24

 

Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy

Oral evidence: Societal resilience: a national conversation, HC 149

Monday 2 November 2026

4.45 pm

 

Watch the meeting

Members present: Matt Western (The Chair); Lord Arbuthnot of Edrom; Catherine Atkinson; Sarah Champion; Mr Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi; Lord Godson; Lord Jack of Courance; Baroness Kidron; Helen Maguire; Mike Martin; Lord Tunnicliffe; Baroness Tyler of Enfield; Lord Watts.

              Questions 24 - 36

 

Witnesses

Becky Heginbotham-Blount, Chief Resilience Officer, Suffolk Resilience Forum, Co-Chair, National Consortium for Societal Resilience [UK+]; Professor Lee Miles, Professor of Crisis and Disaster Management, Bournemouth University Disaster Management Centre.

 

Examination of witnesses

Becky Heginbotham-Blount and Professor Lee Miles.

Q24            The Chair: Today, we are holding the second session of our inquiry, “Societal resilience: a national conversation”. May I ask our witnesses to introduce themselves briefly?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I am the chief resilience officer for the Suffolk Resilience Forum and a co-chair of the National Consortium of Societal Resilience—the NCSR, for short.

Professor Lee Miles: I am a professor of crisis and disaster management at the Bournemouth University Disaster Management Centre. I am also an associate dean of the business and law faculty there, so I am responsible for all things to do with that.

The Chair: Thank you very much. I will kick us off. The UK Public Survey of Risk Perception, Resilience and Preparedness found that 68% of respondents thought that the number of emergencies or disasters would increase in the next 10 years. Obviously, we have had the recent “Be Ready” announcement from the Government, but do you think that the public are sufficiently aware of the risks that we face in our local communities?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Obviously, there is the national risk register, which is public-facing, and we also have the national security strategy, so the documents are out there for those who want to look. Every local resilience forum should have a community risk register—again, that is a publicly available document—to let them know and to localise their risks. Obviously, we have that in Suffolk as well.

When we do community engagement events, those are another opportunity to engage with the public, but there is a balance to be struck. I think that society is quite anxious anyway, so I am not sure that everyone wants to know what all the risks are all the time, but I feel that, as long as they are available to them when they want to find out what they are from trusted sources, and all that is there, it is about finding a balance between not scaring the public with everything and being very transparent. It is there should they want to find it, if that answers the question.

Professor Lee Miles: It goes back to the point about how we see the position of risk. Obviously, we have the national risk register, which provides a clearer idea of how risks are formulated, but risk starts at home, in a sense. Fundamentally, it is about how the individual household or individual citizen sees their own vulnerabilities; it is about that translation.

The other important point to mention is that we have a very complicated aspect here: the mixed messaging that is going on around hazards and risks. It may be about flooding or issues to do with fire, which are often very localised and clear, as well as wider issues to do with strategic geopolitical issues, which are partly coming from the domain of the national security strategy. Those two elements do not necessarily map completely, in the eyes of the public, in the same way.

The Chair: I was surprised to read that 21% of respondents reported being signed up for flood alerts. Does that marry with what you experience, Becky? Do you think that that is accurate?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Sadly, yes, I think that that is accurate. That is what the data suggests.

The Chair: Is it as high as that? I thought that it would be lower, to be perfectly honest.

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: It is something that we have always told the public ever since I have been working in resilience forums—especially in Suffolk, what with it being a coastal county. Our messaging to everyone is, “Sign up for flood alerts”. That generally has been, and will be, our bread-and-butter response, as a local resilience forum, in flood situations. I am happy that the figure is that high but, obviously, it is not as high as we would want it to be. In all of the social media and public-facing correspondence that we have ever had the ability to do, the message has always been, “Sign up for alerts”. It is nice to see that it is that much, but it is also disappointing to see that it is not as much as 100% of people. This is something that we will continue to push as a collective, from a resilience forum perspective, but, for me, that figure probably feels about right when we speak to people and have opportunities to engage with the public.

The Chair: To the point that Professor Miles just made, do you think that there are any particular sectors or types of risk vulnerability about which the public are particularly concerned, in terms of gaps in being prepared or thinking that something is a potentially a real risk to them?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: From my experience of public engagement, generally, when we talk to people about risk—this is mostly face to face at community engagement events—they talk about power cuts and floods. Those seem to be their top risks. Then, when we have our show-and-tell events, with our grab packs and examples of items to put in the household, those always generate conversation. It comes down to asking, “What are you scared of? What do you think about?” It is interesting to find out what people are worried about. People tend to say, “Just power cuts, or if I have to evacuate because of weather”; that comes up as well. Generally, that is the feedback that I receive.

The Chair: Does that vary according to whether you are talking to people from a certain demographic, such as age or background?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: We are also involved with Crucial Crew events, which are multi-agency engagement events for children in key stage 2. Children’s perception of risk is different. It is more fire-focused because, normally, there is an event that children can go to in order to learn about fire safety; again, fundamentally, that covers resilience and having a household evacuation plan. They seem to be more aware of those kinds of risk.

With the elderly and middle-aged demographics, it tends to come down to, “Do I need to evacuate? What do I need to do?” We remind them about flooding, and they have the ability to sign up for free flood alerts; generally, that is the engagement that we get from people. However, Covid and pandemics also come up among the public. Some people ask, “Will there be another pandemic? Will we have to have another lockdown?” Obviously, a lot of people experienced that in quite a traumatic way.

Other risks, such as animal health, do not come up so much. Obviously, we see the whole array of the risk register, but, in the public engagement with which I have been involved, it generally comes down to being able to evacuate safely and flooding.

The Chair: Professor Miles, do you want to say anything on that?

Professor Lee Miles: Basically, on your 21% figure, I would say that there is a difference between awareness and preparedness; that is an important point. The 21% may be a reflection of the fact that we are seeing greater awareness, which is partly due to the fact that we have greater perceived frequency of events; we also have better media awareness and coverage of those events and there are more clear, simplified instructions about where to go and where to look. In that sense, I am probably the opposite of you, in the sense that I would say that 21% is nowhere near where we need to be. We also have the dynamics of climate change, with more frequent weather events, which affect that aspect too. People may become aware and sign up, but the critical question is: what do they do about it? Preparedness is not necessarily at the same level, and we should not equate the 21% with activity across the piece.

​​The Chair:​ I am a child of the Cold War, so the sense of anticipation and preparedness is hard-wired into me. Do you see that in some of the work you are doing— that is, a clear stratification between age groups about the need to be prepared and what they might need to do for resilience?

Professor Lee Miles: There are a lot of competing variables, but the most important point is that it is partly about the individual vulnerability of your own household or community. If you looked within the data of that 21%, you would probably find quite a high number of areas that are already vulnerable to flooding. We have seen more movement in that space, which is good; that is important.

There is another aspect. I led the EM-PREPARE project, which was about empowering preparedness in everyday and household resilience. We found that 75% of households did not have any major measures to do with climate change at all. Something like 69% of UK households were willing to spend only up to one day on improving their preparedness.

That comes down to three things. First, with the greatest respect to the institution I am sitting in, we are living in an environment of lower trust in UK authorities. Citizens do not really trust institutions or advice in the way they used to.

The second point is that we have the economic position of our standards of living, where households and citizens are making choices; they are rational actors. Their vulnerability is related to how they perceive their level of threat or hazard, and how much of their own resources they are therefore willing to invest in it, because resilience also starts at home.

The final point is about new technologies and where people go for information. That goes back to your point about different groups using different sources of information. They may not necessarily use websites or LRFs; they may go to social media or even AI.

Q25            ​​Baroness Tyler of Enfield:​ May I pursue your point about preparedness a bit further? Despite a growing feeling that there is more understanding than there was about the range of threats, there is still evidence that suggests that, as you said, many households are simply not prepared for emergencies. What do you think explains the public’s lack of engagement with preparedness? Do you think that it has anything to do, in terms of the wider geopolitical threats, with the fact that, as an island state, we are not seen as likely to be attacked?

Professor Lee Miles: Let me refer to the previous point. It is about the distance and difference between perception and real risk. For a long time, UK households and citizens did not necessarily perceive the threat of geopolitical threats; they were still there, but they were not perceived as having an impact at home. There was a distance in that, as compared to flooding or high temperatures, which were much closer to home. That is really important in how we look at this.

However, there has been a change, in the sense that, if you look at some of the data, we can perceive that geopolitical aspects are becoming more important in people’s minds. Let me give you some data. When we did the EM-PREPARE study in 2025, we found that the most common perception of risk in households was accidents at home. Only about 5% were concerned about conflict, and only 4% were concerned with terrorism. When we look at the national data, we see that that is now at about 30%, so we have started to see a movement and a linkage, but the linkages are not clear; the cascading relationships are not necessarily clear, either.

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I agree. Other countries, such as New Zealand, often have earthquakes and tsunamis and so have higher risk profiles. They are, therefore, much more prepared. They are a great case study in terms of looking at their general levels of community resilience and their preparedness in how they work. We use them as case studies for good practice and share them through the resilience community. That is reflected across the world, such as in Japan, which has earthquake simulations because they are a real risk for people.

To go back to your comment about the older generation probably being more prepared because of the Cold War threats, remembering World War II rationing and fixing something when it breaks rather than just buying another thing, the mindset is different. There is a bit of a gap in the level of preparedness, which is why I welcome the “Be Ready” campaign to bring up our baseline as a country; to bring back that everyday discussion of resilience; and to get people prepared, so that it is normalised and not scary. Although the Cold War threat probably was quite scary back in the day, we now need to focus on a tangible, real threat: as we go into an El Niño winter, we are preparing for really bad storms and cold snaps, so let us be prepared as a country. Hopefully, that will resonate more with people.

​​Baroness Tyler of Enfield:​ I have a follow-up question. You mentioned the “Be Ready” campaign. Most people are now familiar with having three days-worth of baked beans, et cetera, but do you feel that that campaign, as it currently stands, is sufficient to prepare communities for an emergency? What next steps should the Government consider taking?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I am really happy about it for consistency. Three days-worth is probably a good place to start; obviously, this is very topical on social media at the moment. I have seen that, in other countries, they are saying to have seven or five days-worth. I feel that three days is a good place to start. That now gives all local resilience forums across the UK baseline standard messaging, whereas, before, it came down to capacity in local resilience forums. We are all oddly funded, and it is all a bit inconsistent, so it is really nice to bring back that consistency base level. It is a good place to start, but we could always do better; everything could always be better.

It is good timing, with the winter that we are about to go into. As I say, hopefully, that will resonate more with people. We had the storms at the weekend, and there were lots of people off power, so it is about those building blocks: having not just water and food but candles, torches, spare batteries and power banks in the house. It is about building that resilience conversation in a hopefully not-too-drastic way.

Professor Lee Miles: The obvious and fundamental point is that this is the start of a journey. I had the privilege of working in Sweden for 13 years, where a whole-of-society approach to resilience was being talked about in the 1990s. There, the links to civic society are much closer. It is partly about having a conversation around the things and items that you can immediately speak to citizens about, but it is really about mindsets. It is about developing the mindset that resilience is not just the responsibility of government or the private sector; it also involves citizens.

One of the striking features of the national survey that came out in August was that something like 82% of citizens thought that resilience was fully or entirely the responsibility of government. This means that you do not have a resilient population at all. They do not necessarily see resilience as part of their core business; that needs to be part of that mindset change.

Another point is that, in that survey, there are some very interesting data about where people are challenging the advice—particularly around the three litres of water, for example. Something like 82% of the people in the survey thought that three litres of water would probably not be enough for three days. It would probably last one day, actually, but at least they are getting into a mindset where they are challenging and understanding their own requirements; that takes us a little further down the road where we need to go.

Q26            Mr Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi: Some of us were in the Chamber when the Security Minister made his Statement on the three-year “Be Ready” campaign, asking people to stock up fully for those three days. Professor Miles, do you foresee any issues with the messaging around this campaign, particularly in the cost of living crisis in which we currently find ourselves? Can you see any issues with the messaging?

Professor Lee Miles: From an academic perspective, although I made the point that this is a start, it uses quite traditional mechanisms to connect with the population. The “Be Ready” campaign provides a checklist of things, and it also provides a website where you can go to look for further information. Of course, the register for vulnerable people is an important element, but, as you rightly say, we are in a cost of living crisis.

When we did the EM-PREPARE study in 2025 at Bournemouth University, we found that there is a need to incentivise the population, as rational actors, because you are requiring them to make choices about what they are going to spend their own money on in relation to this. So there is a funding aspect in relation to how you are going to incentivise populations.

As one would expect as you have seen that in the news and in the media, there has been a pick-up, but my final observation is that that has been largely among parts of the population that already share the view that there is more to do on resilience. The real challenge is getting to vulnerable parts of the population, particularly where their standards of living are challenged, and that requires incentivisation. This may mean looking at the extent to which you can build resilience. For example, if people embark on resilience training or do more in their houses, to what extent might they be eligible for lower insurance premiums on their house contents insurance, so that they can share some of the costs? To what extent might you be able to use supermarkets, for example, to provide preparedness packs at discounted rates for parts of the population? Those are the things that will make the difference—where words become actions.

Mr Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi: Moving on to your good self, Ms Heginbotham-Blount, in terms of the cost of living crisis, given your experience, what problems do you envisage with the messaging of the Government’s “Be Ready” campaign?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: We always receive challenge, obviously, in being in a local resilience forum and working with all public sector partners. I champion all of the partnerships but, ultimately, we are here to protect and save lives and to recover and save people, from a resilience perspective.

However, as I said, before this campaign, every local resilience forum was doing its own messaging anyway. Since 2004, resilience forums have been saying, “Be prepared. This is your emergency grab pack. Sign up for flood alerts. Travel safely”. The messaging has always been there. The wording across the UK will, therefore, have been inconsistent because we have all been doing our own things. There has not be national co-ordination on I, so I welcome this consistency, as I said.

The National Emergencies Trust has also created the “Ready Together” campaign, which looks at community resilience for not just place-based communities but community groups; a lot of academic research and time has been invested in that. It looks to be very similar in dovetailing messaging, which, again, is really welcome and will help LRFs be more consistent.

However, the cost of living challenge is a genuine one. At the moment, my feedback to people is that those who can be prepared should be prepared. That takes the pressure off those communities and people who cannot be prepared. The system will aim to look at those people who cannot afford it, but the cost of living crisis is a challenge.

Mr Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi: I want to build on something that you said earlier regarding different nations having taken differing approaches—some three days; others, seven days. We have taken an approach that is similar to the Dutch approach, at around three days. How well do you think communities will engage? What do you think their response to the Government’s “Be Ready” campaign will be? Do you think that it will be positive, overall, or that some of them will take it as a bit of a joke? I know that there have been videos floating around on social media. Do you think that we are serious enough, or do you think that the Government should be doing something a bit different?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Obviously, it has only been two weeks, so we have not yet seen the proper impact in terms of how this is landing in Suffolk, but, before I came here today, I asked all my colleagues, “Can you give me your agency’s feedback?” We have a resilient communities co-ordinator, who is plugged into the local infrastructure organisations—and so has a big outreach to lots of charities and communities—and who is trying to feed how it is being received back.

At the moment, it is a very mixed bag. You have community groups who want to be engaged; there are amazing examples of really robust community groups that have the time, effort and drive to want to be engaged. They are great because they have always been engaged and always will be. Whatever the message is, they will help amplify it.

However, much of the country’s groups and communities are not engaged. You have to meet people where they are at. Some people will be overloaded and overwhelmed with too much news and too much information, which could have a really bad effect. Then you have other people who are interested at the time of an emergency: they do not have the capacity to give their time every week but, if there were a major disaster or an emergency, they would want to be engaged. It is about recognising that there is a wide variety of views.

Mr Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi: Coming back to you, Professor Miles, this is obviously a serious issue. Do you think that the Government are taking it seriously enough, or do you think that it is becoming a joke? What do you want to see happen around community engagement with the “Be Ready” campaign?

Professor Lee Miles: The important thing about the “Be Ready” campaign is turning it into a “Being Ready” campaign; that is the fundamental point. What I mean by that is that we are in a position where we are at the start of the journey: the Government have outlined the kinds of thing that citizens need to take into account in their own lifestyles. That is an important start, but, as I said before, it will be activated only when you turn words into actions done by parts of society that, at this point in time, can afford those things or have high levels of vulnerability.

In the checklist, there is a recommendation to take your time, so we will have different levels of resilience across the population because it will take people time to develop that. Of course, we also have the point about the frequency of events, which says that your resilience capacity could be wiped out very quickly by a series of events that take place over a summer—like the hot summer we just went through—or major flooding events, which are now happening with greater frequency. For me, therefore, the important thing is that the next step in “Be Ready” should be about providing financing for incentivisation and working with businesses to achieve that, because there is a market for new products that are accessible for citizens to be developed. That is important.

The second element is linking all that up, as part of collaboration and connections. It is very important that citizens are linking their flood awareness and what is actually happening, weather-wise, with their level of resilience, because the two things are related at different points in time: you may need higher levels of readiness in your own house than before. Basically, we are saying that there needs to be a policy where we are making our own citizens the risk managers of their own households; that requires further information and more conversations to take place.

Q27            Lord Arbuthnot of Edrom: I was a bit surprised that you said that we have an anxious population, because my assessment—I may be wrong; you have closer knowledge of this—is that the “Be Ready” campaign did not result in any sense of alarm in the population. It just resulted in a reduction in the number of baked bean tins in the supermarkets, which is exactly what we wanted. Are you sure that we are anxious?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: From my observations, generally—I say this as a mum as well—I see what my children and their friends are fed. I would not say that they are anxious in relation to this campaign; I just think that, in general, there is so much negative news. There is so much concern and anxiety that is not to do with this campaign at all; it is just there, in general. We are fed more and more negative and bad news. You turn on the radio and, every hour, there is really bad news. If you start adding in, “These are your risks”, it could be handled really badly. I do not think that it has been, at all—that was not a comment in relation to the campaign; I am just talking about the general level of nervousness that I see through public engagement at community events. When you ask people what they are worried about, they say, “What if I have to evacuate?”, so we produce evacuation cards, household plans and that type of thing. From my observations, I would say that we are a bit anxious.

​​Lord Arbuthnot of Edrom:​ In some Scandinavian countries, there have been exercises involving the general public. Might there be a role for such exercises in this country? If so, how would we engage a potentially apathetic country in them? Do you have any ideas on that?  

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Yes. It would be nice to do an exercise with the public. I would really like that, but only for those who wanted to engage; again, I would not want to force people who did not want to engage. We do rest centre training, and we engage with members of the community who are already proactive and want to be engaged in community resilience. A lot of people volunteered to set up the village hall as rest centres and volunteered for first aid training.

I say “we”—we are lucky in Suffolk because we are a trailblazer LRF, so we are funded by the Government, but a lot of LRFs are not. Again, it is inconsistent across the UK. Those who can engage would do so. It would be nice to have exercising and invite those who wanted to be involved, but I would not want to force anyone who did not want to do it.

Professor Lee Miles: I have three points. First, on your point about what you might call complacency, I do not want to put words in your mouth, so I will use the word “apathy” in relation to this point. Of course, it depends on which parts of the population you are talking about, as well as the extent to which they make a connection with geopolitics, which we have talked about. We have talked a lot about flooding, but the geopolitics are now becoming much clearer, and the connectedness is important.

The main bit of work is around supply-chain resilience, because that is where your connection is. To reinforce a previous answer, that is where the understanding comes—for example, in understanding how a cyber attack on an electricity power station may lead to darkness, not just of the electricity variety but a digital darkness, which is one of the major concerns here. That requires citizens to have wind-up radios or whatever, so there has to be that cascading linkage.

Of course, I am a professor of a disaster management centre that would argue that, in order to really make risk understood, you need to exercise, and that exercising has two purposes. One is changing mindsets: if people are complacent or do not understand what the major issues are, exercising allows them to understand some of the issues better and, from that, to challenge whether they are ready or not. It greatly improves awareness. The point about whether having an exercise will, by default, lead to the population being more prepared is a much more moot point—probably not, but it would mean having a debate on what kind of exercising you need and where.

There is an opportunity, with the changes to our devolved governance, to do much more localised events of that kind and to work with the LRFs. That is the place to start. For me, fundamentally, exercising is about creating trust and expectation. It is important that it is done not at the national level, because that would be incredibly expensive and difficult and the distance to the impact might be large, but at the local level. Localised is the place to start, and that may start with communities.

​​The Chair:​ We were going to go to Helen Maguire, but we will come back to her because we need to sort out a technical problem.

Q28            ​​Sarah Champion:​ Lord Arbuthnot, I am going to push against you, I am afraid. The way in which the “Be Ready” campaign was announced was utterly chaotic and caused panic. I am not sure where you all shop, but my supermarkets were stripped of toilet rolls, beans and water. Although I have sympathy with Lord Arbuthnot, in that it made people buy the right things, I do not believe that the supermarkets had any advance notice so that they could have stocked up on these things. That concerns me. Did different government departments have any advance notice? At a local level, Becky, did your resilience group in Suffolk have any advance notice so that you could have cascaded these messages out in a more measured way? That is my first question, which is specifically for you.

For my second question, can you expand on that a bit, professor? Do you see a joined-up approach across government and local agencies? For example, I chair the British-Taiwanese All-Party Parliamentary Group. In Taiwan, children are taught from primary school about risks, resilience and preparedness. Are you seeing that sort of integration happening in our country? First, though, Becky, did you know that it was going to happen?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: We did. I am not sure whether it was a month’s notice, but we did have prior warning. The Cabinet Office sent out some top lines to say, “Be prepared. A comms campaign will be coming out”, which they sent out to local resilience forums and their partners.

​​Sarah Champion:​ That makes me happy. May I turn to the substantive question? 

Professor Lee Miles: There are two points here. The first point is that there is always a tension between “just in time” and “just in case”. It is an illustration that, as you move into more forms of resilience, that tension becomes quite pronounced. Collaboration with the private sector becomes quite important, but that may not necessarily be as good as we would like it to be; that is the first thing to say, and that would be expected. Can you remind me of the second question?

​​Sarah Champion:​ Do you have an assurance that the resilience message is going across all the different government departments and is then co-ordinated across local authorities, police forces and the NHS?

Professor Lee Miles: The direct answer is no. I do not have that assurance because it has just started out. On the linkages between departments, the danger is that resilience means different things to different departments; that is one of the fundamental points. Part of the strategy now, as part of the national security strategy and the national resilience action plan, is, as one would suspect, to build greater collaboration between them. That is part of the discussion around what resilience means.

If you take supply-chain resilience, for example, which is the point you are mentioning, that involves large numbers of ministerial departments in different contexts. It has implications for LRFs and subnational government as well. We probably need to have more detailed case-by-case analysis flowing through departments, as well as clear definitions of what resilience means in that understanding. It is about definitions and flow-by-flow co-ordination.

​​Sarah Champion:​ The main question that I am getting from my constituents—and, indeed, my mother—is: what are we being ready for? If people had been given that answer, they might have been able to make more informed and less reactive decisions.

Professor Lee Miles: Yes—“Ready for what?”, if you want to put it that way. I reinforce the point that, when you talk about risks or hazards, the vulnerability or the risk is partly defined at the localised level. I am not necessarily convinced on what the priority for the nation is, apart from having national risk registers. You will end up with a common perception of what risk is across the country, because it is localised by its very nature. That is the fundamental point.

It is also localised by what you might call a gender group, or in relation to different parts of our society. The question is: how do you build a whole-of-society approach to resilience when society is, in effect, not whole? That is a real challenge because it means that you have to have a differentiated strategy to apply to different points. What the “Be Ready” checklists are doing is giving you a way to understand the kinds of thing you need to think about and the level you are at.

What the “Be Ready” checklists are doing is giving you a way to understand the kinds of thing you need to think about and the level you are at. It is down to households and citizens to decide whether they need to do more or less in relation to their own localised environment. That is the place to start, I think.

Of course, the fundamental point is that you may not necessarily make everybody resilient. At one level, it is a choice, and these things are part of that choice. That means getting down to trust and how we can build it. For me, in effect, part of the “Be Ready” campaign is about how we can build trust in not just the message but the action and meaning behind the message. That requires a level of trust.

Q29            Lord Watts: My question is for Becky because of her role. How well understood do you think the division of responsibility, between local and central, is? What lessons, if any, have we learned from Covid about being prepared? Are you involved in co-ordinating first and second responders’ roles in what you do locally?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I am so sorry—what was your first question?

Lord Watts: It was about the division of responsibility between central and local government in a crisis. Is it clear what the Government’s responsibility is and what a local area’s responsibility is?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Do you mean my role as a chief resilience officer?

Lord Watts: Yes.

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I would say that it is quite clear because local resilience forums have been around since 2004, and we have had a lot of floods, storms and other incidents—as well as Covid—where we have stood up our command-and-control co-ordination structures really effectively. Every time we have one, we debrief and learn from it. We also have a really good relationship with our government liaison officer. We use MCHLG as our government department to go across government for whatever we need—unless there is something specific, in which case we have the Department for Transport, for example, there, as well as MCHLG. That works really well.

What lessons have we learned from Covid? There are so many. One example for us in Suffolk was having one standing command-and-control co-ordination function. When our Covid response was happening and we had storms and tidal surges coming in, rather than having loads of different command structures—the public sector is so thin and so cut, we did not have the capacity to have lots; it would also have been very confusing—our major lesson was to have one structure to deal with all of the concurrent incidents at once, with the right people around the table. It also meant better connectivity. Before Covid, that would not necessarily have happened; we would have tried to deal with things differently because all of it would have been theoretical.

Last year, we had Exercise Pegasus, which was a national pandemic exercise. That was really good because it was five years on from Covid and it got everyone in the room again. Before that, organisational learning and memory was lost, and people retire. We were there to capture the lessons learned, because it was such a unique incident as compared to a flood; pandemics require a very different response.

It is about making sure that that learning is definitely embedded in our plans and frameworks. It keeps our eye on the ball. To echo the sentiments expressed earlier, exercising is where it is amazing and where things happen. You learn from the lessons. What was your final question?

Lord Watts: What about first and second responders? Are they co-ordinated with your strategy?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: They absolutely are. Our day-to-day work includes working with category 1 and 2 responders. Every local resilience forum is set up slightly differently, but they all, I hope, engage well with category 1 and 2 responders. Building those relationships in peacetime, outside of incidents, is key to doing all of the planning and risk assessments together so that, when there are incidents, everyone is familiar with them.

I am really lucky. In Suffolk, we have such a strong resilience forum in that sense. We know who our cat 1 and 2 responders are. Again, it is a bit of a postcode lottery across the UK, because we are all funded slightly differently and we have different capacities. On the whole, though, I can say from my experience that it works very well.

Lord Watts: Do you have a strategy document that deals with this and sets out all the things we have been talking about?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Yes—we have local resilience forums’ business plans, which outline people’s responsibilities during incidents.

Lord Watts: It might be useful if you could send us a copy.

The Chair: Is that standardised across the country?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: No.

The Chair: We will come on to that.

Q30            Helen Maguire: Can you explain a bit about the role that the education sector—that is, schools and colleges—and companies can play in this whole-of-society approach? Is anything happening now to make people more aware and ready? We spoke earlier about how people who lived through the world wars are much more resilient and understanding, whereas we are in a different situation today. This question is for both of you.

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I really wish that it was on the curriculum. I would love all children and teenagers to have resilience in their curriculum; I would really welcome that, and I hope that we can do it.

As I mentioned earlier, we have Crucial Crew events, which are aimed at children in key stage 2 and are a really fun day of activities for them to learn resilience across a wide variety of different sectors. Again, though, not every local resilience forum does them; it is very hit and miss. Some areas have none. Some areas have really good education packages and do something different, but it is very inconsistent, which is such a shame. I really feel that, if you invest in children, they get inspired by it. They go home and tell their families. It is such a nice way to build resilience and build community pride; it is just a brilliant thing to do.

We do a lot of engagement with charities through our resilient communities co-ordinator. Again, we are very lucky that we have the funding to have someone to do that but, again, Suffolk is different to other LRFs, which may not have this capacity. It is very inconsistent. I would really welcome it as a baseline across the country in order to build that foundation resilience. It goes further than just resilience to shock events; it is about things like growing your own food. We could be more resilient in so many ways.

Helen Maguire: Professor Miles, perhaps you could outline the company side?

Professor Lee Miles: Certainly. On the education side, I may have a conflict of interest, in a sense. I should allude to that very quickly; it relates to smart schools and smart education spaces. When I was in Scandinavia, all of that was built in. It is about the civic part of society. Education is not just about educating society; it is about building our civic capacity as well. That starts with education and children. It is often argued that, to get into households, you have to influence mothers and that part of the family, who are really the relevant householders in relation to building resilience from within. You build it as a generational piece.

Our FE sector has a major role to play in building our technical capacity—particularly around data science and computer science, which we are going to need for messaging. Then, of course, we have undergraduate and master’s degrees, in which professional practice is taught—including at my own institution.

In relation to business, it is often argued that 80% of all recovery is funded by the private sector. Actually, it takes place through construction companies. It takes place through finance and insurance. Collaboration between the public and private sectors is at the heart of any successful crisis management and resilience strategy.

The fundamental point, however, is that we must make sure that the Government and the public sector do not see business as just an asset that is used by them according to their own plans, because they have their own plans and resilience priorities. They also have the potential to act as a market. If we think about the climate, for example, with CFCs, we saw major changes in consumer behaviour simply through their ability to make resilience a market for new products to be developed, from attitudes to flooding all the way through to supermarkets providing different types of resilience kits; that element is there as well. Business collaboration is key.

At the localised level, this is very important because, as part of any local resilience forum, you need to involve your business leaders, who are often part of your local resilience infrastructure as well. They become really important as part of that play.

Q31            Baroness Kidron: My question builds on your last answer, Professor Miles. You alluded earlier to supply chains and information resilience. What level of concern do you have around our dependence on some of the technology companies, in terms of information, AI and other things, which are now absolutely central to our government services infrastructure? I just wonder whether that comes into your purview, because a lot of this discussion is about local government but we are not quite talking about the tools through which those communities speak to us and to each other.

Professor Lee Miles: I am going to talk as a professor—an independent scholar, in that sense. I have real concerns about the relationship between the trajectories, where we have an increasing movement of digital optimisation across government and across all parts of society, and about building resilience. That is an important point for us to consider; we can think about it in a number of ways.

The first is that most of our critical infrastructure requires us—and, in addition to that, most of the ways that our citizens do business require us—to have a digital imprint and provide those digital services through power. What if power is then undermined? Often, for example, if there is major storm damage and our mobile phone networks are damaged, citizens who use their mobile phones as their main way of accessing huge amounts of information, which is related to resilience, cannot do so. So the first point is: how do you reconcile the movement of digital optimisation and maintain resilience? The “Be Ready” checklist is also about having wind-up radios and battery capacities in case the net goes down or, for example, the power goes down, as it did in Spain and as we have seen in the past couple of years. There is a real tension within that.

The second point is that, when you are trying to access certain parts of our society, the gen Z group, in particular, are increasingly using AI solutions and digital solutions as their main point. At a conference last week, it was cited to me that the average person in Europe now uses AI 16 times a day. That is a fundamental point. If your main way of accessing information is not going to websites or social media but using AI, your “Be Ready” metrics—how you transfer that information to those parts of society—have to be highly digitised and digitally aware. That information has to be picked up by AI systems, according to the metrics that they use—the algorithms and so on.

We do not have that in “Be Ready”, although it is in the logic of where we need to be. There are different parts of society, and, the more digital they are, the more they may seem to be easier to contact, but they are using different forms; for example, when it comes to the “Be Ready” website, most data shows that, this year, with the introduction of AI systems and new systems into our search engines, there has been a huge drop in website footfall in general. People are not using sites in the same way, so relying on websites as a way to communicate “Be Ready” messages to the entire population may mean that you are speaking only to some, not all.

Baroness Kidron: To follow up on that, do you have concerns about our lack of sovereignty over certain sorts of infrastructure—let us say, satellite, GPS and things like that—which might be the cause of a crisis, rather than the result of one?

Professor Lee Miles: To be clear, I am not an AI specialist—I will make that disclaimer first. However, any reliance on an AI system incorporates risk. AI usage is very good at improving things: it lowers cost, it makes things more convenient, and, hopefully, it is going to make things better. When it goes well, it should make things go better, but what happens when AI goes wrong? You need redundancy, and that means that you need to build human factors into your human training.

This becomes important in how you develop AI systems, but it also means that, as part of the “Be Ready” campaign, citizens still have to have human readiness if those systems go down—particularly because they are becoming more reliant on them. That means  that they are deskilling and disempowering themselves, but they need to be more ready for situations, where they are not. That is the Catch-22 we are moving into.

Baroness Kidron: Becky, do you have any thoughts on that?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: No. My job is just to deal with the consequences it goes wrong and we have no data, rather than the thoughts leading up to it. It is about being prepared for the fallout.

Q32            Mike Martin: I want to pick up on another stat from the survey that the Chair cited earlier. The UK Public Survey of Risk Perception, Resilience and Preparedness found that 14% of people felt that their local resilience forums—actually, it did not specifically use that term, but they talked about their local authorities—were ill prepared to deal with risk. Professor Lee, do you think that that is a fair and accurate assessment?

Professor Lee Miles: If I may cite the survey back to you, it is interesting that, basically, there is a series of questions in that survey talking about what individuals perceive at a national level—that is, across the UK. Only around 14% of the people surveyed thought that the UK was totally or largely ready. We see 14% largely for local authorities, and we see about 10% for communities. So there is quite a static picture across the groups at all levels: about 10 to 14% think that, in reality, the Government are largely prepared. The important thing is that 45% to 50% do not think that we are prepared at all, across all of those different levels. Does that mean that we are missing a systemic approach across all levels, or do we need to tailor our powers and changes to improve where the localised elements are? We will come to know that in part from the survey and partly from work by local resilience.

Mike Martin: Can I try a hypothesis on you? Some 73% of people had never heard of their local resilience forum. I am the MP for Tunbridge Wells. You might have seen that we recently had the water being knocked off repeatedly. I tell you, I had not heard of an LRF before, but, suddenly, when that crisis came along, it proved very useful. In this new world—I know that Becky is in this trailblazing field and that there is more money going to it; we visited Strategic Joint Command last week, and it is starting to plug into the local resilience forums—is there a strategic communications campaign around what LRFs are, what they do and how to plug into them? Do you think that that would help people feel as though things are being done?

Professor Lee Miles: Basically, regional or local resilience cannot be reliant on one institution.

Mike Martin: It is a mesh.

Professor Lee Miles: It goes back to being about households, communities and the regional level first. Part of the role of the LRFs is to deal with specific issues and challenges, but they are, in effect, a co-ordinating element to deal with those parts. I will not take any more of the floor off my established colleague, but I will say that resilience at the regional level is not just about LRFs; you also need to finance and raise their profiles if they are the main institutions that you have at this point.

Mike Martin: So, Becky, it is a mesh, but the LRFs are the co-ordinating piece. Do we need to advertise them?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I really think that we do, which is why we are piloting this at the moment. It is good that we have the national risk register, so that people know what the risks are, but we should also be publicising them. This goes to your assurance around how we deal with the co-ordination function. That is what we do. It is what every partner does—all the statutory stuff. There is a lot of work that could be done to positively promote the idea of, “Here is the risk, but here is the mitigation”, so that it is not just about risk and there is a level of public co-ordination. So much positive, good work happens in the background, but you are absolutely right: people do not know what resilience forums are.

Mike Martin: So, Becky, if we think about the way humans work, they tend to like to relate to another person. So do LRFs need a spokesperson? Who would that be: the chief resilience officer or the local MP? Would it be the chief exec of the council? Is it worth having someone who is the designated spokesperson so that everyone in, say, Kent—I live in Kent—knows, “Oh, that’s the resilience person. We need to rely on them”?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I think so. That is what we are piloting at the moment with the chief resilience officers, but also via MPs and local leaders. The local resilience forum is a massive partnership of loads of agencies, but we put our “Suffolk Prepared” stamp on it. When partners—including the voluntary sector, which engages with us—put out their preparedness messaging with the “Suffolk Prepared” logo, that builds awareness. We need to try to create trust in that public branding. It can be a confusing space, and there are issues with misinformation and disinformation during incidents and emergencies. If we can build a portfolio to advertise what happens when all the partners come together, which is amazing work, people will start to realise that there is “Suffolk Prepared”, “Norfolk Prepared”, “Essex Prepared”, and they will become aware of it. It is a huge change from how things have happened before, but I feel it is worth trying just to see if it would help.

​​Mike Martin:​ I would like a quick one-word answer from both of you. Would you say that there is a role for the local MP in that?   

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Yes.

Professor Lee Miles: Yes, of course.  

​​Mike Martin:​ The reason I bring this up is that, as the Cabinet Office is writing its documents—as we know, we have just established a COBRA-level civil resilience thing that is plugging into the LRFs, Standing Joint Command and all the rest of it—it is trying to write the MPs out of it so that they do not have a role, so this is an interesting thing that we want to pick up. We picked it up last week at Standing Joint Command.

Moving on to another matter, Becky, you are a trailblazing organisation with partner funding responsibilities. Is it set out to you clearly enough how and where you should spend that money?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Every local resilience forum was invited to bid as an expression of interest, and the top lines were as follows. It asked: if you were centrally funded, how would you increase resilience in your area? There were some strategic objectives, one of which was political accountability, which is why I am really surprised over this paper, because it literally says in there, “We want a chief resilience officer”. The three pillars are political accountability, integration and strategic leadership, and you were asked how you can strengthen them. I think every local resilience forum submitted a plan and then, in the end, there were only five trailblazers in total, including three rural ones.

Mike Martin:​ Did that process work?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: That is what we are now doing. We are all trialling slightly different things because we are all set up so differently. Political accountability in Suffolk is different because we have not gone through LGR or devolution. Northumbria has, so it has a resilience board, but we do not. We are piloting this at the moment, and an independent evaluation is happening through ICF, which MHCLG has commissioned to look at this, to track our progress.

​​Mike Martin:​ Finally, the Government are reviewing the CCA. What do you want to see coming out of that review? 

Professor Lee Miles: This partly feeds into what you were just talking about. Some tidying up really needs to be done, in particular around the CNI—the critical national infrastructure—being included in our definitions of resilience in a much clearer way. That is important. It is there, but it needs to be very clear. What is also important is what you might call an alignment or coterminosity of the regions, because one of the challenges for the LRFs is that the regions do not map. Our health authorities, police trusts, regional governance and fire services do not align in many places and that creates a co-ordination headache of its own kind and brings in the political accountability question about how many you need and so on. Fundamentally, that needs to be a major issue.

The other point is that we know from the Covid experience that the role of devolution was particularly important in the way that it was dealt with across the different territories, and we need to modernise to reflect that, which is really important.

Alongside any modernisation of the Act there needs to be what you might call a financing or funding framework to make this work. I am very conscious that resilience is an expensive activity; there are no two ways about it. It is an expensive activity, but it should be fundamentally at the heart of the nation if it is about saving lives, protecting property, reducing casualties and all the issues that we have in mind. But it is a shared competence and that needs to be more clearly identified, particularly around our category 1 and category 2 responders.

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I agree 100% about the funding, not just to local resilience forums like our secretariat teams but to our partners—every single partner that makes up the resilience forum. That investment in emergency planning and resilience within them to help bring them together would be invaluable. If there was a funding model in there, I would really welcome that, and coterminous boundaries would absolutely make business work so much easier. Those are the top two lines of what I would like to see from that review.

Q33            ​​Lord Tunnicliffe:​ Something that interests me is management culture. My experience, having worked particularly in airline and railway, is that there is a dramatic difference between really good crisis managers—we frequently call them operational managers—and top leadership. That does not mean that one cannot do the other, but they need training to make that change. The talk so far is, “Get all your preparation right”. Well, that cannot be wrong, can it? It is motherhood, and I am in favour of motherhood, but however well you prepare, it will go wrong, at least in part, and you will then need people who are able to make decisions quickly and to resist those decisions being mucked about with or overly debated, and so on. Are those people in existence? If they are not, do you not need to do more training for people to be able to move into those slots when there is a real crisis?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: I totally agree that strong leadership is essential in resilience. Luckily the UK Resilience Academy has realised that too and is looking at management courses, from standardisation through to strategic co-ordination group chairs, and the strong leadership to be able to do that. In my experience, I am really lucky that our senior leaders across our partners and our category 1 and 2 responders are strong leaders. I have seen really good examples of that, but I can speak only for Suffolk.

​​Lord Tunnicliffe:​ Did they manage to accept that they may not be the same person? I was a senior manager, and I was very lazy and took decisions very gently. I had a brilliant crisis manager who found he had a full-time job not just running the troops who did the crisis management but all the time looking at our area of responsibility to see where we could do better.

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Yes. The most successful workstreams are with the people who care about it, have a passion for it and are good leaders. Those people tend to land in the right roles. Every time we have a response situation, we have a debrief afterwards and feed back; if someone was not particularly strong or needed development, we feed that back so that it is picked up. Generally, especially in resilience, you need people who are passionate and care about it so that they can lead and make those swift decisions in an emergency situation.

​​The Chair:​ We are running out of time, I am afraid, so I ask that questions and responses be as tight as possible. Lord Jack will demonstrate. 

Q34            ​​Lord Jack of Courance:​ Thank you. I normally do it, but this time I am going to go a bit off script to pick up on something Professor Miles said a moment ago about the Civil Contingencies Act. You mentioned devolution and Covid. I wonder whether you would agree with me that, in reviewing the Civil Contingencies Act, we should, for something like a virus that knows no borders, be in a position where the devolved Administrations and the Westminster Government work together on the same page, rather than having different rules in different parts of the country and creating confusion, and that we should have clearer messaging. Would you agree with that?

Professor Lee Miles: That is a fundamentally political question. From the crisis management perspective, I would agree that co-ordination is best, and therefore—

​​Lord Jack of Courance:​ That is perfect, thank you very much. I will move on to my next question. Becky, the Government’s resilience action plan has been announced, and there is a range of measures to support public sector resilience. Do you think these measures address the right challenges facing local resilience forums?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: Yes, I would say so, and I welcome the framework and the resilience action plan. Broadly, it is a standardisation and it sets us all in a new direction from 2004.

​​Lord Jack of Courance:​ Do you think that the Government’s commitments go far enough to support LRFs in preparing local communities for emergencies? That is a question for both of you. 

Professor Lee Miles: More needs to be done. I made the point that resilience is an expensive element. Also, if we are, if you like, moving the level of responsibility on to LRFs in a bigger way in any changes in the Act, that requires equal funding to achieve that. Otherwise, you set them up to fail in various aspects; they will not be able to deliver what they are supposed to. The fundamental point, if we change the CCA, is that we have seen that LRFs are moving very much into risk reduction and preparedness, not just response and parts of recovery. This requires transitions of membership to be clear as well, because you need different experts at the table at different points; we should be building that aspect into our frameworks and funding models.

The Chair: We will now move on to the national conversation.

Q35            Lord Godson: Thank you for your testimonies. I have two questions: one is a “big picture” question; the other is more granular, in the light of your use of the old formula of “just in time” versus “just in case”. That is a thread that perhaps runs through everything; it ran through deliberations during the Cold War on emergencies, “Protect and Survive” and all that. First, what are your thoughts, at the end of 2026, on how to balance educating people with not panicking them? That was touched on by one of the Commons Members who spoke earlier; I would be interested in your thoughts on that.

The second question is the more granular one. As a former media man myself, what is the role of local media in educating people to rebut misinformation and disinformation? I am specifically interested in the sources—for example, in Suffolk—of disinformation and misinformation. Where do they come from?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: When it comes to the balance between giving people information and not scaring them, the “Be Ready” campaign has been okay at doing that. It was a soft launch, it is a three-year campaign, and it has started with the priorities. That is right, and it seems to be working. There would always be a risk of panic buying if it went harder, so I am really happy that it did all that.

Locally, BBC Radio Suffolk has been a good supporter. I have been on a show there, and it has done some filming of the rest centre training, which was nice. It is reputable, it verifies its news sources and, hopefully, the public will go to it in a crisis.

However, disinformation on social media is very easy, and, as you mentioned earlier, AI products can rapidly spread disinformation. So what we try to do before an incident, and what we are trying to do now, is establish our own trusted Facebook pages—because people will go on to Facebook—as well as linking in with community groups that already have well-established Facebook pages. It is about identifying community leaders who can amplify our messaging now. It comes back to the question of trust: there may be no trust in a person in a suit on the telly, but people might trust their established community leaders. Building those relationships now is how we are trying to manage that.

Lord Godson: To get granular, can you give us any flavour of where that misinformation/disinformation comes from? Are there any ideological strains where that is particularly manifest?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: It is just people going online—to Facebook, for example, or their AI stream or Twitter. It can come from anywhere. I would not say that I am aware of anything specific.

Professor Lee Miles: I will answer the misinformation question first. It is really about understanding each other’s positions; that is an important thing to recognise. We do a lot of work at the Bournemouth University Disaster Management Centre on training and building trust between different parts of what you might call the resilience network. Part of the challenge for journalists is that their imperative is to find out what happened, who is to blame, what the causes are—all those elements. When you are dealing with an incident, you may want to lock down the situation and stabilise it, so finding out the causes may take time. Often, the work that we do is about twinning and training, so that journalists change roles and there is an understanding from that. You can manage expectations between those two elements. That is the granular point.

The point to end with is: how do we link “Be Ready” actions with trust? Really, it is about managing expectations. At the big level, there are four Es that we need to consider. First, we have to trust that the public will not necessarily be frightened. They can make decisions on their own, and we have to be careful that we do not take a top-down approach and provide information and direction in a society that no longer trusts its institutions in the way it did. It is about enlightened context—that is, explaining the connections between the cascading effects.

The second E is about empowering choices so that, in effect, citizens can make choices, within this resilience framework and checklists, about what they should invest more in. That enables actions, which the third one: providing incentivised schemes and different types of financing so that people and parts of society can be improved.

The final element is evaluating outcomes. Enlightened context, empowering choices, enabling actions and evaluating outcomes are the four Es that are a good way of moving things forward.

Q36            The Chair: I want to ask you one final question. What are your thoughts about mayoralties? Are they more effective in delivering local resilience than, say, county-type structures? I am looking at you, Becky, and thinking about your work and experience. Do mayoralties have too much on their plate, or do you think that they are better placed to handle incident-type responses?

Becky Heginbotham-Blount: There are benefits. I am not in a strategic mayoral authority but, from looking at other LRFs that are, there are benefits from being in a strategic mayoral authority footprint, so long as the other boundaries also marry up with that in order to make working as a as an LRF easier. From having a wider strategic footprint, to align our resilience strategies, to being more efficient with community resilience workstreams and our communications—there are lots of benefits to being in a strategic mayoral authority.

At the moment, though, we are on police force boundaries, which make it quite difficult, because some areas—not Suffolk—have lots of local authorities. So it just comes down to the footprint, but there is definitely a good evidence base. Northumbria has a resilience board, which is chaired by the mayor; that seems a really good model that we want to look at and explore if we go down the devolution route in Norfolk and Suffolk.

Professor Lee Miles: There are two points here. First, you want shared competence. A mayor in any authority will have to deal with resilience as an “end of desk” thing. It will be part of their overall responsibility because that is where they are politically accountable for their region; they will also have resources of their own, which they can bring to bear from their own resourcing table. However, we also need to recognise that any mayor will not be necessarily an expert in resilience, so there is a need to have effective specialist competence. The shared competence becomes really important; it is not an “either/or” but an “and”.

It comes down to the second point, which is about effective collaboration. You must have an effective understanding of who is responsible, what the boundaries or the regions look like, the “what” and how this is going to be implemented. That means going back to more clear understandings of the relationship between any crisis contingency Act, as it develops, and any mayoral developments. Resilience has to be baked into both parts; otherwise, you will have problems in incidents in terms of preparedness, response and recovery throughout.

The Chair: Thank you. It is surprising that we invited some mayors to speak to us but they were reticent—or less than enthusiastic—about coming before us, for whatever reason. However, I am still keen to hear from them, so, if they are watching or listening, maybe they can get in touch. For the moment, I thank both of you for giving up your time this afternoon and illuminating us on the work of LRFs and on how we need to improve our dissemination of information structures and so on for the future.