Children's education damaged by academy failures and misuse of funds
23 January 2019
- Governance of academy trusts must be strengthened and the DfE's oversight more rigorous
- Trusts are not sufficiently transparent or accountable to parents and communities
- Concerns persist about the impact of funding pressures and the extent of asbestos in schools
- Read the report summary: Academies Accounts and Performance
- Read the report conclusions and recommendations: Academies Accounts and Performance
There has been a succession of high-profile academy failures that have been costly to the taxpayer and damaging to children's education.
Some academy trusts have misused public money through related-party transactions and paying excessive salaries.
At Durand Academy Trust and Bright Tribe Trust, there were serious failures of governance and oversight. This cannot be allowed to happen again – governance at academy trusts needs to be stronger and the Department for Education's (the Department's) oversight and intervention needs to be more rigorous.
The Education and Skills Funding Agency (the ESFA) is taking steps to control executive pay and related party transactions, but these actions are as yet unproven and in isolation will not prevent abuse. We expect to return to these issues in future.
Academy trusts are now responsible for educating nearly half of all children in state-funded schools in England, but they are not sufficiently transparent or accountable to parents and local communities.
Parents and local people have to fight to obtain even basic information about their children's schools and academy trusts do not do enough to communicate and explain decisions that affect the schools they are responsible for and how they are spending public money.
The accounts of individual academy trusts, and for the sector as a whole, are not yet as useful and accessible to users as they should be.
Our inquiry also reiterates concerns about the school sector as a whole which we raised nearly two years ago and which have not been addressed.
First, despite the funding pressures the sector is facing, neither Ofsted nor the ESFA is assessing the impact of these pressures on the quality of education and the outcomes schools achieve.
Second, almost a quarter of schools have still not provided the information that the Department needs to understand fully the extent of asbestos in school buildings.
Comment from PAC Chair Meg Hillier MP
“When things go wrong in schools, pupils can be badly affected. We have seen the troubling consequences of poor governance and oversight of academy trusts. Government must raise its game to ensure the failures of the past are not repeated.
“Parents and the wider community are entitled to proper access to transparent information about their local academy schools. They must have confidence that when issues arise, robust measures are in place to deal with them.
“The Government must act to make this happen and, as detailed in our Report, we expect the Department for Education and Education and Skills Funding Agency to demonstrate they are doing so.”