State has set out.
Angela Rayner: We are not. I think that is a disingenuous way—
Angela Rayner: Yes; that is a disingenuous way of looking at it. The previous Government removed mandatory housing plans; we have put them back in place. We have simplified the planning system: we have made it more objective rather than subjective.
Some of the most significant planning application decisions will obviously be made by councillors. But in relation to some small occurrences, planning officers will be able to make a decision on something that is relatively minor and that is an objective criterion under the local plan and the planning regulations. I think this strengthens the system, instead of having the patchwork that we get at the moment, and delivers on the housing that people want to see in their local area.
Angela Rayner: I have strengthened and clarified the powers, so that instead of them being subjective—this is about some of the minor planning applications that go through, are incorporated within the national planning framework and are deliverable. We are not talking about big schemes; we are talking about minor issues, where delegated planning powers will mean, through the objective nature of the planning rules, they would be able to go through and pass the criteria.
Angela Rayner: No, I disagree with that. I think I have made this more objective rather than subjective. I have made it more effective and efficient, and I have given councillors the opportunity to exercise their powers on planning applications that are significant for their area. We consulted on it. We looked at what other local authorities were doing and made sure that we had a consistent approach. I think that is right. Far too many people get frustrated by the fact that you get one decision over here that is completely at odds with another decision, on something that is really quite minor.
Angela Rayner: Again, I completely disagree. The wild west was under the previous Conservative Government, where there were no mandatory local plans, where there were speculative developments and where housing starts pretty much ground to a halt. We inherited a planning and housing crisis because of the previous Government’s decisions.
What I have done is created a clearer path for planning, so that people can make planning decisions. The Chair of the Select Committee mentioned that I announced that there would be 300 new planning officers. There are over 400 new planning officers now. They will work against the criteria for planning applications and ensure they are applied consistently and fairly. Any larger developments or other issues can be called in and decisions will be made by councillors.
Angela Rayner: I am happy to speak to them. If you take that tone with them, I can understand why they would be fearful of the changes. I am happy to speak to them and explain to them exactly what we are doing, which is not taking powers away but ensuring that there is planned housing with infrastructure.
Local councillors now have to have a mandatory local plan: ahead of any housing or development, they have to say where they think it should be, and that sets the criteria for any developers that think, “I want to embark on creating the homes and the infrastructure your local residents need.” They understand what the guardrails are, and it will go through the planning application process as normal and councillors will have input into that process. It is a more objective, rather than subjective, process.
Chair: Secretary of State—
Angela Rayner: Some councils—a very small number—have not adopted the new regime. The deadline was 31 October. I think that is regressive. The majority of councils have. To be really clear, those that have not have put themselves outside the regulations that Parliament set, and therefore they lose all the powers they could have to decide on applications. In fact, instead of helping local democracy, they have taken it away by having, I think, a political issue with the will of what this Government has set out. That is my view, and I am really clear on that.
It is a real shame, because, quite frankly, the Conservatives left us in a shocking state—a real shocking state—with housing. I have been trying to deliver. I have been really clear that we have to build the homes we need, and I have put very strict guardrails in place so that we do not get the speculative development that we often saw under the Conservatives.
Lewis Cocking: But we are getting—
Chair: I am going to have to stop you there. We are running out of time, so I am going to get very strict. Chris, over to you.
Angela Rayner: Thank you for your enthusiasm, Chris. I know you have enthusiasm for new towns, and my Minister for Housing has an equal level of enthusiasm. We embarked on the new towns programme knowing that it would not happen overnight. We are committed to supporting the programme; we want to see it up and coming, and it remains part of our overall plan, but it does take time to get a new town up and running. I will say that even in Greater Manchester we have had over 10,000 homes built in a particular area, so I would class that as a new town under my criteria.
Tom Riordan: Work is continuing on sites in places such as Leeds South Bank and Manchester Victoria North as well, so the work has not stopped.
Angela Rayner: I do not think so, but I do acknowledge the worry, which is a wider acknowledgement that in areas that do not have a combined authority or a mayoral approach, people think, “Well, where do we fit in?” I am sure that will come up in future questions, but I would say that that is not the case. We are encouraging local authorities to collaborate, especially around local plans, so that they can deliver the bigger sites and can look at new town proposals as well. We are not stopping them. Some sites were identified as part of the new towns taskforce as good areas to deliver a new town, but I would not say that is the limit of our ambition.
Angela Rayner: I think they can. It is hard for me to say what others will do, but we have put a number of different support programmes in place, so if an area says, “This is where we want to deliver a new town, and these are the challenges to delivering it,” then we are open to supporting and working with areas to deliver on their housing targets.
Compare that with what we have had, which is a process of over a year for drawing where the map was, and the second round of consultation still going on, in effect. We expected to hear back on the consultation in the summer, but we are now well into autumn, pretty quickly heading towards Christmas, and have not heard back. When will we hear back on that consultation? Are there any reflections on why this process is happening so much slower than previous iterations of the programme?
Tom Riordan: Early next year is the answer. There are strategic issues involved in putting in place the right plans and environmental assessments so that, once we get the green light to move forward, they can do so without interruption. That is what we are trying to make sure happens with the loop back around on the two reviews. Basically, early next year. The Government are determined to get spades in the ground on at least three new towns in this Parliament, and are prepared to progress work on a far larger range of locations if that proves possible.
Angela Rayner: The planning system has changed significantly since the 1960s. That is what some of our reforms are about: making it more objective rather than subjective, and a streamlined process, because planning is a complex area to navigate now, compared with when Attlee was around.
Chris Curtis: That is probably something we need fixing if we want to solve the housing crisis, isn’t it?
Angela Rayner: Which is what I have been embarking on.
Tom Riordan: I take “early next year” as not June—nearer to January than June, let’s say. The decisions have not been taken about the numbers. That is being assessed at the moment and that will be announced early in the new year.
Tom Riordan: That is the intention at the moment.
Angela Rayner: One of the things that we have been doing is making sure that the capital is there, alongside, for example, if infrastructure is needed. The changes to the Green Book, which I get all excited about—not many people do—were about recognising the challenges that areas face.
The challenges of increased construction costs and the affordability gap for people affect developers, who will only do supply if there is demand. The biggest demand that we see at the moment is actually in the social rent sector, but that takes up-front grant, which is a different model from the one that I inherited, which is about section 106, basically, for developers to give social housing and other infrastructure. It is really about the Government trying to give low-cost loans and streamline the planning system.
It has been about trying to challenge the cost of living crisis, and there has been this tilt towards the social rented sector for building homes, so we are filling in a bit of gap in what is starting to appear because of the global economic situation.
Angela Rayner: Again, I have the national housing board, which is meeting next week. That is about dealing with some of the challenges that we face. I would argue that the Government have already taken significant steps towards supporting the viability of house building. Many developers will complain to me that some of this is around the delays and challenges that they face in actually getting spades in the ground. We have invested money in our new homes accelerator, where there have been stalled sites, so that we can invest in understanding why they have stalled and deliver those homes. We have seen results as part of that programme as well.
Tom Riordan: There is the work on Your First Home to try to help with the demand from first-time buyers. There is work to get local plans in place so you get that consistency. Viability is also linked to what people bought land for, and corrections are happening in the economic cycle on that.
But the statistics that the Secretary of State mentioned at the start of the session—on the starts increasing—are good examples of why we think things are correcting. Quite a lot was done on viability in some parts of the country, in terms of city-centre development and densification, that was announced earlier in the year, and the planning related to train stations is another example of where we are trying to work to get the system moving again.
Angela Rayner: A bit brutal.
Mr Mohindra: I meant that in a nice way. Mr Riordan, given your significant background in local government, in your professional opinion what percentage chance do the Government have of delivering the 1.5 million homes?
Tom Riordan: It would be hard to put a percentage on it. My view is that one of the biggest problems we have had in the country has been changing our mind on whether it is about infrastructure projects or targets.
The best thing you could do when trying to build houses in a big city, as I was trying to do with members and the private sector, was to get a plan in place and be really consistent with the plan in terms of decision making, unless there were very exceptional cases where you could not, and then line up consistency and reliability of delivery, including getting multidisciplinary teams in the council to make sure that we were crunching through problem sites.
Tom Riordan: The number of 437,900 homes is a big one for development so far, so I think a lot of really good work is happening across the country. It is all about getting a plan in place, executing it and getting confidence from the private sector that you are going to be consistent. Large parts of the country are doing that but not quite at the level that we want, in terms of the ambition of the target, which was always really stretching.
We have to keep going, as the Secretary of State said. We have £40 billion committed for social and affordable housing. We have work on the £4.7 million for Your First Home. We have to work together on that, and that is what the meeting that the Secretary of State will have will be about.
Tom Riordan: I think it would be negative for the overall ambition if we were to change that target at this point, which the Secretary of State has said. The best thing that the Committee can do, I think, is work with local areas, maybe around the country, to assess how things are going and where real progress has been made and why, because there are examples of that. We built 30,000 homes in Leeds with a really stretching target that many members did not think we would hit and we ended up hitting—sorry, I still say “we”. The thousandth council house has just been built there. It can be done, but it is how you do it across large parts of the country with the different geographies and the different challenges in places like London, the home counties and the north.
Angela Rayner: We have focused on making sure that, on sites where there is planning permission and they have not started, the new homes accelerator and the reforms that we have made have been looking at that. I have not decided one thing over here; we have made a number of significant changes, and that is why we said that house building would ramp up. We inherited a very low bar, so we knew we had to ramp it up.
The 437,900 homes that have been built is a really good indicator. The Government publishes stats on how many net additional homes have been delivered—that has been happening for 24 years—so that is a good marker to hold us to account on what we are doing on that. But there is not just one lever. It is not like, “Oh, you’ve chosen to do this. Why haven’t you done that?” We are doing all those things.
We are pulling every lever we possibly can to support the ambitious programme that we set ourselves. What I am acknowledging is that it was a stretch target and there have been global shocks—a 40% increase in construction costs—that have had an impact on people’s ability to buy and on developer confidence to build. That is why we got the money out the door very quickly on the social and affordable homes program in album 2, and that is why we have been taking those measures at pace to get those houses built.
Chair: I am going to have to stop you, Secretary of State, and pass over to Alan.
In July, the Government announced that No. 10 North would take responsibility for local economic growth and devolution strategy, and some functions would stay with you and your Department. These are obviously crucial cross-cutting agendas across Government. Could you clarify for the Committee who in Government is now leading those agendas?
Angela Rayner: It is really exciting, actually, because it has given us more clout on some of the things that in album 1 I was really eager to do, like devolution and the cross-cutting Government work that I tried to do when I was Deputy Prime Minister.
Having No. 10 North there setting the overarching strategy and convening Government, alongside the First Secretary of State in her Department, means that you have these big offices of state with the weight of the Prime Minister really pushing the agenda forward. No. 10 has responsibilities for the strategic direction, but, as you will have seen, whether it is through the devolution Bill or “Rewiring the state”, myself and Lou Haigh work within our Departments to deliver that through our departmental obligations.
Angela Rayner: Ultimately, the devolution agenda sits within my Department. My Minister is convening alongside Lou’s Minister in her Department, working on the devolution agenda. If there was any controversy or anything like that, then it would ultimately be the Prime Minister or the National Economic Council that would make the determination, but I would strongly suggest that that is just not the way we work.
We want to problem-solve and find solutions. How I have seen it operating so far is as something really helpful in cutting across Departments. Sometimes it is really difficult to get Departments to see a priority. When No. 10 North—the Prime Minister, basically—is saying, “We want this to happen”, you can convene Ministers from other Departments and get a successful outcome.
Angela Rayner: My Department, alongside Lou, has been working on the high street strategy in Total Place; we talked about Total Place before. In album 1, I talked about the new deal for communities, which has a similar theme of seeing it as a place-based issue.
Rather than the Department of Health and Social Care coming in and doing something here and the Department for Education doing it, we know that we can usually identify where the challenges of troubled families and organised crime are on a place-based approach and work across all those Departments to see where the hotspots are and deal with those issues. You have seen that through the high street strategy and you will see it through the work that Lou has been doing on Total Place and the powers that we gave as part of the high street strategy on cracking down on shops that are basically fronts for illegal activity.
Applicants’ personal circumstances and how they are funding development are not relevant to planning and cannot be taken into account. The law does not require people to give their full name and date of birth. Agents working for applicants do not have to give details like that to local authorities and no due diligence is undertaken on sources of funds. That means that serious and organised crime gangs are making planning applications across the region for land they do not own—you do not need to own land to do that—then intimidating landowners to let them build stuff. They are building homes, some of which are inappropriately used as HMOs. Some of the land is used for enviro-crime.
You take the point, Secretary of State—this land is being used for all manner of things that are causing issues across Government. What police forces in the region tell us, which is replicated across the country, is that a lot of these issues are caused by very basic things in the planning system that could be changed. Are you aware of those issues and what action might you be able to take?
Angela Rayner: There is some enforcement and there are some ways, whether it is on covenants, other restrictions or other elements of the planning system. Anyone can put a planning application in. I know that can be quite challenging. We have been looking in particular at Traveller sites and issues around the weekend, which members of the Committee have raised before. We have been convening a group on that. That is one of the reasons we were so insistent on having up-to-date local plans. That means that you have a way of challenging some of the issues that are faced through the planning process.
We keep under review what we can do to support that process, but at the moment we think we are tackling the issues and challenges that people face. We recognise that there are always people who will try to circumvent the planning system, but we are trying to get a balance between ensuring that planning applications go through the local planning system and that there is local accountability for that alongside our obligations as a Department.
Tom Riordan: I encourage police forces to work very closely with local planning authorities if they have concerns; I am sure they do that. Applicants are already required to provide details of owners of land affected by development proposals. It is an offence for them to provide false information knowingly or recklessly under section 65 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
Obviously on the enforcement side, once things have been agreed, local planning authorities need to make sure there is good co-ordination and communication between local police forces and planning teams. As the Secretary of State said, we are keeping this under review, but at the end of the day it is for the local system to make sure that it is vigilant and doing what is needed. If there is criminality, it needs to be sent straight to the police to look at.
I suppose the challenge we have got is that the current tools make it very difficult for councils and police forces to put a stop to some of these developments. Then you have weak planning enforcement because of resource and other issues, once it is built it is hard to deal with and when it goes to the Planning Inspectorate they say, “Well, it meets the local plan. How it was funded is none of our business.” I think that is the challenge, Tom.
Tom Riordan: Sure. As I say, the system at the moment is designed so the planning system regulates the use of land. It is a long-standing principle that planning permission is granted on the merits of development proposals, not who the applicant is. That is at the basis of the whole planning system for the country. It purposefully entitles anyone to apply.
However, we recognise that there are opportunities where criminals sometimes seek to exploit the planning system. That is why local planning authorities already have a robust set of planning enforcement powers and why we need them to work closely with the police. It is why, if there is proof of those things, it needs to be passed through and looked at. It is an area we will always look at, and we will consider concerns that are put forward.
Angela Rayner: Sure, and just to acknowledge, I do know that. As I said, many members of the Committee have raised that. You are absolutely right. People get very angry when it looks like people who are doing illegal activities or trying to get around the rules—because that is in effect what they try to do—get away with it.
I have set up a group to look at some of these issues and see what more we can do on the planning side, working with agencies such as the police. Quite frankly, we do not want to give a message that the Government are soft on crime and on people who want to cause trouble in local communities. I have full sympathy for people who see things like this rock up on a Friday evening or a bank holiday. People think they will get away with it—not on my watch. It is in my sphere of influence and I understand the frustrations. I am happy to look at whatever we can do.
It is difficult because it is like Whack-a-Mole; you try to fix it in one place, and they will come up with something else. You have to have a balance between genuinely enabling planning to happen and dealing with the people who try to get around the rules.
Alan Strickland: It would be good to work with you on that.
Chair: I did not know about the group; it is really good that you have set up a group on that.
Angela Rayner: I will start and then let Tom come in. In album 2 when I came in, I had days to make a decision on significant local government reforms that were in the courts. I had not had the opportunity to read all of the submissions and applications, and I felt very strongly, as the Secretary of State who was going to make that decision, that I needed time to review them. Therefore, I pulled those decisions, and I think it was the right thing to do.
I acknowledge the pain and frustration that that caused people, but if I am going to make a decision I should read it and ensure I have given due respect to the councillors and local areas and ensure I have understood the issues, why people were in court over them, and what the issues were. I am confident that we are reviewing that process. We have gone through Parliament now. We have enabled some areas to go forward. We have said that in other areas we need a bit more time to do that, but I am confident that at the end of that process we will have a more robust decision-making process to allow us to go forward.
I acknowledge the frustration that that has created for some people during that process, but I do think it will leave us in a more sustainable position for the local authorities to deliver at scale for their local communities. That is why I am committed to local government reform.
Tom Riordan: In my second album, I was in a situation where we were trying to get agreement around geographies that did not quite work between a two-tier area and a single-tier area in Leeds and West Yorkshire and then North Yorkshire. Eventually we came to an agreement that we just had to move forward. There were examples in the latest Budget announcement where there are parts of the country that have done that as well. They have been in disagreement, but they have seen the size of the prize in terms of fiscal devolution and the powers that are there.
All I can say is: is this the right thing? I ran a unitary authority with the three very good leaders that I had for 14 years. If you take waste collection and waste disposal, the fact that we controlled both of those meant that we could build an energy-from-waste plant, put a district heating system into our city, save money for some of the poorest people in the city, and get economic development happening. We could never have done that in a two-tier system.
On having housing and social care together, when you deal with people who are at risk of homelessness you can put the two together. You can get the teams working. With the co-terminosity of the NHS that we had in Leeds—one hospital trust, one mental health trust, one council—we were able to work in a much more coherent way. So I think that unitarisation is the right thing.
Finally, at the regional level, when inward investors were coming in and wanting to relocate, they would want to talk about skills, transport and grants—all those things. When I was in Leeds we were at a national level. Now, with the mayoral authorities, it is all in the mayoral area. You can do it together with a combined authority. So I think, like I said, given the size of the prize, it is the right thing to do at both levels. We can reach consensus where there is disagreement. We just have to keep going. We are 90% of the way there now with the announcements made at the Budget. We just need to get that further 10%.
Tom Riordan: Scrutiny is absolutely a fundamental part of the new arrangement. That is in place in the mayoral strategic authorities that have been set up. As constituent members, the local authorities are on the decision-making body with the mayor who will be taking decisions. You cannot rubber-stamp through that system as a mayor. The mayor has to take things through that system in a way that will work effectively.
Again, I have been in a system where there are opposition members on a different controlled body, and that, I think, is a good discipline in its own right. Other issues have been looked at in terms of local accountability and strengthening that with the fiscal devolution that is coming. On measurement and inequality, that is one thing, with the fair funding formula and the 45% change, that has been made to skew that more towards the 10% most deprived areas and is in place. It will be up to local systems to take those decisions—that is what devolution is all about—but the Government have already moved in that direction.
Angela Rayner: Yes. I do not know if you saw this, but Jim McMahon, the Minister, also responded to questions around considering options to strengthen district council involvement working closely with upper-tier authorities. That would include non-constituent membership, voting rights on certain matters and committee membership. Again, that is recognising that some people wanted their voices included but felt that they would be drowned out through that process.
Angela Rayner: Unfortunately, I lost that amendment on the veto powers in the Lords.
Angela Rayner: At the moment, the Prime Minister is really committed to the carrot rather than the stick. We have shown that through the powers and investment, and those that have not gone forward are unfortunately not getting that investment. I was really frustrated by that because to get the Chancellor to commit that level of funding for this shows its importance for local areas. It would have given them more money—a huge amount of investment into their local areas—and powers to really drive their local growth.
For me, as Secretary of State, I found that frustrating, and I think they have to answer to why they are not allowing that investment to flow into their area. But I think that, considering where we got to in terms of the devolution Bill and where we are now, there has been a carrot approach of, “Look, if you go for a strategic authority, you get these powers and this investment. If you go for a mayoral model, you get that on an even bigger scale.”
As a Greater Manchester MP, I would argue that as one of the first to be a mayoral model under the Conservatives, we have seen our fastest growth because we have those powers and it has been a good thing. So it is a rare bit of unity that the devolution agenda in my area—while it has its challenges, of course; we have town and city centres and rural areas that are very different—has created that empowerment and resources for local leaders to work collaboratively to do what is best for our local areas.
Tom Riordan: Last year, I was involved a piece of work about northern growth, and I went out to see Lancashire leaders and business leaders. There was a real problem, and they were playing back to me just how big the Lancashire economy is and how important it is to the country in terms of defence and cyber. I was delighted to see them announced in the Budget. Maybe what we need to do is bring some of the people who have had problems and resolved them together with the people who still have the problems. We are doing all we can to facilitate this. The size of the prize is very significant.
Chair: Order. We are going to stop to observe the two-minute silence for Remembrance Day.
The Committee observed a two-minute silence.
On resuming—
Angela Rayner: One of the first things the Prime Minister said on his first day in office was that he wants to end rough sleeping. That was incredible. On my travels while I have been embarking on this programme, people who work in the sector and people who have been sleeping rough and have been homeless have said that they feel seen for the first time. It is incredibly unifying for the country to do the work we have done.
I initially provided £432 million in additional funding, which is going through local authorities and strategic authorities to support the work they are doing to identify an offer for people for this winter, before Christmas. The additional money that the Government announced is to ensure that years 2 and 3 are also funded.
One of the challenges that was fed back to me is that, if we want to be serious and want this to have longevity, people need to understand that funding stream up front. That is what the Chancellor announced at the Budget. That is what we were able to announce. That took the funding to, I think, £844 million—
Tom Riordan: It was £874 million.
Angela Rayner: Sorry, £874 million for rough sleeping. Of course, the additional money is on top of the more than £4 billion we are spending on homelessness.
The Guardian reported over the weekend on the impact that the early release scheme from prison is having on homelessness and, in particular, the number of people who have been recalled to prison because they cannot attend probation appointments, because they have been sleeping on some cardboard or something like that. What preparation have you undertaken in your Department for the early release scheme, and how do you intend to get a grip on this issue?
Angela Rayner: It is an important point that you raise. There is not only the early release scheme, but the decanting of people from hotels and people’s claims for asylum being processed as well. Those are flows coming in on top of the challenge of dealing with the rough sleepers that we have. My interministerial team is working at pace to make sure that we are sharing information and that it is doing the appropriate thing.
The Minister from the Ministry of Justice has been attending those meetings and working with a pipeline to ensure that the information is shared with local areas and local authorities and that they have accommodation put in place for people as they leave the prison service. That is not least to tackle the issue that the Prime Minister has set me in terms of challenging the rough sleeping figures that we have for this winter.
But we also know that if offenders—as you rightly say, Andrew—have not got a home or somewhere to stay, they are more likely to reoffend and therefore it costs us more in the future. I think that the MOJ recognises that and has been putting resources and support in place and working with us to ensure that that package is available for people who are released from prison.
Tom Riordan: I think that the resources are in place. The challenge is the execution of it and the implementation on an individual basis with pre-release plans for prisoners who are coming out along with the probation support that they need. In some places that is working well and there are good relationships between the prison governor and the chief executive of the council, and the teams work closely together. In others, it needs more work. That is what we are trying to do through this process.
Through the interministerial group, there is strong commitment from Ministers, led by the Secretary of State. We are following that through into regular engagement with councils. We have plans to try and convene councils and prison governors in the highest-need areas. I think that it will take some time to make sure that we have got that throughout the system. There are examples where it is working; it is just a case of making sure that we can get it right across the board and utilise this much-needed funding.
The two extra years makes such a massive difference to being able to plan properly, get the teams in place and know that you can recruit people into those teams who are going to have funding for that period. It is part of the Prime Minister’s commitment to say that this is going to be not just a temporary initiative but something that will be sustained.
Angela Rayner: We have been doing a lot of work on homelessness for some time and the different cohorts that are at risk of homelessness, including identifying women who are particularly at risk of homelessness as well. That includes people who have earned settlement and those who do not, along with people who have no recourse to public funds, and dealing with some of the challenges of that, including section 21 no-fault evictions. There is a number of pieces of work that we have been doing to identify them and to work with partners to ensure that the right support is in place.
It is not just when we see people who are homeless, but preventing homelessness. A lot of the money that we have has been going into preventive services so that, whichever cohort of people it is, there is a mechanism to provide support for them and to ensure that they know what their rights and obligations are as part of that, which is different for different people in different cohorts.
Chair: As a Committee, we really support the work that the Government are doing to address rough sleeping. We are doing a session on this as a Committee. We are very keen to look at the preventive space particularly and at what comes after Christmas in terms of those highest-need areas, which is where you are seeing a bit of a shortfall, and where you are seeing areas where it has worked and not worked.
We are very keen to work with you collaboratively on this. It would be really good if you could let us know where you are looking and where the gaps are so that we can make sure that this is right going forward, and that no one is in a worse situation after Christmas—because the key bit is after Christmas.
Angela Rayner and Tom Riordan: indicated assent.
Angela Rayner: Well, you try and flatter me, but I am not rising to the bait. The reason I took the pause was because, when I make decisions, I want to know that I am making the right decisions, and that means that I’ve got to have the information. That is why there was a pause in LGR.
Look, LGR was always going to be contentious, and it was always going to be litigated. Let’s be honest: this happens. The Conservatives, when they were in power, did some local government reform, and it was full of litigation. It does have it challenges. We expect that, but I think the principles of local areas coming together and saying, “This is what we think should happen,” and of us setting the criteria to try to deliver that are the right thing to do.
The reason I took the decision to pause was because we had a new Prime Minister who wanted a focus on devolution, and I wanted to make sure that it aligned with what he wanted to happen. It was also to make sure that, as we are in an area that was obviously going to end up with litigation—because it always does—if I am putting my name to it, I have seen the documents and I am fully confident that we have done everything that we needed to do. That is why the new Minister, who was in album 1 as well, and I decided that we needed that time to do it.
Angela Rayner: I think that is unfair. I think my predecessor did a really good job, actually, but I was not involved in the process that he took. I was making sure that I made a fresh decision. That is what I would distinguish: not that it is not a defence of my predecessor, but that I was not involved in that process or party to it. I am taking a fresh decision based on what I have seen, to be clear.
Angela Rayner: Well, I am hoping that we don’t get albums 3, 4 and 5, to be honest. You are all very pessimistic for me today. I am more nervous about the vibes coming from this Committee, but I am hoping that I will get through it this time, confidently.
When do you expect local people to see the benefits of reorganisational upheaval, whether in my constituency of Woking with West Surrey council or in other areas? I am mindful of my area; if and when West Surrey council or East Surrey council has to seek exceptional financial support even before vesting day—even before it is established—will that not highlight that LGR has not done what we wanted it to?
Angela Rayner: No, I think LGR was always going to be tricky in some areas and easier in others, because no two areas are exactly the same. It has created a delay in terms of the new boundaries, and we have said that elections will go ahead this year in those areas, with the new system hopefully in place by the following year.
For me, the fundamental thing was making sure that the decision was right, that I understood that it was right and that I could defend it. I am not saying that all areas would have ended up in court, but some areas inevitably would have, and I am just being honest that we knew that. That is why I pulled back the LGR decisions: to make sure that I had dotted my i’s and crossed my t’s, and that I was doing the appropriate thing that I could justify when I had to be accountable for it.
However, I do still think local government reform is the right thing, and I want to press forward with the areas as quickly as we possibly can. We have said that some may go before Christmas and others early in the new year, but we are working at pace to deliver that. That is also why Jim, as the Minister, said in coming back to Parliament that a lot of the decisions he made were “minded to”, so that he could have that dialogue again. That was not so that areas could go through the whole process again, because we have read the submissions, but so that there was a collaborative approach to genuinely iron out any issues.
We believe local government reform is the best thing for those local areas, and it is not us doing it to them; it is us working with them to deliver that plan.
Angela Rayner: We know that some councils have had to apply for additional financial support. To support the process, we have also written off some debts—SEND and so on—and given up-front funding as part of local government reform.
Some councils have been in difficult situations for some time; some of that is the legacy, as I say, of previous Governments, and the challenges that those councils face. We have acknowledged that, and we have given up-front support for it. That is why we are releasing 50% of the funds for some of the local authorities, regardless of whether they have had a decision on LGR.
As I say, we have also acknowledged the SEND moneys and debt that they had and, as you will be aware, cancelled some of that debt in some areas. That is trying to recognise some of the challenges that those local authorities face.
Tom Riordan: There are examples where it has worked: North Yorkshire council has saved £90 million since it was unitised in 2023. There are other examples where that has not translated, but I would go back to my point about bringing the services together and having elected members, so that the general public are much clearer about who is accountable. Those are real wins for the system, together with bringing powers down from the centre to strategic authority level. The whole thing is moving to a more sustainable footing, but it will take time, and it does rely, as the Secretary of State said, on the baselines that were inherited.
Angela Rayner: I am not aware of the decision making of my predecessor. I made a decision based upon—
Tom Riordan: I do not believe it was a ministerial direction, but I will write if that is not the case.
Angela Rayner: That is not to say that they will not receive more. It is just a recognition of some of the work that has been carried out. That work is not defunct. I think that was just to be fair and reasonable as part of that process.
Tom Riordan: I cited the example of North Yorkshire, which is one where it does look to have worked. I also said there are examples of it not saving as much money. I absolutely can see that. My point is about the potential impact of bringing services together. Things like waste management and collection, which is a lot of a council’s resourcing—it is a big chunk of what the council’s budget deals with—benefit from being in the same place.
It is similar with social care—the ability to have a much more singular conversation between the NHS, particularly, and the teams who deal with vulnerable people and try to do the preventive work that the Secretary of State talked about. It absolutely makes sense to try to bring them into a more single structure. In terms of the evaluation of the evidence, it is sometimes hard to put cause and effect next to some of the changes that happen, because other things can contribute, but I am going from my own experience of running a unitary council.
Tom Riordan: I would argue that, in the long run, we are putting in place new structures that are going to last for several years, and hopefully decades—a new system, as the Prime Minister said, of rewiring the state and moving from a highly centralised national system in which people in a local place are probably in charge of about 5% of the decisions that affect their own geography. We are changing that, and that is worth it. It will take time for the benefits to come through. As with any change and transformation, the costs take time to come through. When you have had to work in the system, the benefits are quite palpable.
Angela Rayner: I was going to say that you have not been to Tameside; we are one borough, but every area thinks it is distinctive, so I understand some of the challenges in terms of local areas and their identities. The Minister has been clear on that, whether regarding city status, how district councils feel they are represented or how you can do that footprint.
Coming back to the perm secretary’s point, when you are looking at growth and inward investment on a larger scale, having all the key levers across transport, connectivity, infrastructure, housing and skills can drive that investment. The sum of the parts of an area, whether it is Essex or anywhere else, can really deliver. That is not taking away local identity. It is not making voices less heard.
At the moment, these decisions are taken by Westminster. This is about pushing power down to areas, on a sub-regional level, so they can make those key growth decisions and have that investment in their hands. That is quite exciting. I know people fear that this is about pulling levers up, but it really is not. It is about taking powers away from me, as the Secretary of State, and putting them closer to where your constituents are—with the directly elected mayor or the combined authority.
Tom Riordan: Just on that—
Lewis Cocking: I would rather have the planning powers back.
Chair: Sorry, I am going to have to stop you and go to the next item, because we are running out of time. I am sorry, Lewis and Secretary of State.
Angela Rayner: The Secretaries of State previous to me also made a decision on that, on clear legal advice, to protect and preserve the police investigation. We did it not to conceal but to preserve. That was from the previous Government. I agreed with their decision and took that course of action. Once those hurdles were removed, because the information went to the Crown Prosecution Service, there was a material change. Therefore, just after conference in September, I was able to make the announcement around how that was taken forward.
On fire funding more broadly, I feel that with it sitting in MHCLG it is not often focused on. There has been an undertaking to fix the funding formula for fire, but that will probably not be until 2029. In the interim, there are significant issues around that broken funding formula. For example, Cleveland Fire Brigade is the busiest per capita and is the lowest funded. It faces a shortfall of £1.2 million in the next financial year.
As far as I am concerned, having talked to staff at Cleveland Fire Brigade, that will put people’s lives in danger. Will you, Secretary of State, commit to looking at this issue and at interim support for fire brigades such as Cleveland that are facing shortfalls, ahead of fixing the broken funding formula?
Angela Rayner: We recognise the situation that we inherited. It was a machinery of government change, because of what happened at Grenfell and the phase 2 report, that brought fire under our Department. The Prime Minister recently held a wildfire summit.
I have met the FBU and fire officers, and I know that there is a review of the grey book. There is a recognition that we need to do more for firefighters. We invested £45 million instantly when I came back and heard firefighters who were tackling the wildfires tell me that they did not even have the equipment. As an employer, I found that a completely unacceptable situation. I therefore committed funding to make that happen.
I know that Cleveland has had significant challenges. We have increased their funding by 3.8% already, and we are working with different firefighters to make sure that we meet their needs that need to be met now, and that we are able to give them additional support if and when they need it—through our scheme with different fire authorities, they can ask for support and help. We are recognising the challenges firefighters face and are investing money now, but we are also committed to doing a review on increasing firefighter numbers and making sure that they have the correct equipment and specialist services across each region.
Angela Rayner: Yes. I will get Judith to make sure that she has a meeting with you.
Mr Brash: That is perfect. I appreciate that, Secretary of State.
Mr Forster: Amazingly, we have almost got to the end of this session without mentioning leasehold reform.
Angela Rayner: Matt would be upset if you did not ask me about leasehold.
Angela Rayner: I support your enthusiasm. Yes, it will be introduced before Christmas—I am determined to make sure that that happens. On your second question about whether it will be passed before the King’s Speech or whether there will be carry over, there is a risk of carry over, because of the size of the Bill—that is in recognition of the appetite of you all. We are looking at additional work on the single independent regulator, which has been indicated. The Bill already has—I think—nearly 300 clauses as drafted, so there is a lot in there already, but we are committed to making sure that we have the independent regulator and we have been working on that.
Angela Rayner: There is a lot of technical detail, so there will be some amendments, just to give you a heads up on that. I welcome the Committee’s commitment to working with us on this. The previous Government, to give them credit, did try to work on it. We are having to draft some amendments, because this is highly technical. Again, it is one of those areas that is going to be litigated, so working together as parliamentarians to tackle some of the issues is really useful for all of us.
Angela Rayner: It is not going to fall.
Mr Forster: So this Bill will pass.
Angela Rayner: We are committed to it. I mean, I cannot say what our friends in the other place will do or what will happen during the Bill’s progress. It is a big Bill, and we have tried to do everything we possibly can to take on board a number of interested parties and the consultations that we have had. I put on the record that Matt has done an incredible amount of work, and I know that others have supported him in that work, including the likes of Lord Best and others. I reassure people that we have done the best that we possibly can to make sure that the Bill is ready and can pass as quickly as possible. I urge Members to work with us to get this Bill passed, so that we can make the necessary changes.
Angela Rayner: Again, I think you know that the Housing Minister is on to this. The measures put forward so far have some enforcement concerns, but we recognise that restricted covenants raise wider questions about transparency, proportionality and routes of challenge. We will consider whether further measures are needed to protect homeowners from unreasonable enforcement of restricted covenants, while ensuring that legitimate and proportionate management agents can continue to operate. We are looking at that and making sure that the law provides the routes for homeowners to dispute effectively.
Angela Rayner: Yes, we will set out further details on the commonhold and leasehold reform Bill shortly. Matt is on the issue and is looking at the powers available and what we can do to strengthen them.
Angela Rayner: I forgot to welcome you to the Committee, Sagal, as it is your first meeting. Thank you for all you have done on housing in your area—I know this is a passionate area for you. On 15 October, we launched an eight-week consultation on the draft regulations to implement the Supported Housing (Regulatory Oversight) Act 2023. We expect licensing to be implemented by 2027.
I have looked under the hood at this, and there are a lot of issues. There are different regulations and oversight mechanisms. Frankly, I am not satisfied that it is where we need it to be, so alongside that work, I have met the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions. We are looking at how we can make sure that we strengthen it and get good value for money for people who need supported housing, tackle those who frankly should not be in the system and support those who are providing decent supported housing.
Have we got that at the moment? No. What I have uncovered, certainly with what has happened through the recent media—frankly, I find it disgraceful. Some of these people, the most vulnerable, are not getting the service that they should be provided with. The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions and I are very clear that we need to do a piece of work, and we are embarking on that work now.
Sagal Abdi-Wali: Thank you very much. I look forward to seeing you embarking on that work. I should also declare, for the purposes of this meeting, that I am still a local councillor.
Angela Rayner: I declared that for you, I think.
Angela Rayner: I meant that they said that I am going to be on albums 3, 4 and 5—because I won’t be here!
Chair: I hope not, because I think people don’t want too many changes.
We are very keen to work with you on this. In terms of some of the stuff you have mentioned, you have your meeting of the national housing delivery board on Tuesday. It will be good to see what comes out of that, particularly on housing delivery. You have mentioned some of the challenges that you are facing at the moment in building homes, but hopefully that will iron this out, so it would be good to get more detail about that.
There are the new towns as well. I know that the Government are looking particularly at January of next year, but it would be good if we could get more information, because we are not very clear about what is happening with the new towns. It is good to hear that that is still going ahead, but it would be good to know what the details are. I think I need to declare that I am an interested person, because I am likely to get a new town in my constituency.
Then there is the organised crime piece and the follow-up actions that members of the Committee have raised. It would be really good to get further details on that.
Thank you for sending us information about No. 10 North last night. We received last night the letter about how it is set up, so we may have some follow-up questions on that.
Angela Rayner: I always enjoy this Committee. Sorry, I was just making a joke, Chair, about the fact that they insinuated that I might not be in my post till the end of the Parliament.
Chair: I don’t think they meant that, did you, Lewis?
Lewis Cocking: We are waiting for more music to come out!
Angela Rayner: More hits! There will be plenty; don’t worry. I’m not a one-hit wonder.
Angela Rayner: No, but thank you, and thank you for giving us your predecessor as a Minister. Hopefully, you will know that my Minister is very well up on the issues that the Select Committee raises. We value the Select Committee, and some of the changes we have made hopefully reflect the valuable contribution that you as a Committee have made. It does influence what we do, so thank you.
Chair: Thank you. And some of the work that the Committee has recommended has been implemented, so thank you for that.
[1] The Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government corrected this figure to £40 billion.