Skip to main content

Inquiry launched into the use of call lists for debates

16 December 2024

The Commons Procedure Committee has launched an inquiry into the use of call lists for debates.

Chair's comment

Cat Smith MP, Chair of the Procedure Committee, said:

“Call lists are not new to the House of Commons, having been temporarily employed during Covid, and they are a tool that is used effectively by other legislatures to regulate debates.

There is a discussion to be had over whether the Commons should follow suit, and the impact they would have on the flow and courtesies of debates. Our committee will explore this further, and we look forward to hearing the views of Members and othersstakeholders.” 

Background

Call lists for debates exist in many legislatures around the world. Members who wish to speak in a given debate must apply to do so by a certain deadline, after which the list is compiled and published a set period ahead of the debate.

It has been argued that call lists, and knowing who will speak in a debate and when, can be a helpful tool not only in providing Members with an indication of the choreography of the day and of certain debates (and thus giving them the ability to plan their days more effectively), but also in enabling the chair of a debate to decide on and impose time limits more effectively. However, others argue that they impact the flow of the debate, with the risk of turning debates into a succession of short statements from MPs rather than allowing for broader discussion amongst those taking part in any given debate.

Call lists were employed in the House of Commons during the Covid-19 pandemic as a way of ensuring that the Chair could move easily between Members participating virtually and those participating in person in the Chamber. The temporary arrangements lapsed when the Covid-19 procedures lapsed in 2021.

Further updates on the inquiry will be announced as it progresses.

Further information

Image: House of Commons