Environment and Climate Change Committee

Corrected oral evidence: Dunkelflaute and the risks of electricity intermittency

Tuesday 3 November 2026

10.05 am

 

Watch the meeting

Members present: Baroness Sheehan (The Chair); Lord Ashcombe; Baroness Coffey; Lord Jay of Ewelme; Lord Krebs; Lord Lennie; Baroness Rafferty; Lord Redwood; Lord Rooker; Earl Russell; Lord Trees; Baroness Whitaker.

Evidence Session No. 7 Heard in Public Questions 78 - 94

 

Witnesses

Michael Shanks MP, Minister of Energy, DESNZ; Bill Jones, Deputy Director for Future Electricity Security, DESNZ.

 


Examination of witnesses

Michael Shanks and Bill Jones.

  1.             The Chair: Good morning, and welcome to the Lords Environment and Climate Change Committee. Today is the final session of our inquiry into Dunkelflaute weather events and the challenges that they present to the Government’s ambition to deliver the clean power action plan by 2030.

I would like to warmly welcome the right honourable Michael Shanks MP, Minister for Energy, together with his DESNZ colleague Bill Jones, deputy director for future energy security. Thank you very much for making the time to be with us today.

Before we start, may I remind everyone that the session is webcast live on Parliament TV and that a transcript will be taken and made public. Witnesses will have an opportunity to review the script and, if necessary, make very minor amendments. Members are reminded that they should declare any relevant interests the first time they speak. I will take the opportunity here to say that I am a director of Peers for the Planet.

We are a little bit late in starting, so we will move straight to the first question. Minister, in written evidence from DESNZ, we are told that the majority of capacity procured through the capacity market can be expected to generate or manage demand throughout a Dunkelflaute period, in combination with other non-capacity-market eligible capacity. In that statement, we can infer that the Government have some idea of how they are defining a Dunkelflaute period. Could you share that definition with us?

Michael Shanks: Good morning. It is good to be at this end of the building. Thank you for inviting me along. You have had some very detailed evidence. I read the session that you had with the Met Office, for example, on scientific definitions, and there is a mixed picture of exactly how you would define it. We characterise it as a period of low wind and low sun, usually correlating with a winter period where there might be an increased expectation of demand.

In truth, it is just one of a number of weather and climate events that the National Energy System Operator has to consider in its planning for the system. Although we recognise that it is an event that requires thinking on how the system will run, it is part of a long list of other things in which the capacity market exists to make sure that we are constantly able to meet the demand that the system needs.

The Chair: What demand are you meeting?

Michael Shanks: Every single day, we have to meet the peak demand on the system.

The Chair: Let us just talk about these high-risk periods of Dunkelflaute. We really want to try to understand what level of capacity you think we need. You seem to say here that you understand fully that you can meet those risks, yet we do not understand what those risks are. We have had lots of evidence to suggest that this uncertainty is not helpful to people trying to make decisions in mitigating that risk.

Michael Shanks: It is one of a number of challenges. The system operates in a business-as-usual way when weather events are as predicted, but, on any given day, the weather can change. Gas terminals could be offline for any particular reason. There are a whole series of things that mean that the system operates in different ways every single day. The capacity market exists to make sure that we have the capacity that we can deploy whenever there are differences in generation or, indeed, peaks in demand that perhaps are not the normal demand that the system would come under.

Although I completely understand why, especially in an inquiry focused on Dunkelflaute, you would want clear definitions of that, in truth I do not think that anyone has an absolutely clear definition. It is just one of many things that the system has to be able to respond to on any given day.

The Chair: Dr Emily Wallace from the Met Office stated that a three-week period of wind suppressed to 20% of its usual capacity would be an infrequent, one-in-40-year event. Is that something that the system, as it currently stands, will be able to meet?

Michael Shanks: Again, the system is set up to meet any strains that are put on it at any point in time. That is why we have redundancies built into it. There are a lot of different definitions in terms of how long a period of Dunkelflaute could last, what the impact would be in other parts of Europe in terms of the impact on interconnectors, and how other parts of the generation fleet can respond to it. Of course, we are not wholly reliant on renewables, so it is not entirely affected in that way.

There is, though, also a greater understanding of what the impact of climate change might be on Dunkelflaute in the future. There is more research being done on that at the moment, but, in truth, the way in which the Government consider the system is that it is one of many things that we have to consider in terms of the strain put on the system. The system has to be able to respond to that, but, equally, to other periods of outages. If we think of the summer that we have just had, significant heatwaves put pressure on the system as well. There is a whole range of things that we consider.

The Chair: It would really help to understand the additional work that the Government are undertaking to clarify the risk of climate change in this very uncertain series of events that lead to a Dunkelflaute. Can you shed some light on what extra work is being carried out?

Michael Shanks: We have an interest in it. NESO, which I know you have had evidence from, has said that it has an interest in further research, but this is work that is being taken on by academics and others looking into the longer-term trends in this. It is not work the Government are directly looking at, but we remain in close contact with the Met Office and with others to try to understand this.

Part of the modelling that NESO uses—and I know that you had the chief engineer here to give evidence to you—is looking backwards at all of the evidence of weather patterns and others that can help build the models for the future, but the system is also built in with redundancies, so that, if there are unexpected periods of Dunkelflaute or other weather events, it can respond to those in real time.

The Chair: What the Government are trying to achieve with the clean power action plan and delivering the volume of renewables that that will entail by 2030 is extremely ambitious and risky. Some of those risks are magnified by weather events such as this. We want to be absolutely certain that the Government recognise those extreme risks and are really putting their shoulder to the wheel to make sure that the lights do not go out. Can we be absolutely certain that the Government are fully cognisant of the risks and that the lights will stay on?

Michael Shanks: First of all, we have one of the most resilient energy systems anywhere in the world. We have had renewables on our system for decades now, and that resilience has not changed. I would challenge the idea that there is an extreme risk of deploying renewables. There are many countries around the world that have relied on renewables as a core part of their energy mix for a long time.

The Chair: There is an extreme risk when we have events such as these, which will test the system.

Michael Shanks: Testing the system is different from extreme risk. I would not characterise it in that way.

The Chair: I did not for one minute say that it is extremely risky to go for renewables. For the sake of clarity, I fully support the Government’s ambitions.

Michael Shanks: I am grateful for that. There is a mix of technologies. We were very clear that the decarbonisation of the power system by 2030, which is a hugely stretching ambition, was not just about deploying renewables. It was about building new nuclear far more quickly as a country than we have been able to in the past. It was also about bringing forward storage, which we have not kept up pace with. We have just announced the first long-duration energy storage in 40 years. We should have been building that alongside the renewables that we have been building so that we can store more of it. It is also about how we use the system much more smartly, so that we have flexibility built into it as well.

In terms of the risk point, though, to come to your question, this is not saying that one single technology should ever make up our energy mix. We do not hold that view at all. Gas will continue to play a role in a strategic capacity, and there is resilience built into the plans for clean power.

The Chair: Do you have anything to add, Bill Jones?

Bill Jones: No. I think that that sets out the prospect very clearly. We need a mix of technologies to address this challenge.

  1.             Lord Krebs: Thank you very much, Minister, for coming to see us. We had a session with Ofgem and NESO last week. Although this is an inquiry about keeping the lights on, I am afraid that Ofgem and NESO rather left us in the dark, in the sense that, although they said that the Government are due to make a decision on a pathway for the strategic energy plan by the end of the year, they were not able to shed any light on what things would look like.

They were not able to tell us which technology will be in the plan, what scale it will be, by when it will be ready, where it is going to be situated, or whatever infrastructure is required. I am hoping that you might be able to tell us a little bit more about this strategic spatial energy plan in terms of the technologies and the investment that will be required to deliver it.

Michael Shanks: I can give some context as to why we are going through the process of a strategic spatial energy plan, and outline the process going forward. The pathway that will be chosen will be consulted on. The alternative pathways that have been presented to Government will form part of the environmental assessment that will be published as well, so there will be transparency in what those pathway options are.

We co-commissioned, alongside the Scottish and Welsh Governments, the first ever strategic plan for the country, recognising that, while the renewables that we have built in the system are hugely welcome, we should have been building them more coherently, and we should have done that 20 years ago, or in any of the intervening years since, so that we are not paying huge costs to connect those projects after the fact. That is the purpose of the plan.

It is about a range of technologies, and some of the discussion on the strategic spatial energy plan has come to the view that we will make black and white choices about offshore wind or SMRs. That is not how we are going to reach a conclusion on this, but it is about saying that there is a pathway that involves either a significant amount of onshore solar and wind, or a significant amount of offshore, or a balance of the two, and other technologies built into that mix as well.

The decision will be made on the basis of the cost of the pathway, first and foremost, while also ensuring that we have the industrial advantage that comes from some of those opportunities, and that it strategically makes sense in terms of land use across the country as well.

Every single one of the pathways, as I hope would be taken as a given, conforms to our security of supply standards, so every single one will meet all the supply needs of the country as well as the legally binding carbon budgets of the country. All six follow that pathway. The choices are individually within that in terms of what the mix of technologies will be.

Lord Krebs: Thank you for that. Is there an urgency in your mind about this? There needs to be some long-term investment by the private sector, and possibly by the Government as well. While there is uncertainty, people are not going to invest in particular technologies. What is your comment about the urgency to get this resolved so that people can get on with delivering the infrastructure that is needed?

Michael Shanks: It is a hugely important point. The reason why we announced the clean power action plan two and a half years ago was partly to give that confidence to industry that, after a failed offshore wind auction under the last Government, we were committed to this, so there could be confidence in that investment. That has happened. We have seen more than £110 billion of private investment in clean power since we came into government. The long-term future, I understand, is really important, not least because we want to build the supply chains here, which requires that pipeline of projects to work.

At the same time, though, we want to make sure that we get this right, because the danger to date has been quite an ad hoc approach to building renewables across the country. I am a Scottish Member of Parliament. I live next to two of Europe’s biggest onshore wind farms. They are fantastic pieces of infrastructure, but, if we were logically designing a system, we may not have placed quite so many wind farms quite so far away from centres of demand. The whole point of this plan is to look more coherently at the opportunity across the country.

The pace point is absolutely crucial, but it is equally about making sure that we get it right for this first plan. It will then be an iterative process. Although this takes us to 2050 in broad terms, it is not a one plan in 2027 that we never revise. It clearly will be revised regularly, but it gives us some indication to allow us to then do the centralised strategic network plan, or CSNP—there are always acronyms in this business—which is how we try to bring down the cost of building network infrastructure so that it is more coherently built to meet the future pathways of our energy system.

Lord Krebs: If I am in charge of a company that is providing one of the technologies that could support ultra-long-duration energy storage, when will I know that I can press go and that you have given the clear signal that this is a technology that the Government will adopt?

Michael Shanks: In terms of the timeline for the SSEP, the Secretary of State will make a decision in the coming months, which will be consulted on early in 2027. We want to do that in partnership with the Scottish and Welsh Governments, which we co-convened this with. That process will take us to some point in 2027, and the final decision will be at the end of 2027. In the intervening time, we are continuing to do everything that we can around individual technologies. The energy system is not going to stop for a year.

On long-duration energy storage, gas is probably what you are referencing in that specific example. We have said that we will respond to the consultation on security of supply for gas early next year to give some confidence to the gas storage question. For example, on long-duration electricity storage, Ofgem will soon announce its final decisions on almost seven gigawatts of long-duration storage. All of that will continue. This is about the longer-term future pathways for energy in the country.

  1.             The Chair: I wonder if I can press on the evidence that we heard from Ofgem and NESO last week. They were unable to confirm which technologies would be in the SSEP. However, Julian Leslie from NESO mentioned that it was an iterative plan that would be updated every three years to account for technical innovation. This would suggest that there may be an emphasis on proven technologies in the first instance. That is really the question that I want to put to you. Will that be the case? Is it that proven technologies, such as grid-scale batteries, pump storage or hydro interconnectors, have greater certainty already?

Michael Shanks: Yes, in some ways, but we also are supportive of technologies that are coming forward and that need additional support. For example, there will be a choice to be made about the amount of floating offshore wind that we think will be in a future pathway, but there is no doubt that, as a country, we want to see some floating offshore wind, so we will work on a way to support the industrial opportunity around that. Established technologies are clearly crucial to make sure that we have confidence that things will be built, but also that the cost curve is at the lower end, because affordability is the Government’s number one priority.

In terms of storage, the pathways will make an overall choice around how much long-duration storage we need. They will not go into the detail of the technologies, because that is the process that Ofgem is running in the cap and floor scheme.

The Chair: Long duration is different from ultra-long duration. The plan would be updated every three years. Will it be the case that technologies such as hydrogen storage, carbon capture and storage or compressed air energy storage will be having to wait for three-year periods?

Michael Shanks: No. This is where I just want to add a bit of clarification about the strategic spatial energy plan. This is a reflection on the past two years in which this work has been under way. The sense has been given that it is going to be an extremely definitive plan to 2050, written in black and white, that never changes, and that nothing that is not on it will be delivered. That is not how the SSEP will work.

It is to give us a broad design for what the future system looks like, so that we can build the grid that is most relevant to meet that demand. Projects will come forward. If we think of nuclear, we are really interested in advanced nuclear projects from the private sector. It is not for Government to decide whether there is private investment interested in those projects. It is our job to judge the safety and the planning, and then to allow them to carry on. Whether those are in the SSEP or not, we will continue to support them, and, likewise, emerging technologies that come out in long‑duration and ultra-long-duration storage, which is a hugely interesting area. If we can crack the science and the development behind them, we should be deploying as much as we can.

The Chair: You say that you have received the final pathways options report from NESO and are in the process of selecting one of them. How many pathways are there? What are the methodology and assumptions that lie behind them?

Michael Shanks: There are six pathways that have been presented to the department. The methodology document is publicly available, including all of the detail in the consultation exercises that NESO has gone through. There is a significant amount of information within all of that.

What NESO has presented to us is its view, as the system operator, of a variety of pathways, their cost calculations, and the impacts on land use, for example. It is for Government to then take that information and decide on the wider impacts. There are questions about how much land use we want for onshore solar, for example, versus offshore wind. That is a political choice. There are questions about supply chain benefits that might come from offshore wind versus solar that could be built in the UK, with jobs and economic opportunity. There is a question about cost in terms of how much we are willing to pay versus all the other trade-offs.

Those are all political choices. As the Prime Minister has emphasised recently, Government are in charge of energy policy in the country. The role of NESO and Ofgem is to advise and to regulate, but Government will decide what the future system looks like in the UK.

The Chair: When will we have greater clarity on the SSEP? All the evidence that we have heard so far says that everyone is operating in the dark, as Lord Krebs has said. When will we have greater clarity? Are investors and stakeholders expected to wait until the end of next year?

Michael Shanks: No. Everyone will see publicly the pathway that the Secretary of State has chosen early next year. The expectation is that that will be in the first quarter of next year. In the environmental assessment that goes with that, the other pathways will also become clear, so there will be transparency on the alternative options. It is for NESO to do that consultation, but the Government will have an explanation that goes alongside that as to why we have chosen that pathway. Importantly, there is then the opportunity for industry and the public to add their views to this, and we will come to a final decision next year.

I would just reiterate the point on investor certainty, which is so important. This is not a binary choice that we are making. We have to build an energy system with a mix of technologies. We are open to investment in a whole range of areas, and we continue to work right across industry to make those projects happen.

  1.             Lord Redwood: Minister, I welcome the Chancellor’s recent statement that it makes no sense to keep adding renewables if the grid capacity is not there to deliver it to customers. I welcome your hint today that we already have an imbalance problem, with an excess of wind power in Scotland, and cost and supply difficulties resulting.

I wondered if you could just give us some background on where you and the department are in solving that grid blockage problem and how much delay and extra cost is going to be entailed in putting in synchronous condensers and grid-forming inverters, for example, and the megalink needed to Scotland with pylon and cable capacity.

Michael Shanks: It is a really important question. It is the most pressing thing in my in-tray as a Minister at the moment. The grid is hugely resilient but is not where it should be. If we are honest, we should have woken up decades ago to the fact that the grid was not being invested in at the scale that it should have been.

That is not just because we are moving to renewables. There are hugely important economic growth opportunities on the demand side that cannot connect and are given dates a decade in advance, which is an absolute nightmare for any investor confidence in the UK. It is becoming increasingly complex to manage the grid, because we are trying to upgrade grid that was largely built in the 1950s and 1960s, alongside connecting many more things into it.

It is a collective failure of Governments over decades to build what is probably the most important national asset that we have as a country. The grid is a phenomenal piece of engineering, but it has been largely ignored for decades, and that is a failure.

We are now trying to grip two things that are crucial. One is the connections reform process, which has been painful but really important. When we came into government, more than 700 gigawatts was waiting to connect to the national grid, which was an absurd amount of projects that had just been allowed to grow and grow. We have reformed that queue and cleared out 300 gigawatts. That allows projects that are ready and strategically aligned to connect. That is part of the solution.

The bigger thing is upgrading the grid itself, which will be a huge piece of investment. We have been really open with people. If you think back to the Budget last year, we took £150 of costs away from bills and into the Treasury. People did not see £150 come off their bills, because we had to invest in the grid.

That was a politically difficult thing to do, frankly, when we would have liked to bring people’s bills down, but, if we do not fix the grid now, we will end up, a decade or more from now, in an even worse position than we are now, losing out on economic opportunities, but, crucially, spending billions of pounds on constraining wind and turning up gas, which is a disgraceful way for us to be operating a system. We need to build the grid. We need to invest now. We recognise that that comes with a cost, but there is, as with all of this, an even greater cost if we do not act now.

Lord Redwood: Can you give us any indication on cost on bills in 2030 and on delays in all this?

Michael Shanks: I cannot give you an exact figure to 2030. Ofgem will be able to give you its modelling. The reason that it is a balancing act here is that there is an investment cost to build the grid. For example, if we build Sea Link and Norwich to Tilbury, it will come at a significant cost to consumers, but the cost-benefit will outweigh the investment cost in building it, because of the constraints that we will reduce to bring cleaner, cheaper power to people’s homes. There is a trade-off with short-term investment in order to get to a reduction in constrained costs to bring down people’s bills.

Lord Redwood: Thank you very much. Can I give you my apologies? I have to disappear early because of the change of date, which would not fit in my diary, but thank you for coming.

  1.             Baroness Whitaker: Good morning, and thank you for coming in. Minister, you referred to the capacity market. We have heard that it does not adequately recognise or reward duration and availability of assets to deal with Dunkelflaute. Looking at your Clean Power 2030 Action Plan, you are clearly contemplating reforms, so will they take account of the security of supply benefits that ultra-long-duration storage and low-carbon dispatchable power could deliver, as well as enable innovation? In that connection, could you tell us what is happening with the Marine Energy Taskforce? What does it think should happen to the market?

Michael Shanks: Great. There are lots of really good questions in that. I might pass to Bill in a moment, who is Mr Capacity Market in the department and will speak specifically about that point.

First, we absolutely want to try to get to a place where the capacity market is using low-carbon options as much as possible, but the critical thing about the capacity market is dispatchability. Security of supply will always be the number one aim. We said that, even in the clean power scenario, gas would continue to play a role as a strategic capacity on the system because we recognise its inherent ability to be dispatchable, but the gas fleet is ageing, and so we want to see other technologies come forward.

Long-duration storage is a really critical part of that, but we have not been building it for a very long time. Some of the battery projects that are coming forward are now long-duration. They may have quicker build times. We are also keen to build more pumped hydro storage, but that is not going to happen overnight.

I will pass to Bill in a second on the capacity market, but just on the last point, I set up the Marine Energy Taskforce because I felt from industry that they were not getting a fair hearing from Government over many years. It is a technology that has been proven in many other countries, but is extremely expensive to build.

I wanted to try to get the evidence together to justify tidal or wave technologies that are more expensive as a capital outlay, but, if we look at countries around the world that have them, are often on the system after 70 or 80 years and continuing to generate day after day. I visited a number of hydro projects in the Scottish Highlands that are still generating with much the same technology as they were built with when we electrified the Highlands.

I am interested in the technology, but I have been really open with industry that the cost is prohibitive at the moment. Although we have supported some tidal projects to get to scale, we are going to have to work on how we bring down the cost of the capital outlay to begin with, and I am open to working with industry on that.

Baroness Whitaker: It is the mechanism to get these prototypes up for scaling that seems not to be sufficiently available, so I do not know whether you have any thoughts about that. Perhaps your office could let us know which other countries have managed marine energy.

Michael Shanks: I will. I know of a particularly good project in France, for example, which has been running for almost 18 years. We are supporting the EMEC in Orkney, for example, which is doing a lot of work on wave generation, but you are right that the scale-up point is the challenge. The technology is there at an innovation level, and we know that it works as a way of generating electricity, but scaling it up is a challenge. Tidal energy comes with issues in that, although it is a constant source of energy, it does not necessarily correlate with peak demand, so you still need storage attached to it. There are trade-offs, but I am very interested in looking at it as a technology. I do not know if Bill wants to add anything on the capacity market.

Baroness Whitaker: Could he add in, just finally, whether the Marine Energy Taskforce is preparing a report? I did hear that it was.

Michael Shanks: That is more me again. Yes, it is. I would need to check. I think it had its final meeting and is now drafting the report, but there may be one further meeting to happen. I am happy to write to the committee.

Bill Jones: The capacity market is GB’s primary mechanism for ensuring security of supply. It runs on a technology-neutral basis, where it seeks to buy the capacity that we need, whatever technology that might be, to ensure security of supply according to metrics that NESO develops as the system operator.

It is not the job of the capacity market to bring through new technology or more low-carbon technology, or things like such as that. It is about ensuring security of supply. The sorts of things that the Minister was talking about are where you bring forward new technologies. They are bespoke support mechanisms to develop a technology or to help it overcome barriers.

Baroness Whitaker: By that, do you mean contracts for difference?

Bill Jones: That could be one mechanism. For example, that is what is used in the context of offshore wind. It could be things such as business models to support hydrogen to power. There are a number of ways in which we address the needs of different technologies to try to bring if forward as a competitive technology in an auction process, which is how the capacity market runs. The capacity market does not decide which technology gets agreements under the capacity market. It is about who bids in and who is able to offer capacity that they can deliver to when required to meet a system stress event.

There is quite a detailed, complicated process that we go through in terms of annual auctions to make sure that we have enough capacity on the system to meet those requirements. In the context of Dunkelflaute, we are thinking about whether the capacity market delivers what I was going to call the types of technology, but which can respond to that long-duration event rather than, as it has traditionally been set up, to meet peak requirements.

This device was set up in 2014. We had, basically, a coal and gas system, so we did not have to worry about Dunkelflaute because the technologies that came through were able to do both: meet peak demand and also meet the Dunkelflaute challenge. Now, with a more renewables-based system, where we are facing a bigger challenge in the context of Dunkelflaute, we are going to have to think about whether the capacity market brings forward the right sort of technology that can respond to those sorts of events. We are thinking about that and contemplating how we might reform the capacity market to be able to meet those challenges.

Baroness Whitaker: We would love to see how you are going to reform it when you have decided, if that is within our timescale.

Bill Jones: We are actively thinking about it now. The nature of the capacity market process requires quite a lot of consultation. We need to get the views of industry that can contribute, and all that stuff. It is not a quick fix, but we are actively thinking about it. We will be thinking about bringing forward proposals for reform next year, which might be a process that takes a couple of years to develop. The other thing to remember is that it then takes three to four years before you see those new technologies come through, because the auctions for capacity are looking that far ahead.

Baroness Whitaker: Thank you very much. We will have to manage to postpone any Dunkelflaute.

Bill Jones: Dunkelflaute is already part of what NESO buys against, so it is not like it is a new challenge. It is one that we can see becoming more of a challenge because of the nature of the system, but it is not new. NESO projects its challenge in terms of how much capacity it thinks it needs to secure the system, and has been doing so for many years. It is a constant, iterative process, so each year it thinks about what the new challenges are and how it weighs what technologies can contribute, as well as what challenges it faces in terms of Dunkelflaute rather than peak demand. It is an ongoing process.

  1.             Baroness Rafferty: My question is on the auctions that you have referenced. What exactly are these? Is that the best mechanism to use to engage and secure supply?

Michael Shanks: From a policy point of view, there are two auctions. One is four years ahead, which allows us to give that longer-term procurement, and one comes a year ahead of when we expect the demand to come on, or when it should be available. It is a well-used process, if we think of the CfD auctions, for example, to try to identify the projects that come forward but at a price that is good for consumers.

Ultimately, to qualify for the capacity market, you have to meet all of the requirements for the system, so that everyone that participates is suitable for our needs. It then comes down to the cost that we can procure it at, and we have found that the auction is an effective way of doing that, not least because the generators bidding into it do not have any idea of what the alternative pricing structures are for others. It allows some competition within that and for us to be able to identify the cheapest price possible for consumers.

We keep the rules of the auction under review. We made some changes last year to the capacity market. We continue to do that to make sure that it works for consumers, and crucially, more than any other part of the energy system, the capacity market is about us always being able to meet the needs of the system.

  1.             The Chair: You will be looking at reforming the capacity market, you say. Can I ask over what timeframe?

Michael Shanks: We are open to looking at what shape the capacity market should take in the future, recognising that this mix of technologies is changing right now. We are not actively in a period of consultation on it, so we are looking at the policy development at the moment.

The Chair: The reason why I ask is that we have written evidence from the Renewables Investors Group. One of the issues that it raises is that, “For storage, the de-rating factor rises with the number of hours a site can run, but levels off at about 95-96% at around 9.5 hours. Storage that can run for longer gets no extra credit”. That does not reflect reality. Will the capacity market be reformed to reflect ultra-long-duration storage realities?

Michael Shanks: Bill might want to come in on the detail, but this is one of the areas where, as technology develops, we absolutely want to look at how we might change the parameters of the auction and of the capacity market generally, but we have to see the evidence of those technologies operating. If we take, for example, the recent Ofgem minded-to decision on long-duration storage, there are some really innovative battery projects within that, but we need to see not just that they have the duration, but that they operate on the system in the way that we need them to. That is the crucial thing for the capacity market.

The Chair: It is chicken and egg. Do you think that, if you build it, they will come?

Michael Shanks: If we build what?

The Chair: If you build the reforms.

Michael Shanks: Bill made the point earlier that the capacity market is technology-agnostic. If technology can be proven to meet what we need from the capacity market—in other words, its availability on the system when we need it—we are open to that being included, but we have to have absolute confidence in its ability to do that.

Bill Jones: When it comes to something such as ultra-long-duration storage, we would need to change the parameters of the capacity market to recognise what that technology brought. At the moment, this thing does not exist. It is not operating at a level where it makes any difference. When we have a technology ready to deploy, that is when the capacity market has to decide, “How do we value this technology? What do we think it brings?” That will lead us to identifying a generating class and things like that, which leads to the question of how we value this particular technology.

We are already thinking, as we do every year, about whether we have the right de-rating factors that value technologies for how long they can generate or supply electricity, for example, among a lot of other things. It is a well-established system, but we have not yet had to respond to the question of what ultra-long-duration storage adds and how you value it. We want to enter the capacity market, but it is premature to try to change the system when it is not there.

The Chair: So we have to look at other market mechanisms as well that will enable it, such as reforming contracts for difference. We may come to that later.

  1.             Lord Lennie: Welcome. This is more for Bill than for the Minister, but feel free to chip in. On ultra-long-duration energy storage, let us say that the definition is delivering over 100 hours. Given that these were not competitive in the most recent cap and floor scheme, what are the alternative mechanisms that might bring these emerging or future technologies to the market?

Bill Jones: This is more of a question for the Minister than for me. However, we have a range of mechanisms that help develop new technologies. Whether that is carbon capture and storage, hydrogen to power, or nuclear, there are lots of ways of trying to address barriers that are holding back the development of a particular technology. Ultra-long-duration storage is newer than a lot of the ones that I have been talking about, so I honestly do not know what the right mechanisms will be to help that.

I know that we are looking at research programmes to help support the development of these technologies. As they develop, it will become clearer in terms of what we need to address to enable these things to come forward. The capacity market is right at the end of that chain, as I discussed, in terms of whether, when your technology is ready to deploy, we can make sure that we have the right approach to it so that it can participate.

Lord Lennie: As long as they progress towards the capacity market.

Michael Shanks: Yes, or other mechanisms. The cap and floor scheme is designed to provide the minimum level of support to allow the capital investment to go ahead. Most battery projects in the UK are on a merchant basis. There is no subsidy scheme for batteries more generally in the system. UKRI has announced a £28 million innovation challenge to support ultra-long-duration storage so that we can see that develop here in the UK, but we have not seen any projects deployed anywhere at that scale.

On the point that I was making to the Chair earlier, it is one thing to have the technology in theory or even built, but we then need the system to be able to use the long-duration storage in the way that it is designed for, and not find ourselves using ultra-long-duration storage as just a regular go-to for short-duration use on the system. It is partly the maturity of the construction of the technology, but then how the system uses it and recharges efficiently, and how consumers do not end up paying twice for some of that energy and discharge from it. We are open to all of that.

Partly why we announced window 1, but said very openly that there would be a second window of the Ofgem cap and floor, was to say that, while we have procured more than seven gigawatts, which is at the higher end of our ambition, and we are really pleased with it, it is not the end of our ambition. If people are developing projects, they should not think that that is the end of the road for LDES in Britain. There will be a second window.

  1.             Lord Ashcombe: Good morning, and thank you for coming. Last night, as I was sitting in the Chamber, I have to say that I did look at my phone to see what our energy mix was. We were up to almost 43% of gas, which is probably more than any of us want to see being used. What also interested me was that we were exporting to France, and getting 1.6%, give or take, coming in from interconnectors.

We are in a weather window at the moment that is not hugely profligate in wind or sun, as we can see. I am sure that there is some solar being generated from this murk at the moment, but not a lot. At the other end of the spectrum, we are spilling wind power, as you described earlier. What are we going to do about hydrogen, potentially, which could use that spilt power? What are we doing about gas and carbon capture technology? From everything that we have heard so far, this is all long term in happening, and certainly works for long-term dispatchable power, but everything is taking 10 years, so what are we doing to ensure progress in this area?

Michael Shanks: First, I am glad that I am not the only person who sits looking constantly at the generation mix on my phone to see where we are at as a country. It is good to have a friend in that.

You are right to say that the mix of technologies is important. We have said throughout the clean power action plan that this is not just about renewables, although we want to deploy more renewables in the system. It is partly around that mix of thinking about how we might use hydrogen. We have put some funding into initial hydrogen projects. We are supportive of hydrogen, but, equally, we recognise that there is a cost implication from that in terms of generating on the one hand, turning it into hydrogen, and then potentially turning it back into something. We want to be really clear around how that works, but we are really supportive of that as a storage technology, apart from anything else, and how we soak up that excess that we are generating on the system for a huge amount of the time.

We are really positive about more interconnection with Europe. We would like to see more of that in terms of hybrid assets, such as connecting offshore wind in the North Sea to different countries. The Hamburg declaration announced 100 gigawatts of that shared capacity across Europe, and we really want to work towards deploying that.

Storage is also critical. What we have done over probably the past 20 years is move away from, first of all, coal, which was a huge achievement by multiple Governments, and then build renewables but without the back-up in the storage or the flexibility of the system for us to get the best use of them.

I go back to the point that I made to Lord Redwood that grid would have allowed us to use much more of the wind that is being generated in Scotland right now but we cannot get to where it is needed. It is also about flexibility in the system. How do we get consumers to use electricity more flexibly? We see that, where that is deployed at the moment, people are very willing to use time of use tariffs to charge their car at times when there is excess cheap power in the system, or to do their washing. There are real opportunities for consumers to save money and for the system to shift this traditional sense of peak demand to smooth that out over a longer period of time.

Of course, we are really supportive of building new nuclear, and we should have been making decisions on nuclear a long time ago so that we do not have so much retirement of the existing fleet before the new fleet comes along.

Lord Ashcombe: Coming back to hydrogen and, indeed, carbon sequestration on gas plants, there is quite a lot of infrastructure that will need to be built for this, which does not just fly out of the air, unfortunately, and none of us has any money to do it. How do we encourage that to come forward? The geology is certainly not perfect where we have our current gas plants in terms of putting the carbon capture equipment on it, so some of those may end up getting scrapped and being built somewhere else, but, again, they are $500 million to $1 billion a pop. I should declare that I work in insurance, and we do insure a lot of these things.

I would just like to hear a bit more about how you are going to encourage these technologies. They are being used in certain places. We know how to make hydrogen, but we are not using it with a green source. We are using it with heavy hydrocarbons. We make loads of hydrogen in refineries and petrochemical plants; otherwise, we would not have any plastics and so on.

Michael Shanks: There is a range of really good points there that I could explore in a whole session, because you are right to raise it. The truth about CCUS and hydrogen is that it is difficult to get them directly from market to investability and into building, but we need to try to do everything that we can to nurture the first few projects that come out of that.

Net Zero Teesside, for example, is a really important track 1 project that is under construction and will give us gas generation, but with carbon capture technology. It allows us to have that dispatchability and a new gas plant when we have a lot of the gas fleet retiring. We are seeing projects coming through it, and we have looked at dispatchable power agreements to make sure that there is a long-term investment vehicle whereby, where there is private investment, you can make sure that you have an off-taker for that.

I am not going to pretend that any of this is easy. The Government, of course, had to make some difficult decisions as part of the defence investment plan around where funding would go, and some of that has fallen on carbon capture and hydrogen, but we want to try to support what is not a nascent technology, but, in terms of deployment in the UK, is still very nascent, to get those first projects over, prove the model, and then look at how we can expand in the future.

The final point is definitely not a short-term fix, but I am really interested in looking at how we repurpose the gas network as much as possible to be able to do some of these things with hydrogen for industry, for example. The gas network, unlike the electricity network, has been significantly invested in and upgraded in past decades. It is extremely resilient, but we will start to see the use of the gas network decline quite significantly. It would be a great shame to lose optionality in how we might use that network in the future.

All of this comes back to what is deliverable and at what cost. Unfortunately, we do have to be quite ruthless about what we can afford in order to keep bills as low as possible.

Lord Ashcombe: I agree with that last statement. You mentioned that a lot of gas plants are possibly going to come to end of life, so there is going to be a balance between how much you are going to upscale and revamp them, because that industry spends its entire life rebuilding, rebuilding and rebuilding, against the new.

The Chair: We are coming to that later.

Lord Ashcombe: When will you be publishing the hydrogen strategy? This is always a big question.

Michael Shanks: I know, and, after having been working on this for some time, I can finally say that it will be published very soon.

Lord Ashcombe: What do you mean by “very soon”?

Michael Shanks: Imminently, in fact.

Lord Ashcombe: Will that be this year?

Michael Shanks: I hope so.

The Chair: “Imminently” would definitely mean this year, surely.

Michael Shanks: I hope so, yes. In the Budget, we made very clear that, although we made some difficult decisions about the overall funding, we were releasing the HAR2 invitation to offer, and the hydrogen strategy will be part of that.

Very briefly, in terms of the hydrogen strategy, the previous Government had a very clear commitment of 15[1] gigawatts of hydrogen deployment. My sense even from industry is that that is not a realistic figure, and so we have tried in the hydrogen strategy to be realistic about deployment, but still be really ambitious as a country about what we think we can achieve, and try to set some direction for it, but based on where we think it is practical in terms of delivery rather than an ambition that we do not think is achievable.

Lord Ashcombe: Thank you. We look forward to it.

  1.             The Chair: We will be exploring gas in more detail. Before we move on, I just want to ask about contracts for difference and how they could help with this particular issue.

It was Andy McNeill, I believe, from the Energy Storage Association, who stated that “the contract for difference process has now matured”. What currently happens is that “the developer simply generates whatever it generates and the system operators try to work out how to balance it”. I think that that is correct. He said, “If we can get to a place where we start shaping some of that … at the point of generation, perhaps evolving the CfD process to introduce an element of shaping requirements, as a developer, you then have to put some emphasis on storage”. That makes a lot of sense to me, if we can switch around where the responsibility for producing the storage capacity lies. Is that something that the Government are considering? Bill, I will turn to you first, as you are Mr Markets.

Bill Jones: Contracts for difference is not part of the capacity market. Contracts for difference is a mechanism for bringing forward new development. The question is about the extent to which you put responsibility on, say, a wind generator to also have storage capacity, so that we start to mitigate some of the challenges that we have in terms of excess generation at particular times.

The Chair: We should really be looking to the future, because the idea is that the penetration of renewables such as wind, et cetera, is going to grow very substantially, and we are going to have, as we do at the moment, more and more redundant energy, unless we can do something with it. It seems to me that this is a sensible suggestion.

Michael Shanks: It sounds like a sensible suggestion. I would say two things very briefly. First of all, there is a debate about whether storage has to be next to the generation in order for it to be useful. For example, pumped hydro storage is almost certainly all going to be in the Highlands of Scotland. That continues to have extremely useful system benefits, even if it is far away from where the generation is happening, so the storage does not have to be directly linked.

We are seeing, for example, more solar farms in particular that are looking at batteries alongside solar, so that it can be released into the grid at a more localised level to meet peak demand. We are really interested in that. We are looking at things such as how we can incentivise community batteries so that smaller areas can take advantage of a smart system locally, rather than dispatching it nationally.

The CfD process has been incredibly useful in giving investor certainty to build new projects where we have a high upfront cost, but then a virtually free fuel source and a very marginal cost on an ongoing basis. The cost is the upfront cost of building it. The CfD scheme has now been mirrored across the world as the model, partly because the two-sided nature of it means that there is investor certainty in revenues, and because we, as consumers, also benefit if the wholesale price goes beyond that.

We think it is the useful model at the moment. AR7 and AR8 ran on broadly the same terms as previous auction rounds. We now want to pause before AR9 and look at whether we need some more significant changes to the contracts for difference scheme to make sure that they work for the consumers of the country.

The Chair: We pay economic curtailment payments to wind generators to switch off generation. Surely, in terms of the £1 billion that we pay them to switch off, they could be incentivised to come up with solutions to do something other than not generate that energy.

Michael Shanks: It is definitely true to say that, if we had more storage, we would not be curtailing as much. Far be it for me to defend the developers, but it is not their fault that the generation is not getting to where it needs to get to. That is the fault of the grid. The vast majority of the constraint costs are to switch gas on to meet the gap in demand because we have had to curtail the wind. The answer is to fix the issue with the grid so that we can deploy that generation exactly when we need it, but storage alongside that is absolutely critical. If we can do more in that space, it is a useful suggestion.

  1.             Baroness Rafferty: Thank you for your very helpful answers, Minister. We heard about hydrogen. I would like to ask you a question about biomethane and what plans, if any, you have to boost biomethane production.

Michael Shanks: For a number of reasons, biomethane is important, not least because it is a low-carbon gas that we can inject directly into the existing system. It helps us get to where we want to get to, but with a lower-carbon source. It is also helpful in terms of utilising waste and other things in a more productive way, so it is helpful in terms of various parts of our environmental policy.

We have the green gas support scheme, which helps incentivise this, and we will continue to support that. What we have seen, though, is that it is very small scale, and the market does not appear to be significantly greater than it is at the moment, even if there was a different revenue stream available from Government. We are really supportive, but biomethane generally is a finite resource and has a number of different draws on it, and we do not see it playing a much more significant role in the energy system than it does at present.

Baroness Rafferty: You have outlined many of the challenges in terms of that. One follow-up question might be around R&D. Does R&D have a big role to play here in trying to optimise the various options by which biomethane might play a more important role in the overall supply?

Michael Shanks: Yes, absolutely. There is a huge space around green gases generally to look much more at what is possible in both the use of the gas and in how we more sustainably use the feedstock that is going into it. That helps us solve a number of issues as a country.

There is going to be further deployment through the green gas support scheme. Just to give some sense of scales, we expect that there will be 37 new biomethane plants through the green gas support scheme. They are very small in scale, but they are important and play a really crucial role across the system, so we remain supportive of it. The fact that there does not need to be anything additional to allow it to be injected into the gas grid gives us real opportunity. In terms of anything further that we can do around innovation, we will try to support where we can.

  1.             Lord Trees: We have heard from previous witnesses quite a lot of positivity about biomethane. We have heard from some people that, ultimately, it could provide something like 120 terawatt hours per year, which is a very substantial contribution, and it could be dispatchable, but there seems to be a problem. Do we recognise biomethane as zero-carbon? That is done in a number of countries, but we seem to class it still as of fossil fuel origin, which is a critical difference. What is the impediment to us recognising it as being zero-carbon?

Michael Shanks: I would have to come back to the committee on the specific question. I am sorry; I am not the Minister who deals with biomethane, and I will come back to you on the exact classification. I was not aware of exactly how that is reached. In terms of the scale of the opportunity, industry has referred to 120 terawatt hours. Our sense is that around 30 terawatt hours to 40 terawatt hours is probably deliverable.

Lord Trees: I think that that was by 2050.

Michael Shanks: Yes. As I understand it, that would allow us to reach our net-zero commitment. In terms of going above that, it would be additional to what we need to reach the carbon budgets in any event. This is one of many areas where we are seeing further innovation and development all the time, and it may be that, in the coming years, we will refresh that strategy. I will come back on the zero-carbon point. I am afraid that I am not aware of that.

Lord Trees: It does kill a few birds with one stone. We can use a huge amount of biological waste, which we have problems disposing of, at the same time as contributing to our energy security.

Michael Shanks: I absolutely agree, and this is a good example of the circular economy that we want to see.

Lord Trees: If we could get an answer on this net-zero point, it would be very helpful.

  1.             Lord Rooker: Thanks for coming. It has been very interesting to listen to you. Before I go on to my question, I just wanted to ask you something about the hydrogen policy. We had a piece of negative evidence a couple of sessions ago. It was a discussion about pumping caverns full of hydrogen under pressure, and whether you would want to live on the town on top. There is a public perception issue relating to hydrogen storage. I am not sure if I just heard you say that you expected it all to be up in the Highlands, basically, rather than elsewhere. Is that the case?

Michael Shanks: I think I was referring to pumped hydro storage. Given hydro’s capacity, it is likely to be in the north of Scotland, and perhaps in Wales.

In terms of hydrogen, we are open to looking at the role that hydrogen storage could play. It is likely to be offshore more than onshore storage, utilising some of the space that we have offshore. With all of it, the test for us will be whether it brings additionality to the system and affects bills in a positive way. Otherwise, it is not the job of the Government to theoretically support technologies for the sake of supporting them. They have to play a purpose in the system and, in terms of our number one priority, tackle affordability.

Hydrogen could have a key role in particular with industry. Although we see much of industry moving towards electrification as its decarbonisation route, some will not be able to do that and will continue to need gas, so hydrogen may be the route to that decarbonisation rather than electrification. We are really open to it, but we want to try to make sure, particularly on storage, that it does meet those requirements.

You are right about the public perception of some of these new technologies. We see this, for example, with carbon capture and storage, where industry and Government have to do more to explain the role that this technology plays, and the safety actions. The truth is that we all probably live on top of, or not far away from, significant gas pipes and we do not think about it at all. We have been that way since we changed from town gas to natural gas many decades ago.

You are right to say that hydrogen has an increased public awareness, as does carbon capture and storage, even though it is a well-tested technology in other parts of the world. We need to continue to do all that we can to say that projects are safe and are contributing positively to people in the country, and it is for industry as well as the Government to do that.

Lord Rooker: I fully accept that the heavy investment and the time for these technologies is substantial. We heard from Ofgem and NESO that unabated gas will continue to be the back-up for Dunkelflaute events until low-carbon alternatives are available. We keep telling the public that we are going to need gas for a long time—for decades, in fact—but do the Government have a plan for displacing unabated gas during those events? Is there a timeframe for that? I got the impression from your previous answers that there is still a lot of work to do in that area and that we will be with unabated gas for probably longer than what we have thought.

Michael Shanks: I have often been accused in this job of not talking enough about gas. The reason that I do not is often because of what I said earlier on. The gas network works incredibly well and is incredibly resilient. The electricity network needs more of my focus. That is why I do not talk about it so much, but that should not be taken at all to mean that we do not see as absolutely critical the role that gas will continue to play in domestic heating, in industry, and in power generation for a long time. Even in our 2030 scenarios, we recognise the role that unabated gas would play in a strategic role. That continues to be the case. The dispatchability of gas at the moment is the most important factor in terms of why we will continue to need unabated gas.

Clearly, we want to, wherever we can, introduce CCUS into that, so that we have power generated with carbon capture technology. That is expensive, and there are a number of projects moving forward, but we are supportive of that. We then want to try to bring forward other dispatchable technologies and storage to allow us to displace it, but we still have a view that unabated gas will be important and will continue to be a key part of how we meet our security of supply standards.

We have to deal with the fact, though, that the gas fleet is ageing. We estimate that around 15 of the 35 gigawatts that is currently installed will be 30 years old by the mid-2030s. When people often make this crude comparison between the cost of renewables and the cost of gas, they ignore the fact that the gas fleet also has to be rebuilt and comes with significant capital costs as well. Gas is not a cheap alternative to renewables. We see it as important, but we want to try to move away from unabated gas as soon as we can.

Lord Rooker: Someone is going to have to pay, are they not, at the end of the margin, for what, in effect, is a bit of reserve capacity as we run down? What is the Government’s plan for that?

Michael Shanks: We have consulted on a number of options and have been quite open, unlike in many consultations that Government do, where we consult on the intended outcome. We have been really open in the questions because, in truth, we want ideas about how we might manage the gas fleet differently, including the possibility that the Government just own the very last bit of the gas that we need to generate at that dispatchable moment. Instead of having a gas fleet on the system in a general sense, we deploy it only when we absolutely need it. That is an option. There are a number of other options before we get to that stage as well.

You are right about investability. These plants take a significant amount of time to build and are capital-intensive. The refurbishment is a constant process as well. The capacity market has supported that refurbishment. We will continue to do that while we look at what the long-term future of the gas fleet is and how we get to a place where we are using it only when we absolutely need it on the system.

Bill Jones: There is a distinction between using gas and having gas available. Gas is about 35 gigawatts on the system in terms of capacity, but the load factors and running hours are constantly going down. That creates an economic challenge in terms of making these viable, but it also demonstrates that we are trying to make sure that we rely on it only when we absolutely have to, rather than seeing it as part of the normal generating mix. Dealing with that is quite challenging, especially when we are having to refurbish a lot of old plant if this is going to stay on the system. Refurbishing could still be significantly cheaper than building new plant.

Lord Rooker: The point that I was making, and the message is there, is that, until we have something that we can switch on quickly and safely, we are going to need the gas that we have. There will come a time when the Government or Parliament have to tell the public that everything is okay in terms of intermittency and that we can cope during periods where we need it, and that we will now switch off any more use of gas, but we are a long way from that time, are we not?

Michael Shanks: We are a very long way from that. I would say that we will not reach the point where we do not need gas in any way whatsoever in my lifetime. We have an aim to get to net zero by 2050. That does not mean zero gas by 2050, but we want to try to do everything that we can to reduce its role in the system. If we think of electricity generation, for example, a few years ago it was setting the price of electricity 90% of the time. It is now 60%. It is potentially lower than that now. I have not seen the most recent figures.

As Bill says, the role that it is playing in the system is becoming more and more strategic, and only at those moments when we need the dispatchable power. We want that to continue, but it is absolutely going to remain important for a long time. Some 80% of British homes remain heated by gas boilers. While we have to get away from that as quickly as we can, it is not going to happen overnight.

Lord Rooker: I declare that I bought a new gas boiler last year—

Lord Ashcombe: So did I.

Lord Rooker: —because I have a home in which it is impossible to fit a heat pump. I like the idea of your support for the gas network, because it is fairly unique across Europe and it is a pity that we cannot use it better in terms of hydrogen with the network. I understand that that is ruled out.

Michael Shanks: We want to keep optionality open for that. I would just make a plug for the warm homes loans, which were launched last week. They give households interest-free investment in order to get not just heat pumps but solar panels and batteries in their homes. The technologies are there for anyone who is looking to upgrade.

  1.             Lord Jay of Ewelme: Thank you very much for being with us, Minister. I should declare an interest as I am a former member of the main board of EDF in Paris, so I am well aware of the difficulties of getting nuclear on time. I wanted to give you a further chance now to say a little bit more about gas. It is an extension to the answer that you have just given to Lord Rooker. Can you say a little bit more about the cost of extending the life of the existing gas fleet, what effect that will or may have on consumer bills, both now and in the future, and how that compares with the costs of alternative technologies? Could one of you also say a little bit about what is quite a complicated issue, which is how you compare the costs of different technologies over time?

Michael Shanks: It is a very important question. If I separate out two parts from it, first, in terms of the gas fleet, these are private assets that individual owners will make decisions on about investments in them. What the capacity market exists for partly is to make sure that there is a route to that investment. We buy the power, but part of that includes a recognition of the cost of refurbishing and other costs. Bill might want to say more about that in a moment.

If we are building new plants, the Government are not directly going to build and finance them, but we will put in place the market mechanisms to make sure that there is that investor certainty to justify the capital outlay to begin with.

When we look at them side by side, though, I want to say that the costs of the system that does not involve gas running as often as it does now are all significantly lower. That is not to say that we will not continue to pay for gas as part of that system. It is just that we want to reduce the role that it plays and, particularly, to make sure that it is not the margin price setter as often as it is at the moment, which is the cost that consumers end up paying as a result, but it will remain important.

All the scenarios that we look at—and this goes back partially to the strategic spatial energy plan around how we come off gas in the long term—involve a mix of renewables, nuclear and storage. They come at different costs in order to do that, but they are all lower-cost overall to run the system than it would be on gas.

That is partly because rebuilding the gas fleet comes at a cost, so it is not just the cost of gas; it is also a recognition that, in the last five years, we have gone through two price spikes, where, right now, gas across Europe is at the highest price that it has been since 2022. If we have a power system that continues to be reliant on that gas price, that is what consumers will pay. The last two price caps have been driven entirely by the war in the Middle East. We have to come away from that as quickly as possible so that we control our energy here in the UK and do not have that volatility in the system.

We need to displace gas completely, and this is why the Prime Minister has talked a lot about de-linking. We have deployed renewables but are still too often paying the gas price. Most people, rightly, will not understand why that is the case, and so we need to look further at market reform to make sure that we are paying the true cost of the power that is on the system at the moment.

Lord Jay of Ewelme: Has the international situation at the moment and the price of gas caused you to change your approach in the last year or so about how important it is to reduce the amount of gas and to increase renewables?

Michael Shanks: It reminds us of why we are on this path to begin with. We sat in opposition and watched Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and the Government rightly spending £40 billion bringing down people’s energy bills, but we cannot think that that is an acceptable way for Government to just paper over the symptoms of a system every single time something goes wrong somewhere in the world that drives up bills. We are still paying back, in significant amounts of public debt, the cost of doing that.

We are now four years on, in another fossil fuel shock that had nothing to do with the UK, but we remain at the mercies of international markets and are all paying more on our energy bills again. That is a reminder, if ever we needed one, that we have to get away from this volatility as quickly as we possibly can, which means a clean power system that is nuclear and renewables, and is controlled here in the UK.

That has a capital cost to build, and I recognise that there is some political jeopardy in saying that we are going to spend money on people’s bills now when affordability is a crisis, but, if we do not make these decisions now, we will end up even more exposed in the future and will keep going through these cycles where it is the British public that pay the price for it. If we ever needed a shot in the arm to say, “Let us get going on this”, the current crisis is it.

Lord Jay of Ewelme: What about the broader question of how you compare the costs of different technologies over time? I know that it is a big question, but do you want to say anything about that?

Michael Shanks: There are—

Lord Jay of Ewelme: This is perhaps for Bill Jones.

Bill Jones: It is a really difficult question.

Michael Shanks: That is why I was going to take it.

Bill Jones: It is not only technology-dependent. It is also individual plant-dependent. For example, in the gas space, you can generalise about how much it costs to build a new plant or to refurbish a plant, but it all depends on the individual plant. We expect to be able to bring through the refurbishment of the existing fleet with the existing framework, and with the capacity market as it is, more or less. Dealing with new build is an order of magnitude beyond that, and we are having to think about what the best way is of bringing forward new build to the extent that we need it.

The trouble is that we are always having to try to predict where we are going to be four, five or six years ahead to decide how much more gas capacity we might need. That might give us some indicators about what that looks like, but it also depends on how technologies develop and what happens to demand over time. It is NESO’s job to try to bring all this stuff together to work out what amount of capacity we need. That will give us an indicator about how much dispatchable, enduring capacity that a gas or a gas-like plant might be able to deliver.

  1.             Earl Russell: Thank you, Minister and deputy director. Following directly on from Lord Jay’s really interesting questions, these are some of the most technical and challenging problems that we face, so this conversation is really fascinating. I completely agree with you about the need to try to transition away from gas. We will need to refurbish gas and may need some new gas as well.

My first question is about timeframes for those decisions. With the increasing wait times particularly for purchasing new gas, those decisions are coming at us immediately down the line. Against that is a need to get value for money as set out in the Budget.

Could I ask you really a general question about the lack of time available for making these really important decisions, the complexity of the technological decisions that we are making, particularly about picking new future technologies and particularly for long-duration energy storage, and how you balance that with the need to provide value for bill payers over time? What more can the Government do to communicate these really complicated decisions that they are taking so that the public can begin to get a slightly better understanding of this? I am sorry that that is a big question but it is it is quite an interesting space.

Michael Shanks: No, not at all. It is really important on a number of fronts. On the gas point, supply chains are a real challenge but also a real opportunity right across the energy transition. We have heard from a number of people in the gas system that we could be waiting six years or more for gas turbines.

That is not just a British issue. That is because there is infrastructure being built right across Europe and across the world, so gas is not a quick fix either to some of these things. That is why we want to try to give long-term certainty now. It is also why, as Bill has outlined, refurbishment as much as possible is important. It is also cost-effective for us. We will work through all of those things.

What we are trying to do in a broader sense across the energy system is to work collaboratively to build the supply chain maps here in the UK, so that we can give industry in Britain line of sight across the whole system—networks, nuclear, gas and renewables—to be able to fulfil more of those orders in Britain instead of us constantly doing procurement outside of the UK.

That is critical for our industrial strategy, but it is becoming increasingly clear that it is critical for our energy security because we are competing across the world for the same finite pieces of kit. If we do not build it in Britain, we lose the economic opportunity as well as the capacity to control some of this ourselves, so we need to invest in that as much as possible.

The last point, which gets to the heart of some of the debate that we are having at the moment with the public around energy security and the energy transition, is that we need to articulate an argument that says that we live in an uncertain world and that, regardless of what your political view might be on the climate or any other issues, our energy security here at home should mean having much more of our energy generation in Britain controlled by us, in this country, but that climate change is also a really clear and present risk to the country.

We have lived through the hottest summer on record. It is likely to be one of the coldest summers that we will live through. This is an increasing problem that the public, more than they have done for some time, now feels, and feels the impact of it. Government have a responsibility to act on that, but so too do we have to act on affordability.

The energy trilemma that we talked about on day one coming into government around security, sustainability and affordability is front and centre in people’s minds more than ever before, and it is incumbent on us to make the case for why clean power, as we have talked about, is not just about climate and about security in an uncertain world, but is also the route to bringing down bills. That is not easy, because people see their bills going up at the same time as we are deploying renewables, and so explaining the link back to the gas price and why we remain exposed to that is crucial.

I will say one final thing on this, because there has been a lot of commentary. The transition to a clean power system should rightly be the subject of political debate about whether it is the right thing to do, but I do worry that some of the rhetoric on this is coming down increasingly to the sense that there is risk in terms of day-to-day security of supplies.

It is right that, every single day, NESO balances those risks. It is not right that we have what is an element of scaremongering around the threat of blackouts and other things, with a system that remains hugely resilient and secure, and will help deliver cheaper bills. We have to make that argument more strongly, but I hope that we can try to get some political consensus behind some of that again.

Earl Russell: Thank you. I absolutely agree with your comments.

  1.             Baroness Coffey: We are still with gas, Minister and Mr Jones. It may feel like we have covered some of this ground in terms of back-up supply and strategic reserve. We are in a situation where, as you will be aware, the EU has, on average, 88 days of storage, France over 100, and Germany 62. The UK has about a week. We have also had more emergency notices this year than in any other since 2008.

In a written answer, Minister, when asked about the adequacy of gas storage capacity for this year, you recognised that, “We will further assess whether additional infrastructure, including strategic gas storage, is required, and will publish a full response in due course”. I know, as a Minister, that that normally means never, or that it is on the shelf.

The Government have already said that the cost of a strategic reserve would likely be in the billions of pounds across a 25-year timeline, and we have already discussed extensively the capacity market. There are a number of things coming through in written evidence that we have received, saying that, for example, CCS on gas plants is used rarely and would be an incredibly expensive and inefficient option. One energy firm talks about which of the plants are going to be needed in the future and for how long, and how best to fund them. Meanwhile, other energy companies are basically saying, “Do not create a strategic reserve”. What is the answer, Minister?

Michael Shanks: First, I will just say that “in due course” does not mean never, certainly with this Government. We will respond to it, because it is a really important piece of work. We issued an interim response to give some sense of where the thinking was. The responses that we got were really substantial, and we want to work through the policy development on that. In truth, it is complicated, because there is not an easy answer. Your question quite rightly summarises how some of this is complex.

We want to maintain the optionality of a strategic reserve of gas, but at the same time recognise that we do not use gas storage in the same way as the rest of Europe. About 5% of our gas supply comes from storage. We have a diverse range coming in every day, not least from the UK continental shelf, which still makes up around 40%, as well as our pipeline from Norway and LNG imports.

Storage does not play the same role in our system, but we still recognise, particularly if we look at the current situation, that gas is volatile around the world at the moment. Having a supply of it is clearly crucial, so we want to give that long-term confidence to developers and investors to make their decisions about particular storage sites in the future.

We need to trade that against cost, which comes back to this point about resilience. We clearly want to build the most resilient system that we possibly can, but we cannot, at the same time, spend public money on the most extreme forms of avoiding risks that are very minimal. That is always a trade-off across Government. If you imagine a town that is subjected to flooding, you do not build a flood defence for a one-in-1,000-year flood; you build it for a one-in-50-year or one-in-100-year flood. There are elements of risk management that we have to make here, and we want to explore all of that in detail.

On the wider point about where we make decisions on what to invest in, I am frequently told that I should not be the Energy Minister because I do not have a background in energy policy. I come back to the point that the challenge with this sector is that I could have a meeting with 10 people from the energy world and come away with 20 different, absolutely certain ways that we must build energy in Britain. There is no consensus, which is totally understandable because people come from their own technological point of view. We have to pick our way through that.

In all honesty, we will support some technologies because they play a really strategic role and are worth the investment. For others, even though we might want to see them, we are going to have to be quite strict on the fact that, if it adds money to bills, we just might not be able to support them.

That is partly why the strategic spatial energy plan is important, because it gives investors a real sense of where we are going to focus the majority of our support in the long-term design of the system, but, as I said earlier, I do not want people to think that means that, if you come along with a good idea in Britain, and the investment to make it happen, the Government are going to say no because it does not fit this plan. That is not how we are going to build the system in the future. We need a bit of both.

I am sorry that that does not specifically answer the question, but, in truth, this is a really complicated patchwork of different technologies that will be deployed for different purposes, and we need all of it. Even when we achieve the clean power objectives that we have set out, it is still based on a real mix of technologies, including unabated gas into the future.

Baroness Coffey: I know that Mr Jones will agree with the Minister, but could you perhaps give us a bit more sense of what you might be looking at? To give you an example, you mentioned how the volatility of the gas price is lower than it has been. Recognising that other countries have a lot more storage and even lower volatility, how do you see that working out with your supply balancing? I appreciate that it is formally NESO’s job, but Government still have to have a view. Bringing Jackdaw onboard will help a little bit, but only modestly. I just wonder if Mr Jones had anything to add.

Bill Jones: There is a distinction here between energy security and electricity security, and I am on the electricity security side of the fence. This is very much energy security. As the Minister said, the UK has a variety of sources for bringing in gas. The fact is that we still have the UK continental shelf, which is, in effect, a storage facility for us. Some 40% of our gas need is already in storage in the UK’s space. We have a very different geographic environment compared to a lot of our continental neighbours.

I do not know what the right answer is in terms of how much additional storage capacity we should be using, but what I can point to is the fact that there is going to be a strategy coming out next year about the UK’s energy resilience, and energy security more widely, which will set out how we are going to approach these things.

Baroness Coffey: I hope that is within 12 months.

Michael Shanks: On the point on storage across Europe, it is worth just saying that, although we all hoped that the conflict in the Middle East would be much shorter-term, injections into European storage were at elevated prices as well, and that has not provided that shock absorber from cost. Of course, we are now going into a winter with those elevated prices, which are the highest that we have seen since 2022.

We will come out of that winter with storage at a lower level, and there is no indication that this situation in the Strait of Hormuz will have cleared anytime soon. Although storage plays a really important role, it is worth saying that it is not the safeguard against price spikes that people think it might be. Ultimately, the answer for us as a country is to get off the need for gas as much as we can, and then to get it from a diverse range of sources. You pointed to the decision that we made on Jackdaw, which was about maintaining our energy security, but it does not take a penny off anyone’s bills, whether it comes from the North Sea or anywhere else.

  1.             Lord Ashcombe: Thank you, Minister, for staying a little over. We have had a long discussion about where, what and how we generate. We still have the problem with the grid, which is not fit for purpose in our current situation because of the way that we are generating the power, particularly, as you described, coming from Scotland and everything else. How are we going to square that circle, and how long is it going to take? Everything is heavily interlinked here, and the grid is fundamental.

Michael Shanks: I am really glad that we are closing on the grid. It is absolutely foundational to everything else that we are trying to do in the electricity system. It is 100 years this year since the Electricity Act passed through this place, which laid the groundwork for the first grid in this country. It was upgraded a few decades after that into the super grid. That is basically the bones of what we continue to exist on today, and it has been added to over many years.

I want to just caveat what I am about to say by saying that the grid remains hugely resilient in its current form, but it is not able to add the optionality that we want to see in terms of demand projects, which are really important for the country’s economic growth, and the mix of generation.

People should not think that the grid is not resilient, but every single day we switch lights on and plug phones in and everything else, and expect the grid to do what we need it to do. It does that, but under significant strain. If we are honest, we should have recognised decades ago that the way that we manage the grid in this country has not worked for investing in its future. It has allowed investment to make sure that individual assets are resilient, but has not allowed the investment to build going forward.

That is partly an issue with the way that we have set up the system in this country, which is why the Prime Minister announced Great British Grid, to give some public control to it again, because 40 years of privatisation has not left us with better systems in this country. It has left us more vulnerable, in fact, so we have to change that.

We also, fundamentally, have to spend more money on it. When my party were in government, we started the significant rollout of renewables. We then had 14 years of the previous Government, which I give great credit to for continuing to build renewables, although they do not give themselves credit for it anymore. That was the right thing to do, but we did not build the grids. That is just a mistake that we should all own up to and now try to do everything that we can to fix, which is why we are investing significantly in building it.

It is a really complex picture. Just to give you some sense of what every single week looks like for me, I pore over the details of individual projects to see where they are in the system and where the connection challenges are, because, even if we build the grid, it is such a complex piece of infrastructure. We will have to look at system access to allow outages, and things to connect in. That comes with trade-offs. The construction of these projects is huge. Sea Link got its DCO just this week, but there are a number of other significant infrastructure projects.

We have to build more quickly as a country. We have to be more innovative in how we use the grid that we have at the moment, getting much more out of the system that we have right now, and not just always building more. We have to fix the mistake that we made of building generation without a strategic plan for how we connect it. That cannot carry on anymore as a country.

All of those things need to happen. It is fiendishly complicated. I do not point fingers of blame at anyone, but, collectively, the energy system and the Government have not done their job properly for decades, and we are now left picking up the pieces from that. If we do not invest in this, we do not unlock the opportunities in the future. It is the most important thing in all of the conversations that we have had today.

The Chair: That is excellent. Thank you, Minister, and thank you, Bill Jones. You have been very patient in answering our questions, and we really appreciate the frankness with which you have addressed the issues that we have raised. With that, I call the public session to an end.


[1] Note by the witness: correction to ’10 gigawatts’